2.1. Morphological identification of strain OAOSH22
The morphological observations revealed that our isolate exhibited several morphological features that are consistent with the characteristics of the genus
Odontella. These features include bipolar valves, two elevations at the apices with rimmed ocelli at the summits, two pore occlusion types, a distinct expanded hyaline valve margin with an upturned rim, rimoportulae located in the subcentral position, valvocopula extending beneath the flange, and chain formation [
32]. The morphological characteristics of the isolate are outlined in detail below and illustrated in
Figure 1. The cells were strongly silicified, with an apical axis of 25–51 μm (n = 16). Numerous small circular or elliptical chloroplasts were observed to be adhered to the cell wall (
Figure 1A). The cells typically exhibited a colony formation characterized by a zigzag pattern, with a single horn connecting them, or a linear colony formation with both horns serving as points of connection (
Figure 1A). Valves were more or less elliptical (bipolar), with two obtuse horns (elevations) with an ocellus at each pole and a distinct convex area between the horns (
Figure 1A, B, F; arrowhead). The valve mantle became increasingly constricted toward the edge and greatly curved outward from the edge again (
Figure 1F; arrow). Valves were found to be embedded within the girdle band (
Figure 1E, F). Two or more labiate processes (up to 14 observed) with spine-like external tubes were located in the central convex area of each valve (
Figure 1D–F). The areolae were arranged radially from the center of the valve (11 in 10 μm, n = 7) and occluded by two types of vela (
Figure 1C; arrow and arrowhead). The surface of the valve exhibited a multitude of small spines (
Figure 1C, D, F).
Microscopic observations revealed that strain OAOSH22 exhibited the characteristic morphological traits of
O. aurita (Lyngbye) C.A. Agardh 1832 [
32]. The size of
O. aurita cells exhibits significant variability [
33]. Therefore, it can be confused between
O. aurita and other species that share similar morphological features, such as
O. obtusa and
Hobaniella longicuris.
O. obtusa exhibits shorter and more obtuse horns, displaying greater inflection at the base and a lower elevation at the center of the valve compared to
O. aurita [
34].
H. longicruris exhibits elongated and slender horns with minimal curvature at the base in comparison to
O. aurita. Additionally, it possesses dome-shaped areolae [
32].
2.3. Optimization of culture conditions for strain OAOSH22
In order to determine the optimal cultivation conditions for
Odontella aurita OAOSH22, an analysis was conducted to assess the growth response under different conditions of irradiance, temperature, salinity, and nutrient concentration at the laboratory scale (
Figure 3 and
Figure 4).
The PAM technique is commonly employed for the assessment of parameters associated with the photosynthetic efficiency of microalgae using chlorophyll fluorescence quenching analysis [
35]. RLC obtained using PAM technique offer comprehensive insights into the saturation characteristics of electron transport and the overall photosynthetic capacity of microalgal strains [
36]. This information can be utilized to ascertain the ideal level of irradiance necessary for the cultivation of a particular type of microalgae [
37], and to approximate the highest achievable productivity of the culture when the optimal irradiance is provided [
38]. The determination of the light saturation coefficient (
Ek), which signifies the point at which photosynthesis reaches saturation, involves the consideration of two factors: the maximum electron transport rate (
ETRmax) and the initial slope (
α) of the RLC. The initial slope of a graph represents the quantum efficiency of photosynthetic electron transport [
39].
Ek can be regarded as the ideal irradiance level for the cultivation of microalgal strains [
40]. The optimal irradiance (
Ek) required to saturate photosynthesis in
O. aurita OAOSH22 was determined to be 76.5 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1 using the rapid light curve method. Furthermore, the
ETRmax was determined to be 5.29 (
Figure 3). The growth of microalgae and the production of biomass are influenced more significantly by suitable irradiance rather than nutrient accessibility, as supported by previous studies [
41,
42,
43]. High levels of irradiance can lead to photoinhibition, whereas low levels of irradiance can impede growth rates. Various studies have shown that certain microalgae species are capable of attaining their highest growth rates when exposed to irradiances below 100 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1 [
44]. Additionally, it has been observed that photoinhibition can occur even at irradiance levels ranging from 100 to 200 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1, which is significantly lower than the typical intensity of sunlight [
45,
46]. The results of this investigation exhibited a resemblance to the outcomes of previous studies. However, irradiances below 100 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1 may be deemed appropriate for laboratory-scale cultivation, as evidenced by the findings of this study. On the contrary, when it comes to large-scale cultivations beyond the pilot scale, it may be necessary to increase the light intensities in order to counteract the self-shading effects [
47].
The growth curves of
O. aurita OAOSH22 at temperatures of 5, 10, 15, 20, and 25°C are illustrated in
Figure 4A. Biomass production attained its maximum value of 138.7 mg L
-1 following a 9-day incubation period at a temperature of 15°C. However, no growth was observed at both 5°C and 25°C. Temperature is a critical determinant in the growth and development of microalgae [
49]. Various aspects are influenced by it, encompassing the growth rate, cell size, biochemical composition, and nutrient requirements [
50].
O. aurita is a prevalent species that is commonly encountered in temperate regions and exhibits year-round presence. The species under consideration is classified as tychopelagic and is primarily distributed in coastal regions [
51]. They primarily inhabit the seafloor during the summer and autumn seasons, and can exert dominance in water columns from late winter to early spring [
33,
51]. This species was observed to thrive in a temperature range of -1.8 to approximately 26.0°C, with the most favorable temperature for growth reported to be between -1.5 and 6.0°C [
52]. Martens [
53] conducted a study at the Sylt-Rømø tidal basin, where it was found that a low temperature of -2°C was the main factor responsible for the bloom of
O. aurita. However, Baars [
52] proposed that the species' normal growth is best achieved at temperatures below 20°C. In contrast, Pasquet et al. [
54] conducted a study to investigate the impact of temperature on chlorophyll-fluorescent photosynthesis parameters and found that this particular species is capable of tolerating temperatures as high as 28°C.
In order to achieve optimal growth of our strain, it is crucial to consider the salinity of the medium. The growth curves of
O. aurita OAOSH22 at various salinities (24, 27, 30, 33, and 36 psu) are depicted in
Figure 4B. Biomass production reached its peak at 138.2 mg L
-1 on day 9 of the experiment under a salinity level of 33 psu. Additionally, biomass production exhibited comparable levels within the range of 24 to 30 psu. There is limited existing research on the correlation between growth and salinity levels in
O. aurita. However, McQuoid [
55] found that low salinity levels below 15 psu could have a detrimental impact on the germination process of
O. aurita. Therefore, the growth of this species can be significantly reduced by changes in salt levels caused by environmental factors, such as variations in rainfall and drought, during outdoor cultivation.
In the present study, the biomass production of
O. aurita OAOSH22 exhibited a slight increase of approximately 1.2-fold (ca. The biomass production showed slight increase (
Figure 4C) when the concentration of nitrate in the medium was twice enriched (100 mg L
-1 DCW) compared to the control. However, when the nitrate concentrations were doubled or higher, there was little to no increase in biomass production. Therefore, a concentration of 150 mg N L
-1, which is twice the amount of nitrate found in the standard F/2 medium, appears to be adequate for the growth of
O. aurita OAOSH22. Previous studies have consistently reported a strong correlation between the concentration of nitrate and the biomass of microalgae [
56,
57,
58]. Similar findings have been observed in studies focusing on
O. aurita [
20,
47,
59]. However, Xia et al. [
60] found that the biomass of
O. aurita was produced at similar levels (approximately 4 g L
-1) under both high (18 mM) and low (6 mM) nitrate concentrations when cultured at 100 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1. Additionally, they observed that biomass production increased by approximately 1.5-fold under high nitrate concentrations compared to low concentrations when cultured at 300 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1. This observation demonstrates that the provision of sufficient nutrients alone may not guarantee optimal growth outcomes, as the fulfillment of basic physical environmental conditions is also crucial in determining growth effects.
In the present study, it was observed that the utilization of a silicate-enriched medium resulted in a significant enhancement in the biomass production of
O. aurita OAOSH22 (
Figure 4D). The growth of
O. aurita exhibited a positive correlation with the concentration of silicate, as evidenced by the increase in biomass. The maximum biomass of 216 mg L
-1 was observed on the 6th day of culture when the silicate concentration was 8 times higher than that of the basic F/2 medium. Xia et al. [
59] demonstrated that an increase in silicate concentration positively correlated with the biomass production of
O. aurita. However, contrary to the findings of the present study, no significant difference in biomass production was observed across varying silicate concentrations (27.3–104.2 mg L
-1). Silicates play a crucial role as vital nutrients in promoting diatom growth and are indispensable for the development of their cell walls composed of silica [
61]. Therefore, the presence of silicates can have a substantial impact on the growth of diatoms [
62,
63]. When the availability of silicate is limited, a majority of diatoms experience disruptions in their cell cycles during the G1/S or G2/M phases, resulting in thinner frustules [61, 64]. Additionally, the imposition of silicate restriction resulted in a reduction in the fucoxanthin content within
Phaeodactylum tricornutum [
65]. Conversely, it is imperative to appropriately adjust the concentration of silicate based on the target indicator material to be utilized, as research has shown that the restriction of silicate strongly promotes lipid accumulation in diatom cells [
66,
67].
In the case of phosphate, when the phosphate concentration increased 2–8 times compared to the basic F/2 medium, the biomass production of
O. aurita decreased 0.6–0.7 times regardless of the concentration, and the additional supply of phosphate negatively affected the growth of
O. aurita (
Figure 4E). Phosphorus comprises a mere 1% of the dry weight of microalgal cells; however, it serves as a significant constraint on microalgal growth in natural environments [
50]. However, the impact of phosphorus on the growth of microalgae is comparatively less significant when compared to nitrogen. Additionally, it has been observed that beyond a certain concentration, phosphorus does not contribute to the growth and biomass production of microalgae [
68,
69]. Lu et al. [
70] reported a negative correlation between phosphate concentration and biomass production in their study on
Nitzschia laevis culture. As a consequence, it appears that providing additional phosphate supply beyond the inherent phosphate concentration present in the F/2 medium is not required for the growth of
O. aurita OAOSH22.
Iron plays a crucial role in various metabolic processes that regulate photosynthesis through enzymatic reactions. It is a key component of cytochrome b and c, which function as electron transporters in both the photosynthetic and respiratory chain. This involvement of iron positively impacts the growth rate of diatoms [
43,
71,
72]. The study conducted by Sahin et al. [
15] demonstrated that
Nanofrustulum shiloi exhibited 1.3- and 1.1-fold increases in response to an iron-rich environment. Contrarily, the limitation of iron frequently leads to an elevation in the silica composition of diatoms [
73]. This, in turn, can cause a reduction in the concentration of silicate in the medium, ultimately resulting in the inhibition of diatom growth. In the present study,
O. aurita OAOSH22 exhibited no significant variation in biomass production when provided with additional iron supplementation, as compared to the control group (
Figure 4F).
2.4. Carotenoid content of strain OAOSH22
The concentration of major carotenoid pigments in
Odontella aurita OAOSH22 is depicted in
Figure 5. Additionally, the LC Chromatogram can be found in
Figure S1. The main carotenoid pigment in the isolate obtained in this study was fucoxanthin, with a content of 7.10 ± 0.47 mg g
-1 DCW. It was also found to contain a small amount of diadinoxanthin (0.98 ± 0.06 mg g
-1 DCW) and diatoxanthin (1.37 ± 0.04 mg g
-1 DCW).
The fucoxanthin, a xanthophyll pigment derived from carotenoids, is a naturally occurring pigment. According to Matsuno [
74], it is estimated that this particular carotenoid contributes to over 10% of the overall carotenoid production in nature and holds the highest prevalence among carotenoids in marine ecosystems. In the context of fucoxanthin production, it is highly probable that commercially viable microalgae species would include diatoms (Bacillariophyta), Prymnesiales (Haptophyta), and Chrysophyceae (Ochrophyta) [
75]. One notable chemotaxonomic characteristic of diatoms is their high concentration of fucoxanthin, which is also found in brown algae [
76]. The fucoxanthin content in diatoms is approximately 1–6%, which is over 100 times greater than that found in brown algae [
77]. Moreau et al. [
28] conducted a study on the anticancer activity of fucoxanthin against bronchopulmonary cancer and epithelial cancer, and reported that
O. aurita is a significant source of fucoxanthin. Fucoxanthin exhibits health-promoting effects attributed to its potent antioxidant properties [
78]. Additionally, it demonstrates anti-obesity, anti-diabetic, anti-cancer, anti-angiogenic, anti-inflammatory, anti-metastatic, and anti-Alzheimer's disease activity [
20,
79]. Due to its diverse physiological activities, fucoxanthin has found extensive applications in the food, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industries. It has gained significant attention as a functional material with anti-obesity properties [
80,
81]. Fucoxanthin has been scientifically proven to possess superior anti-cancer, anti-microbial, and free radical scavenging properties compared to widely used compounds such as
β-carotene and astaxanthin [
82,
83,
84,
85]. It is anticipated that there will be a rise in demand.
Xia et al. [
59] conducted a study on the fucoxanthin content of
O. aurita and found that it reached up to 21.7 mg g
-1 (dry weight). The actual content varied depending on the optimal culture conditions, specifically a light intensity of 100 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1 and a nitrate supply of 6 mM. This finding was significant as it represented the highest reported fucoxanthin content in diatoms [
86]. Although the fucoxanthin content observed in our study was lower than that reported in previous studies focusing on
O. aurita, it was found to be comparable to or higher than the levels found in other species such as
Chaetoceros gracilis,
Cylindrotheca closterium,
Nitzschia laevis, and
Phaeodactylum tricornutum [
69,
87,
88]. The content of high-value-added substances can vary from strain to strain even in the same species [
89], and is influenced by culture conditions such as light intensity [
59], temperature [
90], salinity [
56], nutrient concentration [
58], and culture media [
91]. For instance, it has been observed that with an increase in light intensity, there is a corresponding increase in microalgal biomass [
75]. However, it has also been noted that this increase in light intensity leads to a decrease in fucoxanthin production [
92]. Light intensity exceeding 150 μmol photons m
-2 s
-1 has been found to induce the synthesis of photoprotective pigments, namely diadinoxanthin and diatoxanthin [
93]. Therefore, further investigation into the optimal culture conditions is required in order to enhance the fucoxanthin content.
2.5. Fatty acids composition of strain OAOSH22
The composition of fatty acids in
Odontella aurita OAOSH22 consisted of saturated fatty acids (SFAs) (42.5%), monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) (37.8%), and polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) (19.7%). The predominant fatty acids synthesized by this strain were palmitoleic acid (C16:1, 36.4 ± 1.4%), palmitic acid (hexadecanoic acid, C16:0, 25.8 ± 1.0%), eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA, timnodonic acid, C20:5ω3, 17.7 ± 3.3%), and myristic acid (tetradecanoic acid, C14:0, 15.6 ± 1.2%) (
Table 1).
The distribution of fatty acids exhibits significant variation among different microalgae taxa, as well as within species. Diatoms are commonly known to possess a significant concentration of various fatty acids, including myristic acid (C14:0), palmitic acid (C16:0), palmitoleic acid (C16:1), stearic acid (C18:0), oleic acid (C18:1), and EPA (C20:5ω3) [
17,
94,
95,
96,
97]. These fatty acids play a significant role in various industries such as food, pharmaceuticals, cosmeceuticals, aquaculture, and biofuel [
79]. In particular, PUFAs, represented by EPA and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), have garnered significant interest. PUFAs refers to unsaturated fatty acids containing 18 or more carbon and two or more double bonds [
98]. PUFAs, such as omega-3 or omega-6 unsaturated fatty acids, play crucial roles in various physiological processes within the human body. However, these fatty acids are either not naturally synthesized (e.g., linoleic acid and α-linolenic acid) or are synthesized in limited quantities (e.g., EPA, DHA, and arachidonic acid). Consequently, it is necessary to obtain these PUFAs through dietary intake [
99]. Among these, EPA offers a range of nutritional and health advantages, including its anti-inflammatory, anti-microbial, anti-cancer, vision and cardiovascular-protective, anti-Parkinsonian syndrome, and anti-Alzheimer's disease effects [
20,
79].
Odontella aurita is a representative EPA-rich species among microalgae and is known to have an EPA content of more than 20% of the total fatty acid [
20,
47,
54,
100,
101,
102]. The fatty acid composition of
O. aurita OAOSH22 was similar to previous studies, but the content of EPA was marginally lower, measuring at 17.7%. Several prior studies have documented that a deficiency of silicate in the growth medium stimulates lipid synthesis and leads to an elevation in EPA levels [
65,
67,
103,
104]. Hence, it is postulated that the elevated concentration of silicate in the medium employed in this investigation exerted an adverse impact on the content of EPA.
Currently, the primary source of EPA is derived from oily fish species such as salmon, mackerel, pilchard, herring, and trout [
104,
105]. However, diatoms present a promising alternative source of EPA, offering the advantage of meeting vegan dietary requirements [
86]. In particular, the species
O. aurita has already been commercially utilized for food in Europe, suggesting that it holds significant potential in the food and health functional food industries [
21,
107,
108].
Myristic acid, the predominant fatty acid present in this particular strain, serves as a stabilizing agent for a variety of proteins, including those associated with immune system function and anti-cancer properties [
109]. Additionally, it finds extensive application in the beauty industry as a fragrance, surfactant, detergent, and emulsifier [
110]. Palmitoleic acid has been documented to exhibit antibacterial properties [
79], and has recently been suggested as a potential food ingredient for managing complex obesity [
111].