Ref. No |
Proposed Methodology/ Approaches/ Models. |
Standard& Terminologies |
Information Technology |
Advantages |
Limitation |
[1] |
An approach based on an OpenEHR to improve the semantic interoperability of clinical data registry is proposed. The following five phases of approach is as follows:
|
|
|
|
NA |
[2] |
In this study, authors reused the OpenEHRmodelling approach and also developed virtual different components of a modelling platform as a stable platform or multiple reference model (RM) for ageing population. Authors also described methodology for one- to- one mapping between OpenEHR systems and the column families NoSQL schema. |
|
|
- A)
Data collection and Feature Extraction.
- B)
As a decision support system ranging from general health preservation monitoring to critical situation management.
|
NA |
[3] |
Authors provided the proof- of concept for integrating SISMaster (Material and Neonatal Healthcare Information System) developed by the federal university of Minas Gerais (UFMG) with EHR system developed of healthcare for the state of Minas Gerais. |
|
|
It allows EMR systems to exchange data with SES/ MG EHR systems.
Adaptable with all other EMR systems.
Improves the Quality of Care.
Ensure and enhance interoperability based in standards.
|
NA |
[4] |
An OpenEHR archetype interoperability solution for Health Information System (HIS) –Clinical Decision Support System (CDSS) data integration is proposed.
In other words, an integration tool to enable CDSS to collect health related data from various institutions without a need for modification.
|
|
|
The Proposed Approach can be applicable to other dual-model based standards and other CDSS.
Mapping tables, performed in this study, solve the issue of local terminologies.
Model- to- model transformations improves efficiency and corrections of the designed approach.
|
Mapping EHR data to the CDSS become complex due to the heterogeneity of formats, models, abstraction levels and semantics. |
[5] |
|
OpenEHR -CKM
OpenEHR -RM
OpenEHR -archetype
odMLterminologies
|
|
Granularity of EEGBase between data and metadata is improved.
With the help of this approach researchers can do reverse analysis.
Improves semanticInteroperability.
|
NA |
[6] |
Authors defined the data warehouse environment to anticipate the problem of interoperability and infrastructure challenges in clinical archetype based EHR systems.
For this, an OpenEHR compliant instances, stored in an OpenEHR repository, is proposed with the help of aggregation and transformation functions,
For Modelling of clinical data structure, authors implemented OpenEHR and OpenEHR archetypes.
LinkEHR studio for transferring unstandardized clinical to a format or LinkEHR for model mapping.
|
|
OLAP
XML
RESTful Web Services.
JavaEE distribution
Spring Framework
|
The designed archetype terminologies perform each of the necessary operations like modelling, extraction, transformations, loading & Query.
|
Authors did not highlight the issues related to structure of information. |
[7] |
An ontology based flexible approach for automatic transformation of clinical model into OpenEHR archetype is proposed.
For transformation purpose, authors implemented web ontology language (OWL)
Authors also make use of reusable transformation templates.
|
|
|
|
NA |
[8] |
Authors proposed a graphical retrieval method to identify clinical information model (CIMs) online to represent EHR data.
Authors implemented Bayesian network and CKM or Clinical Information resources to create new OpenEHR archetype to support semantic interoperability.
|
|
|
|
|
[9] |
Authors aimed to describe a summary representation of Obscare workflow and to check whether archetypes in the OpenEHR CKM repository can represent Obscare clinical concepts. It includes the following phases; a) Obscare form selection. b) Description of the workflow care process. c) Detailed data extraction, and d) Clinical Knowledge model (CKM) model analysis.
|
|
|
|
|
[10] |
Authors modelled an EMR prototype for infants affected by cerebral palsy (CP).
Dual model approach with semantic web technologies is implemented. The methodological processinvolves three main concepts which are; a) OWL- DL based archetype Expressions. b) Creating an ontological source to annotate EMR archetypes. c) Creating archetypes annotations to enhance data extraction.
|
|
|
The insertion of semantic relations by adding new semantic concepts.
Supply the knowledge base with the additional checking rules.
It provides better quality of care and ensures semantic interoperability between all involved therapy’s Information systems.
|
|
[11] |
Authors proposed a fuzzy interoperable framework for Distributed EHR Systems. It consists of following layer; a) At lower layer which includes ontologies used to save EHR healthcare information. b) At middle layer, data collected from lower layer is converted into global ontologies by various mapping algorithms and experts. c) At highest level, graphical user interface is provided.
|
Open EHR
HL RIM
DB2 OWL.
ADL2OntoModule
|
|
Heterogeneous data can be aggregated while maintain the semantic, by the framework.
It Improve the semantic interoperability between the various EHRs.
|
NA |
[12] |
Authors in this study designed an interoperable concept which enables an easy integration of the Clinical decision support system (CDSSS) across different institutions, by using Open EHR archetypes, terminologies, binding and AQL
|
|
|
High Reusability rate.
Better performance
Fast, trusted and having high detection of SIRS.
Data and others facts can be added dynamically into the
Knowledge base.
|
|
[13] |
|
|
|
Proposed framework has promised flexibility.
Other legacy system can be integrated into this framework.
Highly beneficial for biomedical and healthcare research community to achieve semanticInteroperability.
|
|
[14] |
Authors designed a distributed model, named OmniPHR, to integrate PHRs from various hospitals. a) Blockchain technology is implemented to divide the patient’s health related data into data blocks such as laboratory data, drug related data, etc. b) Proposed incorporates model also concept of paging.
|
|
Blockchai
Routing Overlay
Chord Algorithms.
OMnet++.
OverSim Framework.
|
|
|
[15] |
A Framework based on data transformation and reasoning services intended for clinical data and knowledge is developed.
Authors Implemented dual model approach i.e. OpenEHR and ISO/ 13606 to improve the semantic interoperability. Main components of Framework is; a) Integrated representation. b) Storage and exploitation of mappings. The overall objective of this approach is to maximize the reuse of information artifacts and mappings in the design and development of different transformation workflows using EHR.
|
OpenEHR
ISO/ 13606
LinkEHR and
SWITmapping tools.
OWL.
|
J2EE
Neo4J
REST API
Cypher.
XML
|
|
Lack of control mechanism.
Another shortcoming is persistence of workflows.
Does not support workflow languages.
|
[16] |
Authors in this study designed a methodology which is based on OpenEHR archetype and software agents to deal with interoperability between legacy systems.
Authors also designed a system, as a case study, that supports the preparation of a cardiac surgery by reusing Legacy information Systems.
Dual modeling approach is applied. At first level, a common Reference Model (RM) is defined and at second level archetypes expressed in the Archetype Definition Language (AQL).
|
|
|
Reusable and flexible domain artifacts.
Specific applications can be build reusing artifacts.
Improves semantic interoperability.
Proposed methodology can be employed in other application domains.
Very useful for various stakeholders.
|
|
[17] |
|
|
SOA
RESTful web services.
XML
|
|
Adaptation of Clinical Decision Support System at Local level is still a barrier to share their Clinical Decision Support System (CDS) capabilities.
More Qualitative evaluation needed to verify the accuracy and reliability of the proposed model.
|
[18] |
Authors developed a multi- professional information model for decision- making process in primary care in Brazil.
For this, authors applied Delphi method to perform consensual analysis. The Proposed model comprised of following three stages: a) Expert panel selection b) Preliminary model development. c) Delphi method for content validation.
|
|
|
|
|
[19] |
|
|
|
Able to process several archetypes at a time.
Able to define reusable graphical representation for EHRs.
Able to target stakeholders by providing them flexible and adjustable graphical user interface.
Preserves the advantage of the state- of- the- art technologies.
High Performance.
Provide efficient modelling facilities.
Highly user interactive.
Improves semantic interoperability.
|
|
[20] |
Authors in this study proposed a method for clinical model comparisons.
Lin similarity estimates and Sokal and Sneath similarity implemented together with two aggregation techniques (average and best- match-average respectively.)
The purpose behind is to give an overview of multiple clinical models whether these modelsate local templates or standardized informationModels.
|
|
MatlabHierarchical.
Clustering.
Dendograms.
|
|
|
[21] |
Objective of this paper of this research is to use the HL7 metamodel in the Model Driven Engineering (MDE) context.
Authors performed and practically implemented the comparison of all modelling tools to identify the best tool deal with technology transfer issues.
|
|
|
Reduce the development time and help to identify the possible errors inconsistencies in early phases of development.
This proposed concept will help the software engineers to design health information systems with solid support.
Authors find that there are elements in the HL7 metamodel that do not correspond to elements of the UML metamodels. UML metamodels through stereotypes anticipate this issue.
|
|
[22] |
|
|
Archetype Modeling
Artificial Intelligence
|
|
|