3.2.1. Effects of Xanthan Gum (XG) and High-Methoxy Apple Pectin (AP) Composite Ratio on Rheological Behavior
Figure 1A-(a) displays strain sweep profiles (50 rad/s) of the composite XG-AP and standalone XG thickened matrices without thermal processing, both constrained to 2% weight. The 2% AP matrix exhibits liquid-like behavior (
Figure S2), while standalone XG matrices (0.6% or 0.8%) exhibit solid-like behavior within the linear viscoelastic region (LVR), as summarized in Table 3. Increasing the XG ratio from XG0.6AP1.4 to XG0.8AP1.2 shifts the viscoelastic characteristics from liquid-like to solid-like.
Figure 1A-(b) presents frequency sweep profiles at 1% strain for the samples without thermal processing. The results indicate that the qualitative feature, as exhibited by the slopes of Gʹ for standalone XG (XG0.6 and XG0.8) and composite XG-AP (XG0.6AP1.4 and XG0.8AP1.2) matrices are similar, while the slopes of the Gʹʹ curve vary significantly. The overall trends suggest that the addition of AP in the composite XG-AP group imparts viscous characteristics to the samples, while XG primarily contributes to the elastic characteristics of the composite XG-AP matrices. Table 4 provides the viscosity values at different shear rates for all samples. The viscosity of each sample decreases as the shear rate increases, with the standalone XG group (XG0.6, XG0.8) exhibiting a larger degree of shear thinning compared to the composite groups XG0.6AP1.4 and XG0.8AP1.2.
To evaluate the modification effect of the XG composite ratio on the thermal stability of thickened matrices with the AP base, the set thermal processes for 5 minutes at 95℃ and 105℃ were imposed, and the results are presented in
Figure 1B
,C, respectively. Comparing the results of solitary (standalone) XG samples (XG0.6 and XG0.8) in strain sweep and frequency sweep, both Gʹ and Gʹʹ values decreased significantly after the thermal processing, and the increase of thermal processing temperature resulted in a more significant decrease. For composite matrices, the strain sweep profile of the 95℃ processing shows that the decrease of Gʹ and Gʹʹ in the XG0.6AP1.4 sample is less than that of the XG0.8AP1.2 sample. The viscoelastic characteristics of the former (XG0.6AP1.4) indicate good thermal stability at 95℃ for 5 minutes. However, the matrices treated at 105℃ (
Figure 1C) showed very different trends.
Compared with the results of
Figure 1B-(a) of the 95℃ processing, the sample XG0.8AP1.2 in
Figure 1C-(a) does not show a significant decrease in Gʹ, but a substantial decrease in Gʹʹ. Presumably, the Gʹʹ of the aforementioned composite matrices (0.8/1.2) is mainly dominated by apple pectin molecules, so the rise in temperature aggravates the degradation of apple pectin. It leads to the decline of composite matrices, which can also be observed from the results of the XG0.6AP1.4 sample. In the strain sweep profile, the XG0.6AP1.4 matrix showed liquid-like characteristics (Gʹ < Gʹʹ) after thermal processing at 95℃; however, the temperature rise would promote the pectin degradation. As a result, the XG0.6AP1.4 sample altered to a solid-like behavior (Gʹʹ < Gʹ) in the strain sweep profile after the thermal processing at 105°C. The frequency sweep results of thermal processing at 105℃ also indicate that the viscoelastic moduli of XG (control) group samples are lower than that of samples subjected to thermal processing at 95℃ due to the increase in temperature. In the composite group, because pectin is the main component contributing to the viscous characteristics, the slope of Gʹʹ curve of XG0.6AP1.4 is significantly greater than that of XG0.8AP1.2, and both samples demonstrate more remarkable elastic characteristics with the increase of pectin degradation after the thermal processing.
Table 4 exhibits the shear-rate-dependent viscosity of the composite matrices and their corresponding controls prior to and after designated thermal processing. All samples show a similar trend of shear thinning, while the standalone XG sample matrices show the most significant degree of shear thinning. For the XG0.8AP1.2 composite matrix, the degree of shear thinning is close to that of the standalone XG group due to its higher XG ratio.
Following a 5-minute exposure to a 95℃ thermal load, the viscosity at a shear rate of 50 1/s decreased by varying amounts: 37.6% for XG0.6 (i.e., 280→174 mPa.s), 61.6% for XG0.6AP1.4, 8.5% for XG0.8, 39.2% for XG0.8AP1.2, and 54.1% for AP2.0. These results indicate that higher concentrations of standalone XG matrices correspond to more substantial viscosity reductions after thermal processing. Notably, XG itself does not provide resistance to thermal processing, aligning with findings reported by Naji et al. [
45].
While the viscosity of AP matrices also decreased significantly post-thermal processing, composite matrices experienced only slight reductions. Notably, the XG0.6AP1.4 matrix exhibited the least viscosity reduction at 8.5%. The composite XG-AP matrices present a stronger thermal stability than the standalone XG or AP, and XG0.6AP1.4 (or 3:7 in ratio) is the best among them. We speculate that it might be due to certain co-structures formed by XG and AP that impart the composite matrices' excellent thermal stability. Therefore, the ideal modification effect can be achieved by exploring the optimized mixing ratio of XG and AP.
Deducing from the observations above, the remarkable rheological behavior provided by XG can be utilized to modify the viscoelastic characteristics of the AP matrices—which are dominated by viscous characteristics at low concentrations. In addition, the composite matrices can provide the corresponding hydrocolloidal matrices with a polymer system possessing more robust thermal stability. Therefore, including composite matrices into thickened edible fluid matrices for seniors is quite exploitable and provides products featuring thermal stability after high-temperature processing.
3.2.2. Modification Effects of pH and CCA on the Rheological Behavior of Thickened XG-AP Matrices
The pH of the 2% AP is approximately 3.3 (control), and
Figure S2 provides insights into the rheological behavior of the 2% AP matrices under varying pH and thermal conditions. Thahur
et al. [
46] have reported that carboxyl dissociation in AP matrices can be hindered under low pH conditions. Following thermal processing at 95℃ and 105℃, it is evident that the
Gʹʹ for matrices at pH 5 and 6 are significantly lower compared to those at pH 3 and 4 matrices. This observation suggests that
β-elimination reactions may occur most rapidly at pH levels near neutrality during the thermal pyrolysis of pectin, aligning with the findings of Fraeye
et al. [
47]. Additionally, high-methoxy pectin is generally considered resistant to acid hydrolysis. In summary, AP matrices subjected to a 5-min thermal load at 95℃exhibit higher apparent viscosity compared to those at 105℃. Furthermore, it can be inferred that maintaining a low pH can help mitigate thermal degradation in terms of consistency.
Figure S3 illustrates the impact of calcium ions (Ca 2.5 through 10) on standalone 2% AP matrices. The addition of CCA as the calcium ion source was expected to hydrate the water in the matrices, resulting in a denser intermolecular pectin structure. A prior study by Noriah
et al. [
48] noted that the addition of calcium ions to low-concentration pectin matrices led to an increase in
Gʹ, consistent with the findings in this study. While the loss tangent value for samples with added calcium ions is slightly higher, ~1 (Table 3), compared to the control samples, it can be inferred that incorporating CCA as the calcium ion source predominantly enhances the elastic properties of pectin m matrices rather than the viscosity properties, making the samples closer to a solid-like state. The experimental results, both before and after thermal processing, indicate that the formulations containing Ca2.5 and 7.5 exhibit more favorable modification effects and are therefore selected for further formulation evaluation.
Previous experiments indicate that adding CCA as a calcium ion source can modify the viscoelastic characteristics of the 2% standalone AP matrices, and the samples added with calcium ions show higher viscosity (thickening effect) after thermal processing. Therefore, this section aims to explore the effect of calcium ion (CCA) dosage on the rheological properties of the samples. The groups with the highest viscosity after thermal processing (added with 2.5% and 7.5% CCA) in the previous experiment and the XG0.6AP1.4 matrix base without CCA addition were employed for the investigation.
Figure 2A displays the rheological profiles of the three samples before thermal processing. The strain sweep (at a high frequency of 50 rad/s) reveals that the liquid-like state of XG0.6AP1.4 transitions to a solid-like state when calcium ions are added (XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5 and XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5), consistent with previous experimental findings that the addition of CCA enhances the elasticity of the matrices. The influence of CCA on XG-AP composite matrices is evident, maintaining the desirable weak-gel-like state pursued in this study. Notably, in the absence of CCA, the Gʹʹ of composite matrices exhibits significant changes after thermal processing (
Figure 2A-a). Furthermore, in frequency sweep tests, the samples with added CCA (Ca2.5 and Ca7.5) consistently exhibit significantly higher values of
Gʹ and
Gʹʹ compared to matrices in the absence of CCA.
Therefore, it is speculated that calcium ions can provide a more robust molecular structure of composite matrices. In the frequency sweep profile, the system in the high-frequency region of the samples in the absence of CCA presents a more viscous than elastic feature, and the crossover point can be observed. However, the sample's molecular structure is more stable after the addition of calcium ions, as the sample elasticity becomes dominant and there is no crossover point within the same range of frequencies. Therefore, the viscosity dominance would occur only at still higher frequencies. In examining the impact of CCA addition, the results before thermal processing reveal that the XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5 and XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 curves closely coincide in both strain and frequency sweep profiles. This suggests that calcium ions from CCA exert a limited modifying effect on the samples prior to heating. Therefore, further investigation was conducted to assess whether calcium ion concentration would affect the rheological properties of the samples after thermal processing.
Figure 2B displays the rheological profiles of the samples subjected to a 5-minute thermal treatment at 95℃. In the strain sweep profile, it is observed that the
G' of XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5 is higher than that of XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5. However, the G'' of XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5 is slightly lower than that of XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5. This outcome aligns with previous experimental findings when comparing the impact of CCA addition on standalone 2% AP matrices, where Ca2.5 and Ca7.5 exhibited the most favorable modification effects prior to thermal processing.
However, after undergoing thermal processing at 95℃ for 5 minutes, it becomes evident that XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 exhibits superior thermal stability compared to XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5. The latter, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5, displays reduced thermal stability due to a decrease in G'', indicating a weakening of the pectin structure. This results in the XG-AP composite matrices leaning more towards a viscoelastic profile biased towards XG and consequently experiencing an increase in elastic characteristics. A notable difference in the frequency sweep profile compared to the pre-thermal group is the absence of the original crossover point in the high-frequency region for XG0.6AP1.4. This absence is attributed to the partial degradation of the pectin structure. The results obtained from the 5-minute thermal processing at 95℃ highlight that a higher calcium concentration is effectively.
Figure 2C shows the rheological profiles of the samples affected by a 5-min thermal load at 105℃. Due to the increase of temperature compared to the temperature of 95℃, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 presents almost the same rheological characteristics as XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5 in strain sweep and frequency sweep results. As the temperature rises to105℃, the increase of calcium ion concentration ceases to enhance the thermal stability. It has been reported that the addition of calcium ions can enhance the associative strength of high-methoxyl pectins [
49,
50], diverging from the "egg-box" model seen in low-methoxyl pectins and more closely resembling alginate gelation [
51]. Yang et al. [
52] have noted that a calcium-concentrating process, brought about by water evaporation, enables high-methoxyl pectin molecules to improve their hydrophobic interactions, which is crucial for gel formation. However, the specific molecular interactions between high-methoxyl pectin and calcium ions require further investigation to be fully understood. Therefore, the addition of CCA can improve the thermal stability of composite matrices only at a lower temperature (95℃) under the same processing duration.
The viscosities (Table 4) measured at a shear rate of 50 Hz (1/s) were used to investigate the effect of CCA addition on the sample viscosity. The viscosity values of XG0.6AP1.4, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca2.5, and XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 prior to thermal processing are 638.8, 757.6, and 807.7 mPa.s, respectively. They become 584.7, 674.8, and 676.5 mPa.s, respectively, with thermal processing at 95℃, and 569.0, 580.0, and 606.3 mPa.s, respectively, with thermal processing at 105℃. The existence of calcium ions can promote the viscosity of the sample with or without thermal processing. According to the above results, the viscosity of XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 is comparatively higher in all three conditions, although the disparity is small in general. We also observed that the inclusion of calcium ions into XG0.6AP1.4 composite matrices has a modification effect on both the viscoelastic characteristics and viscosities. Especially with Ca7.5, the viscoelastic characteristics after thermal processing at 95℃ are closer to the weak-gel-like state, and the viscosities are also the highest in all cases at a shear rate of 50 Hz (1/s). Therefore, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 is considered a better choice for the dysphagia-friendly fluid model system for the following evaluation.
For the evaluation of pH effect, an XG-AP composite ratio of 3:7 with 7.5% CCA was employed (i.e., XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5). The measured pH is 2.92 prior to any adjustment, which is in line with the low-pH environment. Therefore, samples with pH 5 and 6 are additionally prepared to investigate the influence of pH on the rheological properties and matrix stability after thermal processing.
Figure 3 presents the results of the rheological analysis concerning the pH effect. In
Figure 3A, we observe the rheological profiles of the samples before thermal processing. The previous strain sweep results indicated that the incorporation of CCA substantially enhances the elasticity of XG0.6AP1.4 composite matrices, which originally exhibited liquid-like characteristics, to the extent that
G' surpasses
G'' and demonstrates a weak-gel-like behavior. Notably, the samples with pH adjusted to 5 and 6 also exhibit a weak-gel-like pattern, but with both
Gʹ and
Gʹʹ values higher than those of the original XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5.
The frequency sweep also shows results similar to the strain sweep, and additionally, the viscosities of the three samples exhibit shear-thinning characteristics. At a shear rate of 50 1/s, the measured viscosity follows the trend [control, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 (807.7 mPa.s)] > [pH 5, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 (565.0 mPa.s)]> [pH 6, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 (393.0 mPa.s)].
Figure 3B shows the rheology profile of the same set of samples subjected to a 5-min thermal load at 95°C. The strain sweep and frequency sweep profiles show that the
Gʹ of the XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5 sample with unadjusted pH value (pH = 2.92, control) did not decrease significantly, and the sample still exhibited weak-gel-like characteristics. Thus, the composite matrices can maintain properties similar to those prior to thermal processing with good stability. In contrast, the other two samples with pH values adjusted to be close to the neutral one (pH = 7) showed quite different trends. The
Gʹ and
Gʹʹ of the [pH 5, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample decreased, especially the
Gʹʹ; the
Gʹʹ of the [pH 6, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample also decreased, while the
Gʹ increased.
Therefore, the above and previous experimental findings (as detailed in
Figure S2) offer mutual support. When subjected to heating at pH 5 and 6 conditions, pectin undergoes more pronounced degradation compared to lower pH levels. This degradation similarly affects XG-AP composite matrices. The degradation of apple pectin, primarily responsible for imparting viscosity to the samples, results in a significant reduction in
Gʹʹ for the pH 5 and 6 samples. It is speculated that the degree of AP degradation in the pH 6 environment exceeds that in the pH 5 environment, causing a weaker modification effect on XG-AP composite matrices in the latter. Consequently, both samples exhibit increased
Gʹ, resembling the viscoelastic traits of XG.
In
Figure 3C, which showcases the rheological profiles of the samples after thermal processing at 105℃ for 5 min, the overall trend remains largely consistent with that observed after thermal processing at 95℃. As a higher temperature will accelerate the pectin degradation, a decrease in Gʹʹ can be seen from the strain sweep profile of the [XG0.6AP1.4- Ca7.5] sample (
Figure 3C-(a)). For comparison, the [pH 5, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample exhibited a similar increase in the elastic characteristics as with the [pH 6, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample when the thermal processing temperature was increased to 105℃.
The changes in viscosity due to thermal processing are calculated from the reported data shown in Table 4. For the measured viscosity at a shear rate of 50 1/s, the viscosity of all samples decreases after thermal processing. However, it can be seen that the two samples with pH close to the neutral state exhibited more pronounced viscosity reduction than those of lower pH values. After being heated at 95°C and 105°C for 5 minutes, the viscosity of the [control, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample decreased by 16.24% and 24.9% (807.7 →676.5 and 807.7→606.3 mPa.s), respectively; the [pH 5, XG0.6AP1.4-Ca7.5] sample decreased by 57.8% and 62.1% (565.0 → 238.3 and 565.0→214.1 mPa.s), respectively; the [pH 6, XG0.6AP1.4-0Ca7.5] sample decreased by 45.8% and 52.4% (393.0 → 213.1 and 393.0→186.9 mPa.s), respectively.
As per the previous discussions on the effects of the pH values of the matrix systems, the viscoelasticity and viscosity of the XG-AP composite matrices can be observed to decrease more significantly after thermal processing, with pH closer to the neutral state (pH 5 or 6). The degradation of apple pectin in these samples leads to decreased viscous characteristics, resulting in promoted elastic characteristics (similar to the rheological characteristics of XG). The viscosity, which currently serves as the primary standard [
9,
10,
13,
53] of dysphagia-friendly edible fluids, especially decreased significantly. Therefore, it can be deduced that the pH value is crucial for preparing edible fluid models. When high-methoxy pectin is used as the major thickener base, better thermal stability can be warranted with acid-base ones.