1. Introduction
Arterio-venous bypass surgery is one of the main approaches for revascularization of chronic limb-threatening ischemia (CLTI) patients. However, veins are not designed to support arterial pressure and undergo significant vascular remodeling to adapt to the arterial environment. This remodeling is accompanied by the development of intimal hyperplasia (IH), i.e., the formation of a collagen-rich neointima layer between the media and the innermost layer (intima/endothelium) of the vein. IH is due to a cascade of cellular events leading to the differentiation, proliferation, and migration of vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMC) from the vessel wall into the intima [
1]. This excessive cell growth and collagen deposition eventually lead to reduced blood flow (restenosis) or occlusion of the bypass.
30 to 50% of the saphenous grafts fail 1–18 months after the implantation [
2]
.
Hydrogen sulfide (H
2S) contributes to the homeostasis of a wide range of systems, including the cardiovascular systems [
3]. Notably, endogenous H
2S bioavailability is attenuated in patients with CLTI and in patients with diabetes-related vascular inflammation [
4]. Circulating H
2S is also reduced in humans suffering from vascular occlusive disease [
5,
6], and patients undergoing surgical revascularization with lower H
2S production capacity have higher postoperative mortality rates [
7].
H
2S is produced in mammalian cells through the reverse transulfuration pathway by two pyridoxal 5ʹ-phosphate dependent enzymes, cystathionine γ-lyase (CSE) and cystathionine β-synthase (CBS), and by a combination of two additional enzymes, 3-mercaptopyruvate sulfurtransferase (3-MST) and cysteine aminotransferase (CAT). Mice lacking Cse display increased IH in a model of carotid artery ligation [
8,
9]. On the contrary, Cse overexpression decreases IH formation in a murine model of vein graft by carotid-interposition cuff technique [
10]. In addition, we and others demonstrated that systemic treatment using diverse H
2S donors inhibit IH
in vivo in various models in rats [
11], rabbits [
12] and mice [
8,
9,
13]. We also showed that several H
2S donors inhibit IH
ex vivo in human vein segments [
9,
13,
14]. The study of Cse
-/- mice supports that CSE expression in endothelial cells (EC) is the main source of endogenous H
2S production in vessels [
15,
16,
17,
18]. However, CSE expression has also been found in VMSC, and may contribute to VSMC proliferation and migration, vascular remodeling and IH [
8,
19]. CBS is also found in the cardiovascular system, but its role and distribution in vessels is unclear [
3]. Other reports suggest a key role of 3-MST in H
2S production in the vascular endothelium [
20]. It was recently demonstrated that Cse expression is negatively regulated by shear stress
in vitro [
21]. This is in line with a previous study showing that only disturbed flow regions show discernible CSE protein expression after carotid artery ligation in the mouse [
22]. However, the expression of CSE in human vessels remains poorly characterized. In this study, we studied the expression and regulation of CSE, CBS and 3MST in segments from healthy human saphenous vein and artery. We observed that CSE is expressed both in the endothelium and media of large vessels, while CBS expression is detectable only in the media, and 3-MST expression is mainly restricted to the endothelium of small vessels. Our data confirms that CSE expression in vein is negatively regulated by shear stress and, as a result, upregulated in absence of flow and downregulated in vein segments placed under arterial perfusion. We further confirm that CSE is involved in primary human VSMC migration, but not proliferation.
4. Discussion
Endogenous H
2S production in mammals results from the oxidation of the sulfur-containing amino acids cysteine and homocysteine via the reverse ''trans-sulfuration'' pathway mainly via CSE and CBS, and 3-MST. Although the enzymes and pathways responsible for H
2S production are well described, little is known about their regulation in pathophysiologic conditions. In this study, we investigated the expression and regulation of CSE, CBS and 3-MST in segments of human saphenous vein and artery. CBS was mainly detected in the media layer of human vessels. In contrast, 3-MST was mainly detected in the endothelium and in the EC of small vessels of the vasa vasorum in both arteries and veins. This suggests a more prominent role of 3-MST in EC of small caliber vessels and capillaries, which is consistent with previous studies suggesting a key role for 3-MST in EC [
20]. 3-MST is also expressed in the media of arteries, but not the media of veins, indicating differential regulation of 3-MST in arterial and venous vessels. Rodent studies suggest that CSE is mainly expressed in EC in the cardiovascular system and that the endothelium is the main source of H
2S in blood vessels [
15,
16,
17,
18,
37]. That said, CSE has also been described in VSMC and proposed to be a functional, albeit minor source of H
2S [
8,
19,
38]. Here, CSE was expressed in the endothelium of large vessels, and in small vessels of the vasa vasorum in native human artery and vein. CSE was also abundant in the media layer.
We then investigated the regulation of the three enzymes in vein segments placed in
ex vivo culture. CBS protein expression was reduced in vein segments placed in pathological culture conditions
ex vivo, both in the absence of flow and in high pressure flow. This indicates that shear stress does not regulate CBS expression in VSMC. Interestingly, while CBS protein levels were lower, CBS mRNA levels were increased in
ex vivo culture, suggesting a differential regulation of mRNA and protein expression and a possible effect of
ex vivo culture on protein stability. However, histological analysis suggested a more complex regulation, as CBS was no longer detected in most cells, while it was overexpressed in a few cells present in the media and neointimal layer. Further studies are required to determine which cells overexpress CBS when most cells in the media and neointima appear to down-regulate CBS expression. This is of particular interest as adult VSMC are highly plastic cells [
39], and the switch from a quiescent 'contractile' phenotype to a proliferative 'synthetic' phenotype plays a major role in the context of IH [
40]. Recent VSMC lineage tracing studies in mice using
in vivo cell fate tracing with SMC-specific genetic reporter tools suggest that a small subset of VSMCs expand after injury to form clonal patches of neointimal cells [
41,
42,
43]. Further studies are required to elucidate the identity of this small subset of VSMCs in human tissue, and whether CBS is expressed or not in this subset in the context of IH.
3-MST mRNA and protein expression were severely reduced by
ex vivo perfusion of vein segments, independent of flow and shear stress. This is not surprising as our model of
ex vivo culture results in endothelial dysfunction and rapid loss of endothelial-specific markers [
26,
27,
44]. However, static
ex vivo culture tended to stimulate 3-MST mRNA and protein expression despite severe endothelial dysfunction. This suggests that 3-MST may be negatively regulated by shear stress in a similar way to CSE. 3-MST was largely undetectable in the media layer of veins, but it was detectable in the media of arteries, suggesting that 3-MST plays a role in arterial VSMC, but that high shear stress per se does not negatively regulate 3-MST expression. 3-MST was overexpressed in VSMC in veins in static condition and in cultured VSMC
in vitro, suggesting that 3-MST could be involved in VSMC reprogramming in the context of IH. However, arterial perfusion prevented 3-MST expression, so it is unlikely that 3-MST play a main role in IH
in vivo. In a recent study, 3-MST was found to be expressed in VSMC and cardiomyocytes, and 3-Mst
-/- mice were protected against myocardial ischemia-reperfusion injury [
45]. Further studies are required to better characterize the role and regulation of 3-MST in VSMC.
About CSE, our data confirm that CSE is negatively regulated by shear stress. Using our model of
ex vivo vein perfusion, we observed that high pressure inhibits CSE expression both in the media and in the endothelium. In contrast, static
ex vivo vein culture stimulates CSE expression. This is in line with previous evidence showing that CSE expression is downregulated by high shear stress and is predominantly found in regions of disturbed flow.[
21,
22]. However, we did not observe higher levels of CSE in native human vein segments compared to aortic segments, despite the high shear stress in arteries. In fact, CSE, CBS, and 3MST levels were higher in arteries than in veins. However, this could be due to a higher cell content in arterial tissue compared to venous tissue, which contains more connective tissue than arteries. Consistent with this hypothesis, higher CSE levels did not translate into higher CSE activity as measured by the lead acetate assay. Interestingly, this regulation by shear stress is not unique to EC and was also observed in VSMC. Further studies are needed to better understand the regulation of CSE expression in vein and artery, specifically in VSMC and EC.
Given that CSE is highly expressed in VSMC and downregulated by high-pressure perfusion in veins, we further investigated the role of CSE in human primary venous VSMC. We document that CSE is a specific modulator of VSMC function independent of EC or EC-derived H
2S production, and that CSE controls the migration of primary human VSMC. This is in agreement with studies showing that VSMCs isolated from Cse
-/- mice are more motile than their WT counterparts, and that blocking Cse activity with PAG in VSMC increases cell migration [
8,
19]. We and others reported that H
2S donors inhibits VSMC proliferation [
12,
14,
36]. Here, we did not observe a significant effect of CSE on cell proliferation. This contrasts with a previous study showing that Cse overexpression decreased proliferation and even induced VSMC apoptosis. This discrepancy probably results from the level of Cse overexpression, which was much higher in the previous study by Yang et al. [
36]. In this study, the authors used arterial VSMC, whereas we used venous VSMC. Venous and arterial VSMC are functionally different so the venous versus arterial origin of VSMC may also contributes to the discrepancies in our results. Nevertheless, it would not be surprising if higher CSE expression and activity, leading to greater H
2S production, resulted in cell apoptosis. Indeed, elevated levels of H
2S are known to induce cell cycle arrest and apoptosis [
46]. Note that evidence suggests that the threshold for the pro-apoptotic effect of CSE and H
2S may differ depending on the cell type [
8,
19], which may reflect cell specific sulfur metabolism and H
2S detoxifying capacities.
The mechanisms whereby H
2S affect VSMC proliferation and/or migration are not fully understood. Cytotoxic CSE overexpression or exogenous H
2S supplementation induces VSMC cycle arrest and apoptosis by stimulating ERK1/2, p38 MAPK, and p21 Cip [
36]. Exogenous H
2S donor treatment in VSMC has also been shown to inhibit the MAPK pathway, especially ERK1,2, and the mTOR pathways, which correlates with reduced VSMC proliferation and migration [
13]. Here, no effects on ERK and mTOR signaling were observed upon CSE manipulation. This probably reflects the more subtle CSE variation in our experimental design compared with exogenous H
2S supply or high Cse overexpression in previous studies. Rather than a physiological response to Cse-derived H
2S, the effect of Cse overexpression on VSMC proliferation may be due to cell cycle arrest associated with a cytotoxic effect of H
2S. In accordance with this hypothesis, it was previously shown that inhibition of ERK did not prevent the effect of NaHS on VSMC migration [
8], while ERK inhibition was instrumental in the effect of Cse and H
2S on VSMC proliferation [
36]. Of note, several studies in EC also reported that Cse regulates cell migration, but not proliferation [
30,
47]. We propose that low levels of H
2S affect VSMC migration without affecting their proliferation. Our main finding is that CSE variations reshape VSMC, suggesting an effect on the cytoskeleton and interaction with the ECM. This is consistent with our previous finding that H
2S donors inhibit microtubule polymerization in VSMC [
9], and the findings that CSE deficiency in mouse VSMC results in increased expressions of β1-integrin and increased migration [
8]. In EC, it was recently shown that integrins are extensively sulfhydrated, and that β3 integrin S-sulfhydration promotes adhesion and is required for EC alignment with flow [
48]. In this study, they further demonstrated that Cse deficiency in EC leads to overactivation of RhoA, a major hub regulating cell migration and adhesion. Interestingly, β3-integrin is also expressed in VMSC and β3-integrin signaling is instrumental for enhanced VSMC proliferation and migration in vascular disease [
49,
50]. We hypothesize that CSE-mediated integrin sulfhydration promotes VSMC adhesion, thereby limiting migration. Further studies are needed to determine the exact role and balance between β1- and β3-integrins and RhoA signaling in the regulation of cell migration by CSE in VSMC.
The fact that high pressure inhibits CSE expression in vein segments suggests that CSE downregulation occurs in vivo in arterio-venous bypass grafts, which contributes to VSMC migration and graft IH.