1. Introduction
Forest ecosystems are a natural resource of great importance to humanity, since many people depend on them for their survival, in addition to other benefits such as human and environmental health, carbon sequestration, and genetic resources that underpin important wood and wood products-based industries [
1]. At present, the health of forests, both natural and managed, is more heavily threatened, and these threats arise from direct and indirect anthropogenic influences on fungal pathogens, and insect pests [
1,
2]. Plantations in the tropics (planted forests of a single species) are usually of non-native species, such as the genera of
Pinus,
Eucalyptus, and
Acacia, the main forest species planted in Venezuela.
Non-native trees in plantations are in part successful because they have been separated from their natural enemies, but when plantation trees are reunited with their coevolved pests, which may be introduced accidentally, or when they encounter novel pests to which they have no resistance, substantial damage or loss can ensue [
3]. The longer non-native trees are planted in an area, the more threatened they become by native pests. Where the trees are of native species, they can be vulnerable to introduced pests. But the relative species uniformity of monoculture stands in intensively managed native plantation forests can make them especially susceptible to the many native pests occurring in the surrounding natural forests [
4,
5].
An example of an epidemic of native pathogens moving onto an exotic species is provided by the shoot pathogen
Gremmeniella abietina (Lagerberg) Morelet, endemic and not particularly damaging on Scots pine in Sweden but causing widespread destruction of Swedish plantations of the extensively planted exotic lodgepole pine [
6].
The
Botryosphaeriales contains numerous fungal species that occur as saprophytes, parasites, or endophytes on a diverse range of plant hosts [
7,
8], as well as opportunistic pathogens of woody plants, especially when host plants are stressed [
9]. Different species within of order
Botryosphaeriales are well known pathogens on forest trees and other woody plants associated with branch and trunk cankers, dieback, decline and mortality, and represent a growing threat to forest ecosystems worldwide [
7,
8]. An ecological and biological characteristic of the species in the
Botryosphaeriales order is the lack of host specificity able to colonize and cause disease in diverse native and introduced plant hosts [
7,
10].
Different
Botryosphaeriales genera can infect multiple hosts, increases the threat that they pose as potential economic and ecological important pathogens of native and cultivated trees around the world. Examples of inter-host exchanges of the
Botryosphaeriales, and that include those amongst and between native and non-native trees, we have
Botryosphaeriales species have moved between trees in native stands of
Eucalyptus (
Myrtaceae) and adjacent plantations of these trees [
11], between native waterberry trees (
Syzygium cordatum;
Myrtaceae) and related eucalypt plantations (
Myrtaceae) [
12], from
Pinus resinosa windbreaks to pine nurseries [
13], among various tree hosts in the
Casuarinaceae,
Cupressaceae,
Fabaceae,
Myrtaceae,
Proteaceae,
Santalaceae [
14], and among native
Terminalia spp. (
Combretaceae) and between these trees and
Theobroma cacao (
Malvaceae) [
15]. The epidemiology of
Botryosphaeriales species is complex. These fungi can be monocyclic or oligocyclic pathogens that cause polyetic epidemics. As monocyclic pathogens, they complete one disease cycle, or even part of one, in one season. Depending on the weather conditions, these species can be oligocyclic pathogens, i.e., polycyclic pathogens with a few (two or three) disease cycles per season [
16]. In Venezuela, the
Botryosphaeriales species are polycyclic since there are no marked seasons in the tropics as in the temperate regions. In the tropic, high temperatures and humidity are present almost all year round, therefore, these fungi will present several disease cycles and produce constant inoculum or spores throughout the year.
Species identification in
Botryosphaeriales has been largely based on the asexual morphs due to the lack of diversity among sexual morph features within this order and the difficulty of finding the sexual morphs in nature or obtaining them under laboratory conditions [
17,
18]. Different species within the same genera of
Botryosphaeriales frequently possess overlapping morphological features [
19] that can cause confusion in their accurate identification. In recent decades, several researchers began using identification techniques based on DNA sequencing and phylogenetic analyses to resolve the taxonomic problems associated with overlapping morphological characteristics among the species asexual morphs within
Botryosphaeriales genera [
17,
18,
20,
21,
22]. The phylogenetic analyses of DNA sequence data have significantly impacted all aspects of the systematics and taxonomy of the
Botryosphaeriales, including a redefinition of families and genera, identification of new species, cryptic species, and more recently hybrids [
23]. Crous et al. [
24] defined all genera in the
Botryosphaeriales based predominantly on phylogenetic inference and characteristics of their asexual morphs, and without morphological evidence of a sexual morph. In various cases, genera were thus established in the family based on asexual names.
The
Botryosphaeriales order has undergone changes in its systematics, mainly at the family level. A total of nine families have been included in the last 5 years within the
Botryosphaeriales order, based on phylogenetic, morphological, and ecological differences [
23]. These families are:
Aplosporellaceae Slippers et al. 2013 [
25],
Botryosphaeriaceae Theiss. & Syd., 1918 [
24],
Endomelanopsisaceae TaoYang & Crous, 2016 [
26],
Melanopsaceae Phillips et al. 2013 [
25],
Phyllostictaceae Fr., 1849 [
27],
Planistromellaceae M.E. Barr, 1996 [
28],
Pseudofusicoccumaceae Tao Yang & Crous, 2016 [
26],
Saccharataceae Slippers et al. 2013 [
25] and
Septorioideaceae Wyka & Broders, 2016 [
29], being the
Botryosphaeriaceae family with the largest number of genera within it.
The purpose of this review is to update all relevant information on morphological descriptions and DNA sequencing data on the Botryoshaeriales fungi that produce different diseases on cultivated and wild plants, as well as their distribution and diversity on woody plants in Venezuela.
4. Taxonomy, diversity and distribution of a new genus, new species and reports found in Venezuela and other regions of the world
The taxonomy of a new genus, new species, and reports of
Botryosphaeriales identified by DNA sequences and their hosts in Venezuela are discussed below (
Table 3,
Figure 1,
Figure 2 and
Figure 3).
Cophinforma atrovirens (Mehl & Slippers) A. Alves & A.J.L. Phillips (Basionym:
Fusicoccum atrovirens Mehl & Slippers) was isolated from stems and branches of
A. mangium,
Eucalyptus urophylla-hybrids,
E. urophylla x
E. grandis and reported for the first time in Cojedes (CR) and Portuguesa (WCR) states, [
53], and from fruits and trees of
Theobroma cacao L., in Merida state (AR) [
54], Venezuela. Initially, Mohali et al. [
53] reported this fungus as
Botryosphaeria mamane D.E. Gardner (asexual morph
Cophinforma mamane (D.E. Gardner) A.J.L. Phillips & A. Alves), but Phillips et al. [
8] found that ITS sequences of the Venezuelan isolates of
C. mamane are the same as the ITS sequence of
C. atrovirens, therefore they consider the Venezuelan isolates to represent
C. atrovirens.
In other regions of the world
C. atrovirens was isolated from asymptomatic branches and twigs of
Pterocarpus angolensis, in South Africa [
55]; dead branch of
Eucalyptus sp., in Thailand [
56] as
Cophinforma eucalypti Doilom, J.K. Liu & K.D. Hyde; it was also isolated from
Dimocarpus longan Lour., but producing lesions on inoculated seedlings of
Eucalyptus sp., in China [
57]; and stem rot and dieback on Cashew tree (
Anacardium occidentale) in Brazil [
58].
Diplodia scrobiculata J. de Wet, Slippers & M.J. Wingf., (syn
. Diplodia guayanensis F. Castro-Medina, J.R. Úrbez-Torres, S.R. Mohali & W.D. Gubler sp. nov., MycoBank 812480) was isolated from the trunk of
A. mangium in plantations of Monagas state, North Eastern Region (NER), Venezuela [
59].
Diplodia guayanensis was distinguished from
D. scrobiculata by its larger conidia [
59]. Later, sequence alignment ITS,
tef1 and
btub of
D. scrobiculata and combining two (ITS and
tef1) [
60] and three loci (ITS,
tef1 and
btub) [
61] for phylogenetic analysis both concluded that
D. guayanensis is indistinguishable from
D. scrobiculata based on phylogenetic analyses, and considered it to be a synonym for
D. scrobiculata, and this was further supported on the basis that Úrbez-Torres et al. [
59] used older sequences for
D. scrobiculata in their phylogenetic analyses [
60], although Zhang et al. [
61] used the old sequences and obtained the same results as Linaldeddu et al. [
60]. Furthermore, morphological variability is common in these fungi [
8,
60]; however, distinctive RFLP patterns were obtained for
D. guayanensis compared against their closely related species
D. scrobiculata and
D. sapinea (Fr.) Fuckel (A and B) using
Cfol restriction fragments in
tef1 PCR products [
59]. The PCR-RFLP fingerprinting profiles have been useful in this study to distinguish
Botryosphaeriales, although overlapping RFLP patterns may be observed between some species using one, two, or more RE [
62].
Diplodia scrobiculata was isolated and identified for the first time from needles of
Pinus banksiana Lamb.,
P. resinosa Aiton,
P. greggii Engelm. ex Parl., in USA (Wisconsin, Minnesota, California), Mexico, and Europe (France, Italy) [
63]; wilted twigs, branch dieback, necrosis and stem cankers on
Pinus halepensis Mill., trees, in Tunisia [
64]; symptomless and die-back on
Pinus patula Schiede ex Schltdl. & Cham., in South Africa [
65]; asymptomatic trees in
Pinus radiata D. Don plantations but producing lesions on inoculated
P. radiata seedlings in Spain [
66];
Pinus sp., in Canada [
67]; and dieback on Coast redwood (
Sequoia sempervirens (Lamb. ex. D. Don) Endl.) in California, USA [
68].
Lasiodiplodia brasiliensis M.S.B. Netto, M.W. Marques & A.J.L. Phillips was isolated for the first time in Venezuela from
T. cacao plantations in the state of Merida (AR), Venezuela [
54], although Zhang et al. [
61], reported to
L. brasiliensis on
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis,
F. insipida and
J. copaia wood in Venezuela, these authors taken by mistake these sequences from GenBank that belong to
L. theobromae from Venezuela (see
Table S1 of these authors).
Lasiodiplodia brasiliensis was identified and reported for the first time in Brazil on stems of Mango (
Mangifera indica L.) and fruits of
Carica papaya L. [
69] and other hosts in Brazil; saprobic on dead branch of teak (
Tectona grandis L.f.), in Thailand [
70]; Mango dieback, in Peru [
71];
Adansonia madagascariensis Baill., in Madagascar [
72];
Eucalyptus sp., in China [
56]; as endophytic fungus isolated from healthy, brown, and ligaloes tissue of evergreen trees (
Aquilaria crassna Pierre ex Lecomte), in Laos [
73]; symptoms of gummosis, stem cankers, and dieback on Persian lime (
Citrus latifolia Tan.), in Mexico [
74];
Gossypium hirsutum L., in Australia [
75]; leaf blight of
Sansevieria trifasciata Prain (mother-in-law’s tongue or snake plant), ornamental plant, in Malaysia [
76]; dieback and corky bark on longan trees (
Dimocarpus longan L.), in Puerto Rico [
77]; branch dieback,
T. cacao, Cameroon and
Psychotria tutcheri Dunn fruits, in China [
61].
Cruywagen et al. [
72] and Farr & Rossman [
78] mistakenly cited to
L. brasiliensis as the causing of dieback in strawberries (
Fragaria x
ananassa Duchesne), in Turkey, but the pathogen reported was
L. theobromae [
79].
Lasiodiplodia crassispora Burgess, Barber sp. nov., was isolated for the first time from wood of living
E. urophylla in Acarigua, Portuguesa State (WCR), Venezuela and canker of
Santalum album L., (sandalwood) in Western Australia, Australia [
80]. The sandalwood is native to southern India, eastern Indonesia, and northern Australia (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santalum_album), therefore,
L. crassispora found in central-western Venezuela (WCR) could have been introduced through imported eucalyptus seeds used for the plantations in Venezuela.
Lasiodiplodia crassispora was associated the internal wood decay symptoms observed in the cordon samples on grapevine (
Vitis vinifera L.), in South Africa [
81];
E. urophylla, in Uruguay [
82]; perennial cankers in the vascular tissue of grapevines, in California, USA [
83]; endophytic in
Corymbia sp. Hook, and minor lesions in inoculations on 4-month-old baobab seedlings (
Adansonia gregorii F.Muell.), in Australia [
84]; dieback and stem-end rot of mango, fresh fruit of table grape (
Vitis spp.), and causing dieback on
Annonaceae in Brazil [
85,
86,
87]; dieback symptoms from trunks and branches on grapevines in Sonora and Baja California, Mexico [
88].
Lasiodiplodia crassispora (syn.
Lasiodiplodia pyriformis F.J.J. van der Walt, Slippers & G.J.Marais) isolated from the leading edges of lesions on branches of
Acacia mellifera (M.Vahl) Benth., in Namibia [
61,
89].
Lasiodiplodia pseudotheobromae A.J.L. Phillips, A. Alves & Crous was reported for the first time in Uverito plantations, Monagas State (NER), Venezuela in
A. mangium [
90].
Lasiodiplodia pseudotheobromae was identified for the first time from
Gmelina arborea Roxb., (Melina) and
A. mangium in Costa Rica,
Rosa sp., in Netherlands,
Coffea sp., in Zaire and
Citrus aurantium L., Suriname [
91]; isolated from trees apparently healthy or showing canker and dieback symptoms of
Acacia confuse Merr.,
Albizia falcataria (L.) Fosberg,
Eucalyptus sp.,
Mangifera sylvatica Roxb., and
Paulownia fortunei (Seem.) Hemsl., in China [
92]; dieback on blackthorn (
Acacia mellifera (M.Vahl) Benth.), in Namibia [
89];
Adansonia digitata L., in Mozambique and South Africa [
71]; Cashew gummosis (
Anacardium humile A.St.-Hil.), in Brazil [
93];
Annona muricata L., in Australia [
75];
Bouea burmanica Griff.,
Hevea brasiliensis (Willd. ex A.Juss.) Müll.Arg.,
Persea americana Mill.,
Coffea arabica L.,
Mangifera indica,
Ficus racemosa L.,
Syzygium samarangense (Blume) Merr. & L.M.Perry,
Dimocarpus longan Lour., in Thailand [
94]; stem cankers, gummosis, and branches dieback
Citrus latifolia Tan., in Mexico [
74]; trunk cankers,
Citrus reticulata Blanco, in Pakistan [
95]; symptoms of branch dieback, cankers and fruit rot in
Citrus sp., in Iran [
96]; dieback, Mango, in Egypt, Peru and South Korea [
71,
97,
98]; stem canker on the native Uruguayan tree,
Myrcianthes pungens (O.Berg) D. Legrand and pathogenic in inoculated 4 month-old
Eucalyptus grandis seedlings, in Uruguay [
82]; dieback and fruit rot on Rambutan trees (
Nephelium lappaceum L.), in Puerto Rico [
77]; symptoms of branch dieback and cankers, and shoot and panicle blight in pistachio (
Pistacia sp. and
Pistacia vera L.), in Spain, [
99]; shoot-dieback, gummosis, and sunken necrotic bark lesions in young nectarine (
Prunus persica) trees, in Turkey [
100];
Rosa sp., in Netherlands [
91]; leaf blight of
Sansevieria trifasciata, in Malaysia [
76]; die-back disease on
Schizolobium parahyba (Vell.) S. F. Blake var.
amazonicum (Ducke) Barneby trees, in Ecuador [
101]; trunk Diseases in
Vitis vinifera, in Tunisia [
102]; and post flowering stalk rot of maize (
Zea mays L.), in India [
103].
Lasiodiplodia theobromae (Pat.) Griffon & Maubl., is a cosmopolitan fungus occurring predominantly throughout tropical and subtropical regions [
38,
80]. It has also been known as a human pathogen causing keratomycosis and phaeohyphomycosis [
103], and as a plant pathogen associated with about 500 plant hosts causing numerous diseases, including dieback, root rot, fruit rots, leaf spot and cankers of many others [
38], and it also occurs as an endophyte [
104].
Lasiodiplodia theobromae has been reported in Venezuela on
A. mangium, and
E. urophylla, in Portuguesa State (WCR) [
105];
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis,
E. urophylla x
E. grandis, and
A. mangium, in Cojedes (CR), Falcon and Portuguesa States (WCR) [
53];
Pinus caribaea and
A. mangium, in Monagas State (NER) [
59];
Ficus insipida, logs yard located within the natural forest of the Imataca Forest Reserve, between the Bolivar and Delta Amacuro States (GR) ([
106];
Theobroma cacao, in Merida State (AR) [
54].
In Venezuela, regarding the population structure of
L. theobromae isolated from forest tree plantations was of a high gene flow between populations and a lack of population differentiation from the three host types considered,
A. mangium and
Eucalyptus urophylla, in Cojedes and Portuguesa State, and
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis in Falcon State, therefore the reproduction was predominantly clonal, and all three Venezuelan populations were pooled [
104].
Lasiodiplodia venezuelensis Burgess, Barber, Mohali, sp. nov., MB500237 was isolated and described for the first time from wood of living
Acacia mangium Willd., in Acarigua, Portuguesa State (WCR), Venezuela. Later, was found causing blue stain on
Pinus caribaea Morelet var.
hondurensis (Sénécl.) W.H.Barrett & Golfari wood and light-brown cankers with a black exudate on
A. mangium in Monagas State (NER), and blue stain on
Ficus insipida Willd., wood, Imataca Forest Reserve (natural forests), between the Bolivar and Delta Amacuro States (GR) [
59,
80,
106]. To date,
L. venezuelensis has only been reported in Venezuela, and found in the natural forest causing blue stain wood of
F. insipida, and as a pathogen in
A. mangium plantations.
L. venezuelensis could be an endemic native fungus causing blue stain in light wood species native for Venezuela as is the case of
F. insipida and moving onto an exotic species as a pathogen in
A. mangium plantations [
59].
Neofusicoccum arbuti (D.F. Farr & M. Elliott) Crous, Slippers & A.J.L. Phillips (syn.
Neofusicoccum andinum (Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf.) Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf. comb. nov. MycoBank MB500871. Basionym:
Fusicoccum andinum Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf.) [
8,
24,
105], was isolated from asymptomatic branches of mature
Eucalyptus sp., trees in Mucuchies (3140 m), Cordillera Los Andes mountains (AR), Venezuela [
105].
Li et al. [
57,
107] using combination of ITS,
tef1,
tub2, and
rpb2 regions, with maximum parsimony (MP)/maximum likelihood (ML) tests analyses, they could separate cryptic species between
N. andinum and
N. arbuti. Later, Zhang et al. [
61], evaluated the species in
Botryosphaeriales, and performed Bayesian analysis of the combined ITS,
tef1,
tub2 and
rpb2 sequence alignment to obtain a new phylogenetic tree of
Neofusicoccum spp. They found that the ex-type culture of
N. arbuti had nucleotide similarities with the sequences of the ex-type of
N. andinum [(ITS: 466/471 (98.94 %), rpb2: 536/537 (99.81 %), tef1: 240/241 (99.59 %) and tub2: 376/376 (100 %), respectively], therefore
N. andinum was reduced to synonymy with
N. arbuti. Mohali et al. [
105] did not include the
N. arbuti sequences in the phylogenetic tree because these were not available at that time [
61].
Neofusicoccum arbuti was isolated from cankers of
Arbutus menziesii Pursh (Pacific madrone), in Washington and California, USA, and Canada [
108], and stem canker and dieback of
Vaccinium spp. (Blueberry), in Chile [
109].
Neofusicoccum parvum (Pennycook & Samuels) Crous, Slippers & A.J.L. Phillips and
Neofusicoccum ribis (Slippers, Crous & M.J. Wingf.) Crous, Slippers & A.J.L. Phillips both were isolated on
E. urophylla S.T. Blake, and
Botryosphaeria dothidea (Moug. ex Fr.) Ces. & De Not., isolated on
E. urophylla x
E. grandis W. Hill ex Maiden hybrids all from asymptomatic plant tissue, as well as trees exhibiting blue stain and die-back and from entirely dead trees in Portuguesa State, and
N. parvum on
Psidium guajava L., in Zulia State (ZR) [
53].
Inoculation trial was conducted on
E. urophylla x
E. grandis hybrid stems in Portuguesa State with the fungi
B. dothidea,
N. parvum and
N. ribis, and after 7 weeks lesions development was recorded.
Botryosphaeria dothidea produced very small lesions in comparison to
N. ribis and
N. parvum which produced significantly larger lesions, bark swelling around the inoculation points and in some cases the bark was cracked producing black kino exudation when the outer bark was removed from the points of inoculation [
110].
Pseudofusicoccum Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf. gen. nov. MycoBank MB500884;
Pseudofusicoccum stromaticum (Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf.) Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf., comb. nov. MycoBank MB500885, Basionym:
Fusicoccum stromaticum Mohali, Slippers & M.J. Wingf., [
8,
24,
105], was isolated from branches of
Eucalyptus urophylla S.T.Blake and
E. urophylla x
E. grandis W. Mill ex Maiden-hybrids, and from branches and stems of
Acacia mangium Willd., in Western Central Region (WCR) of Venezuela [
105].
Crous et al. [
24] introduced to
Pseudofusicoccum genus for species that are morphologically similar to
Fusicoccum and
Neofusicoccum but phylogenetically distinct from both of these genera.
Pseudofusicoccum genus resembles species of
Fusicoccum but distinct in having conidia encased in a persistent mucous sheath, and conidia are also more cylindrical than in
Fusicoccum species [
24]. Yang et al. [
26] using robust backbone phylogeny for
Botryosphaeriales (LSU and rpb2 genes) described and raised this genus as a new family,
Pseudofusicoccumaceae Tao Yang & Crous where morphologically the family, is typified by
Pseudofusicoccum.
In Venezuela, inoculations with
P. stromaticum were made on 2-year-old trees in plantations of
E. urophylla x
E. grandis hybrid clones. Seven weeks after inoculation produced small lesions on the stems, but at the same time it was observed that the inoculation points had started to heal and produce callus by the end of the trial [
110].
Pseudofusicoccum stromaticum has been widely reported in Brazil causing diseases in different hosts such as: dieback on mango (
Mangifera indica L.) stems, pathogenic on 5-month-old mango seedlings, and producing the small lesions on inoculated mango fruits [
111,
112]; dieback, wilting of branches, discoloration of the vascular system, decline and subsequent death of Malay apple (
Syzygium malaccense L.) trees [
113]; associated with gummosis on native cashew (
Anacardium othonianum Rizzinin) [
93]; dieback and stem and branch cankers on cashew (
Anacardium occidentale L.), guava (
Psidium guajava L.) and caja-umbu (
Spondias mombin L. x
S. tuberosa Arruda) trees [
114]; as endophyte in
Myracrodruon urundeuva Fr. All. (
Anacardiaceae) [
115], and dieback of the
Annonaceae [
87]. In Uruguay,
P. stromaticum was associated with cankers showing gummosis in peach shoots and showed moderate virulence on both inoculated apple and peach shoots [
116].
In addition to
P. stromaticum, eight species have subsequently been added to the genus, such as
Pseudofusicoccum adansoniae Pavlic, T.I. Burgess, M.J. Wingf., on
Adansonia gibbosa (A.Cunn.) Guymer ex D.A.Baum,
Acacia synchronicia Maslin,
Eucalyptus L'Hér., and
Ficus opposite Miq., in Australia and,
Ficus krishnae L. and
Jatropha podagrica Hook, in India [
117,
118];
P. africanum Marinc., Jami & M.J. Wingf., on twigs of
Mimusops caffra E.Mey. ex A.DC. (coastal red milkwood), in Eastern Cape Province, Haga Haga, South Africa [
119];
P. ardesiacum Pavlic, T.I. Burgess, M.J. Wingf., on
A. gibbosa and
Eucalyptus sp., in Australia;
P. artocarpi T. Trakunyingcharoen, L. Lombard & Crous, on twigs of
Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam., in Chiang Mai Province, Thailand [
94];
P. calophylli Jayasiri, E.B.G. Jones & K.D. Hyde on decaying fruit pericarp of
Calophyllum inophyllum L., in Krabi Province, Mueang Krabi District, Thailand [
120];
P. kimberleyense Pavlic, T.I. Burgess, M.J. Wingf., on
Acacia synchronicia Maslin,
Adansonia gibbosa,
Eucalyptus sp., and
Ficus opposite Miq. in Australia [
121] and
Persea americana Mill., USA [
61];
P. olivaceum Mehl & Slippers on asymptomatic branches and twigs of
Pterocarpus angolensis (Kiaat), in Mpumalanga Province, Kruger National Park, Pretoriuskop,
Terminalia sericea Burch. ex DC., and
Terminalia prunioides M.A.Lawson, in South Africa [
55,
61];
P. violaceum Mehl & Slippers on asymptomatic branch of
P. angolensis Mpumalanga Province, Mawewe Nature Reserve, in South Africa [
55], and
Microcos paniculatus, in Hong Kong, China [
61].
This genus is known only as the asexual morph and thus far nine species have been reported [
61]. To date,
P. stromaticum has been reported exclusively from South America while the remaining of the
Pseudofusicoccum species have been reported from other regions, such as South Africa, Australia, Thailand, China, USA, and India [
61,
117,
118].
5. Symptoms associated with species from Botryosphaeriales in Venezuela
Botryosphaeriales species infect plants via wounds or through natural plant openings, such as buds, lenticels, and stomata, resulting in diverse symptoms, such as twig, branch, and main stem cankers; die-back of leaders, shoots, or whole branches; seed capsule abortion; collar rot; damping off or blight of seedlings; root cankers; blue-stain; decline; and death of whole trees in severe cases [
7]. The
Table 1, different genera within the
Botryosphaeriales were found and isolated from different hosts and locations in Venezuela, associated with diverse symptoms, and identified through its asexual morph, and other were identified using DNA sequence data (
Table 3,
Figure 1 and
Figure 2).
Diplodia spp. and
Lasiodiplodia spp., have been reported to cause different symptoms, such as blue stain (synonymous sap stain), which is a result of melanin, a pigment produced by the fungal pathogen [
122]. The blue color of the wood develops as an optical effect due to refraction of light [
123], such as observed in the following examples:
Lasiodiplodia theobromae,
L. venezuelensis and
Diplodia mutila (Fr.) Mont., on
Pinus caribaea var.
hondurensis (
Figure 4a–i);
L. theobromae and
L. venezuelensis on
Ficus insípida (
Figure 4j,k). The discolorations in the wood of living trees/woody plants or dead logs are the result of diverse biotic and abiotic causes [
124,
125]. Wood discoloration and decay are often the result from wounding, such as those caused by animal chewing, branch breaking, pruning, mechanized wood harvest, construction injury, motor traffic, etc. [
126], and insects. Further discolorations can result from tree-produced substances, such as deposition of heartwood substances developed by living tree cells, later microbial stains, and finally colored derivatives of wood decay processes [
124], examples of tree/wood discolorations include the following: sudden death or die-back in
E. urophylla and
Eucalyptus hybrid of Portuguesa State caused by
Lasiodiplodia crassispora,
L. theobromae,
Neofusicoccum parvum,
N. ribis,
Botryosphaeria dothidea,
Pseudofusicoccum stromaticum, and
Cophinforma atrovirens (
Figure 4l,m); discolorations on
Acacia mangium in Cojedes and Portuguesa States caused by
Lasiodiplodia theobromae,
L. venezuelensis,
Cophinforma atrovirens, and
Pseudofusicoccum stromaticum (
Figure 4n,o).
Discolorations and canker in the stem of
A. mangium caused by
Lasiodiplodia pseudotheobromae,
L. theobromae,
L. venezuelensis, and
Diplodia scrobiculata (syn.
D. guayanensis) in plantations of Maderas del Orinoco Company (
Figure 5a–d), as well decline symptoms observed in
A. mangium, and
P. caribaea var
. hondurensis. Pathogenicity tests were carried out in commercial plantations at the company Maderas del Orinoco to investigate the status of
Botryosphaeriales associated with decline symptoms observed in
A. mangium and
P. caribaea var
. hondurensis. Three
Lasiodiplodia spp. and one
Diplodia sp., were inoculated in
A. mangium, and two
Lasiodiplodia spp., on
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis.
A. mangium showed bark swelling, vascular discoloration, necrosis, and cankering around the inoculation points (
Figure 5e–g), while in
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis did not cause any lesions [
59,
90]. This study showed that
Lasiodiplodia spp., and
Diplodia sp., are highly virulent to
A. mangium, showing. Other pathogenicity tests were carried out in the field, which gave us information about the susceptibility or tolerance to diseases, such as is the case of
Eucalyptus spp., a forest species introduced in Venezuela to obtain fibers for cardboard production. These assessments of inoculations were made with different genera and species of
Botryosphaeriales in commercial plantations of
Eucalyptus at the company Smurfit Kappa Reforestadora Dos, Portuguesa State on different commercial clones of
Eucalyptus-hybrids (
E. urophylla x
E. grandis), and where these clones were shown to be tolerant of
Botryosphaeriaceae were observed [
110].
Cophinforma atrovirens was isolated from
T. cacao fruits with anthracnose and together with
Lasiodiplodia theobromae, and
L. brasiliensis were found in association with dieback or sudden death symptoms on
T. cacao trees [
54] in Merida State (
Figure 5h), producing discolorations in branches (
Figure 5i) and stems (
Figure 5j,k). These discolorations were mainly associated with wounds caused by bark beetles-
Scolytinae (
Figure 5l). Stems, branches, and roots with cankers and dieback on
P. caribaea var
. hondurensis trees in plantations from 4 to15 years old and in nurseries on 8-month-old seedlings in displaying completely browned needles (
Figure 5m,n) were observed at the Maderas del Orinoco Company, and the main fungal pathogen reported as causing these diseases was
Sphaeropsis sapinea (Fr.) Dyko & B. Sutton [
34]. Cedeño et al. [
34] based their identification on the asexual morph, conidia 39,8 (37-45) x 12,7 (11-16) μm, one septum and rarely two or three septa (
Figure 5o,p); measurements close to
Diplodia sapinea (25.5-) 30.5-52.5 (-54) x (10-) 12.5-20 (-21) μm,
D. scrobiculata (37.5-) 39.5 (-41.5) x (13-) 14 (-15.5) μm, and
D. scrobiculata (syn.
D. guayanensis) (33.5-) 40.6-42.4 (56) x (12-) 15.8-16.7 (-18.5) μm [
59]. The absence of septa (aseptate) in mature conidia of
Sphaeropsis separates it from the
Diplodia genus, which is characterized by septate conidia [
8] (
Table 2), therefore, the diseases observed by Cedeño et al. [
34] in the nurseries and plantations of
P. caribaea var.
hondurensis could have been caused by a fungal species in the
Diplodia genus.
Neofusicoccum arbuti (syn.
N. andinum) was collected from asymptomatic branches of mature
Eucalyptus sp. trees growing in the Cordillera Los Andes Mountains of Venezuela at an altitude of ca. 3000 m (
Figure 6a–d). Photographs of other
Botryosphaeriales genera;
Diplodia scrobiculata (syn.
Diplodia guayanensis) (
Figure 6e,f),
Pseudofusicoccum stromaticum (
Figure 6g–i);
Neofusicoccum ribis/
Neofusicoccum parvum (
Figure 6j,k),
Cophinforma atrovirens (
Figure 6l, m), and
B. dothidea (
Figure 6n-p).
6. Conclusions
This is a review and update of information that represents almost 40 years of research work with species pertaining to the order Botryosphaeriales that cause diseases, with special reference to woody plants. The nomenclature of the different species and genera found within the Botryosphaeriales order have been updated, including the identification of the news species of Lasiodiplodia, a new genus and specie of Pseudofusiccocum, and new reports for Venezuela using molecular tools.
At the morphological level, nine genera were isolated and identified within Botryosphaeriales order, where Lasiodiplodia spp is the most abundant of all genera. This was isolated from fruit plantations such as citrus, mango, cacao, avocado, and forest tree plantations of exotic species such as pine, and from native forest species.
With molecular tools, it was possible to define exactly the name of the species that produce or are associated with forest diseases, especially in forest plantations of exotic species. Lasiodiplodia theobromae and L. venezuelensis both didn't cause lesions when they were inoculated in Pinus caribaea var. hondurensis trees, but they were routinely reisolated from asymptomatic wood which indicates the latent pathogen status of these species in this host, as well causing of blue stain on pine wood observed in fallen trees and in log yards at sawmills.
Lasiodiplodia pseudotheobromae, L. theobromae, L. venezuelensis, and Diplodia scrobiculata (=D. guayanensis) were isolated from trunks with symptoms light-brown cankers with a black exudate in Acacia mangium plantations. Inoculation tests carried out on this host showed bark swelling around the inoculation points and necrosis of the vascular system below the bark and black exudation, showing these four species their high virulence on A. mangium.
The fungi B. dothidea, C. atrovirens, L. theobromae, N. arbuti (=N. andinum), N. parvum, N. ribis and P. stromaticum isolated from Eucalyptus spp., plantations, were inoculated on hybrid Eucalyptus trees, where N. ribis and N. parvum produced significantly large lesions (canker) on the trunk, therefore these pathogens can be considered as new emerging diseases on these forest species introduced in the country; B. dothidea produced very small lesions, and the remainder of the fungi did not.
Regarding natural tropical forests in Venezuela, the blue stain of the wood on Ficus insipida in lumber yards was caused by L. theobromae and L. venezuelensis.
Plantations of the non-native forest species,
Pinus caribaea var.
hondurensis, in the East of Venezuela (between the States of Anzoátegui and Monagas), began in 1961. This plantation had a planted area of approximately 600,000 ha, but currently there are 112,000 ha. Later, and on a smaller scale, non-native species,
Acacia mangium, was planted. These forest plantations border one of the largest natural forest reserves in South America, The Imataca Forest Reserve occupying approximately 3.7 million ha, and located between the Bolivar and Delta Amacuro States in Venezuela [
106]. The proximity between non-native and native species has allowed native pathogens, such as
Lasiodiplodia venezuelensis, found so far only in Venezuela, and together with
L. theobromae,
L. pseudotheobromae,
D. arbuti (=
D. guayanensis) to be transferred to these specie exotics causing blue stain on pine wood, and canker in
A. mangium plantations.
Batista et al. [
2] have assumed that human movement and trade are the main routes of dispersal for all species within the order
Botryosphaeriales with worldwide distribution across all continents, with the exception of Antarctica, with climatic variability being the main limitations for the appearance of new stable populations and additionally, they also highlight that the disease expression is mainly due to occasional climatic events that can affect the susceptibility of the host.
Botryosphaeriales are reported as saprophytic, parasites, endophytic, and opportunistic pathogens in different crops, natural forests, and plantations, causing significant losses to the Venezuelan economy, but these losses are not quantified. Information on diseases caused by fungi of the Botryosphaeriales order and their description at the morphological level in Venezuela is very scarce, scattered, and with little information, in addition to future research in plant pathology, phylogenetic studies and fungal taxonomy, and the rest of the other areas of science that are developed in Venezuela is in great uncertainty due to current economic and political problems.