[24] |
Deep learning through LSTM classification and regression for transmission line fault detection, diagnosis and location in large-scale multi-machine power systems - Belagoune, S., Bali, N., Bakdi, A., Baadji, B., Atif, K. (2021) |
DL (Presents three innovative DL classifier regression models based on DRNN for FRI, FTC, and FLP)
Current and voltage signals are monitored using PMUs at various terminals and used as input characteristics for DRNN models
SDL with LSTM to model spatiotemporal sequences of high-dimensional multivariate characteristics
|
Accurate region classification in large-scale multi-machine power systems
Excellent performance in fault location prediction
Excellent categorization and prediction accuracy
|
|
[25] |
A deep learning based intelligent approach in detection and classification of transmission line faults - Fahim, S., Sarker, S., Muyeen, S., Das, S., Kamwa I. (2021) |
|
Accurately manage limited system information and develop resistance to system sounds
Extracts faulty features into a single characteristic, making the fault identification procedure easier
Does not call for manual labeling of data during training and testing, increasing its scalability and applicability to varied datasets
Accuracy rates surpassing 99% in identifying and classifying faults, even under difficult conditions such as the presence of system disturbances, high impedance faults, and line parameter fluctuations
|
The evaluation focuses primarily on simulated datasets
Does not discuss the possible computational or resource needs involved in putting the suggested model into practice in practical applications
Does not offer the model's generalizability to other transmission line layouts and operating situations outside of those that were evaluated
|
[26] |
Self-attention convolutional neural network with time series imaging based feature extraction for transmission line fault detection and classification - Fahim, S., Sarker, Y., Sarker, S., Sheikh, M., Das, S. (2020) |
|
Ability to adjust to various operating environments
Imperceptibly concentrates on the output data from the hidden layer, improving the system's classification precision
Operates well with a variety of sampling frequencies and signal kinds, demonstrating its robustness and adaptability
Withstand noise interference
|
It does not discuss the possible computational or resource needs involved in putting the suggested model into practice in practical applications
The evaluation focuses primarily on simulated datasets
Future deployment of the classifier utilizing actual data gathered from equipment in real-world power grids may necessitate careful consideration of data quality, calibration, and measurement errors
It does not offer the model's generalizability to other transmission line layouts and operating situations outside of those that were evaluated
|
[27] |
End to end machine learning for fault detection and classification in power transmission lines - Rafique, F., Fu, L., Mai, R. (2021) |
‘End to end’ ML model employing LSTM |
Removal of the requirement for intricate feature extraction procedures
Differentiate between several states, such as fault and non-fault, and between various kinds of faults
Flexibility to different problem scenarios and system specifications
Capable of handling voltage and current signals, providing a variety of data sources
Ability to recognize and function in situations of power swings, increasing its usefulness in practical situations
Strong performance across a range of fault scenarios, including as changes in fault impedance, loading circumstances, distance from measurement nodes, and signal noise levels
|
Further examination is necessary in order to determine its efficacy and dependability in real-world applications using data from real power systems in both recorded and real-world settings
Necessary to carefully evaluate the computational load that comes with reconfiguring operational data using a Timesteps strategy to reduce computational load, particularly for large-scale power systems with substantial data requirements
The degree of noise in the signals, the intricacy of the power system structure, and the availability of measuring instruments could affect the robustness of the model
|
[28] |
Detection and classification of transmission line transient faults based on graph convolutional neural network - Tong, H., Qiu, R., Zhang, D., Yang, H., Ding, Q., Shi, X. (2021) |
|
Permits building a model for graph classification
Integrating topological data into the network to deliver temporal and spatial data for fault identification and categorization
Show the suggested method's high accuracy and excellent generalizability in identifying a variety of transient defects in a variety of settings
Demonstrates sensitive and steady performance with respect to robustness and response speed
|
The suggested solution uses a spectral convolution for graph convolution, which is theoretically sound but not very flexible
It is considered that the edge weight is essential for locating faults, indicating that more investigation is required to improve the weighing system
Recommended investigation in the application of dynamic GNN in order to overcome the drawbacks of spectral convolution and facilitate the identification, categorization, and localization of malfunctions in dynamic power grids
|
[29] |
Transmission Line Fault Classification Using Hidden Markov Models - Freire, J., Castro, A., Homci, M., Meiguins, B., Morais, J. (2019) |
|
When it came to fault classification, the HMM algorithm performed better and had reduced error rates
About 90% faster processing times were demonstrated by the HMM method than by any of the FBSC architecture's classifiers
Direct fault event classification is made possible by the HMM method, which streamlines the classification procedure and may even result in less processing cost
|
The study used a particular dataset, UFPA Faults, and concentrated mostly on short-circuit faults
As the stated findings were produced on a workstation with particular hardware requirements (i7 CPU, 16GB memory), the algorithm's application to systems with varying processing capacities may be limited
Its usefulness in practical applications has not yet been confirmed
|
[30] |
High Impedance Single-Phase Faults Diagnosis in Transmission Lines via Deep Reinforcement Learning of Transfer Functions - Teimourzadeh, H., Moradzadeh, A., Shoaran, M., Mohammadi-Ivatloo, B., Razzaghi, R. (2021) |
|
Exhibited greater performance in identifying and precisely finding single-phase to ground short circuit problems in power networks
Attained strong correlation values during the training and testing phases, demonstrating the models' efficacy in fault classification
The DRL approach demonstrated its effectiveness in identifying subtle fault situations and perhaps averting catastrophic failures by outperforming the CNN method in the early identification of high-impedance faults (7000 and 9000 ohms)
|
Mainly concerned with single-phase to ground short circuit problems by simulating data from an IEEE transmission line
Depends on local data gathered from the transmission line, which may restrict its application in circumstances where access to extensive or centralized data is restricted
Deep learning technique skill and substantial computational resources may be needed for its installation and training
|
[31] |
Detection and Evaluation Method of Transmission Line Defects Based on Deep Learning - Liang, H., Zuo, C., Wei, W. (2020) |
|
Identification of transmission line defects using automation, which decreases labor intensity and the necessity for manual inspection
The absence of accessible and standardized datasets in the field of transmission line components is addressed by the development of the Wire_10 dataset, which consists of aerial photos taken by UAVs
Based on the Wire_10 dataset, the defect detection network achieves a low false detection rate of 0.68% and a mean Average Precision (mAP) of 91.1%
|
The scope of the dataset collected by UAVs may be constrained, which could result in missed and false detections in some circumstances, especially in the winter and in non-rural locations
The present dataset may not fully capture the fine features of transmission line components since it classifies problems into broad categories
In actuality, the precise categorization of transmission line components can be complicated, necessitating close examination of a number of variables
|
[32] |
Detection and classification of internal faults in bipolar HVDC transmission lines based on K-means data description method - Farshad, M. (2019) |
|
Exhibits excellent precision and dependability while identifying and categorizing internal DC faults in bipolar HVDC transmission lines
Demonstrates resilience to external errors and standard operating circumstances
Demonstrates its flexibility and adaptability by being able to handle a variety of fault situations, including ones that weren't taken into account during creation
Contributes to its accuracy and stability by being less sensitive to elements including measurement noise, fault resistance, and fault location
Lessens reliance on connected equipment and communication channels
Appropriate for integration into current systems without requiring substantial hardware modifications
|
Although the scheme's low sample frequency makes it more applicable in current systems, it might make it less capable of capturing high-frequency transient events or intricate waveform data
Although the scheme's low sample frequency makes it more applicable in current systems, it might make it less capable of capturing high-frequency transient events or intricate waveform data
|
[33] |
Fault Detection and Classification in Power Transmission Lines using Back Propagation Neural Networks - Teja, O., Ramakrishna, M., Bhavana, G., Sireesha, K. (2020) |
|
The Π-modeling of the three-phase medium power transmission line system simplifies representation and analysis, making fault detection algorithms easier to construct
Compatibility and simplicity of use when MATLAB/Simulink® is used
Creating training data from transmission system simulated values guarantees a regulated training environment for neural networks
By utilizing feedforward BPNN techniques, faults can be accurately classified and detected. This is because neural networks can identify intricate patterns from training data
|
The transmission line system may become overly simplistic if it is converted to a Π-model.
The analysis was limited to fault scenarios including AG and ABG, which may not accurately reflect the range of faults that might arise in real-world transmission line systems.
The system complexity, dataset size, and computational resources are only a few of the variables that may influence the optimization algorithm selection
In order to evaluate the efficacy of fault detection algorithms in practical applications, performance analysis mostly concentrated on MSE, epochs, and training time, ignoring other critical metrics like accuracy, precision, and recall
There are no specifics given about the hybridization criteria, optimization method, or anticipated performance gains
|
[34] |
Component identification and defect detection in transmission lines based on deep learning - Zheng, X., Jia, R., Aisikaer, Gong, L., Zhang, G., Dang, J. (2020) |
|
By eliminating the need for extra specialist hardware, using power grid video surveillance technology for transmission line component classification and fault detection lowers installation costs
The use of SSD, Mask R-CNN, and Faster R-CNN algorithms shows how successful deep learning methods are in target identification and semantic segmentation
Understanding the advantages and disadvantages of the Faster R-CNN, SSD, and Mask R-CNN algorithms is possible through comparison and study
Contextual and semantic information are better combined when an object detection framework built on FPN-SSD is introduced
Attaining an average accuracy of 89.3% on the dataset indicates how well the suggested algorithm works for identifying transmission line components and detecting defects
|
Limiting the suggested algorithm's application to situations involving different kinds of transmission line components by concentrating on just five different kinds of transmission widgets
The complete variety of transmission line environments may not be captured if sample images are just derived from drone aerial inspection shots of the power grid
Lacks in-depth investigation into component failure detection in favor of focusing mostly on target detection of aerial photography components
|