Introduction
SCD is a global health issue affecting millions of people [
1,
2]. The highest prevalence is in Africa with Nigeria being identified as the epicenter, having 4 to 6 million affected individuals [
3]. Fraiwan
et al. [
4] reported that approximately 150,000 children with SCD are born each year in Nigeria with 70-90 % dying before the age of five.
Sickle cell disease (SCD) is a genetic haemoglobinopathy which is passed down to children from parents who are carriers [
5]. Haemoglobin SS, is the most clinically severe subtype [
6,
7,
8], and it has now been well established that the disorder is not only a rheological disease but is also characterized by chronic inflammation and oxidative stress. These processes lead to the development of vasculopathy and several other chronic complications [
9]. SCD is caused by a single-point mutation in the gene encoding for the β-globin chain resulting in the replacement of glutamic acid with valine [
10,
11]. The consequence of this mutation is the production of an abnormal haemoglobin (HbS), which polymerizes in low oxygen concentrations [
12,
13] and results in the dysfunction and deformation of the red blood cells to a sickle shape form [
2,
9].
Haemoglobin polymerization triggers a sequence of events leading to several complications, including vascular-endothelial dysfunction, anti-inflammatory (nitric oxide) deficiency, inflammation, oxidative stress, hypercoagulability, and recurrent immune cell activation [
2,
14,
15]. These events result in an elevation of free radicals through the release of free haemoglobin, heme, and activation of pro-oxidant enzymes [
2,
16]. Excessive free radicals contribute to increased oxidative stress, which induces chronic inflammation and a reduced life expectancy [
17].
Patients with SCD require regular blood transfusions which increases exposure to foreign antigens and elevates the risk of producing alloantibodies that may cause delayed hemolytic transfusion responses and make it difficult to find suitable blood [
18,
19,
20]. Moreover, it has been reported that multiple blood transfusions may lead to transfusion transmitted infections, inflammation and iron overload [
21,
22]. These factors all influence the pathogenesis and development of SCD, however the consequences of a dysregulated immune system are complex and therefore further investigation is required [
23,
24].
The innate and adaptive immune responses in SCD are impaired and cannot effectively protect against infection [
25,
26] with some researchers reporting that persistent activation of the innate immune system results in the generation of excessive amounts of reactive oxygen species (13, 28-30). According to Ahmad and Ahsan [
27], Engwa
et al. [
28] and Atiku
et al. [
10] elevated amounts of reactive species induce oxidative stress and tissue injury while other reports have revealed that the adaptive immune cells are also dysfunctional resulting in lower antibody levels compared to healthy individuals [
24]. In addition, preliminary studies have revealed that the number of T and B cells as well as their function are impaired [
24,
26,
29]. Based on these investigations, this review aims to examine the current literature and provide an updated understanding of the relationship between the immune response, inflammation, oxidative stress, blood transfusion, and the pathogenesis of SCD.
Immune mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of sickle cell anaemia
Leukocytes such as neutrophils, eosinophils, basophils, monocytes, lymphocytes, and platelets have been implicated in the pathogenesis of SCD, as evidenced by several studies [
23,
24,
30,
31]. These cells are reported to be responsible for promoting inflammation, adhesion, and the painful crises characteristic of SCD [
23,
32]. Even in the absence of infection, leukocytosis and immune activation is a common phenomenon. In support of this, studies using flow cytometry were adopted to analyse peripheral blood neutrophils for expression of CD18. CD18 is upregulated during inflammation and binds to the adhesion molecules ICAM-1 and ICAM-4 on the endothelium resulting in activation and inflammation. These experiments revealed that CD18 expression was increased in SCD patients and that the neutrophils had a higher affinity for the vascular endothelium and increased adherence which resulted in the recruitment of sickled red cells and an elevated risk of vaso-occlusive crises [
33,
34].
Further contributions have demonstrated that polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs), have high CD64 expression and elevated levels of L-selectin, SCD16 and elastase resulting in further amplification of the adhesiveness to the endothelium [
35]. According to Antwi-boasiako
et al. [
36] both male and female SCD patients who experience complications have noticeably higher leukocyte counts than their healthy counterparts with the white blood cell count frequently being used by clinicians to predict stroke and acute chest syndrome [
37]. Free haemoglobin and heme released during hemolysis have been identified as key players in the activation of the innate and adaptive immune response [
9,
23] and reports suggest that patients with high hemolysis rates are at greater risk of early mortality [
2,
19]. The continual breakdown and destruction of red blood cells result in sustained activation of innate immune cells resulting in a chronic inflammatory state [
24,
38,
39].
Endothelial cells are one of the first cell types to be activated in the presence of heme. Heme activates endothelial cells inducing the expression of adhesion molecules (E-selectin, intercellular P-selectin, vascular cell adhesion molecule 1, which initiates the activation and recruitment of other immune cells, including macrophages, neutrophils, mast cells, and platelets. The activated macrophages secrete several pro-inflammatory cytokines, including IL-1β, through stimulation of the NLRP3 inflammasome which further contributes to the creation of a pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant enviroment [
23]. Consequently, this sustained inflammatory state results in a vaso-occlusive crisis which is commonly described in patients with SCD [
15,
40].
Heme also has a direct link with the activation of neutrophils by acting as a prototypical pro-inflammatory molecule and recruits neutrophils to the site of injury via the stimulation of protein kinase C and ROS generation [
2,
15]. In addition, heme inhibits neutrophil apoptosis via modulation of phosphoinositide 3-kinase and NF-κB signaling, which further contributes to the development of chronic inflammation [
41]. Neutrophils have been identified as playing a significant role in the development of VOC with increased counts being associated with clinical complications, including earlier death and hemorrhagic stroke [
40].
Platelets, which are small anucleate cells and play a role in the immune response , have also been implicated in the pathogenesis of SCD. Malik [
42] and Nolfi
et al [
43] reported that platelet activation together with a decrease in nitric oxide (NO) is triggered by the release of heme into the circulation. Once activated, the platelets release several soluble mediators such as CD40 ligand and thrombospondin which have the potential to iniate thrombosis and pulmonary hypertension [
23,
42]. Molecules secreted by the platelet bind to CD36, also known as glycoprotein IV, on sickled RBCs and endothelial cells. Platelets go on to associate and bind to other immune cells, including neutrophils, macrophages, and monocytes [
39]. It has been demonstrated that activated platelets bind to neutrophils and monocytes in a P-selectin signaling pathway to form aggregates that promote VOC, inflammation, and thrombosis through various mechanisms [
30]. In SCD mice, Allali
et al. [
23] reported that platelet-neutrophil aggregates may be an important factor in the development of pulmonary arteriole microemboli.
Although many studies have investigated the role of the innate immune system, the role of the adaptive immune response is still poorly understood. Studies performed on human and animal subjects have reported that, in SCD, both T and B lymphocytes are dysfunctional [
44,
45]. To further analyze this, the relationship between splenic size and lymphocyte counts have been investigated by several researchers [
24,
46,
47,
48,
49]. Ojo
et al. [
50] used flow cytometry to analyze CD4+ T-lymphocytes in blood samples from 40 steady state SCD patients and correlated the counts with ultrasonography used to determine spleen size. They reported that in patients with auto splenectomy, the mean CD4+ count was not significantly different to HbS patients with a normal-sized spleen. Several studies have further investigated the effect of hydroxyurea (HU) on lymphocyte subset counts [
45,
51,
52] and have shown that SCD patients receiving HU had lower total lymphocytes, T cells, CD4+ T cells, memory CD4+ T cells, and memory CD8+ T cells compared to those who were untreated [
24]. These findings may be explained by the fact that Hydroxyurea is often used as a chemotherapeutic drug and acts by inhibiting DNA synthesis resulting in cytotoxity and cell death.
Alloimmunization is an important complication resulting from chronic blood transfusions. Studies investigating the effects of alloimmunization on the lymphocyte counts of patients with SCD have reported significant changes [
24,
47,
53,
54,
55,
56]. One such study demonstrated a significant decline in regulatory CD4+ T lymphocytes and an increase in regulatory CD8+ T lymphocytes [
57], suggesting that these patients may be at risk of developing autoimmunity.
Further investigations of the B cell lineage have demonstrated that they are also functionally abnormal. Abnormalities include decreased antigen-specific B cell proliferation and IgM secretion. According to Ochocinski
et al. [
29] defects in B cell lymphocyte function in children affect the production of natural anti-polysaccharide antibodies, making children with SCD more susceptible to infection and disease.
Autoimmunity in Sickle cell disease
Autoimmunity is a disorder in which the immune response is directed against its own normal body constituents such as cells and tissues. Any disease resulting from this dysregulated immune response is termed an autoimmune disease and can be as a result of antibodies produced by B lymphocytes or the action of T lymphocytes directed against normal tissue. Patients with SCD often exhibit aberrant activation of the alternate complement pathway which can lead to higher risks of infection and is thought to predispose patients to autoimmune disease (AID) [
58]. In healthy individuals, the prevalence of antinuclear antibodies vary with incidences of between 12 and 30% [
59] while in Africa, the prevalence is higher and ranges from 7 to 39% [
60].
In patients with SCD high autoantibody titres have been observed even in the absence of clinical autoimmunity [
61,
62]. The mechanisms leading to the formation of these autoantibodies are unclear but may involve impaired splenic function. The spleen has several purposes which include the removal of old and damaged red cells as well as the regulation of the immune response. The importance of the spleen in preventing the development of autoimmune processes has been demonstrated in studies which have documented high autoantibody titres after splenectomy [
63]. Moreover, chronic inflammation [
28] and alloimmunization by multiple transfusions have also been implicated in the development of autoantibodies but these have not been fully confirmed in clinical studies [
27,
61,
62]). The coexistence of SCD and autoimmune disease is difficult to treat as those receiving steroids, which is used to control the inflammatory response, experience repeated vaso-occlusive crises [
64,
65,
66]. In confirmation of this, Bernini et al. [
67] reported on 4 cases of SCD who received increased doses of corticosteroids during pain crises and chest pain syndrome. Although the treatment shortened the period of complication, the high dosage resulted in severe VOC episodes and haemorrhagic stroke. Likewise, recurrent blood transfusions or exchange transfusions although assisting in the prevention of vaso-occlusive crises leads to increased risks of antigenic alloimmunization. [
68]. Biological therapies such as anti – TNF hydroxyurea and haemopoietic stem cell transplantation may be better therapeutic choices [
69].
The role of oxidative stress in the pathogenesis of sickle cell anemia
Oxidative stress is an important contributor to the pathogenesis of sickle cell anaemia (SCD) and associated complications such as sickling, vaso-occlusion, and ischemia-reperfusion injury [
2,
27,
36,
70,
71]. Oxidative stress occurs due to an imbalance between the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) and the ability of antioxidant agents, including enzymes such as superoxide dismutases, catalase, and glutathione peroxidase, to neutralize them [
28,
36,
72]. Patients with SCD are frequently exposed to oxidative stress, and studies have found higher levels of ROS in RBCs of SCD patients compared to healthy controls. The concentration of the reactive intermediates generated from the oxidative reactions have often been used as markers of disease severity [
28,
73] and the mechanisms leading to oxidative stress in SCD patients' red blood cells (RBCs) are well established. Some of these include haemoglobin (Hb) autoxidation. When SaQ1234567890 */haemoglobin is released into the bloodstream as a result of haemolysis, superoxide (O
-2) is produced, which can dismutate into hydrogen peroxide (H
2O
2) and serve as a starting point for additional oxidative reactions [
9,
74]. Apart from haemoglobin (Hb) oxidation, other factors enhancing ROS production include ischemia-reperfusion injury caused by oxygen deprivation [
12] which has been reported to promote the activation of proinflammatory mediators such as xanthine oxidase, NADPH oxidase, nitric oxide synthase, and lipoxygenase [
2,
28]. Another factor contributing to the excessive ROS in SCD patients is the release of iron and heme from unstable HbS, which may catalyze the Fenton reaction. Iron (II) will react with hydrogen peroxide ions leading to the formation of ion (III) and hydroxyl radical [
12].
Figure 1 illustrates each of the above mechanisms.
To counteract radicals, the body produces antioxidants [
38,
76,
77]. These include non-enzymatic antioxidants such as microelements carotenoids, ascorbic acid [
78], enzymatic antioxidants including dismutase, catalase, glutathione peroxidase and heme oxygenase-1 [
2,
28]. However, due to the high levels of oxidative stress in SCD patients, antioxidants are overwhelmed by the continual source of ROS. Some unneutralized ROS have been reported to oxidize membrane lipids, proteins, and DNA causing cell death and organ damage [
79]. This damage leads to further ROS production, thereby aggravating the disease. The oxidative damage to lipids known as lipid peroxidation happens when membrane phospholipids are exposed to a hydroxyl radical (HO
•) and hydroperoxyl (HO
• 2), which have been reported as the two most prevalent ROS affecting lipids [
80,
81]. During lipid peroxidation, highly toxic molecule end products, including malondialdehyde (MDA) and 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal (HNE), can easily interact with proteins and DNA, causing damage [
2,
78]. Malondialdehyde (MDA) is an important marker for evaluating oxidative stress in patients with SCD [
28]. A study in Cameroon observed an increase in MDA in SCD patients compared to healthy individuals [
82]. Similarly, in Ghana, Antwi-Boasiako
et al. [
36] reported that MDA levels were significantly higher in SCD patients with vaso-occlusive crises, followed by patients in steady-state. F
2-isoprostanes, as a marker of oxidative stress, has been reported to be higher in sickle cell patients compared to healthy controls [
83,
84]. Nader et al, 2020 [
85] assessed the contributions of NO and oxidative stress on eryptosis (apoptosis of red cells), and the release of RBC-Mp’s on vascular dysfunction. It was reported that oxidative stress initiates eryptosis and the release of MP’s generated during this process may be significant in macrovascular dysfunction. RBC-MP’s could be harmful to the microcirculation’s endothelial cells by activating toll-like receptor-4 (TLR4) and promoting the expression of adhesion molecules as well as the release of cytokines which in turn fuels vascular dysfunction. Although this investigation offers fresh insight into the underlying processes of vascular dysfunction in SCD, more research is required. New therapeutic targets that aim to prevent eryptosis and /or TLR4 activation are suggested [
85].
Oxidative stress in SCD is associated with worsening symptoms, including accelerated haemolysis [
86], endothelial damage [
80], decreased NO bioavailability [
2], and hypercoagulability [
87]. Oxidative stress is inevitable in a patient with SCD; however, antioxidant therapeutic strategies, including the use of L-glutamine, N-acetylcysteine, and manganese porphyrins, have the potential to reduce the detrimental effects [
70].
The role of inflammation in the pathogenesis of sickle cell anaemia
Inflammation is the body’s natural response to toxic chemicals, infection, and injury. Although it is difficult to determine the exact events that trigger the chronic inflammatory state in sickle cell disease (SCD), some mechanisms have been reported [
31,
45]. The sources of inflammation in SCD include red cell alterations, haemolysis, vaso-occlusive processes, ischemia-reperfusion injury, infections, release of histamine, oxidative stress, thrombin generation and activation of complement [
31,
84]. Many reported complications such as acute chest syndrome, stroke, leg ulcers, nephropathy, and pulmonary hypertension, have been linked to inflammatory processes [
88].
Haemolysis is the major inflammatory trigger affecting the bioavailability and function of anti-inflammatory molecules such as nitric oxide (NO) and heme oxygenase 1 (HO-1) [
87,
89,
90]. Heme oxygenase 1 (HO-1) is an enzyme with numerous anti-inflammatory properties, including the breakdown of heme and the generation and release of reaction products, including carbon monoxide, ferrous ions, and biliverdin [
91,
92,
93,
94,
95]. Continuous haemolysis leads to the overproduction of heme which in turn accelerates the HO reaction, causing excessive accumulation of reaction products and if not sufficiently sequestered, will have serious consequences [
91]. During haemolysis, free haemoglobin and heme destroy nitric oxide (NO) produced by endothelial nitric oxide synthase. Nitric oxide functions in preventing endothelial activation as well as controlling leukocyte activation and emigration from blood vessels to tissue [
2]. Researchers have demonstrated that free haemoglobin in the plasma destroys NO 1,000-fold faster than haemoglobin encapsulated within the red blood cells [
9].
Neutrophils are one of the first cells to respond to infections. Their movement to the site of injury is triggered by Pathogen Associated Molecular Patterns (PAMPs) from microbes or Damage Associated Molecular Patterns (DAMPs) derived from damaged host cells. Activated neutrophils release ROS, proteases, myeloperoxidase, defensins, cathepsin G, and elastase to combat foreign organisms at the site of infection [
96]. These enzymatic proteins are all involved in inflammatory processes [
97] and when cell adhesion takes place, chemokines and cytokines are produced which go on to stimulate dendritic cells resulting in presentation of antigen to memory CD4
+ T cell as well as to naïve CD8+ T cells. This leads to activation of the adaptive immune response [
98].
ROS, produced by activated neutrophils hinders the function of effector NK cells, while GM-CSF cytokines and IFN-γ produced by NK cells, prolong the survival of neutrophils in an in vitro system [
99].
Due to the prominent role neutrophils play in the inflammatory response it has been hypothesised that they could be important in the response to plasma methaemoglobin prodused during haemolysis. This was investigated and the results showed that methaemoglobin is an endogenous DAMP ligand for TLR2 and that neutrophils actively respond to (metHb + LTA) induced production of ROS. Interestingly, it was also observed that this response diminishes in the presence of other white cells indicating that cells of the immune system communicate with each other to modulate cellular responses during a haemolytic reaction [
100]
Vaso-occlusive crises (VOC), occurs when sickled red blood cells obstruct blood flow to the tissues [
24,
101,
102]. This, in turn, triggers an inflammatory reaction as the body attempts to correct the condition. In SCD, vaso-occlusive processes generate ischemia-reperfusion injury, known as tissue damage, caused by a disruption in blood supply [
2,
102,
103]. Ischemia-reperfusion damage increases oxidant generation and leukocyte adhesion, contributing to chronic inflammation.
Transforming growth factor (TGF-), interleukin-17 (IL-17), Tumor necrosis factor (TNF-), IL-6, and IL-8 are all significantly elevated in steady state SCD patients when compared to controls. These studies all confirm the chronic inflammatory environment present in patients with SCD; [
40,
103].
The relationship and interdependence between inflammation and oxidative stress in SCD
Comprehensive studies have demonstrated that oxidative stress and inflammation are closely linked [
76,
81,
104]. Both mechanisms occur concurrently in many pathological conditions, including sickle cell disease (SCD), resulting in a vicious cycle that aggravates the disease [
9,
105]. Several factors contribute to the overproduction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in SCD, which, if not immediately sequestered, can create a chain reaction that results in chronic inflammation [
12,
76]. Oxidative stress can activate a wide range of transcription factors and receptors, such as nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB) and activator protein-1 (AP-1) [
75,
76], which control the expression of a wide variety of genes, including those responsible for producing pro-inflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines [
75,
106].
Pattern recognition receptor toll receptor 4 (TLR4) triggers the innate and adaptive immune response by promoting the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines like TNF, IL-1, and IL-6, IL-12. This process can be activated by oxidative stress and thus leads to inflammation [
71,
107]. Cell-free haemoglobin, derived from sickle RBCs, contributes to vascular dysfunction by promoting inflammation via the activation of TLR4 [
9,
12]. Besides the direct activation of transcription factors and receptors damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) released during haemolysis cause damage to some biomolecules and promote inflammation through the NF-𝜅B pathway [
108]. Hydrogen peroxide, for example, can react with nitric oxide (NO) to form peroxynitrite, a highly reactive oxidizing and nitrating agent capable of damaging lipids, DNA, and protein. These reactions promote cellular necrosis and apoptosis [
31].
On the other hand, chronic inflammation can induce oxidative stress through the continuous activation of immune cells [
71,
76,
109]. At the site of injury, immune cells such as phagocytic and non-phagocytic cells release reactive oxygen species (hydrogen radical, superoxide, hydrogen peroxide, etc.), chemical mediators (cytokines, nitric oxide, etc.), and enzymes (lipases, phosphatases, etc.) contributing to higher oxidative stress [
110,
111,
112]. Nonphagocytic cells have been reported to generate reactive species in response to proinflammatory cytokines, leading to an imbalance between proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines leading to oxidative stress [
27,
81].
Figure 2 depicts the relationship between oxidative stress and inflammation in SCD. If oxidative stress appears as the primary abnormality, it will stimulate inflammation which will further induce oxidative stress and vice versa.
Due to the interaction between oxidative stress and inflammation, some researchers have discovered that using antioxidants to treat only oxidative stress may not always be successful [
2,
15,
70]. Inflammation and oxidative stress work together to amplify each other and cause progressive damage once the process begins. Finding antioxidants that can simultaneously prevent oxidative and inflammatory pathways has proven to be difficult. Hence a comprehensive understanding of these pathological events could contribute to developing novel therapeutics.
The cause of high alloimmunization in SCD patients
Alloimmunization is prevalent in SCD patients and increases with the number of blood transfusions, age of the first transfusion, genetics and sex. [
54]. Thompson
et al. [
54] linked high alloimmunization in SCD patients to the presence of chronic inflammatory disorders which triggers the development of auto-antibodies and alloimmunization. Low expression of CD64 (FcyR1) in classical and intermediate monocytes and the inflammatory milieu found in SCD patients have also been shown to contribute to their high alloimmunization [
114]. Another reason for the development of antibodies is the miss-match between the donor and the recipient which becomes important when choosing donors. Reports from studies in Uganda, Burkina Faso, and Egypt showed that alloimmunization is lower possibly because both donor and recipient belong to the same ethnic group [
56,
88]. This hypothesis was supported by a study conducted in Cape Town which reported an increase in alloimmunization attributed to donors and recipients being from different ethnicity. [
54]. Other mechanisms implicated in the development of alloantibodies could be iron overload and pregnancy.
Pretransfusion antibody screening typically includes Rhesus and ABO grouping. However, other blood group systems,[ including Kell, Kidd, Duffy, Lewis, Lutheran, P, and MNS, often regarded as minority or weak blood groups, have been linked to alloimmunization or antibody formation [
115,
116]. Considering this, it has become imperative that routine blood grouping should include other blood group antigens for effective, complete, and accurate pretransfusion screening. This is crucial in the case of sickle cell disease patients who require multiple blood transfusions [
36,
117]. Patients with sickle cell disease are more at risk of developing alloimmunization, which makes cross-matching and suitable blood for transfusions problematic when the issues of minor antigens are not considered during the transfusion [
114,
118]. According to Boateng
et al. [
119], the frequency of alloantibody development in patients with SCD is as high as 76% compared to the general population [
120]. The frequency of red blood cell alloimmunization in SCD patients may not be the same in every part of the world due to blood transfusion rates, ethnic mismatch, and the age of the initial transfusion [
20,
121,
122].
Other Treatment options
The US Food and Drug Administration has approved hydroxyurea, L-glutamine, crizanlizumab, and voxelotor to reduce the acute complications of SCD [
24,
31]. Hydroxyurea is the most commonly used of these, while other drugs, including L-glutamine and crizanlizumab have not been widely adopted despite European approval [
123]. Additionally, although hydroxyurea is effective in reducing acute complications improving quality of life, organ function and prolonging survival, it also remains underutilised primarily due to inexperience and unfounded safely concerns [
124]. Although the mechanism of action of hydroxyurea is still unclear, previous studies have shown that after treatment nitric oxide (NO) production is improved and the concentration of fetal haemoglobin a(HbF) in erythrocytes is enhanced, thereby preventing HbS polymerization [
11,
125]. Several studies have looked into the effectiveness and safety of these drugs in reducing the frequency of vaso-occlusive crisis and inflammation in SCD patients [
126,
127,
128,
129] and have reported that voxelotor increases haemoglobin levels, does not impair oxygen delivery, reduces hospitalization for VOC and decreases sickle red blood cell levels. It has been reported that L-glutamine and crizanlizumab reduce VOC episodes and prolong the time between the first and second pain crises. In this study, it was reported that inflammatory molecules were reduced with hydroxyurea therapy in children with sickle cell SCD [
40]. Others have supported this and have observed that patients receiving hydroxyurea had lower interleukin IL-6 levels [
130,
131]. In contradiction however, others have reported elevated levels of interleukin (IL)-6 compared to untreated patients [
77,
101,
132,
133,
134].