1. Introduction
The rapidly developing hydrogen energy and high-tech industries are increasingly encouraging the development of hydrogen generation technologies. Nowadays, the most popular and effective technology for high-purity hydrogen evolution is the membrane separation. Over the past few decades, membrane technology has been developed and investigated to meet various requirements of different applications [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7]. It has a number of advantages, such as low energy consumption, the ability to conduct continuous separation, easy scaling and the ability to combine with other separation technologies [
8,
9]. Palladium membranes are most preferred in the industrial hydrogen separation conditions. [
10,
11,
12]. Such phenomena is due to the high ability of palladium to transport hydrogen in a wide temperature range due to the higher solubility and diffusion ability of the FCC lattice. However, the practical application of membranes based on pure palladium is limited, since the metal tends to embrittlement in a hydrogen atmosphere [
13,
14]. Therefore, the membranes usage for hydrogen separation is very difficult and sometimes even impossible due to lattice expansion caused by dissolved hydrogen at temperatures below 300 °C [
15,
16]. This fact is due to the two immiscible Pd α- and β-phases, the first of which is a solid solution, and the second one is palladium hydride [
17,
18]. There is a transition between the α- and β-phases with the lattice space increase up to 10%. It leads to a lattice distortion, the high internal stresses formation, deformation, and, ultimately, the membrane destruction [
19]. In addition to embrittlement, palladium is quite susceptible to poisoning and surface contamination by impurity gases, which contain sulfur or carbon compounds [
20,
21,
22]. Also, a significant difficulty in the fabrication of membranes based on pure palladium is the high metal cost [
23,
24]. Alloying of palladium with other metals, such as silver, gold, copper, ruthenium, nickel, makes it possible to overcome these difficulties [
25,
26,
27,
28]. For example, Q. Zhou et al. have studied gas separation properties of membranes based on Pd-Au and Pd-Au-Ag alloys [
29]. The obtained results demonstrated the lowest hydrogen gas adsorption energy of -0.017 eV and -0.010 eV for Pd-Au and Pd-Au-Ag and excellent hydrogen selectivity and permeability characteristics of the developed membranes. Z. Han et al. [
30] have investigated the characteristics of hydrogen separation by Pd-based alloy membranes using the density functional theory (DFT) modeling and molecular dynamics calculations. According to the results, the Pd-Cu and Pd-Ni membranes showed excellent hydrogen selectivity compared to nitrogen, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, methane, hydrogen sulfide at various temperatures, and the hydrogen permeability exceeded the limits of industrial production. S. Agnolin et al. [
31] described the fabrication of thin Pd-Ag membranes on Hastelloy X tubular filters. A thin membrane layer was deposited on the surface of a tube modified by polishing and applying a smoothing interdiffusion barrier layer based on a boehmite dispersion. The filter pre-treatment was critical to increase the permeability and hydrogen selectivity of the final membrane in fact.
One of the most promising membrane systems is the Pd-Cu binary alloy, which has good mechanical properties, high thermal stability, excellent hydrogen selectivity and permeability, relatively low cost, resistances to hydrogen sulfide poisoning, prevents hydrogen embrittlement at low temperatures [
32,
33,
34]. According to the phase diagram [
35,
36], Pd-Cu alloys mainly have two different crystal lattices: face-centered cubic (fcc) and body-centered cubic (bcc) [
37,
38]. The most attractive for the membrane alloys manufacture is the bcc structure, since such Pd-Cu alloys demonstrate the highest hydrogen permeability compared to the fcc structure ones [
39,
40,
41]. Pd-40%Cu with a bcc structure and the highest hydrogen permeability seems to be especially promising of the variety of known alloys [
42,
43].
Another important factor in improving the Pd-based membranes efficiency and durability is the membrane film thinning. The deposition of a thin film on porous supports allows to increase the hydrogen penetration rate and to reduce the cost of the material compared to the traditional Pd dense-metal membranes [
44,
45,
46]. Nowadays, the most common methods for manufacturing such a composite membrane are vacuum deposition, chemical-vapor deposition, chemical and galvanic deposition [
47,
48,
49]. Among these methods, magnetron sputtering has a clear advantage, since it provides the synthesis of ultrathin films with a minimum impurities, greater flexibility in the alloy synthesis, ease of control of process parameters, and the possibility of creating a nanostructured film [
50,
51].
However, another significant problem of hydrogen membrane separation today is the extremely small and unstable or non-existent permeability of palladium-containing membranes at low temperatures (less than 200 °C). This fact is caused by the kinetic inhibition of establishing the equilibrium of metal-hydrogen systems, which is mainly due to an inactive or contaminated metal surface [
52]. In this case, surface processes limit the hydrogen transport. The limit, which slows down the establishment of equilibrium between molecular hydrogen in the gas phase and atomic hydrogen absorbed in the palladium phase, can be partially overcome by increasing the surface roughness coefficient. "Catalytically active" cracks facilitates the establishment of equilibrium with hydrogen gas. They occur during alternating electrolytic oxidation and reduction, prolonged exposure to a glow discharge or calcination in air. So N. Vicinanza et al. [
53] subjected Pd77%Ag23% membranes to a three-stage air heat treatment to investigate the positive effects of such treatment on hydrogen transfer. It was found that air heat treatment affects the roughness and increases the effective membrane surface area, which increases the hydrogen permeability after each of the stages. In particular, surface activation can be carried out by applying a "hydrogen carriers" coating (modifier). There are various methods such as the reduction of metal ions in solution, growth in the gas phase, evaporation on a substrate, electrochemical deposition, which are promising for obtaining modifying coatings. "Hydrogen carriers" are hydrogen chemisorbing substances such as platinum metals [
54]. The nanostructured palladium layer formation on the membrane surface will increase the actual working surface area, thus lead to an increase in the chemisorption centers number [
55,
56]. The deposition of a modifier based on pentagonal structured multiply twinned nanoparticles is particular interesting and effective. Membranes modified with such a coating make it possible to increase hydrogen permeability by several times in the low-temperature operating range [
57,
58]. The novelty of the work is to study of the effect of surface modifiers of various morphologies on membrane materials in the low-temperature hydrogen transport.
In according to the foregoing, the aim of this work was to intensify the process of low-temperature hydrogen permeability of palladium-copper membranes by modifying the surface with a nanostructured coating, which is pentagonal multiply twinned palladium-gold particles.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Methods for Creating and Studying Membrane Materials
Thin films of the Pd-40%Cu alloy were obtained by three methods:
The first method was to obtain a homogeneous Pd-Cu alloy by melting the constituent metal components of palladium and copper in an electric arc furnace in an inert argon atmosphere. Metals in the form of Pd ingots and oxygen-free copper were get to a copper crucible for melting. The pressure inside the chamber was 0.05 MPa. In the melting process, the inverter current was increasing from 30 to 90 A. Next, the obtained Pd-40%Cu ingot was rolled out on rollers to a film thickness of 20 μm with intermediate annealings.
The second method consisted in obtaining dense defect-free films of the Pd-Cu alloy with thickness up to 300 nm on a hydrogen-permeable substrate from an aluminium oxide by magnetron sputtering from a continuous Pd-40%Cu target. The target was obtained by the first method by alloying components and rolling up to 40 µm with intermediate annealing. The films were deposited at a current of 40–50 mA on both sides of the substrate.
The third method for obtaining Pd-40%Cu on the base surface completely repeats the previous one. However, the main difference between the third method and the second one is the usage of a composite target consisting of palladium and copper plates with an area ratio of 60:40. The main advantage of this method is easily changing of the elements percentage in the alloy without the melting procedure and any changes in the resulting alloy structure.
The obtained films phase composition was determined on a Shimadzu XRD-7000 X-ray diffractometer. The samples were studied in the range of 2θ angles from 30° to 80° with a scanning step of 0.02° using CuKα radiation (λ = 1.5406 Å) at a current of 30 mA and an accelerating voltage of 40 kV.
2.2. Synthesis and Study of the Morphology of Nanostructured Coatings
Modification of the developed Pd-40%Cu alloy films was carried out by two methods:
The first method – classical palladium black – was carried out using electrochemical deposition from a palladium chloride solution using a potentiostat-galvanostat Elins P-40X. Palladium-copper films were preliminarily prepared by washing and degreasing, after which samples were fixed in an electrolytic cell for polarization. Anode polarization was carried out in HCl at a current density of 10 mA cm–2, then cathodic polarization was carried out in H2SO4 at the same current. After pretreatment, the cell with prepared electrodes was filled with a palladium chloride solution. Deposition was carried out at a current density of 6 mA cm–2 on both sides of the films.
The second method – Pd-Au nanoflowers – was based on the classical palladium black method; so the synthesis was carried out according to a similar algorithm. A significant difference from the previous method was the synthesis process itself. The prepared electrodes were placed in a working cell filled with a growth solution of palladium chloride with a surfactant tetrabutylammonium bromide. Electrodeposition was carried out from a palladium-gold alloy electrode at a current density of 3 mA cm–2 on both sides of the films to obtain palladium-gold particles.
The samples surface morphology was investigated by a JEOL JSM-7500F scanning electron microscope.
2.3. Study of Developed Materials in Catalytic and Membrane Applications
Cyclic voltammetry (CV) in the alkaline methanol oxidation reaction in the potential range from –0.9 to + 0.5 V at a scanning rate of 50 mV s–1 investigated the catalytic activity of the modified films. The composition of the working solution is 1 M NaOH + 0.5 M methanol. The measurements were carried out on a P-40X potentiostat-galvanostat in a three-electrode cell: the working electrode was each sample of modified Pd-40%Cu films, the counter electrode was a platinum electrode, and the reference electrode was a silver chloride glass electrode (Ag/AgCl), relative to which the potentials were reported.
The long-term stability of the developed nanoparticles as catalysts was studied by chronoamperometry in the reaction of alkaline methanol oxidation at a constant potential of -0.3 V during 0–2400 s.
The study of the hydrogen transfer processes through the developed samples of membrane materials was carried out by the special measuring hydrogen permeability device according to the method described in the work [
59].