3.1. Characterization
The XRD patterns depicted the crystal structure of the Fe
3O
4 and Fe
3O
4/Ag NPs in
Figure 2a. The diffraction peaks at 2
θ values of 30.1, 35.5, 43.1, 56.9, and 62.6°, which were assigned to the (220), (311), (400), (511), and (440) planes of the face-centered cubic structure of Fe
3O
4 (JCPDS card no. 79-0418), confirm the synthesis of Fe
3O
4 NPs [
37,
38]. While the peaks of Fe
3O
4/Ag NPs prepared at three different hydrothermal times can be observed at 38.2, 44.6, 64.5°, and 77.5 ° corresponding to the reflections of (111), (200), (220), and (311) crystal planes of Ag (JCPDS card no. 87-0720), indicating the face-centered cubic structure of the Ag NPs [
39].
Figure 2b depicts the XRD patterns of CNC, Fe
3O
4, and three FAC materials synthesized at three different hydrothermal times. Comparing the XRD patterns of the three FAC samples reveals that the characteristic Fe
3O
4 and CNC diffraction peaks at the 2
θ positions are nearly unchanged. However, in the XRD diffractograms of FAC3 and FAC4, the intensity of the remaining characteristic peaks is comparatively low, except the silver (111) lattice peak at 2
θ = 38.2°. In addition, there are impressive peaks at positions 2
θ = 27.7° and 32.1°; the intensity of these peaks diminished gradually from the 3 hours hydrothermal sample to the 4 hours hydrothermal sample and disappeared by the 5 hours hydrothermal sample. More time may have been required for CNC to convert Ag
+ ions to Ag, resulting in the appearance of these unfamiliar peaks. The reduction reaction had yet to occur fully. When the reaction time is increased to 5 hours, the CNC has sufficient time to convert all Ag
+ ions to Ag, resulting in the disappearance of these peaks and an increase in the intensity of the diffraction peaks that characterize the Ag crystal structure.
The FE-SEM image of Fe
3O
4 (
Figure 3a) reveals that the solvothermal-fabricated Fe
3O
4 has a spherical shape with an average diameter of approximately 300 nm.
Figure 3b depicts the EDX spectrum of Fe
3O
4, which confirms this material has high purity when only Fe and O elements are present, with no other impurities. At three different time intervals, the hydrothermal treatment of Fe
3O
4 in AgNO
3 solution produced FA materials with remarkably similar morphology. In contrast to Fe
3O
4, the formation and attachment of Ag to the surface of Fe
3O
4 during the hydrothermal process gives FA spherical particles an uneven surface (
Figure 4). The FAC material indicates that Fe
3O
4, Ag, or Ag/Fe
3O
4 particles form on the CNC surface in the presence of the CNC. The FE-SEM imaging results indicate that the average particle size in the hydrothermal sample after 3 hours is approximately 180 nm; after 4 hours, it is approximately 150 nm; and after 5 hours, it is approximately 70–100 nm (
Figure 4). When hydrothermal durations are between 3 and 4 hours, nanoparticles are unevenly distributed and tend to clump together. When the hydrothermal time is sufficiently extended (5 hours), the particle density becomes more remarkable than that of the two preceding samples. The 5-hour nanoparticles disperse uniformly on the surface of crystalline cellulose and are less susceptible to agglomeration. As the hydrothermal duration increases, the particle density on the CNC surface increases, the particle size decreases, and the particles disperse more effectively.
The results of the TEM image analysis (shown in
Figure 5) make the composition of the FAC composites quite evident. The Ag NPs and the Fe
3O
4 NPs are interconnected and dispersed across the surface of the CNC bearing. The amount of time spent in the hydrothermal process causes the particle size of the Fe
3O
4 to decrease gradually. Additionally, the particles become more densely packed and uniformly distributed.
Figure 6 shows the EDX spectrum of samples FA5 and FAC5. The EDX spectra of both FA5 and FAC5 materials revealed the presence of O, Fe, and Ag peaks. In addition, the EDX spectrum of FAC5 shows a prominent signal peak at 0.27 keV, which is characteristic of the C element of CNC in the material.
The magnetic property of our materials was investigated using a vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM). All of our magnetic hysteresis is depicted in
Figure 7. The saturation magnetization (M
s), remanent magnetization (M
r), and coercivity (H
c) values of seven samples are displayed in
Table 1 based on the results of the VSM, from Fe
3O
4 to FA to FAC, the Ms of the samples decreased. The saturation of magnetization of Fe
3O
4 reduces when Ag nanoparticles are present on the Fe
3O
4 surface and reduces more when having CNC. This result is consistent with previous research [
40,
41,
42].
In contrast to FA materials, the Ms value of FAC materials increases with increasing hydrothermal duration in the presence of CNC. The phase composition of the materials may cause this result. As mentioned in the XRD results, FAC3 and FAC4 samples have low M
s due to impurity phases with diffraction peaks at 2
θ = 27.7° and 32.1°. These peaks disappeared in the FAC5 sample after 5 hours of hydrothermal treatment, so FAC5 has a higher Ms than FAC3 and FAC4 samples. Even though the magnetism of FAC5 is significantly diminished compared to that of pure Fe
3O
4, it can be readily separated from the solution by applying an external magnetic field (
Figure 7). This magnetic behavior not only makes the FAC5 catalyst economically viable for recovery and reuse, but it also precludes the production of secondary sources of pollution, which are generated by catalyst residues that are not recovered after processing.
Figure 8 depicts the TGA and DTG of CNC and FAC5. According to Alvarez and Va1zquez, the decomposition temperature of cellulose is approximately 360 °C, where high-weight macromolecules are broken down into small-weight glucose units [
43]. The DTG curves (
Figure 8b) reveal that CNC has the highest decomposition temperature at 357.0 °C, and the initial decomposition temperature is relatively high at 315.0 °C. Upon hydrolysis by HCl acid, hydroxyl groups on the cellulose surface tend to interact to form densely packed hydrogen bonding networks around nano cellulose, resulting in a higher decomposition temperature [
44].
The TGA results (
Figure 8a) indicate that after Ag and Fe
3O
4 are bonded to the CNC template, the material decomposes at approximately 284.0 °C and reaches its maximal temperature of 297.1 °C. It can explain that when metal and metal oxide form on the CNC surface, the metal decomposes faster than the initial CNC due to its high heat conductivity. In addition, a significant amount of FAC5 decomposes at 343 °C, with the highest decomposition temperature occurring at 364.6 °C. It is the thermal degradation region of cellulose, where the weight loss is relatively high, and the charred residue exceeds the initial CNC (13.7%). According to FAC5, metals, and metal oxides have high heat resistance, and they remain in the structure after cellulose decomposes completely, resulting in the sample’s thermal stability. Therefore, FAC5 has a reduced decomposition rate and more char residue than CNC.
3.2. Catalytic Reduction of 4-NP
The reduction of 4-NP in excess NaBH
4 was selected as a model reaction to evaluate the catalytic activity of the prepared FAC5 nanocomposite. UV–vis absorption spectroscopy was used to track the progression of the catalytic reduction. During the experiment, the peak UV absorption of an aqueous solution of 4-NP moved with increasing intensity from 318 to 400 nm after adding freshly generated NaBH
4 solution. The production of 4-nitrophenolate ions with a more vital -conjugated donor-acceptor characteristic is probably responsible for the initial color change (mild to intense yellow) followed by a red shift when NaBH
4 solution is added [
45]. After a delay, the UV absorption peak of 4-NP at 400 nm and its brilliant yellow color disappeared upon adding the FAC5 catalyst. The development and progressive strengthening of a new peak at 300 nm confirms the progression of the reaction due to the production of 4-AP.
Figure 9 depicts the absorption spectrum of 4-NP as a function of time for the catalysts FA5 and FAC5. In the presence of 2.5 mg FAC5, 4-NP was nearly completely reduced within 10 min, accompanied by a change in color from vibrant yellow to colorless.
Ct and
Co were the absorbance values of 4-NP in the presence of NaBH
4 at time
t =
t and
t = 0, respectively, and were plotted against time (
t) in
Figure 9 in the presence of the FA5 and FAC5 catalysts. FAC5 has higher catalytic activity than FA5. After 60 min, the absorption peak of 4-NP at 400 nm in NaBH
4 and without the catalyst is almost unchanged.
Similarly, 4-NP reduction proceeded very slowly when it occurred in the presence of a catalyst but without NaBH4 as a reducer. These occurrences indicate that the reaction requires both the catalyst and reducing agent (NaBH4). In addition, the potential catalytic activity of the CNC and Fe3O4 adsorbent was examined in the presence and absence of NaBH4 under conditions analogous to those stated for FAC5. After 60 min of reaction, however, the absorption peak intensity at 400 nm kept unchanged relative to that of the initial 4-NP, indicating that Ag NPs played a crucial role in the conversion of -NO2.
3.3. Removal of MO and MB via Adsorption Process and Catalytic Reduction
At ambient temperature, the adsorption of two water-soluble organic dyes (MB and MO) was tested using CNC, FA5, and FAC5. 15.0 mg of each substance was added to a 30 mL beaker containing a 1.0 × 10
−4 M aqueous dye solution. The mixture was agitated at 300 rounds per min. The experiments were evaluated by measuring the absorbance of the dye solution at intervals and then determining the MB concentration using the dye calibration curve. The dye removal was calculated using the following formula:
where
Ct is the dye concentration at time
t, and
Co is the initial dye concentration.
Figure 10a,c depict the (
Ct/
Co) versus time profiles for determining the remaining MB and MO after using CNC, FA5, and FAC5 adsorbents. All materials generally possess MB adsorption, and the equivalence is reached in 10 min. Due to the electrostatic interaction between the negatively charged hydroxyl groups on the surface of CNC and the positively charged cation MB dye, CNC exhibits excellent MB adsorption. Twenty-five percent of MB remained after a 30-minute test on CNC. FA5′s adsorption MB is significantly lower than that of CNC. After 30 min of MB adsorption, the remaining MB concentration in FA5 was 48.3%. Upon the appearance of Ag/Fe
3O
4 on the CNC surface, the MB dye’s absorption increased dramatically compared to Ag/Fe
3O
4. The FAC5 material exhibited the highest adsorption efficacy, as shown in
Figure 10a. After 30 min, the remaining concentration of MB was 10.5%. The presence of CNC in the hydrothermal process facilitates the uniform dispersion of Ag/Fe
3O
4 on the CNC surface, increasing the surface area of FAC5 relative to FA5. The results shown in
Figure 11a provide information regarding the two samples’ BET surface area (S
BET). According to the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) classification, the evaluated materials exhibited type IV patterns with hysteresis loops. Two samples exhibited narrow H3-type hysteresis loops (parallel plate-shaped apertures) based on the hysteresis loop patterns. In addition, the zeta potential values of the FAC5 suspension obtained through DLS analysis were –27.2 ± 1.1 mV negative (
Figure 11b). This also facilitates enhanced cationic MB dye adsorption. MO, as opposed to MB, is a negative anion dye. Thus, CNC hardly absorbs MO. FA5 and FAC5 adsorption on MO also occurred and reached equilibrium after 10 min of agitating both substances in the MO solution. Due to its greater surface area, FAC5 has a higher MO adsorption capacity than FA5.
Given the outstanding adsorption behavior of FAC5 nanocomposite for MB, our next objective was to investigate its performance in degrading hazardous organic dyes using NaBH
4 as a reducing agent and monitoring the variation in the intensity of the UV absorption peak at
λmax = 664 nm [
46,
47] allowed for the evaluation of the MB catalytic degradation process.
Figure 10b also depicts the time-dependent change in the modification in the MB absorption spectrum. Within 10 min, the MB dye solution completely lost its color, from the intense blue color (MB) to colorless leucomethylene blue (LMB). In addition, the reduction of MO was comparable to that of MB.
Figure 10d depicts the UV–vis absorption maximum variation at
λmax = 464 nm for MO [
48,
49] at various time intervals. As the reduction progressed, it was observed that the characteristic peak intensity decreased significantly and nearly disappeared within 10 min. There was no significant change in the distinct absorption peak of MB and MO after 60 min of exposure without a catalyst or a reductant.
Figure 12 depicts a potential mechanism for reducing 4-NP and organic dyes using the FAC5 catalyst with NaBH
4 based on the above experimental results. In addition, the experimental results indicate that the reduction rate is significantly accelerated in the presence of Ag metal on the catalyst’s surface compared to NaBH
4 alone.
Figure 12 shows that hydrolysis of borohydride ions in aqueous solution generates H
2 gas and BO
2− [
50,
51,
52]. As the hydrogen mediator for the reduction of 4-NP, 4-NP is deposited onto the surface of Ag NPs to produce a silver hydride complex. Ag NPs serve as redox catalysts for dye reduction by conveying electrons between donor species (BO
2−) and acceptor molecules (MO or MB) [
53,
54,
55,
56]. The MB experiment observed that the colorless (reduced) form of MB (LMB) underwent sluggish aerial oxidation in an open atmosphere after 3–4 hours. However, the characteristic blue color dissipated upon shacking, as the excess NaBH
4 in solution once again diminished it. Similar observations, called “clock” reactions, have been reported in the past [
57]. In contrast, the reduced MO solution did not change color even after several days, indicating no subsequent re-oxidation. As shown in
Figure 12, the MO decolorization products were N, N-dimethyl-benzene-1,4-diamine, and 4-aminobenzenesulfonate, formed via hydrogenation and subsequent -NH-NH- bond dissociation [
58].
The recyclability of FAC5 nanocomposite was an essential factor for more cost-effective processes, and we examined the sample’s efficiency in repeated reaction cycles. The FAC5 nanocomposite could be readily separated from the solution by an external magnetic field due to its strong magnetic properties. The nanocomposite was utilized for the MB and 4-NP reduction after being washed five times with distilled water. After three repetitions of this procedure, the FAC5 nanocomposite remained stable and exhibited a high level of reactive activity, indicating its outstanding recyclability. As depicted in
Figure 13, the FAC5 was effectively reused in three successive 10-minute cycles. It was observed that the catalyst had not significantly lost activity after three cycles. This result indicates that the FAC5 nanocomposite developed in the present study is exceptionally stable and resistant to multiple reuse cycles.