2.1. Characterizations of the AAILs-impregnated Sorbents
The thermogravimetric analysis of MOF-177 and AAILs@MOF-177 composites was performed to monitor the thermal stability of AAILs-supported MOF-177 composites from 25 to 800 °C in a nitrogen atmosphere. TGA thermograms of composites along with those of pure AAILs and pristine MOF-177 were presented in
Figure 1a–d. The thermograms of pristine [Emim][Gly] and [Emim][Ala] indicate that both AAILs were thermally stable up to 200 °C, but beyond that temperature, a sharp weight loss was observed, indicating a very rapid decomposition. According to the derivative weight loss profile shown in
Figure 1b,d, it was found that the onset decomposition temperatures (T
onset) were at about 215 °C and 225 °C, respectively. Whereas the pristine solid support MOF-177 was much more thermally stable than the pristine AAILs, with onset decomposition temperatures (T
onset) of about 421 °C in agreement with similar studies reported in the literature [
30,
31]. A little decrease in weight of around 2 to 4 wt.% was found in the composites at temperatures under 75 °C. This drop can be attributed to the potential evaporation of any residual methanol (BP 65 °C) that was employed during the synthesis of the composites. The thermogram of the composites revealed that the incorporated AAILs decomposed before the pristine solid support itself, as expected. However, note that there was no sharp decomposition of AAILs around the T
onset of AAILs, rather a gradual decomposition over the temperature range of 250 to 400 °C, and continued until MOF-177 itself started to decompose as displayed in
Figure 1b,d. The gradual decomposition was more profound at higher loadings of AAILs such as 30-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 (
Figure 1b) and 30-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 (
Figure 1d). This progressive breakdown event could be attributed to the surface association that took place between MOF-177 and the incorporated AAILs.
In an attempt to determine the effect that encapsulated AAILs had on the solid support of MOF-177, the crystal structure of the composites was investigated utilizing X-ray diffraction (XRD), and the results of this investigation were illustrated in
Figure 2. From the diffractogram of pristine MOF-177, the main characteristic peaks were at 5.5°, 6.2°, 9.6°, 10.4°, and 11.3°. A similar pattern was reported in the literature by Li and Yang [
32], with a major peak at 5.2°, at 4.7° and 6.2 ° by Saha and Deng [
31] and at 5.5° and 6.2° by Santos et al. [
33]. As displayed in
Figure 2a,b, the XRD of the composites revealed that the impregnation of AAILs into the MOF-177 support had a significant impact on peak intensity and position. For a small loading of 10 wt.% for both [Emim][Gly] and [Emim][Ala], the prominent characteristic peaks were at 5.5°, 6.2°, 9.6°for pristine MOF-177 and have therefore significantly declined but peaks at 11.1°and 11.7° retained their intensity with a minor shift from the original positions. It was evident that the intensity of major peaks diminished with the increment of AAILs loading and eventually almost disappeared at a loading of 30 wt.%, as displayed for both 30-[Emim] [Gly]@MOF-177 and 30-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177, suggesting some morphological changes. The existence of the guest molecules and their interaction with the host solid support account for the observed behavior. A similar complete disappearance of all the major characteristic peaks of MOF-177 due to the presence of chloroform was reported by Saha and Deng [
31] and according to the authors, the occupying guest molecules in the pore of MOF-177 caused a shift in the atomic orientation in the crystal planes. The TGA thermograms discussed in the preceding section confirmed that there was a significant interaction between AAILs and MOF-177 support. Overall, the XRD data indicated the occurrence of morphological changes in AAILs@MOF-177 composites, especially for a loading higher than 20 wt. %.
To further assess the impact of the incorporation of AAILs on the textural properties of MOF-177 support, N
2 adsorption-desorption isotherms were obtained under a liquid nitrogen environment (77 K) using the ASAP 2460 (Micromeritics) for the unmodified MOF-177 and AAILs@MOF-177 composites, and the isotherms were presented in
Figure 3. The samples’ specific surface areas were determined at relative pressures (P/P0) between 0.04 and 0.1 bar using the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) model. The Langmuir correlations and calculated results are presented in
Table 1. The pristine MOF-177 showed significantly higher N
2 uptake, and the isotherm profile corresponded to a reversible Type I isotherm (IUPAC classification) which was indicative of a microporous material lacking hysteresis during desorption. BET and Langmuir surface areas of pristine MOF-177 were 4172 m
2·g
-1 and 4962 m
2·g
-1, respectively, which were close to the reported values by Yaghi’s group [
29]. Both BET and Langmuir surface areas of MOF-177 reported in the literature varied significantly from 3100 – 4962 m
2·g
-1 and 4300 – 5994 m
2·g
-1, respectively [
29,
31,
32,
34]. It is observed from
Figure 3 that N
2 adsorption in all composites was significantly lower than in the pristine MOF-177 which was evidence of a substantial drop in surface area as well as pore volume (
Table 1). For instance, upon impregnation of 10 wt.% [Emim][Gly] and [Emim][Ala], BET surface area as reduced to only 187 m
2·g
-1 and 152 m
2·g
-1, respectively. The surface area and pore volume of the composites were further reduced with the addition of AAILs. The BET surface areas and pore volumes obtained for a 30 wt.% loading of [Emim][Gly] have been estimated to be 27 m
2·g
-1 and 0.02 cm
3·g
-1, respectively. These results indicate that the pores were almost filled. It should be acknowledged that the [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 composites exhibited somewhat greater surface area and pore volume compared to the [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composites. The reduction of surface area and pore volume confirmed that the AAILs were encapsulated into the pores of MOF-177. However, the severe decline in both surface area and pore volume especially for higher loading of AAILs can be attributed to possible structural and morphological changes due to the collapse of some of the MOF-177 structure which was also apparent in the XRD results discussed earlier.
2.2. CO2 Adsorption Isotherms
MOF-177 is one of the highest porous MOFs reported to date in the open literature, and as a result, it has higher adsorption capacity at high pressure. However, its adsorption capacity at post-combustion conditions (up to 0.15 bar) was very low [
16]. The current investigation involved the synthesis of composites including [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 and [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177. These composites were prepared by introducing two amino acid anion-functionalized ionic liquids (AAILs), commonly referred to as task-specific ionic liquids (TSILs), into the MOF-177 using the wet impregnation method. These composites’ equilibrium CO
2 uptakes were determined at 30, 40, and 50 °C. Each isotherm covered pressures between 0.1 and 10 bar.
Figure 4 shows the equilibrium CO
2 uptake in pure MOF-177 and [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 for pressure spanning from 0.1 to 10.0 bar (
Figure 4a,c,e) and a narrower pressure range (
Figure 4b,d,f) spanning from 0.1 to 1.0 bar. The addition of [Emim][Gly] to MOF-177 increased its ability to adsorb CO
2 at low pressures between 0.1 and 1.0 bar. When compared to pristine MOF-177 and all other [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 composites at all temperatures, CO
2 adsorption capacity increased dramatically with the incremental addition of AAILs loading and peaked at a loading of 20 wt%. At 0.2 bar and 303 K, the CO
2 adsorption for 20-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 was 0.45 mmol·g
-1 solid, which was three times that of the pristine MOF-177 under the same circumstances. However, increasing the TSIL amount to 30 wt.% failed to result in a noticeable rise in CO
2 uptake; rather, a decrease in CO
2 uptake to 0.26 mmol·g
-1-solid was observed when compared to 20 wt.% loading, even though it was a bit higher when compared to pure MOF-177 at the same conditions. It is noteworthy that the carbon dioxide absorption capacity of all composites consisting of [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 exhibited a decrease in performance at the given temperature, in comparison to the pure MOF-177, when the pressure exceeded 2 bar. CO
2 uptake by all composites decreased when the temperature was elevated from 30 °C to 40 °C and 50 °C while maintaining the same pressure.
Figure 5 shows the equilibrium CO
2 uptake in the pure MOF-177 and [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 for pressure spanning from 0.1 to 10.0 bar (
Figure 5a,c,e) and a narrower pressure range (
Figure 5b,d,f) spanning from 0.1 to 1.0 bar. It demonstrated that the incorporation of [Emim][Ala] had a favourable CO
2 adsorption capability for pressure below 2 bar and followed exactly a similar trend of [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 composites. 20-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 outperformed all other [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composites and pure MOF-177 in CO
2 capture capacity. This composite reached up to 0.42 mmol·g
-1 solid at 0.2 bar and 303 K, which was nearly three times higher compared to the unaltered MOF-177 under the same conditions. When the loading of [Emim][Ala] was raised to 30 wt.%, CO
2 capture capacity dwindled, and the resulting values were in the middle of the range for capture capacity at 10 and 20 wt.% loading. It was worth noting that under identical temperature and pressure, the CO
2 adsorption capacity of [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composites was slightly lower than the [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 composites with the same AAIL loading.
The introduction of [Emim][Gly] and [Emim][Ala] AAILs to the MOF-177 sorbent led to a notable enhancement in CO
2 adsorption under post-combustion circumstances (P
CO2 ≈ 0.15 bar) due to the strong attraction between CO
2 and the amino group present in AAILs. Previous research indicated that the amino group of AAILs reacted with CO
2 via a process analogous to that of amines dissolved in water [
20,
35,
36]. Wang et al. [
37] suggested that as the cation and anion of [Emim][Gly] were small in size, they could therefore come nearby an amino group and reacted to form a carbamate with a stoichiometry of 1:2. Hence, it was reasonable to assume that the amino group present in these composites reacted with CO
2 to form carbamate, resulting in a higher CO
2 capture capacity than pure MOF-177 below 1 bar.
It is noteworthy to mention that, when the pressure is below 1 bar, chemical adsorption becomes the prevailing factor. This is attributed to the strong affinity between CO
2, and AAILs. Consequently, the CO
2 adsorption capacity is enhanced. However, it is important to note that the occupation of MOF-177 pores by AAILs molecules leads to a significant reduction in the available surface area of the composites. Nevertheless, as the pressure escalated, the composites’ advantage waned, resulting in a CO
2 uptake that was lower than that of the pristine MOF-177 at pressures exceeding 2 bar. This decline can be due to the significant reduction in pore volume as well as the surface area of the composites. In the context of moderate to high pressure, the adsorption capacity of the sorbent is primarily influenced by physical adsorption sites, in addition to the active chemical adsorption sites [
38].
Our experimental results revealed that there was an upper limit to the loading of AAILs which was found to be 20 wt.% and beyond the limit, CO
2 uptake decreased. This phenomenon of reduction in CO
2 capacity which is ascribed to the reduction of accessible active sites of the sorbent due to the blockage or collapse of the MOF-177 support at high AAIL concentrations, which was also evident in the XRD, BET surface area, and pore volume results of 30% AAILs@MOF-177 as discussed earlier. An analogous finding in trend was reported by Wang et al. [
37] for the impregnation of [Emim][Gly] into the nanoporous structure of polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) by varying the loading from 0 to 100 wt.% and the optimum loading was found to be 50 wt.%. In another study, Uehara et al. [
26] reported that the optimum loading of [Emim][Lys] was 60 wt.% for the mesoporous silica support of SBA-15.
The stability of the composites in the CO
2 capture operation was investigated by performing multiple cycles of adsorption at 313 K and desorption cycles at 373 K at atmospheric pressure in the presence of N
2 for 20 wt.%-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 using the IGA microbalance. The obtained results are displayed in
Figure 6. They showed that the composite sorbent can almost maintain its original adsorption capacity during multicycle operations. In addition, the CO
2 uptake process for AAILs@MOF-177 was completely reversible suggesting that the composites can be readily regenerated in the presence of flowing N
2 at 100 °C.
2.3. Selectivity for CO2/N2
To be deemed effective in the post-combustion capture of carbon dioxide (CO
2), a solid sorbent must have a notable level of selectivity towards CO
2 when compared to nitrogen (N
2). Consequently, the determination of N
2 adsorption isotherms at a temperature of 40 °C was undertaken to quantify the CO
2/N
2 selectivity. Each isotherm encompassed a range of pressures ranging from 0.1 to 10 bar. In our current study, we employ a particular methodology to determine the optimal selectivity. our strategy entails calculating the selectivity by comparing the molar uptakes of individual components at a given pressure, as indicated in Equation (1) [
2].
where S denoted the selectivity and q
CO2 and q
N2 represented the molar uptakes of CO
2 and N
2, respectively.
Figure 7 presents the results of the calculations made on the CO
2/N
2 selectivity for both [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 and [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composites. Throughout the whole pressure spectrum, the CO
2/N
2 selectivity of pure MOF-177 fluctuated somewhere between three and five. It was discovered that the impregnation of [Emim][Gly] and [Emim][Ala] into MOF-177 boosted the selectivity for all loadings compared to the virgin MOF-177 up to a pressure of 2 bar. Regarding the composites involving [Emim][Gly]@MOF-177, it was observed that the compound 20-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 demonstrated the highest selectivity, reaching around 13 at a pressure of 0.2 bar and a temperature of 313 K. Nevertheless, the observed value exhibited a gradual decline as the pressure was raised, as depicted in
Figure 7a. It is important to note that the increase in loading to 30-[Emim][Gly] did not increase selectivity; rather, it resulted in a selectivity that was worse than that at 10 wt.%, except at 0.1 bar. Similar behaviour was seen for [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composites, with the maximum selectivity of around 15 (0.1 bar) and 11 (0.2 bar) displayed by 20-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177. It was discovered, however, that the selectivity of a 30-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composite is nearly identical to that of a 20-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 composite.
The encapsulated amino acid-base ionic liquids contributed to the enhancement of CO
2/N
2 selectivity. This improvement was observed at pressures below 2 bars. As previously discussed, it has been proposed that the existence of amino acids leads to the formation of active chemical sorption sites for CO
2, facilitating the creation of an N-C bond. This interaction is similar to the way CO
2 interacts with an aqueous amine solution [
39]. This resulted in additional CO
2 capture, although the surface area and pore volume were reduced due to the addition of the ionic liquid. On the other hand, N
2 did not have an affinity for the amino group as the adsorption was physical and depended on the available surface area. Hence, CO
2 uptake was dominant at low pressure compared to N
2, resulting in higher CO
2/N
2 selectivity. However, as the pressure increased, the physical adsorption sites also became the determining factors of the adsorption capacity besides the active chemical adsorption sites in the sorbent. Consequently, the CO
2/N
2 selectivity of composites decreased as pressure increased and became lower than the unmodified MOF-177 for pressures above 2 bar.
2.5. Isosteric heat of adsorption (Qst)
The determination of the adsorption enthalpy of carbon dioxide (Q
st), referred to as the isosteric heat of adsorption, plays a pivotal role in the adsorption process. It displayed the gas molecules’ affinity for the adsorbents and the degree of their interaction with them. The energy requirements for the adsorption-desorption process were therefore quantified. CO
2 isotherms at 303, 313, and 323 K were used to calculate the adsorption enthalpy (Q
st). At first, the DSL model was employed to establish a suitable match for the isotherms, as elucidated in the preceding section. Subsequently, the Clausius-Clapeyron equation (3) was utilized [
39].
In the given context, the symbol P denotes the pressure in units of bar, N represents the extent of CO
2 adsorption, T signifies the temperature measured in Kelvin (K), and R denotes the universal gas constant. The equation was utilized to produce graphs depicting the natural logarithm of the partial pressure (ln P) as a function of the reciprocal of temperature (1/T) while maintaining a constant rate of carbon dioxide consumption. The value of Q
st was then determined by calculating the slope of these plots. The findings are depicted in
Figure 10, illustrating the outcomes for both pure MOF-177 and AAILs@MOF-177.
Q
st values for the pure MOF-177 remained relatively stable at 13 kJ·mol
-1, in contrast, a significant rise in Q
st was observed for the composites, particularly at low levels of CO
2 uptake. When compared to other [Emim][Gly] composites, 20-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 showed the highest values for Qst, reaching a maximum of -28 kJ·mol
-1 at 0.2 mmol·g
-1 CO
2 uptake. This value was double that of pure MOF-177 under identical conditions [
Figure 10a]. Similarly, it was observed that the composite material 20-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 displayed the most significant Q
st values compared to other composites of [Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 [
Figure 10b]. The significant increase in Q
st can be ascribed to the strong intermolecular forces between carbon dioxide (CO
2) and the ionic liquids that have been incorporated within the pores of MOF-177. There exists a hypothesis suggesting that the anions of AAILs, containing the -NH
2 group, undergo a reaction to form an N-C bond. This reaction is believed to contribute to the higher heat release observed after the adsorption of CO
2 [
39]. The decrease in the quantity of available adsorption sites can be attributed to the observed decline in the Q
st value across all composites, which coincided with an increase in CO
2 uptake. A similar observation was reported for a composite of MIL-100 (Fe) modified with DETA [
11]. As expected, Q
st for both 30%-[Emim][Gly]@MOF-177 and 30%-[Emim][Ala]@MOF-177 were in between 10 and 20 wt.% loading, which confirmed the CO
2 adsorption isotherm and selectivity pattern observed and discussed in the previous section.