1. Introduction
AM60 magnesium alloys have perfect mechanical properties such as strength and high fracture toughness [
1,
2]. This material has a low density and is biocompatible. For this reason, AM60 were used in structures under corrosion and fatigue loads. Magnesium is used in many industries such as automotive, aerospace, healthcare and biomedical. Magnesium is also used in implants and stents [
3,
4,
5,
6].
Song et al. [
7] searched for a comparison of the corrosion performance of AM60 magnesium alloys in an atmospheric environment, both with and without the application of self-healing coatings. The results indicated that rainwater in scratched areas can acceler-ate corrosion in magnesium. Additionally, it was found that self-healing coatings possess better inhibitive properties. Liu et al. [
8] explored the corrosion characteristics of the AM60 magnesium alloy that incorporate either cerium (Ce) or lanthanum (La) when sub-jected to thin electrolyte layers. The smart map analysis confirmed the skeletal structure formation from the rare earth (RE) alloying. Finally, the corrosion pattern observed in AMRE1 alloy indicates the corrosion area, and the application of thin electrolyte layer (TEL) effectively suppresses the development of pitting corrosion. Matsubara et al. [
9] found the impact of iron impurity on the corrosion behaviors of AM60 and AM50 magne-sium alloys. The findings suggested that an increase in the Fe/Mn ratio correlated with higher rates of corrosion. That article concluded that these inclusions had a role of initia-tion corrosion points. Xie et al. [
10] researched enhancing the anti-corrosion and anti-wear characteristics of AM60 magnesium alloys. They improved this through ion im-plantation and a gradient duplex coating. The research revealed a significant improving behavior under the corrosion condition in magnesium alloys when it was coated. This improvement was evident in the current density of corrosion. Kumar [
11] researched the effects of incorporating hydroxyapatite (HA) into AZ91D, AJ62, and AM60 alloys. The study found that HA, through the formation of complex metal hydroxides, enhances corrosion resistance. As a result, AJ62/3HA and AZ91D/3HA alloys were found as promising bio-material candidates due to their finer grains, exceptional resistance to corrosion, and strong biocompatibility, making them suitable for various applications. Other studies were conducted on the corrosion behavior of the AM60 alloy in the NaCl environment. Researchers in these studies attempted to increase the strength under the corrosion in the AM60 alloys by adding materials such as rare earth cerium and lanthanum metals, organic inhibitors, and mineral inhibitors [
12,
13,
14,
15].
Akbaripanah et al. [
16] studied the impact of the equal channel angular pressing (ECAP) technique besides extrusion on the fatigue characteristics of the AM60 magnesium alloys. In the second pass of ECAP, researchers found that fatigue lifetime increased. This result was important because the improvement was seen in both low cycling and high cycling. Khan et al. [
17] investigated the fatigue behavior of anodized AM60 magnesium alloys when exposed to a humid environment. The researchers found that anodized samples under high humidity conditions (80% RH) slightly improved fatigue strength. Hiromoto et al. [
18] performed a work on the fatigue properties of bio-absorbable magnesium alloys with hydroxyapatite coatings, formed through the chemical solution deposition method. In the final phase of the research, the investigators discovered that the hydroxyapatite (HAp) coatings on the sample remained intact without developing cracks even after 107 fatigue cycles considering the fatigue limit. This suggested that the HAp coating offered approximately 3% cyclic elongation, showcasing its potential to increase the durability of AZ31 magnesium alloy components in specific applications. Considering the wide range of applications for magnesium alloys, numerous studies were carried out on these materials. As a result, a substantial body of research was dedicated to exploring the corrosion fa-tigue behaviors in the magnesium alloy. Through these investigations, researchers sought to enhance the alloy resistance to corrosion fatigue by altering their composition and micro-structure [
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26].
Shi et al. [
27] investigated a novel MAO-PLA coating applied to zinc alloys with the potential for use as an orthopedic implant material. In the research, the Zn-0.5Mn-0.5Mg alloys were subjected to surface modification by micro-arc oxidation (MAO) besides sol-gel PLA techniques. This treatment enhanced osteogenesis and reduced the material toxicity for potential medical applications. Ultimately, based on the results obtained, researchers concluded that the surface modification of the MAO-PLA on the Zn-0.5Mn-0.5Mg alloys appeared to be suitable for improving biocompatibility. Anand et al. [
28] assessed biode-gradable composites, Zn-Mg-Mn-(HA), coated with a polymer-ceramics composite (PLA/HA/TiO2) for orthopedic applications. They observed higher corrosion rates in the as-cast sample, 1Mg-1Mn-1HA, than 1Mg-1Mn. However, after applying the polymer-ceramic nanofiber composite coating, the corrosion rates significantly decreased in electrochemical tests. Wang et al. [
29] investigated the corrosion resistance of biode-gradable iron and zinc materials by applying a poly(lactic) acid (PLA) coating to use these materials for temporary medical implant applications. The study found that PLA enhances iron (Fe) corrosion rate more effectively than zinc (Zn). This observation is likely attributed to the non-passivating nature of iron in an acidic environment. Beyzavi et al. [
30] explored bio-polymer coatings, generating these coatings on the AM60 magnesium alloy with 3D printing by fused deposition modeling (FDM) in their study. These coatings were applied to explore the electrochemical behavior of the treated magnesium alloys. Their data on testing of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy revealed that the transparent Polycaprolactone (PCL) and PLA coatings exhibited the highest impedance. However, all the biodegradable coatings exhibited a significant increase in impedance, approximately 63.1-99.7%, compared to the magnesium alloy.
Based on the conducted studies, it was determined that many researchers had worked in the field of AM60 corrosion, and their goal was to improve corrosion using various methods [
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15], Moreover, studies have shown that the use of biodegradable polymer coatings such as PLA can have a positive impact on corrosion [
27,
28,
29,
30], Furthermore, it was disclosed that several studies were carried out in the field of fatigue of AM60 [
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26].
The innovation of this research is to compare the fatigue lifetime of coated Mg after corrosion in SBF with pure Mg.
3. Results
The samples with the coating were placed in the SBF solution for 27 days. Then, the weight of the specimens was recorded during this period.
Figure 6 depicts the change in weight according to the days that the samples were in the solution. According to this figure, the weight of the samples did not change in the first days. However, on some days it decreased, then on the last days the weight of the sample increased. This is due to water absorption by the polymer coating [
46]. Hasanpour et al. [
47] investigated water absorption and corrosion of pure magnesium and magnesium with PLA. The specimens were immersed in the SBF solution for 30 days. It was concluded that the corrosion rate in samples with PLA is increased due to more water absorption. Balogova et al. [
48] for PLA samples showed that the mass of samples increases with increasing water absorption. Redondo et al. [
49] also reported water absorption in corrosion tests for PLA samples. Alksne et al. [
50] reported swelling and water absorption over time for Composite samples made of PLA+hydroxyapatite (HA) and PLA+bioglass (BG).
Figure 7 shows the corrosion rate and the average rate of corrosion. Based on this figure, the corrosion rates decreased over the time. Chor et al. [
51] also reported a decrease in the corrosion rate for a sample made of PLA materials over the time. Voicu et al. [
52] combined MgZ31 with PLA nanofibers and the corrosion of samples in SBF solution was investigated. The results illustrated that the rate of corrosion decreased with the help of PLA coating. Shi et al. [
53] fabricated a PLA layer on the sample by placing AZ31 in the PLA-chloroform solution. The corrosion results demonstrated that the coating layers decreased the corrosion rate.
Figure 8 shows the stress-lifetime curve for all samples and the average of samples PF-AM60-PLA and CF-AM60-PLA compared to samples PF-AM60 and CF-AM60. Basquin equation is shown in Equation 2 [
54]. In this regard, (
) is the coefficient of fatigue strength, (
b) is the exponent of fatigue strength, and
is the fatigue lifetime. These coefficients are reported in
Table 4.
According to
Table 4, R
2 for all samples is within the acceptable range. Only in CF-AM60-PLA samples, the value of R
2 has decreased. Some of these samples were highly corroded compared to their similar samples. These samples are shown in
Figure 8 (a). Because of that, their corrosion fatigue lifetime has been greatly reduced.
Figure 8.
The stress-lifetime curves of AM60 and AM60+PLA for (a) averaged data and (b) all data.
Figure 8.
The stress-lifetime curves of AM60 and AM60+PLA for (a) averaged data and (b) all data.
Compared to the PF-AM60 sample, the PF-AM60-PLA sample on average had a 49% increase in fatigue lifetime. This is exactly as expected. PLA coating has increased the cross-sectional area of the sample. Therefore, fatigue resistance has increased. However, at the higher stress levels, the fatigue lifetime increased up to 67%.
The fatigue lifetime of CF-AM60-PLA specimens has decreased compared to CF-AM60 samples. However, it should be considered that 10XSBF solution was used for CF-AM60-PLA samples. In fact, despite using a 10 times stronger solution, the fatigue lifetime has decreased by only 35%.
Figure 9 shows the FESEM images of the fracture surfaces of the PF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa of the stress level. In these figures, PLA coating and glue were seen separately. In addition, striations caused by fatigue loading were seen. Cleavage was also observed on the fracture surfaces of this specimen, which indicated the brittleness of the material [
23].
In general, there are three stages containing the crack initiation, the crack growth, and the final failure due to fatigue loading. Due to bending fatigue loading, the highest stress occurs on the surface of the samples. Therefore, cracks start and grow in these areas. In the last stage, the sudden and final failure of the specimen occurs [
55,
56].
Figure 10 depicts the fracture surfaces of the PF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa of the stress level. In this sample, the separation of glue and AM60 and also the separation of glue and PLA coating were observed. Similarly, striations and micro-cracks were also seen. Then, on the fracture surfaces of PLA coatings, the defects were also observed. These defects are spherical and their diameter is about 0.01 mm. One of the causes of these defects was the temperature of the nozzle during 3D printing. The temperature of 180 °C for PLA causes the material to vaporize. These vapors create bubbles in the sample. After bursting, these bubbles cause the formation of defects in the sample [
57,
58,
59].
Figure 11 depicts the fracture surfaces of the CF-AM60-PLA sample at 80 MPa of the stress level. The separation of glue and sample is shown as a failure mechanism. In addition, one of the effects of corrosion is cavities and holes which were shown in research to reduce the fatigue lifetime of the specimen due to stress concentration. these products were seen in FESEM images [
55,
60,
61]. Moreover, micro cracks were observed. These microcracks enhance the crack initiation stage in fatigue loading [
56]. In research, it was shown that these cracks appear under CF conditions [
62]. In another research, it was shown that the micro-cracks in the sample due to corrosion caused stress concentration and decreased the fatigue lifetime of the sample [
63].
Shrinkage holes are also shown. Magnesium alloy is produced by the casting method, which is the cause of this type of shrinkage cavities. Moreover, angular cleavage plates were seen on the fracture surfaces, which indicated the brittle fracture behavior of the part.
Figure 12 illustrates the results of the EDS analysis. In this Figure, according to
Table 3, the constituent elements of the SBF are shown.
Table 4.
The obtained fatigue properties of AM60 magnesium alloy.
Table 4.
The obtained fatigue properties of AM60 magnesium alloy.
Test Conditions |
All Data |
Average Data |
(MPa) |
b |
R2 |
(MPa) |
b |
R2 |
PF-AM60 |
506.92 |
-0.137 |
0.9407 |
589.97 |
-0.151 |
0.9534 |
CF-AM60 |
419.50 |
-0.133 |
0.9144 |
494.11 |
-0.148 |
0.9999 |
PF-AM60-PLA |
1444.60 |
-0.208 |
0.9849 |
1502.30 |
-0.211 |
0.9999 |
CF-AM60-PLA |
429.96 |
-0.146 |
0.6109 |
618.86 |
-0.180 |
0.6785 |
Figure 9.
Fracture surface of PF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 9.
Fracture surface of PF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 10.
Fracture surface of PF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.
Figure 10.
Fracture surface of PF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.
Figure 11.
Fracture surface of CF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 11.
Fracture surface of CF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 12.
EDS analysis for CF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 12.
EDS analysis for CF-AM60-PLA at 80 MPa.
Figure 13 depicts the fracture surfaces of the CF-AM60-PLA sample at 120 MPa. In this figure, the separation of glue and sample, and also other effects such as cracks between the coating and the glue were shown. In addition, shrinkage cavities were seen, indicating improper manufacturing methods. The cleavage plates and striations were also seen. In research, it was shown that in Mg alloys at higher stress levels due to the presence of Al and Zn, the size of the holes caused by corrosion is larger, which leads to the initiation of cracks. This is while smaller holes were created at the level of less stress. These holes are connected and a crack is formed [
64].
Figure 14 shows the results of the EDS analysis on the outer surface of the coating. Corrosion holes were seen on this surface. Moreover, soluble SBF elements were seen.
In general, signs of corrosion were seen only on the outer surfaces of the coating layers, and the magnesium alloy did not suffer corrosion, which is one of the advantages of using the coating.
Figure 13.
Fracture surface of CF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.
Figure 13.
Fracture surface of CF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.
Figure 14.
EDS analysis for CF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.
Figure 14.
EDS analysis for CF-AM60-PLA at 120 MPa.