2.2.1.1. β-Carboline monomers
Attending to the saturation of the indole-fused pyridine ring, these compounds can be classified as β-carbolines (βCs), dihydro-β-carbolines (DHβCs) and tetrahydro-β-carbolines (THβCs). It is worth mentioning that N-methyl quaternary salt of β-carboline alkaloids also occur in nature.
The simplest
β-carboline, Norharmane (
217), firstly isolated from a higher plant, can be found in different marine sponges. In 2007 Herraiz et al. showed that
217 presents possible applications against PD [
159].
The presence of substituents in the basic structure of βC and level of reduction of the ring lead to enhanced or new properties in comparison with 217. The rest of the section has been structured according to the substituted position in the βC which is responsible for the therapeutic activity, trying to group them in their corresponding families and making a comparison with their reduced analogues when possible. Therefore, the following subsections will be presented: C1-subtituted-βCs, Manzamines, N2-substituted-βCs and C3-substituted-βCs. It is important to remark that although manzamines belong to C1-substituted-βCs, their specific structure and bioactivities require a separate discussion from their simpler analogues.
βCs in which the C1-substitution is responsible for their therapeutic activity represent the largest family of these scaffolds. The variety of functional groups than can be found at C1 is pretty wide, ranging from simple alkyl chains or aryl groups to complex glycosides or polycycles.
Harmane (
218) could be isolated from the culture of the marine-sponge associated fungus
Neosartorya tsunodae KUFC 9213 [
160]. Compound
218 exhibited stronger AChE and BuChE inhibition (Ic
50 >10 μM) compared to
217 and a weak, in-vitro antileishmanial activity against
Leishmani infantum [
161]. 1-Ethyl-
β-carboline (
219), isolated from the marine bryozoan
Orthoscuticella ventricosa, exhibited moderate antiplasmodial activity (IC
50 = 18 μM) against
P. falciparum K1 strain [
150]. The addition of a C4-OMe to the pyridine ring (
220) exerted detrimental effect on the activity [
162]. Other
βCs from the same bryozoan such as 1-Ethyl-4-methylsulfone-
β-carboline (
222), Orthoscuticelline C (
223) and Orthoscuticelline D (
224) had lower efficiency, indicating that the addition of C4-sulfone to the ring or hydroxy, amino or sulfonic acid groups to the alkyl chain were not beneficial [
150,
163].
However, Harmine (
221), a C7-OMe analogue of
217 firstly isolated from plants but widely found in marine species, exhibited a wide range of bioactivity: antitumor, antibiotic, antifungal, antioxidant, antiplasmodial, antimutagenic, antigenotoxic, acts on gamma–aminobutyric acid type A and monoamine oxidase A or B receptor, improves insulin sensitivity, exerts vasorelaxant effect, suppress osteoclastogenesis, among others. These properties have been well documented by Patel and coworkers [
164].
Eudistalbin A (
225), isolated from tunicate
Eudistoma album, presented in vitro cytotoxicity (IC
50 = 3.2 μg/mL) against KB cells.[
148] Plakortamine A (
226), isolated from the sponge
Plakortis nigra, showed antitumor activity against HCT-116 line ( IC
50 = 3.2 μM) [
149]. Both Eudistomidin C (
227) and J (
228), obtained from tunicate
Eudistoma glaucus,[
165] hold potent cytotoxicity against murine leukemia L1210 (IC
50 = 0.36 and 0.047 μg/mL, respectively) [
165,
166], while only
228 is active also against P388 and KB cancer cells (IC
50 = 0.043 and 0.063 μg/mL, respectively) [
166]. 14-Methyleudistomidin C (
229), from the ascidian
Eudistoma gilboverde, demonstrated significant cytotoxicity against four different human tumor cell lines (IC
50 < 1.0 μg/mL) [
167]. Ingenine E (
230), isolated from the sponge
Acanthostrongylophora ingens, is strongly cytotoxic against MCF-7, HCT-116 and A549 lines [
168]. It is worth to mention that although Orthoscuticelline C (
222) is chemically similar to
215-228, its anticancer biological activity has not been tested so far.
Opacalines A (
231) and B (
232), found in the ascidian
Pseudodistoma opacum, exhibited antiplasmodial activity due to alkyl guanidine-substituted chains (IC
50 = 2.5 and 4.5 μM, respectively) [
169]. As observed, the N9-hydroxylation affects negatively to this activity. Other synthetic debromo- or TH
βCs derivatives of
231 and
232 were less active than the parent compounds, indicating that the Br atom plays an important role in the activity.
Eudistomins W (
233) and X (
234), isolated from tunicate
Eudistoma sp., hold antifungal activity against
C. albicans and
B. subtilis,
S. aureus, and
E. coli, respectively; as well as some antibiotic properties [
170].
Imidazolium-containing Gesashidine A (
235), first isolated from a
Thorectidae sponge, showed antibacterial activity against Micrococcus luteus but no cytotoxicity against cell line L5178Y [
171]. Interestingly, the presence of a C3-carboxylate shuts down the antibacterial activity of Dragmacidonamine A (
236), isolated from the same sponge, and its sulfoxide Hyrtimomine H (
237), obtained from
Hyrtios sponge. However, it enhances their cytotoxicity when compared to
235.
Figure 49.
C1-substituted βC compounds 218-237.
Figure 49.
C1-substituted βC compounds 218-237.
Reduced DH
βC and TH
βC analogues of compounds
218-237 (
Figure 50) have similar therapeutic activity as their unsaturated counterparts. Eudistomidins B (
238), G (
239), H (
240) and I (
241), isolated from
Eudistoma glaucus, exhibited cytotoxicity against L1210, L5178Y, P388 and KB cancer cells, although weaker than related compounds
223-237. Ingenine F (
242), obtained from
Acanthostrongylophora ingens, showed similar levels of cytotoxic activity against MCF-7, HCT-116, and A549 lines as compound
230 [
172]. (+)-7-Bromotrypargine (
243), isolated from the marine sponge
Ancorina, exerts antimalarial activity as
231, but also weak cytotoxicity against HEK293 [
173]. Haploscleridamine (
244), isolated from
Haplisclerida sponge, was identified as an inhibitor of cathepsin K [
174]
; while its C3-CO
2H analogue Hainanerectamine C (
245), identified from
Hyrtios erecta sponge, showed moderate anticancer activity as inhibitor of Aurora kinase A [
33].
Hyrtimomine I (
246) and
J (
247), hydroxyimidazolium
βCs found in
Hyrtios sponge, exhibited antifungal activity against
A. niger (IC
50 = 8.0 μg/mL each) and
C. albicans (IC
50 = 2.0 μg/mL each), but only
246 against
C. neoform (IC
50 4.0 μg/mL). However, Hyrtimomine H (
248), from the same sponge, showed no activity, indicating that C3-CO
2H group is crucial [
175]. It is worth noting that this kind of activity has not been reported so far for similar compounds
235-237.
Figure 51.
C1-substituted βC compounds 246-248.
Figure 51.
C1-substituted βC compounds 246-248.
Blunt and Munro indicated that C1-vinyl groups might be beneficial for antitumor activity. 1-Vinyl-8-hydroxy-
β-carboline (
249), collected from bryozoan
Cribricellina cribaria [
176], and Plakortamine B (
250), produced by the sponge
Plakortis nigra [
149], were found to be active against P388 (IC
50 = 100 ng/mL) and HCT-116 line (IC
50 = 3.2 μM) respectively. C1-aryl compound Chaetogline F (
251), obtained from fish-derived fungus
Chaetomium globosum 1C51 through biotransformation [
177], represents a more promising structure for the design of anti-Alzheimer drugs [
178], and presented antibiotic activity against
Veillonella parvula,
Bacteroides vulgatus,
Streptococcus sp., and
Pepto streptococcus sp. [
179]. Apart from antibiotic activities, other authors found that some synthetic C1-aryl derivatives exhibited activity against
Leishmania donovani [
180].
Figure 52.
C1-substituted βC compounds 249-251.
Figure 52.
C1-substituted βC compounds 249-251.
C1-furyl-subtituted Flazin (
252), obtained from the oyster
Crassostrea sikamea,[
181] is a promising candidate for the development of anti-HIV drugs [
182]. An exhaustive SAR study carried out by Liu et al. identified the synthetic Flazinamide (
253) as the most promising drug. Eudistomin I (
254), isolated from
Eudistoma olivaceum tunicate, contains a dihydropyrrole ring that confers its antibacterial effect [
183,
184,
185]. Indole-substituted Eudistomin U (
255) and Isoeudistomin U (
256), isolated from
Lissoclinum fragile, and their synthetic analogues, have been reported to have antibacterial, antimalarial, and anticancer properties, as extensively reviewed by Kolodina and Serdyuk [
186]. Plakortamine D (
257), a C1-isoxazolidine-substituted scaffold obtained from
Plakortis nigra sponge, bestows antitumor activity against HCT-116 line (IC
50 = 15 μM) [
149]. Finally, Annomontine (
258), Ingenine C (
259) and Ingenine D (
260), all of them bearing aminopyrimidine rings and isolated from the Indonesian sponge
Acanthostrongylophora ingens, exhibited cytotoxic activities against MCF-7 and HCT-116 [
168,
187].
Figure 53.
C1-substituted βC compounds 252-260.
Figure 53.
C1-substituted βC compounds 252-260.
1-Acetyl-
β-carboline (
261), isolated from
Marinactinospora thermotolerans, showed weak cytotoxicity against NCI-H460 cells (IC
50 = 18.73 μg/mL)[
188] and antibiotic properties against
S. Aureus [
189]. Eudistomidin K (
262), from the tunicate
Eudistoma glaucus, exhibited weak cytotoxicity against P388, L1210 and KB cells (IC
50 > 10.0 μg/mL) [
166]. Marinacarbolines A-D (
263-266), obtained from
Marinactinospora thermotolerant, and their synthetical derivatives, bear an additional C3-amido moiety with pendant aryl rings. Their cytotoxicity was firstly investigated in 2015 [
190]
, but Hong and Lee have performed very recently and in-depth SAR study against ocetaxel-Resistant Triple-Negative Breast Cancer [
191]. Compounds
263-266 also exhibit promising antimalarial activity [
128]. Eudistalbin A (
267), isolated from
Eudistoma album tunicate, exerts cytotoxic activity in vitro against KB cells (IC
50 = 3.2 μg/mL).[
148] Eudistomin T (
268), from the tunicate
Eudistoma olivaceum, exhibited only weak phototoxicity, but also antibiotic properties [
184].
Figure 54.
C1-substituted βC compounds 261-268.
Figure 54.
C1-substituted βC compounds 261-268.
Eudistomin Y (
269), isolated from
Eudistoma tunicates, and its synthetic analogues, tend to exhibit antifungal [
192] and antibiotic [
192,
193]
, but also significant cytotoxic and antiproliferative activity [
192,
194,
195]. SAR analyses indicated that an increasing number of Br atoms in the aromatic rings increased their antibiotic effect. Reduction of the benzoyl moiety does not affect its properties, as found for Eudistomin Y
11 (
270).
Figure 55.
C1-substituted βC compounds 269-270.
Figure 55.
C1-substituted βC compounds 269-270.
Xestomanzamine A (
271), isolated from sponge
Acanthostrongylophora sp., presented moderate antibiotic, anti-HIV and antifungal activity, but no cytotoxicity against A594 and HCT-116 [
196]. However, imidazol-containing Hyrtiocarboline (
272), from
Hyrtios reticulatus sponge, showed significant cytotoxicity against H522-T1, MDA-MB-435 and U937 lines (IC
50 = 1.2, 3.0 and 1.5 μg/mL, respectively) [
197]. Imidazolium-containing Hyrtiomanzamine (
273), from
Hyrtios erecta sponge, and Dragmacidonamine A (
274), from
Dragmacidon sponge, exhibited some cytotoxicity [
171,
197]. Also,
273 exhibited some immunosuppressive activity [
198]. Indolyl-substituted Pityriacitrin (
275), firstly isolated from a
Paracoccus marine bacterium, exerts promising anticancer activity against MCF-7, MDA-231, and PC3 lines [
199]. In-depth SAR analysis of Pityriacitrin analogues showed that C3 amide, hydrazide, hydrazones, 1,3,4-oxadiazole, 1,2,4-triazole, and pyrazole moieties are essential for potent anticancer activity [
200].
Hyrtiosulawesine (
276), found in the Indonesian sponge
Hyrtios erectus, present a great variety of applications, such as antioxidant [
201], antiphospholipase A2 [
202], antidiabetic [
203], anti-inflammatory [
204], antimalarial [
205], and cytotoxicity towards Hep-G2 line (IC
50 = 19.3 μmol/L) [
206]. 6-O-(β-glucopyranosyl)hyrtiosulawesine (
277), from the same marine species, is only slightly cytotoxic on hepatic cells, and have antimalarial activity (IC
50 = 5 μM).
Figure 56.
C1-substituted βC compounds 271-277.
Figure 56.
C1-substituted βC compounds 271-277.
Finally, Shishijimicin A-C (
278-280) (
Figure 57), isolated from sea squirt
Didemnum proliferum, presents antitumor activity against P388 cells [
207]. This property is attributed to the intricate conjugated en-diyne group, being
278 the most powerful enediyne-based antitumor antibiotic identified to date. Remarkably, the total synthesis of compound
278 was accomplished in 2015 by Nicolaou [
208].
Manzamines are a special family of C1-substituted
βCs in which the C1-moiety generally consists of a characteristic complex penta- or tetracyclic system, or a monomacrocycle. Manzamine A (
281) (also named Keramamine A) [
209] was the first reported member of these compounds [
210].
281 showed a broad spectrum of biological effects: potent antileishmanial and antimycobacterial activity [
211]; cytotoxicity against pancreatic cancer, P388, and human colorectal carcinoma [
210,
212,
213]; and anti-Alzheimer activity [
214]. It also exhibited antiviral effects against HSV-1, HSV-2 and HIV [
211,
215,
216]. Compound
281 exhibited potent antitubercular activity against
M. tuberculosis (H37Rv) [
217]. 8-Hydroxymanzamine A (
282) (also named manzamine G or manzamine K) exhibited moderate antitumor activity against KB and LoVo lines and anti-HSV-2 activity [
216].
ent-8-Hydroxymanzamine A (
283) is active against P388 (IC
50 = 0.25 µg/mL) and exert in vitro antitrypanosomal effect [
218]. Manzamine M (
284) proved cytotoxicity against L1210 cells (IC
50 = 0.3 µg/mL), and antibacterial activity against
Sarcina lutea (MIC = 2.3 µg/mL) and
Corynebacterium xerosis (MIC = 5.7 µg/mL) [
219].
12,34-Oxamanzamine A (
285), with a C12–C34 ether bridge, exhibited lower antimalarial and antituberculosis activity compared to the other manzamines [
220]. 12,28-Oxamanzamine A (
286) and 12,28-Oxa-8-hydroxymanzamine A (
287), with C12-C28 or C12-C34 ether bridges, showed effective antifungal, anti-inflammatory and anti-HIV-1 activities [
221].
3,4-Dihydro-6-hydroxymanzamine A (
288) presented cytotoxicity against L1210 cells (IC
50 = 1.4 µg/mL), and antibacterial activity against
Sarcina lutea (MIC = 6.3µg/mL) and
Corynebacterium xerosis (MIC = 3.1 µg/mL) [
219].
N-Methyl-
epi-manzamine D (
289) and
epi-Manzamine D (
290) showed cytotoxicity against HeLa and B16-F10 cells [
220]. 1,2,3,4-Tetrahydro-2-
N-methyl-8-hydroxymanzamine A (
291) (8-Hydroxy-2-
N-methylmanzamine D) is cytotoxic toward P388 line (ED
50 = 0.8 µg/mL) [
222].
Figure 58.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 281-291.
Figure 58.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 281-291.
Biologically active pentacyclic manzamines having a ketone or alcohol group in their eight-membered ring instead of a double bond have been also reported. Manzamine E (
292) and Manzamine F (Keramamine B) (
293) displayed cytotoxicity toward L5178Y and P388 cells [
223].
Ent-manzanine F (
294) inhibited H37Rv (IC
50 < 12.5 µg/mL) [
218].
ent-12,34-oxamanzamines E (
295) and F (
296) showed weak inhibitory activity against
M. tuberculosis (IC
50 value of 128 µg/mL) [
220]. Pre-
neo-kauluamine (
297) exhibited proteasome inhibitory activity, potent antitrypanosomal effect and antimalarial activity [
224,
225].
Figure 59.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 292-297.
Figure 59.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 292-297.
Several biologically active manzamines containing a
βC ring system with a C1-tetracyclic scaffold have been reported. Manzamine J (
298) showed cytotoxic activity against KB cells (IC
50 >10 µg/mL), while its
N-oxide (
299) against L1578Y (IC
50 = 1.6 µg/mL). Additionally,
298 has anti-tubercular activity against H37Rv [
217]. Manzamine B
N-oxide (
300) displayed weak activity against several Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria [
226]. Acanthomanzamines D (
301) and E (
302), presented a strong proteasome inhibitory effect (IC
50 = 0.63 and 1.5 µg/mL, respectively) [
227].
Manzamines H (
303) and L (
304) hold cytotoxicity against KB cells (IC
50 = 4.6 and 3.5, respectively). Compound
304 also possess weak activity antibiotic activity. [
226] Ma’eganedin A (
305), proved to be a potent antibiotic against
Sarcina lutea and
B. subtilis (MIC = 2.8 µg/mL each) [
228].
Furthermore, 3,4-Dihydromanzamine J (
306) and all the aforementioned manzamines
291,303-305 showed cytotoxic activity against L1210 line (IC
50 = 5.0, 2.6, 1.3, 3.7 and 4.4 µg/mL, respectively) [
217].
Figure 60.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 298-306.
Figure 60.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 298-306.
Finally, other types of monomacrocyclic, and diverse hexa- and heptacyclic biologically active manzamines have been reported. Manzamine C (
307) exhibited cytotoxicity against A549, HT-29 and P388 cells with (IC
50 = 3.5, 1.5, and 2.6 μg/mL, respectively) [
229]. Pyrrolizine-substituted Kepulauamine A (
308) unveiled weak inhibition against K562 and A549 cells and is moderate antibiotic activity [
226]. Manzamine X (
309) exhibited cytotoxic activity against KB cells (IC
50 = 7.9 μg/mL) [
230], while 6-Deoxymanzamine X (
310) against L5178 cells (ED
50 = 1.8 µg/mL) [
231]. Manadomanzamines A (
311) and B (
312) exhibited anti-tubercular effect (MIC = 1.9 and 1.5 µg/mL, respectively); antiviral activity against HIV-1 (EC
50 = 7.0 and 16.5 µg/mL, respectively); cytotoxicity against A549 (IC
50 = 2.5 µg/mL, only
311) and HCT-116 cells (IC
50 = 2.5 and 5.0 µg/mL, respectively); and antifungal effect against
C. albicans (MIC = 20 µg/mL, only
312) and
C. neoformans (MIC = 3.5 µg/mL, only
311) [
196].
Figure 61.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 307-312.
Figure 61.
Chemical structures of Manzamines 307-312.
N2-methyl-
β-carbolinium salts Irene-carbolines A (
313) and B (
314), isolated from ascidian
Cnemidocarpa irene, exerted anti-Alzheimer activity [
232]. Notably, other non-brominated derivatives identified in the same species didn’t afford any activity.
N2-aryl-
β-carbolinium species Reticulatol (
315), Reticulatine (
316) and Reticulatate (
317) could be obtained from
Fascaplysinopsis reticulata sponge.
316 and
317 presented modest antitumor activity, while
315 showed significant selectivity for leukemia [
233].
Figure 62.
N2-substituted βC compounds 313-317.
Figure 62.
N2-substituted βC compounds 313-317.
Variabines A (
318) and B (
319), with a C3-ester, were isolated from the sponge
Luffariealla variabilis, have respectively little and significant effect in the inhibition of chymotrypsin-like activity of the proteasome and breast cancer metastasis [
234]. Therefore, the inhibitory activities are lost by sulfonation of the 6-OH group. Stolonine C (
320), from tunicate
Cnemidocarpa stolonifera, induced apoptosis in PC3 line.[
235] Tiruchanduramine (
321), obtained from the ascidian
Synoicum macroglossum, could be identified as a promising inhibitor of
α-glucosidase due to the presence of a cyclic guanidine group [
236].
C3-indole-subtituted
βCs have been also found in marine sources, such as the family of Hyrtioerectines isolated from the sponge
Hyrtios erectus. Hyrtioerectine A (
322) showed moderate cytotoxicity against HeLa cells (IC
50 = 10 μg/mL) [
237]. Hyrtioerectines D-F (
323–
325) exhibited antibacterial behavior against
C. albicans,
S. Aureus and
Pseudomonas aeruginosa; antioxidant activity; and weak antitumor activity against MDA-MB-231, A549 and HT-29 lines, being
323 and
324 more active than compound
325. Therefore, methylation of the phenol group hampers the antioxidant activity, while a C4-CO
2H moiety is more beneficial than an amido group for antitumor properties.
Figure 63.
C3-substituted βC compounds 318-325.
Figure 63.
C3-substituted βC compounds 318-325.
Regarding saturated carbolines, Hyrtioerectine B (326) prompted moderate cytotoxicity against HeLa cells (IC50 = 5.0 μg/mL).
Figure 64.
Chemical structures of Hyrtioerectine B (326).
Figure 64.
Chemical structures of Hyrtioerectine B (326).