The delivery system of PCAN was designed from biodegradable polymeric blend in the form of three-dimensional fiber matrix. The electrospun nonwovens studied were prepared from the polymeric blend of poly(L-lactide-co-glycolide) and poly[(R,S)-3-hydroxybutyrate] (PLGA/(R,S)-PHB; 80 wt%/20 wt%) using electrospinning method. The electrospinning processes typically produce randomly oriented, electrospun nonwoven. Our previous studies on the polymer solution concentration showed that increase of polymer concentration causes a slower sedimentation of bioactive compound particles in syringe during electrospinning process. Very good fibers were produced using a 10%
w/v polymeric blend solution in HFIP [
20]. Thus this concentration was used in the production of electrospun mats from PLGA/(R,S)-PHB blend with and without proanthocyanidins. The other solution properties (density, viscosity, surface tension etc.) and operating parameters (flow rate, electric field strength and electric current flow), presents in section Electrospinning experiment were also significant parameters to obtain a desired proper size of fiber diameter.
The second DSC heating traces for PLGA/(R,S)-PHB three-dimensional fiber matrix without PCAN shows only one glass transition temperature, T
g with equal 38.9 °C which is located between the T
g values of blend components (see
Figure 2). Thus, thermal analysis confirms that the electrospinning process does not disturb the miscibility of the blend components. In the case of the electrospun nonwoven loaded with PCAN in DSC trace, two T
g values were observed which indicates that the addition of PCAN to the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB polymer system disrupted its compatibility.
2.1. Degradation of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun nonwoven
The polymeric electrospun nonwoven were subjected to hydrolytic degradation. The progress of mats hydrolysis was assessed by macro- and microscopic observations as well as molar mass, structure, and thermal properties changes of samples studied. The visual inspection of initial PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN nonwoven fabric as well as their changes during incubation was investigated with aid of POM microscopy and are shown in
Figure 3.
The digital images, as well as POM micrographs, show that the surface of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB mats before incubation was smooth and bioactive substance was uniformly distributed in the polymer matrix (
Figure 3). After degradation, pitting and cracks were observed on the surface of both types of mats, which are layered in nature. It is especially visible in the case of a mat loaded with PCAN. The morphology of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB three-dimensional fibers matrix were also investigated with aid of SEM microscopy and results are shown in
Figure 4.
As shown in SEM micrographs, the bioactive substance formed different size agglomerates, which are irregularly intercalated between the fibers (
Figure 4). It is probably caused by the very poor solubility of the bioactive substance in organic solvents and the impossibility of keeping a homogenous solution used in the electrospinning process. The fibers in PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven studied possess average diameters of 2.2 µm. The PLGA/(R,S)-PHB fibers look smooth and linear which is typical for electrospun nonwoven prepared by electrospinning. The addition of PCAN caused disorganization and entanglement of fibers, which also showed different diameters varying over the entire length of a single fiber. Disordered fibers in the electrospun nonwoven have an impact on the forming of porous structures with different densities [
24,
25]. Appearance of the sample’s surface morphology in the higher magnification results from the gradual softening of the material during the analysis.
The changes in number-average molar mass of the samples during the degradation process were monitored by gel permeation chromatography, GPC. All investigated samples show the systematic shifting of GPC traces to a lower molar mass value with the progress of the degradation process (
Figure 5).
The results of this measurement revealed that Mn values for both mats without and with PCAN decreased and reached a value at the level of 1000 g mol−1 after 71 days of incubation. The overlapping of the GPC curves may indicate differences in the degradation profile of the polymeric mat components. It is worth noting that the molar mass loss of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB sample with PCAN is lower than for the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB mats not loaded with biological active substance. This indicates that the addition of PCAN has an influence on the behavior of three-dimensional fiber matrix of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB during degradation.
The
1H-NMR spectra of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven without and with biological active substance, PCAN before and after degradation time are shown in
Figure 6.
The resulting 1H-NMR spectra show the signals of protons characteristic for the LA, GA, and 3-HB repeating units according to the structure presented in
Figure 1. In addition, in the spectra obtained after 71 days of degradation, proton signals were detected, characteristic of low-molecular-mass OHB and OLA oligomers terminated with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups which are formed during hydrolyses of the polymeric mats components the (R,S)-PHB and PLGA, respectively [
26]. The presence of proton signals of OHB and OLA oligomers with a simultaneous change in the area of proton signals of GA units (due to the formation of OLAGA copolyester oligomers) indicates the progress of the hydrolysis process. Random cleavage of the polymer chains leads to a decrease in the molar mass of the components of the blend. This was confirmed by the GPC results (see
Figure 5). It should also be noted that no signals from PCAN were observed in the obtained 1H-NMR spectra. This is because PCAN does not dissolve in CDCl3.
Moreover, on the basis of
1H-NMR spectra recorded after a certain period of degradation, changes in the chemical composition of electrospun nonwovens PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN were also estimated and the results are presented in
Figure 7.
The (R,S)-PHB component content in three-dimensional fiber matrix samples remaining after a specific incubation period was calculated based on the integrals value of signals corresponding to protons of methyl groups of both 3-HB repeating units and OHB oligomers formed during degradation [
26].
Figure 7 shows that the content of the PLGA component in the tested mats without and with PCAN decreases while the content of the PHB component increases. However, it was observed that changes in the chemical composition of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven started from the beginning of the incubation process, while in the case of the PCAN-loaded mat, a decrease in the PLGA content was observed after 51 days of degradation. The lower degradation rate of the PLGA component in this case is probably related to the presence of PCAN, which interferes with the penetration of water into the electrospun nonwoven.
Figure 8 presents the second DSC heating traces for PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun nonwoven samples remaining after 71days of hydrolytic degradation.
A decrease in T
g from 38.9 °C to 17.9 °C was observed for the sample without PCAN, after 71 days of their incubation. In contrast, for the sample with PCAN, a decrease of T
g value from 47 °C to 28.9 °C was observed (see
Figure 2 and
Figure 8). The observed differences in the thermal properties of the tested mats probably result from the different rates of hydrolytic degradation of the loaded and unloaded PCAN mats, leading to the formation in the degradation process of a different amount of oligomers, which remain in the tested mats. The PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven degraded faster, and oligomers formed acts as plasticizers of the system. In the case of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun nonwoven loaded with PCAN the biologically active substance located between fibers of the polymer matrix probably hinders the absorption of water, which slows down the hydrolysis process, and the observed amount of low-molar mass oligomeric degradation products formed was lower. The presence of PCAN between the fibers inside the electrospun nonwoven was confirmed with the SEM analysis (see
Figure 4). The progress of the hydrolytic degradation of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN three-dimensional fiber matrix was also monitored by the mass loss measurements.
Figure 9 shows a mass loss for the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun nonwoven observed during degradation carried out in the water.
The observed mass loss of the tested samples during their incubation in water is related to the release of low-molar mass degradation products of the mats polymer components into the water environment, as well as, in the case of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun nonwoven, by the release of the bioactive substance contained therein. At the first stage of incubation up to 51 days a higher mass loss was observed in the case of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrospun mat samples than for PLGA/(R,S)-PHB ones. A significant increase in the mass loss of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN sample after 51 days of incubation can be connected to the fact that the three-dimensional fiber matrix start to disintegrate after this incubation time, and the release of PCAN is facilitated. The observed violent increase in mass loss after 51 days of incubation may additionally arise from the increased rate of degradation of the matrix themselves, which is facilitated by less amount of PCAN contained therein. The above observations were confirmed by the results obtained from the 1H-NMR analysis. At first stage, the differences in mass loss of the electrospun nonwoven samples result mainly from the release of a biological active substance, PCAN. In the second stage, starting on day 51, due to the increased migration of low-molar mass degradation products from the mats into the water, for both electrospun nonwoven samples greater mass loss was observed. Wherein in the case of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven mass loss was systematically higher than for the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN samples; after 71 days of degradation, mass loss of 51.1% and 38.5% was observed for the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN samples, respectively. Thus, PCAN contained in the electrospun nonwoven slows down degradation, which may be due to the presence of physical interactions polymer-PCAN such as ion-ion attraction/repulsion, hydrogen bonding, and van der Waals forces which can significantly alter the degradation time and hinder the release of oligomeric degradation products of the three-dimensional fiber matrix into the degradation environment.
2.3. ESI-MS study of the degradation products released from PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN electrosun nonwoven
The chemical structure of the low-molar mass oligomeric degradation products which were released from the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN three-dimensional fiber matrix into the degradation medium was determined with the aid of ESI-mass spectrometry. The ESI-mass spectra recorded for the water solutions collected after 71 days of incubation of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB and PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN samples are shown in
Figure 11a and
Figure 11b, respectively.
The oligomers of the lactic acid OLA and OLAGA copolyester oligomers as well the oligomers of poly(3-hydroxybutyrate), OHB terminated with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups were identified as low-molar mass degradation products released into the water during the incubation of the polymeric mats studied. The ESI-mass spectrum recorded for the water solution collected after 71 days of incubation of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB sample shown in
Figure 11a, is less complicated. One maximum can be distinguished in it with the visible major series of ions at m/z 557, 643, 729, 815, 901, 987 (with mass increment between the signals equal to 86 Da). Those signals represent sodium adducts of 3-HB oligomers terminated with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups. The structure of oligomers visible on ESI-mass spectra was confirmed with aid of ESI-MS
n experiments. The conducted tests confirmed that the PLGA matrix component degrades faster than the PHB component. During the incubation, PLGA copolyester systematically degrades to oligomers with lower and lower molar mass and, consequently, lactic and glycolic acids. Therefore, 3-HB oligomers dominated the solutions after an increasingly longer period of degradation. The two major maxima of singly charged positive ions were observed on the ESI-mass spectrum recorded for the solution collected after incubation of the PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN sample and presented in
Figure 11b. The main series of ions at m/z 257, 328, 401, 473, 545, and 617 (with a mass spacing of 72 Da) located in the area of the first maximum correspond to the sodium adducts of lactic acid oligomers with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups. Moreover, in the range of the first maximum, the ions representing sodium adducts of copolyester oligomers with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups can be also noticed. At the second maximum located in the mass range of m/z 600-1000, the visible major series of ions at m/z 557, 643, 729, 815, 901, 987 (with mass increment between the signals equal 86 Da) corresponds to sodium adducts of 3-HB oligomers terminated with hydroxyl and carboxyl end groups.
It is worth noting that the mass spectrometry analysis confirmed that the fiber matrix containing the biological active substance PCAN decomposes more slowly than the samples without the addition of this substance. The slower degradation of the three-dimensional fiber matrix is probably due to the interactions between the PCAN found on the fibers of the electrospun nonwoven, the polymer components, and the resulting degradation products. Difficult access of water to the interior of the electospun nonwoven caused by the presence of PCAN slows down the hydrolysis process and hinders the release of oligomeric degradation products into the degradation environment.
2.4. Cytocompatibility test (MTT assay)
Cytocompatibility stands as a fundamental attribute of a material when it comes to its utilisation in the biomedical sector. In this current research, the in vitro MTT assay was employed to assess the cytocompatibility of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB electrospun nonwoven, both without and with the 20 wt% addition of biological active substance, PCAN. The MTT assay results indicated varying levels of cytocompatibility of PLGA/(R,S)-PHB with the selected cell lines: U251MG, MSTO, PANC 1. MSTO demonstrated the highest cell viability (90.91 ± 6.54%) when exposed to conditioned DMEM media followed by PANC 1 and U251MG (
Table 1). These results confirmed that the U251MG cell line is sensitive to PLGA/(R,S)-PHB.
When cell lines were exposed (
in vitro) to DMEM conditioned with PLGA/(R,S)-PHB/PCAN the viability was significantly reduced (p <0.05) for all three cell lines. MSTO cell line demonstrated highest cell viability (%) out of all the three tested cell lines (
Table 1). These findings are in accordance with our previous study where the cytotoxicity of P(D,L)LA/(R,S)-PHB with 20 wt% of PCAN was reported [
20]. When PCAN containing electrospun nonwoven are produced with PLGA/(R,S)-PHB, the viability of MSTO cell lines was recorded to be better than P(D,L)LA/(R,S)-PHB with 20 wt% of PCAN. These findings confirm that PCAN at this concentration (20 wt%) demonstrates the cytotoxic effect in the in vitro test settings but different cell lines respond differently with MSTO being highest viable vs. PANC 1 being least (
Table 1).
PCAN possess an established antioxidative characteristic that affects numerous signaling pathways including, nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2), mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), nuclear factor-kB (NF-κB), and phosphoinositide 3-kinase/protein kinase B (PI3K/Akt) [
28]. The decrease in cell viability, as shown in
Table 1 and
Figure 12, might be linked to the free radical scavenging capacity of PCAN, which can impact signaling pathways [
29]. Nonetheless, it is important to note that PCAN has demonstrated safety profile advocating its safe application in clinical medicine [
28]. Furthermore, PCAN has a strong antimicrobial property advocating the application of these electrospun nonwoven in periodontal pockets [
20]. However, further work is required to evaluate the behavior (
in vivo) of these electrospun nonwoven before their clinical application as a drug delivery system for periodontal application to control infections.