Several non-surgical approaches, such as pharmacological, electrical, laser therapy, and cell-based therapies, have been developed to promote remyelination and improve functional recovery in PNI [14,111-114]. For human patients, the most common treatment implies surgical resolution, and, in cases of a short gap (<1cm), neurorrhaphy is frequently used with end-to-end sutures of the proximal and distal ends [7, 23,115,116].
4.1. Surgical Approach
In regard to the surgical approach, for short gaps (<1cm), the neurorrhaphy technique is used, however it would cause excessive tension for a larger gap [
7,
23,
115,
116]. Thus, for medium and larger gaps, the most common technique is nerve grafting nerve reconstruction [
7,
117,
118]. For gaps larger than 3 cm, the autograft is the current gold standard with an immunogenically inert scaffold that stimulates adhesion molecules and neurotrophic factors [
7,
23].
In human medicine, nerve transfers have been used as a reliable surgical option, preserving muscle and sensory innervation [
119,
120]. Also, it was described that end-to-end nerve transfers for radial nerve palsies, traumatic ulnar nerve injury and ulnar nerve compressive neuropathy [
121,
122]. On the other hand, there is a case series describing vein wrapping after nerve repair [
123].
Commercially nerve wraps based on collagen are available, such as NeuraWrap Integralife Sciences by bovine-derived type I collagen, already used for nerve repair of a rat sciatic never [
124,
125]. The AxoGuard nerve wrap (Axogen) by porcine small intestine submucosa was also already used [
126,
127]. The Hyaluronic acid-carboxy methylcellulose film (HA-CMC) and human amniotic membrane wrap are still in research [128-130].
Other alternative approaches are based on tissue engineering with the use of scaffolds and mesenchymal stem cells and their potential, such as strength, biodegradability, biocompatibility, porosity, cell adhesion, differentiation, proliferation and growth [
131].
4.2. Electrostimulation Modality
In the last years, ES has been shown to have potential enhancing regeneration in different types of nerve injuries, including crush lesions [
17,
132,
133], transection [
134,
135] and long-distance injuries [
17,
136]. This modality has been helping recovery in the context of one health, due to its therapeutic mechanism to reduce muscle atrophy and promote active muscle reinnervation, increasing the expression of structural protective proteins and neurotrophic factors. Furthermore, it may possibly modulate sensory feedback and reduce neuralgia by inhibiting descending pathways [
137].
Previous studies have suggested that the nerve effects of ES could be achieved by upregulating the expression of BDNF [
60,
138,
139], glial cell-like derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) [
137,
140], TrKB) [
141,
142] and adenosine monophosphate (CAMP) [
143].
The positive effects of ES in nerve repair were reported in both animals [
32,
33,
40,
46,
61,
135] and humans [
32]. This efficient modality could maintain muscle weight, the twitch characteristics, modulating fatigue and mechanosensitivity [
32,
33,
46].
Furthermore, functional electrical stimulation (FES) is an ES technique that uses sequences of short bursts of electrical pulses to stimulate nerves neat the motor plate region or through peripheral afferent nerves, activating peripheral spinal reflex. FES uses a low intensity current sufficient enough to trigger an action potential that induces muscle contraction. Low-frequency FES is used to promote nerve regeneration, however the methods and frequencies applied diverge and need to be standardized, due to increase of nerve damage with high-frequency currents. Additionally, the use of biocompatible gels that provide skin maintenance and current uniform distribution on the electrodes, makes this a better non-invasive stimulation approach with conventional surface electrodes suitable for innervating large muscles close to the skin [
137,
144].
FES has shown to increase intraneuronal CAMP, improving regenerative ability via increased expression of the neurotrophins and cytoskeletal proteins [
17]. Also, this modality may mimic physiological wave of Ca
2+ influx that generates a retrograde signal, leading to activation of cell autonomous mechanisms and promoting regeneration. BDNF, NGF and neurotrophins 4/5 may play an essential role in neuronal regeneration and maintenance [17,145-147]. These beneficial effects are associated with up-regulation of BDNF and its TrkB receptors in motoneurons [
60,
141].
Studies in both humans and animals, have demonstrated that FES promotes preferential re-innervation of motor and sensory neurons, leading to a faster recovery [
14,
60,
148], helping in the remyelination process [
14,
39], and avoiding nerve injury-induced muscle atrophy [14, 149, 150].
Most studies that are performed in animals’ resort to a low-frequency ES, usually 20 Hz [
32,
39,
53,
151,
152], or 10 Hz [
40,
45], although a variable range of values from 20 to 200 Hz [
153], or 4 to 75 Hz [
33,
46], has been documented.
The correct selection of frequency is mandatory, because as mentioned before, higher frequencies can deteriorate and aggravate atrophic muscle events [
7,
115,
154]. Thus, to determine standard parameters, such as duration, it is important to consider extent damage variations of different injuries and possible side effects on the healthy tissues [
7,
115].
In human medicine, this modality can be also associated with surgical techniques [
115,
154]. For improving plantar spasticity, it was described a 5 day/week protocol [
155] for 3-4 weeks, although longer treatments of 6-12 weeks could be necessary with pulse frequencies of 30-50 Hz and pulse duration until 300 microseconds [155, 156-160]. Treatment time has to consider potential fatigue, but usually ranges from 20-30 min per session [157-159].
Gunter and collaborators (2019) [
161] stated that ES didn’t lead to neural damage when continuous stimulation with 20 Hz was applied for 16 h. Also, Agnew and McCreery (1990) [
162] had several works demonstrating that ES was safe for application in the treatment of cats with PNI [
163]. Furthermore, it was shown that a 20 Hz frequency was considered safe but increasing to 50-100 Hz, even pulsed current and partial fiber recruitment, could lead to neural damage.
Supporting this statement, Waters et al. (1985)[
164], applied ES during 12 years in human patients with peroneal nerve lesion, using a frequency of 33 Hz, concluding that there was evidence of long-term safety with frequencies near 30 Hz.
Duty cycle describes the percentage of “on” and “off” stimulation time and it was shown that 50% of efficient stimulation time, with 50 Hz, could stimulate the peroneal nerve of a cat for a period of 16 h, with considerably less damage when compared to 100% stimulation time [
162,
165].
Thus, multiple animal studies defend the beneficial effects of ES with low frequencies and electrodiagnostic tests revealing highly increase of CMAP scores after ES [166-170].
Actually, long-term stimulators have been surgically implanted in human patients, targeting nerve and securing electrode array [
171]. These invasive devices penetrate the nerve to facilitate targeted activation of nerve fascicles [
161,
171].
Finally, ES may influence the concentration of circulating cytokines [
172,
173], modulation neuroinflammatory response [
174], through the macrophage and microglia action, which could be related to temporary decrease in spasticity up to 40 min after treatments [
175].
Additionally, ES could help in the four phases of PNI: oxidative stress stage (0-12h); inflammation stage (12h-3 day); atrophy stage (3-14 days) and atrophic fibrosis stage (14-28 days). The effects of treatment on peripheral neurogenesis vary according to the position of stimulation [
176].
The author uses a standard protocol to the PNI that includes: until 50 Hz; duty cycle of 1:5; 10-16 mA; 10 min; and a trapezoid pulsated current (BTL - 4820 Smart ®, Hertfordshire, GB).
Figure 2.
Functional electrical stimulation on the flexor muscle group of the hindlimb applied on a dog (A) and on a cat (B).
Figure 2.
Functional electrical stimulation on the flexor muscle group of the hindlimb applied on a dog (A) and on a cat (B).
4.3. Exercises and Physical Activity
Even if there is not a clear relation between rehabilitation exercises and axon regeneration, there are specific physical exercises that avoid secondary lesions, such as disuse muscle atrophy, contracture, edema, stasis and pain. There is no developed standard treatment to be applied, the used ones differing mostly in intensity duration and time [
32].
However, exercises may promote angiogenesis, neurogenesis and neurotrophins expression, increasing nerve vascular integrity, decreasing apoptosis and modulating inflammation. Experimental findings, mostly in rodents, have shown the impact of exercise on synaptogenesis, myelination, neural recovery, growth development and muscle reinnervation. Examples are the resorting to treadmill training [
32,
36,
41,
177], high speed exercise running [
178,
179], swimming [
35,
180], voluntary locomotor exercises of endurance and resistance [
66,
181], isometric exercises [
182], sensory retraining [
183], manual stimulation [
184], passive range of motion exercises and joint mobilizations [
37,
62].
The mechanisms of action related to the influence of physical exercises in nerve repair are different and based on research [
32], resulting in the evidences that this could be due to neurotrophin increment, such as BDNF and Glial maturation factor (GMF), resulting in survival and regeneration of damaged axons [
61,
185].
Thus, effects of these exercises differ according to intensity and volume of training, as well as the type of nerve injury. For example, running in the land treadmill for 10 weeks could lead to a faster nerve repair in rats [
33], probably related to reduce level of myelin associated glycoprotein (MAG) on axonal growth inhibitor [
9]. The MAG and complex gangliosides are related to long-term axon stability in both central nervous system and peripheral nervous system [
186], as a minor component of periaxonal myelin [
187], allowing axoncytoarchitecture and regulating axon outgrowth [
186], which is particularly important in human patients with peripheral nervous system immune diseases, such as Guillain-Barre Syndrome [
188].
Axon regeneration development by treadmill training has been previously demonstrated and was shown in rats [
9,
34,
189] and mouses [
9,
36,
190] with moderated daily training for 2 weeks [
9].
The efficacy of exercise seems to start from the 4th regeneration week after nerve injury and not before that [
32]. Therefore, overtraining and high workload could interfere with peripheral nerve recovery, mostly in the initial stages with detrimental effects [
60], that could imply a physiological stimulus that interferes with anatomical and biochemical recovery [
60,
152]. However, sensory rehabilitation with intensive protocols could promote sensory perception [32, 183].
Also, immobilization seems to have detrimental consequences on the count of number of neural fibers, delaying repair because of reduction in regeneration rate and not by the influence on nerve regeneration [
32].
As expected, GDNF, BDNF and Insulin-Like Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1) protein levels are increased in muscles that are exercised and may improve blood flow, activation of Schwann cells [
191], leading to neovascularization, angiogenesis and enhanced metabolism rate [
192]. In addition, it seems to have impact in decreasing neuropathic pain and allodynia, but with poor positive effects described in humans [
192].
Locomotor training could be one of the best options to help in PNI, starting with moderate exercise that increases in intensity and volume [
7]. The BDNF, which is highly related to locomotor training, it is also potentiated in association with electrical activity [
60], promoting remyelination. The increase in neurotrophic factors by locomotor training may be limited by the distance between the end axonal tops estimated by 5 mm [
6].
Spontaneous peripheral nerve recovery is commonly inadequate and depends on the type of injury and damage extension [
1]. A few studies in animals where moderate exercises and rehabilitation methods of motor and sensory functions were used, reveal that such an approach could improve coordination and sensory-motor tasks [
41], and the locomotor training could be an example of that in dogs, cats and humans [
193] (
Figure 3).
4.4. Combination of Electrical Stimulation and Locomotor Training
There is evidence in the current literature that brief low-frequency electrical stimulation effectively promotes axon regeneration, maximizing functional recovery in PNI, namely in facial nerve stimulation with 20 Hz for 30 min/day after a crush injury as well as after transection of the sciatic nerve with silicone tube and collagen gel surgical repair [
194].
Thompson and collaborators (2014) [
195] showed that moderate treadmill training and brief ES (with 20 Hz, for 1h, in the sciatic nerve pathway) were applied in different groups of mice, for 5 days/week, revealing enhancement of axon repair. The same efficacy was proved in human patients submitted to carpal tunnel release due to medial nerve injury by constriction of the wrist ligaments (94). Thus, these studies could be translated between human and veterinary medicine to improve recovery following injuries [
148].
One the other hand, Elzinga et al. (2015) [
196] showed that the same type of ES stimulated axon growth and muscle reinnervation after nerve surgery in rats and humans, improving regeneration in delayed nerve repair. In addition, activity-based exercises, such as land treadmill combined with electrical stimulation, after PNI, increases the potential of axon regeneration [
60,
134,
195]. The same was reported with 20 Hz for 1 h in rats, mice [
60,
196] and human patients [
197,
198].
Prior investigations, had addressed the role of ES for the complex pathophysiology of neuropathic pain, particularly in the inhibition of synaptic stripping and the excessive excitability of the dorsal roost ganglion, reducing pain and improving neurological function [
176]. This modality could be safely used in conjunction with other treatments, such as pharmacological, cell-based therapies and rehabilitation techniques [
17,
176]. Every day exercise with bipolar ES for 20 min significantly improved nerve regeneration and sensorimotor recovery, assessed by gait analysis, coordination tests and electrophysiological outcomes. Nowadays, there are human medicine clinical trials being conducted based on the effect of conditioning ES as a preoperative treatment prior to nerve decompression and reconstruction [
199].
An early moderated and progressive training with electrical stimulation and locomotor training could help reducing neuropathic pain [
32,
42], preventing neurotrophin-mediated hyperexcitability [
32,
200] and reducing facilitation of the monosynaptic H-reflex [
32,
36]. Additionally, this combination could be critical to enhance chances of recovering mobility, avoiding secondary muscle or joint contractures [
6].
To Menchetti and colleagues (2020) [
6], 25% of cats showed improved neurological condition with the support of physical therapies in time scenario, which is considered fundamental. Thus, FES and treadmill exercise has been shown to have positive synergetic effects on nerve regeneration and muscle reinnervation [
14].
The exact mechanism of ES and locomotor training to be implemented is still poorly established, however CAMP and BDNF are reported to play a key role. ES could cause an increased influx of Ca2+ into the neurons followed by an increase in intracellular CAMP levels [
14], and could be used as a rehabilitation intervention to stimulate and accelerate the process of nerve regeneration.
Implementation of these rehabilitation protocols in delayed time frames after PNI could, however, lead to different reactions on axon regeneration and motoneuron synapsis [
34,
86,
166].
4.5. Other Rehabilitation Modalities
Low-level laser therapy (LLLT) is another modality that could be applied in a clinical setting after PNI [
14]. This induces upregulation of nitric monoxide that is related to necrosis and apoptosis [
201]. The nitric monoxide and other free radicals that result from lipidic peroxidation of the central and peripheral nervous systems, may have an important role in neuropathic pain [
202] and might be inhibited by laser therapy.
LLLT could be combined with TENS, which was implemented in radial nerve injury of human patients, translating in significant effects compared with a control group, maintaining this improvement for 1-3 years [
137]. Therefore, laser therapy was commonly applied in PNI every day, during 5 consecutive days, followed by application once or twice a week, with positive effects [
14].
These studies were based on the possible ability to promote regeneration and functional recovery of injured peripheral nerves, accelerating myelination, increasing axonal diameter, stimulation Schwann cells proliferation and improving motor nerve function [14,203-205]. The mechanisms behind this could be associated to DNA and RNA synthesis with consequent protein synthesis alongside cell proliferation, modifying nerve cell action potentials. The tissue biostimulation effects with possible increase in axonal diameter are important, although many issues arise due to the lack of standardized parameters [
7].
As for the author’s suggestion, the use of a 980 nm laser is essential, with a power of 10-19mW/cm2 at the level of the PNI, for 3 to 5 days in a row, followed by 3 times per week, then two times, usually until 8 weeks of treatment (
Figure 4).
The combination of laser therapy with ultrasounds is also a possibility, which has mechanical and thermal properties, stimulating blood circulation, release of BDNF, increase cell metabolism and tissue nutrition [7, 154]. Some authors considered ultrasound to be more effective than LLLT in improving strength, pain and sensory deficits. Although, according to Page et al. (2013) [
206], there was no evidence of better results in using ultrasounds with the implementation of a splint, when compared to any other surgical procedure.
For the authors, ultrasounds are usually performed with intensity ranging from 1 to 2.5 w/cm2, in a pulsed mode, with a duty cycle of 20% for 10 min. Recommended speed of the movement with the head sound over the skin should be slower but never static and are mostly performed with longitudinal or circular patterns.
On the other hand, the use of LLLT plus splints showed to help in carpal contractures in human medicine [
207].
4.6. Cell-Based Therapies and PNI
Cell-based therapies are the most innovative treatment approaches in the PNI field. This can help damaged tissues by targeting differentiation processes that influence cell morphology, metabolic activity, growth factors secretion and signal response [
1,
29].
Stem cells can help in nerve regeneration by promoting a neuroprotective microenvironment that modulates degeneration and apoptosis, supporting neurogenesis, axonal growth and remyelination [
208] (
Figure 5). Increased cell metabolism could be also related to increase in neurotrophin 3 (NT-3), neurotrophin 1 (NT-1), neurotrophin 4 (NT-4), ciliary-derived neurotrophic factor (CDNF), BDNF, NGF and GDNF 4 [208-210].
In addition, stem cells, such as mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) may increase neovascularization and promote secretion of tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase – 8 (VEGF), angiopoietin 1 and transformation of growth factor B and IL-8 [
208,
210].
The MSCs have a paracrine role modulating neuroinflammation and immune response. This immunomodulated response occurs through pro-inflammatory cytokines produced by lymphocytes and can activate MSCs. Thus, MSC can inhibit scar tissue formation, promoting angiogenesis and tissue regeneration [
1,
7].
Furthermore, MSCs have self-renewal properties and are able to differentiate into neural-like and Schwann-like myelinating cells [
1,
7]. They display a role in decreasing the expression of pro-apoptotic factors, while potentiating anti-apoptotic mechanisms [
211].