At the end of 2021 for the purpose of promoting circular economy, the European Commission proposed the limitation of waste export from the European Union. There are three different models worldwide in regard managing of end-of-life tyres (2):
One of the techniques for tyre recycling is pyrolysis or thermal cracking. Pyrolysis is a thermochemical process, which causes the decomposition of organic matter upon heating in an inert atmosphere. Unlike mechanical tyre recycling, where long polymer chains remain preserved, pyrolysis products are fragments of lower molecular mass. As a product of pyrolysis, a solid phase is formed in the form of pyrolysis char, basically char or soot and a volatile fraction that is further decomposed into condensable hydrocarbons (pyrolysis oil) and gas. The relative share of individual phases is determined both by the chemical composition and the choice of reactor for pyrolysis, as well as by the process operating conditions. As a matter of fact, by adjusting the temperature, reaction time, carrier gas flow rate, heating rate, product cooling rate, pressure, particle size of the starting raw material, adding catalyst, etc., it is possible to control the rate and extent of decomposition, i.e. change the relative proportion of individual phases and the presence and yield of different products [
5,
6].
1.1. Products of pyrolysis of car tyres waste; composition and characteristics
As already mentioned, the yield and distribution of pyrolysis products depend on the selection of the process parameters as well as on the performance of the reactor systems in which the process takes place. Various data can be found in the literature that differ from author to author, but most are in the following yield ranges (expressed in mass percentage of pyrolysis products): 10-30 % for gas, 40-60 % for oil and 30-40 % for solid residue (basically pyrolysis char, char or carbon black) [
32,
33].
The solid residue of the tyre pyrolysis process contains mostly carbon and minerals that come from the filler and are present in the composition of the tyre before pyrolysis. This product is often called pyrolysis char or carbon black. Carbons based materials, e.g. coal, carbon black, graphite, carbon fibers, have different structures and may be amorphous or crystalline. The structure of carbon materials depends on their starting materials and on the heat treatment process adopted [
34].
Several authors investigated this residue for the purpose of using it as activated carbon, after the activation process. Activated carbon is product of two processes, namely carbonization of raw material and activation process. The first process enhances the carbon content and builds the porosity, while the latter expands the structures of pores. Physical and chemical activation processes can be used for the production of activated carbon. Carbon dioxide or steam can be used as oxidizing agents and they are mostly applied for the production of activated carbon from the end-of-life tyres. After pyrolysis of waste tyres, the treatment with activating gas is carried out at temperatures between 800 and 1000 °C in order to develop pores. Carbonisate shows a structure in which graphite-like crystallites dominate. Unorganized carbon is developed from tarry substances during carbonization and it fills up the free space among the graphite-like crystallites. In order to increase the porosity, activation process needs to take place by applying steam or carbon dioxide. Disorganized carbon is detached by gasification. It comes to mass loss and carbon atoms, which originate from the original crystallites. They act as activating agent, developing new pores or changing the existing one. As the gasification further takes place, the burn-off of the carbonaceous material continues, and therefore it comes to further increase in the porosity. On the other hand, carbonization and activation can be performed by adding a substance, resulting in a decrease of the formation of tarry products.
This process is called chemical activation. Mostly used activating agents are ZnCl
2, H
3PO
4, and KOH. Chemical agents prevent the tar formation and increase the yield of carbon. The rigidity of the matrix depends on the properties of the agent used. At the end of the procedure, the chemical agent is washed out. The process of chemical activation differs from the physical activation. During chemical activation, the agent breaks into the carbon structure, acting as a matrix for the creation of pores. When the chemical agent is washed out, a new porosity is obtained, and the carbon yield at the end is greater than that obtained after physical pretreatment, because the excessive burning of the carbon is not needed to create pores [
35].
An interesting study was conducted by Jones
et al. [
36], in which the authors have studied the effect of Zn, ZnO, and ZnS on the physical properties of spent tyre pyrolysis char and their transformation mechanisms with CO
2 activation. It was found out that ZnO and ZnS act as catalysts during activation, increasing the surface area, pore volume and burn-off. Mikulova
et al. [
37] performed the pyrolysis of scrap tyres under different conditions (temperature ranging from 380 to 1200 °C, and heating rates 10, 20, and 50 °C/min). Carbon black was analyzed by Raman and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, and the porous structure was determined. It was showed that carbon black has two structures, graphitic and disordered. Thermal heating above 380 °C activated the destruction with porous structure formation and specific area and total pore volume also increased. Heating rate had not any effect on porous structure. Shah
et al. [
38] have produced activated carbon from tyres waste through pyrolysis process and demineralization with acid prior the activation. Acid treatment is a great way to demineralize and improve the surface area of the carbon black, after activation at 900 °C. The study revealed that acid treated activated carbon from tyres waste is a good adsorbent. Lee
et al. [
34] analyzed the carbon black activation, mostly through XRD analysis with particular reference to the structural parameters. The amorphous fraction of the carbon black surface was firstly activated, and later the less-developed crystalline carbon region inside the carbon black particles was activated. As the activation process took place, the more-developed crystalline carbon region was activated, and on this way pores inside the carbon black grew larger. At the end of the activation process, crystallite size decreased, implying that graphite crystals had been activated, and so causing the growth of internal pores, creating larger pores.
Generally, activation of carbon promotes higher surface area, higher micropore volume and average pore volume, as it is shown in [
39], which further implies more symmetrical structure of active carbon. Waste tyre activated carbon can be applied in different applications, wastewater treatment, dye removal, or energy storage [
40].
Rodriguez
et al. [
41] performed a chemical analysis of char obtained by pyrolysis at different temperatures. Chemical analysis determined that the solid residue contains approximately 84% m/m carbon, 2.3-2.6% m/m sulphur, which is important from the aspect of using char as a fuel, and that its heating value is ranging in the interval 27-29 MJ/kg. Some authors state that the heating value of char is approximately 30 MJ/kg [
32,
42]. Choi
et al. [
43] conducted one- and two-stage pyrolysis of tyres waste. Authors studied the concentration of sulphur in obtained pyrolysis oil and concluded that that pyrolysis oil obtained at temperatures around 500 °C had lower sulphur content than pyrolysis oil obtained at temperatures around 600 °C.
The liquid phase is considered the most important product of pyrolysis of tyres waste. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS) is the most commonly used technique for analyzing not only liquid, but all pyrolysis products. In their work, Laresgoiti
et al. [
44] gave one of the most complete descriptions of liquid products of pyrolysis by applying GS/MS analysis, elemental analysis (proximity analysis), where the heating value of the corresponding products is also given. Liquid products of pyrolysis represent a complex mixture of C
6-C
24 organic compounds, including a lot of aromatics (53.4–74.8%), a certain amount of nitrogen compounds (2.47–3.5%) and oxide compounds (2.29–4.85%). Their calorific value is approximately 42 MJ/kg, which is a higher value than in commercial heating oils, but the presence of sulfur (1-1.4% m/m) is close to the upper limit, or higher than the permitted values. Rodriguez
et al. [
41] also reported a heating value of approximately 42 MJ/kg, with a nitrogen and sulfur content of 0.4 and 1.2 m/m, respectively. Furthermore, about 30% m/m of the total amount of the liquid phase is a light fraction with a boiling point in the interval 70-210
, which is essentially the same as commercial petroleum, while 60% m/m has a boiling point in the interval 150- 370
, which is in range of typical commercial oils.
The yield and composition of pyrolysis gases vary and have different values from one study to another, which can be attributed to different operative conditions associated to the process, reactor, etc. The approximate yield of gases in tyre pyrolysis is 10-30% m/m [
32,
45] and essentially the yield of pyrolysis gases increases with increasing the temperature. Its heating value is between 30 and 40 MJ/kg. Basically, different authors agree with the fact that pyrolysis gases are H
2, H
2S, CO, CO
2, CH
4, C
2H
4, C
3H
6, and other light carbohydrates [
14].
1.2. Influence of the process parameters on tyre pyrolysis
When it comes to the quantitative and qualitative composition of the products of the pyrolysis process, a very wide range of published results can be observed. Representation of each individual phase depends on the operating conditions of the process, namely temperature, pressure, heating rate, size of raw materials, method of heat transfer, catalysts, etc., as well as on the type of reactor used for pyrolysis.
Depending on the temperature range, pyrolysis process can be divided into three categories: slow pyrolysis when temperature does not exceed 300 °C, moderate or medium-temperature pyrolysis when temperature of the pyrolysis process is between 300 and 500 °C, and fast pyrolysis or high-temperature pyrolysis, when temperature is above 500 °C [
46].
Most authors examine tyre pyrolysis in the temperature range of 400-600 °C [
15,
25,
47,
48,
49,
50,
51], focusing mainly their attention on the liquid phase yield. By increasing the pyrolysis temperature, the proportion of pyrolysis gas increases and the proportion of char and the liquid phase decreases. The increase in gas yield and the decrease in yield of liquid products are directly related to the increase in temperature, due to decomposition of vapors into stable gases and to the occurrence of secondary re-polymerization. The pyrolysis process begins at around 237 °C, where weaker molecular bonds break and new, shorter molecules are created. These new molecules have a lower molecular weight than the parent molecule. Long exposure to high temperatures causes the breakdown of organic molecules that eventually leave the char. Akkouche
et al. [
52] studied the pyrolysis of waste truck powder in fixed bed reactor with a water-cooled liquid recovery system and a gas sampling valve. They varied the heating rates between 5 and 25 °C/min and concluded that heating rate had only significant influence on the gas yield. Heating rates in the range between 10 and 15 °C/min minimize the evolution of CO, CO
2 and H
2 and promote the formation of C
2H
6, C
3H
6, C
4H
6 and H
2S.
Williams
et al. [
53] performed pyrolysis of tyres waste in the temperature range of 300-720 °C and heating rate ranging from 5 to 80 °C/min, and finds that the maximum conversion of tyres occurs at a temperature of 600 °C, if the yield of pyrolysis oil is considered as a reference. Similar research results are presented by Clark
et al. [
54].
Laresgoiti
et al. [
55] prove that pyrolysis temperatures above 500 °C have no significant effect on gas yield and carbon residue. However, the change in temperature affects the composition of pyrolysis gas products. Rodriguez
et al. [
41] performed pyrolysis with a raw material with a cross section of 2-3 centimeters, as a simulation of the entire tyre, at temperatures in the interval 300-700 °C. Their report states that the distilled liquid products are a mixture of hydrocarbons, containing 0.4% m/m of nitrogen and 1.2% m/m of sulphur. About 30% m/m of this is a volatile fraction with a boiling point of 70-210 °C and about 60% m/m boils in the temperature range of 150-370 °C.
After the occurrence of the pyrolysis of tyres, the content of hydrogen sulfide is below 0.3% m/m, while in the laboratory analyzes that preceded the pyrolysis, there was about 2% m/m of sulfur in the raw material. After pyrolysis, sulfur remained in the char in the form of zinc sulfide and calcium sulfide [
16]. These data are extremely important if pyrolysis oil is to be used as fuel, and at the same time indicate the disadvantages of using char as an energy source due to the increased sulfur content. The yield of liquid products increases at temperatures in the range of 400-500 °C. After that, at temperatures higher than 500 °C, there are no significant changes and the yield of liquid products is constant. The increase in gas yield in relation to the change in temperature is 2.4% m/m at 400 °C, while at an increase in temperature to 700 °C the gas yield increases to 4.4% m/m [
56]. Similar behavior is found by Xu
et al. [
57] with the FTIR spectrum at different temperatures.
Islam
et al. [
58] examine the influence of temperature, raw material size and heating rate on pyrolysis yield and product composition; the maximum yield of the liquid phase (49%) is obtained at 475 °C, raw material in the form of a cube of side 4 cm, with a heating rate of 5 °C/min under a nitrogen carrier gas in a reactor with tubular flame heaters.
Zabanioti and Stavropolos [
59] performed pyrolysis under helium atmosphere in the temperature range 390-890 °C and at a heating rate of 70-90 °C/min, and in these conditions they conclude that the char yield decreases with temperature to a final value of 20% m/m from the total initial mass of raw material at 830 °C. The gas yield also increases with increasing temperature and reaches a maximum of 73% m/m of the total initial mass of raw material also at about 830 °C. Lee
et al. [
20] in the similar temperature intervals (700-880 °C) obtain a char yield of approximately 32%, the gas yield with increasing temperature increases from 30% m/m to a maximum of 40% m/m at the expense of liquid products which on in the end it has approximately 25%. Increasing the temperature does not significantly affect the char yield.
Chang [
60] showed in his research that the yield of tyre pyrolysis is distributed between 30-53% m/m gas, 28-42% m/m liquid distillates and 14-28% m/m char. Barobboti
et al. [
61] performed pyrolysis in the temperature interval 400-460
, with nitrogen as a carrier gas, which had a flow rate of 0.2-0.5 m
3/h, while the size of the raw material was in the interval 2-20 mm. As optimal conditions, viewed from the aspect of yield of liquid distillates, they indicated a temperature of 430 °C, with a N
2 flow rate of 0.35 m
3/h and a raw material size of 10 mm. Under the aforementioned experimental conditions, the yield ratio is char 32.5% m/m and 51% m/m liquid distillates and 16.5% m/m pyrolysis gases. The introduction of a carrier gas into the pyrolysis process of tyres waste increases the yield of the liquid phase at the expense of the solid residue and pyrolysis gas [
62]. The yield depends on the carrier gas, so that the use of water vapor as a carrier results in a lower content of sulphur in the liquid phase (0.1289% m/m), while its content increases in the solid phase (2.5% m/m). However, the use of N
2 or H
2 as carrier gas gives the opposite effect, which is again important from the aspect of using pyrolysis products as a fuel. Murena
et al. [
63] performed pyrolysis with hydrogen in order to better saturate the broken bonds of the polymer chain. They came to the conclusion that using this method, pyrolysis can be performed at slightly lower temperatures and that the reaction takes place in the temperature range 390-430 °C. At such parameters the yield of liquid distillates is maximized, while char is reduced to a minimum. Roy
et al. [
42] performed pyrolysis with a constant temperature of 500 °C, but varied the pressure in the interval 0.8-28 kPa. It was shown that the change in pressure did not significantly affect the yield of pyrolysis as a whole, and that the change in pressure did not affect the change in the yield of any individual product. Nevertheless, the change in pressure significantly affects the composition of the obtained products, especially the composition of char and liquid products. An overview of the influence of pyrolysis process parameters on yield investigated by various authors is presented in the review paper by Juma
et al. [
14].
Various types of reactors, such as fixed bed reactor, vacuum reactor, fluidized bed reactor, etc., are used in tyre pyrolysis. Williams [
25] gave an overview of pyrolysis yields for different types of reactors, showing the conditions under which the experiment was performed and the type of pyrolysis reactor. From the above review, a fairly wide range of yields of different products can be observed, depending on the applied conditions and type of reactor. In general, in fixed bed reactors the yield of liquid, solid and gaseous products ranged from 20.9, 40.7 and 23.9 % m/m (at 950 °C, under ~2 °C/min), while to 63, 30 and 7 % m/m (at 350-450 °C, under 30 °C/min), respectively.
In general, based on the above-mentioned findings, it can be stated that the research in the field of pyrolysis of tyres waste indicates different results; some authors state that changes in process parameters do not have a significant impact on products; others focused their research mainly on temperature, as a process parameter. What is characteristic of the mentioned researches is that they were carried out both in different conditions, often insufficiently explained, and in different types of reactors. In addition, the types of samples are mostly different, both in terms of shape and mass, the tests in most cases are reduced to TG analysis, coupled by DTG (first order derivative of TG) data [
64]. It can be stated that there is a significant variation of the data on the working conditions of the process, the configuration of the reactor systems when it comes to tyre pyrolysis.
Taking into account all the previously mentioned facts, this study aims to shed a light by analyzing a significant number of appropriate cases studied with the view to find the most suitable temperature and flow of inert gas to obtain, in a fixed bed reactor, the maximum yield of pyrolysis oil.