3.1. Sensing Behavior as an Indicator for Gas Sensor
Electrical characteristics of the MZF composite had been tested in air and ethanol gas (100, 200, and 300 ppm) environments. The characteristics of the sample can be seen in
Figure 3a which shows the sample operating in the temperature range of 210-365
oC. On the other hand, decrease in resistance value happens on every 5
oC increasing temperature. The more increasing the temperature, the more decreasing the resistance value will be. This characteristic shows the properties of semiconductor materials in which their conductivity increases together with their increasing the temperature.
Differences on resistance values at different ethanol concentration show that the sample gives a different response. In the range 210-255
oC operating temperature, the sample was still unstable to detect the ethanol gases. So, the electrical resistance value had a random trend. However, when the sample above 255
oC operating temperature, the sample had a higher resistance than that of not given ethanol gas (
Figure 3a)). This is caused by electrons excited from valence band to conduction band. Then, they recombine with holes. The detailed description above shows that the composite ceramic materials which have been fabricated are the P-type semiconductor [
21,
22,
23,
24,
25]:
The gas sensing mechanism of MZF can be represented by Equations (1), (2), (3), and (4). In an ambient condition, the oxygen is absorbed by the surface of the sensing layer (Eq. 1). When it is in the working temperature condition, the oxygen will react with free-electrons to form oxygen ion (Eq. 2). Then, the oxygen ion reacts with the MZF lattice (Eq. 3). This situation results in certain potential barrier which is called prior condition. Later on, ethanol is injected into that environment causing reaction between ethanol gas molecules and oxygen ion molecules in the MZF lattice. This makes the electrons recombine with lattice holes (Eq. 4), so that a new potential barrier which is denser than the previous one and is called final condition (resistance value is higher) is formed [
26]. These prior and final resistances indicate the responses of the sensor: the higher difference in the resistance value between those conditions, their response and selectivity will be higher In addition, the resistance values can also be represented by the %response function of the sensor to working temperature. This is often called sensor sensitivity. Sensor sensitivity is shown in
Figure 3b). At different concentrations, the sample has also different optimum working temperature. In the range of 310-355
oC, the sensor does not show its selectivity, it causes the sensor response is still random. It is assumed that the surface of MZF film is not even, so the electron transfer (ET) is unstable for resulting the current.
The best working performance of the sample is at 360
oC. At that temperature, the sample shows significant sensing behavior, in which its responses are approximately 42.25% (100 ppm), 47.21% (200 ppm), and 48.24% (300 ppm), respectively (see
Figure 4). This operating temperature is lower another work of Fe-based gas sensor [
27]. The working temperature is affected by the thickness of the sample [
28,
29], which is shown in
Figure 6b). A thinner layer will widen depletion area and affect narrower area of electron mobility among the grains (
Schottky contacts is higher). This phenomenon results in an enhancing sensitivity to target gas, but it also generates an increasing working temperature that is very avoided.
On the contrary, the sample layer which is thicker will decrease sensitivity and working temperature. This is caused by the massive mobility of the electrons since the layer of electron mobility is under the surface of the sample. It clearly shows that Schottky contact is lower [
30,
31].
The difference in the sensitivity of the composite ceramic to ethanol gas indicates that the sample is able to distinguish different ethanol gas concentrations. Even though the precursor sources are different with another research, the fabricated MZF composite has a compete performance compared with the use of high purity precursors of Fe-based [
18,
27]. Otherwise, even this work had a lower sensitivity than our previous work [
32], this because difference of treatment on the temperature of firing the film. We assumed that the temperature of firing in this work has not created the homogenous crystal. So that, the distance between grain is various which cause the operating temperature is high as we can see in the
Figure 3b). This shows that the MZF composite which is fabricated using local minerals of Indonesia has also good responses and is suitable to be utilized as an ethanol gas sensor device.
Crystal and morphological structures
The scanning angle of 2θ was used from 5 to 100
o. The XRD pattern of the sample was shown in
Figure 5. The XRD patterns match with the database of ICDD (
International Center for Diffraction Data) or COD (
Crystallography Open Database). The ICDD No. 96-200-9104 (No. 2009103 in COD database) matches with the Fe
16Mn
2.8Zn
5.2O
32 (
*) at the position of 35.17, 56.51, and 62.05
o [
33]. The ICDD No. 96-900-6897 (No. 9006896 in COD database) matches with the Zn
8Fe
16O
32 (♦) at the position of 30.21 and 43.25
o [
34]. The ICDD No. 96-900-0140 (No. 9000139 in COD database) matches with the Fe
12O
18 (•) at the diffraction peak positions of 24.13, 33.112, 40.83, 49.42, 54.00, 63.96, and 71.82
o [
35]. These patterns look like the XRD results of [
36] which employed different source of Fe.
The addition of Mn
2O
3 into ZnO-Fe
2O
3 causes changing in the type of the semiconductor material. The semiconductor of ZnO-Fe
2O
3 has N-type [
18,
19]. When the Mn
2O
3 is added, the type of the semiconductor material changes into P-type. This happens as Zn
2+ in ZnFe
2O
4 is substituted by Mn
3+, where the numbers of Mn
3+ holes are more than the numbers of electrons from Zn
2+, so that the materials of the Mn
2O
3-ZnO-Fe
2O
3 excess the holes. This scheme deals with as reported by [
37,
38] that they used P-type semiconductor from Bi
xSb
2-xTe
3 as a source.
The three phases of the crystallite indicate that the sample is a composite which has sizes of 27.7 nm (
*), 25 nm (♦), and 58.9 nm (•). The three phases are formed due to pH value in the precipitation step of the material synthesis process. The pH value of the residue is about 8.91 which indicates that it is still difficult to form singular phase. The structure of the singular MZF material may be able to be formed if the pH value is about 12.5 [
39].
Figure 5.
Morphological structure of the MZF composite: (a) surface, (b) section area.
Figure 5.
Morphological structure of the MZF composite: (a) surface, (b) section area.
Surface morphology of the MZF composite is shown in
Figure 6a). There are a lot of small-sized grains which form like granola all around the surface. The average size of the grains is 496.31 nm. In addition, the surface morphologAy has a high porosity which is approximately ~172.134,1 µm
2. The thickness of the MZF composite is about 2.51 µm. The thickness morphology of the composite ceramic is shown in
Figure 6b at section part. In gas sensing, the porosity and thickness are two parameters that are able to foster increasing sensitivity to gas. The small grain-size supports the electron transport, so that the electrons can be excited easily and facilitated well, and the sensor will sense the target gas quickly [
40]. Nevertheless, the surface morphology is nonhomogeneous, so the transfer electron is unstable which affects to unstable of the sensor response. This means that the small size of the particle only is not enough, but we need the uniform surface to determine good response of gas sensing.