Computational FSI methods are pivotal in micro elastofluidics, enhancing the design and functionality of devices such as microvalves, micropumps, and micromixers. These techniques enable precise modelling of fluid and structural dynamics, critical for devices that control and manipulate fluid flow at the microscale. FSI is also instrumental in biomedical applications, including cell separation and particle manipulation. Additionally, in cardiovascular applications, FSI helps to develop devices that match the biomechanical properties of blood and vascular tissues, significantly improving the intended therapeutic purpose. This underscores the integral role of FSI in advancing micro elastofluidic technology across various scientific and medical fields.
4.1. Microvalves and Micropumps
Microvalves and micropumps are the typical microfluidic components with strong FSI. FSI dictates how flexible membranes and channels within these devices respond to fluid pressure, ultimately shaping their ability to regulate and deliver tiny volumes of liquid in lab-on-a-chip and drug-delivery devices. Much work has been done in analysing the intricate interplay between fluid forces and deformations of flexible structures. Researchers have proposed designs of microvalves and micropumps that achieve unparalleled precision in flow control.
Among the different types of microvalves, elastomeric membrane [
127] microvalves are a prime example of where FSI plays a critical role [
128]. The core principle behind these valves is the deformation of a flexible membrane in response to fluid pressure [
129]. Active valves often utilise external actuation through FSI for precise flow control. Various actuation mechanisms have been proposed [
130,
131,
132,
133,
134]. Passive valves harness flow forces through FSI to achieve remarkable self-regulation [
135,
136,
137]. In a passive microvalve, the fluid pressure deforms the membrane, which in turn alters the flow resistance. This dynamic interplay between the fluid and the membrane allows the valve to maintain a constant flow rate over a specific pressure range.
Numerous models for passive check valves and passive regulating valves have been proposed. For instance, Nguyen
et al. [
138] utilised FSI to study passive valves and proposed models for ortho-planar micro check valves for incorporation in polymeric microdevices,
Figure 9A. These check valves efficiently prevent backflow and require an inlet pressure of less than 1 kPa to open. Ortho-planar designs provide enhanced sealing performance, thanks to their parallel out-of-plane motion. Later Kartalov
et al. [
139] proposed a PDMS push-up valve utilising the pressure drop along the channel length and performed FSI simulation to investigate the flow rate and threshold pressure,
Figure 9B. This model maintained a constant flow rate of 0.033 mL/min with a threshold pressure of 103 kPa. Yang
et al. [
140] designed a planar check valve and did an FSI study to model self-adaptive variable resistors to use in microfluidics models,
Figure 9C. This valve design achieved a relatively high flow rate of 1.2 mL/min with a threshold pressure of 100 kPa. In addition,
Doh et al. [
141] developed a passive parallel membrane valve designed for low-threshold pressure operation using the concept of FSI,
Figure 9D. The valve consists of two control channels, two vertically oriented membranes, and a single fluidic channel. The autonomous deflection of the membranes within the microchannel enables the valve to achieve flow regulation at a pressure as low as 15 kPa. Moreover, Zhang
et al. [
142] utilised FSI on flow regulation in microfluidic environments and developed a unique parallel membrane valve featuring a stacked five-layer architecture,
Figure 9E. This design, with two horizontal membranes enclosing a fluidic channel and sandwiched between control channels, achieved a remarkable flow rate of 2.79 mL/min with a low 10 kPa threshold pressure. Zhang
el at. [
137] achieved low threshold pressure in microfluidic high throughput delivery systems and designed a passive valve for stable flow control. The valve utilises an ellipsoid control chamber and a dual micro-hole elastic membrane,
Figure 9F. Membrane deflection in response to pressurised flow through the micro-holes dynamically modifies the control chamber's resistance. This self-regulating mechanism maintains a constant flow rate regardless of inlet pressure changes.
Figure 9.
Microvalves and micropumps. Microvalves and micropumps. (A) Ortho-planer micro check valves with different stiffness; (B) Poiseuille Law pressure drop self-regulating valve; (C) Self-adaptive planer check valve with flexible cantilever flap; (D) Parallel membrane with low threshold pressure, self-regulating valve; (E) Stacked parallel membrane with low threshold pressure, regulating valve; (F) Ellipsoid control chamber auto-regulating valve.
Figure 9.
Microvalves and micropumps. Microvalves and micropumps. (A) Ortho-planer micro check valves with different stiffness; (B) Poiseuille Law pressure drop self-regulating valve; (C) Self-adaptive planer check valve with flexible cantilever flap; (D) Parallel membrane with low threshold pressure, self-regulating valve; (E) Stacked parallel membrane with low threshold pressure, regulating valve; (F) Ellipsoid control chamber auto-regulating valve.
Micropump is another crucial component of many microfluidic systems. Since their invention, micropumps have seen significant advancements, offering advantages such as compact size, portability, energy efficiency, wide range of flow rate, affordability, and potential for integration with other microfluidic components. Micropumps are typically constructed using Micro-electromechanical Systems (MEMS) techniques on biocompatible materials such as silicon, glass, or various polymers (such as Polymethyl Methacrylate (PMMA), PDMS, or SU-8 photoresist) [
143,
144]. Micropumps fall into two broad categories: (i) mechanical, using moving parts like diaphragms and valves, and (ii) non-mechanical which manipulates fluid flow through hydrodynamic [
145], electroosmotic [
146], or electrowetting [
147] forces. In mechanical micropumps, fluid flow is pressurised by an external force i.e. piezoelectric (PZT), electromagnetic (EM), electrostatic, and thermo-pneumatic, applied to either fixed flexible membranes or moving structures. This force transfer to the fluid occurs through fluid-structure interaction. Much work has been done in harnessing and manipulating the pumping function on the micro-scale through FSI. Wang
et al. [
148] proposed a piezoelectric micropump utilising fixed-end PDMS valves with integrated compressible space. This micropump utilises a resonantly driven membrane actuator, two fixed-end PDMS check valves for stability and reduced leakage, and strategically placed compressible spaces,
Figure 10A.
Figure 10.
Pumping schemes. (A) Piezoelectric micropump utilizing fixed-end PDMS valves with integrated compressible space; (B) Magnetically actuated membrane micropump with in-plane check valves; (C) Electrostatically actuated micropump utilizing four electrodes to induce peristaltic motion; (D) Thermo-pneumatic micropump with a thin polyimide membrane actuator.
Figure 10.
Pumping schemes. (A) Piezoelectric micropump utilizing fixed-end PDMS valves with integrated compressible space; (B) Magnetically actuated membrane micropump with in-plane check valves; (C) Electrostatically actuated micropump utilizing four electrodes to induce peristaltic motion; (D) Thermo-pneumatic micropump with a thin polyimide membrane actuator.
Piezoelectric actuator deforms the pump membrane This deformation of the membrane affects the fluid inside the pump by changing the space it occupies, which increases or decreases the pressure. Essentially, as the membrane changes shape, it pushes on the fluid, helping to move it through the system. The micropump design relies on two key interactions: (i) electromechanical interaction, where the piezoelectric sheet converts electric signals into movement of the beam, and (ii) fluid-solid interaction, where the pump diaphragm interacts with the working fluid. An alternating voltage causes the beam to deform, driving the membrane and thus the fluid flow. Simultaneously, the fluid resists the movement of the membrane. The reported micropump delivers a maximum flow rate of 105 mL/min and a maximum back pressure of 23 kPa under a 400 V sinusoidal voltage at 490 Hz. Maximum power consumption at zero back pressure is approximately 42 mW.
Ni
et al. [
149] introduced a magnetic micropump utilising FSI for easy fabrication and seamless integration into other microfluidic systems. The device features in-plane check valves for flow control and a magnetically actuated membrane,
Figure 10B. The deformable elastic membrane then interacts with the flowing fluid and in turn, pressurises the fluid. Since actuation is controlled directly by an external magnetic field, enabling efficient wireless operation is ideal for various applications. Experimental results indicate that the micropump can deliver 0.15 μL/min at 2 Hz, offering 1 nL per stroke resolution, and works against 550 Pa backpressure.
Moreover, Lee
et al. [
150] fabricated an electrostatically actuated micropump incorporating FSI, utilising four electrodes to induce peristaltic motion,
Figure 10C. In this study, the micropump makes use of electrostatic force to create bidirectional peristaltic motion. Its unique design features a single deformable membrane with four movable polyimide electrodes hence eliminating the need for valves. Actuation signals cause the membrane to bend in small, sequential steps, which increases the pressure of the fluid in stages. This action splits a single chamber into two, three, or four separate sections, allowing for controlled movement of the fluid within the device. Experiments showed, optimising the actuation signal dramatically increased the flow rate. With a basic signal, the pump achieved 38 μl/min, but an optimised signal boosted this to 136 μl/min (both at 90 V and 15 Hz). This represents a 3.6-fold improvement. Hamid
et al. [
151] modelled a cost-effective thermo-pneumatic micropump with a thin polyimide membrane actuator,
Figure 10D. The model includes a microheater, thermal cavity, and planar valve. This thermo-pneumatic micropump utilises thermal air expansion within a chamber to actuate a thin polyimide membrane. The membrane movement then interacts with the fluid and hence creates pressure fluctuations accordingly. This device effectively controls fluid on the picolitre to nanolitre scale, making it suitable for applications such as artificial kidneys and drug delivery systems, and is both simple and economical to fabricate.
4.2. Cell and Particle Manipulation
Cell sorting is a laboratory technique for isolating a specific cell type from a mixed population. Isolation criteria include physical parameters (size, morphology), cell viability, and the presence of specific intracellular or extracellular proteins [
152]. Purified cells obtained through sorting are essential tools for research, diagnostic procedures, and cell-based therapies. Cell sorting encompasses a broad range of established techniques, employing both active and passive mechanisms [
153]. Active sorting utilises external fields (electric, acoustic, magnetic, or optical) to manipulate cell trajectories. Passive systems primarily leverage inertial forces, filtration, and cell-surface adhesion for purification. Understanding FSI in both cell-fluid and fluid-channel interactions is crucial for optimizing and designing cell sorting devices. Extensive experimental works have been conducted to utilise FSI phenomena for cell sorting and manipulation. However, numerical simulations are vital to fully comprehend these FSI phenomena. Numerical modelling of cell dynamics complements experimental approaches, enabling the in-depth study of fluid-particle interactions. Accurately simulating these dynamic processes presents challenges due to the complexity of FSI coupling, cell mechanics, and the computational cost of simulating cell-cell interactions at scale.
Sun
et al. [
154] developed an LBM model to simulate blood flow in realistic microvascular networks and the separation of different types of cells,
Figure 11A. This approach allows for the detailed analysis of FSI between blood cells and the vessel wall. This model treated blood as a suspension of particles (red blood cells [RBCs] and white blood cells [WBCs]) within the plasma, explicitly incorporating cell-cell and cell-wall interactions. The LBM approach allows for simulating RBC and WBC interactions as the cells flow through a microvascular network. This approach enables (i) quantification of forces exerted between RBCs and WBCs, tracking of trajectories of individual cells, (ii) analysis of pressure variations within the network due to cellular traffic, and (iii) the evaluation of forces experienced by the vessel walls at any location. Simulations demonstrate that vessel curvature and junctions increase the apparent viscosity and induce stress perturbations near stagnation points. The results suggested a potential link to atherogenesis at stagnation points and may also significantly influence our understanding of endothelial biology and its role in atherosclerosis formation.
Mao
et al. [
155] conducted computational modelling of particle sorting, specifically addressing FSI, for high-throughput hydrodynamic size-based sorting of solid microparticles in microchannels,
Figure 11C(i). With this model, high-resolution separation was achieved by combining cross-stream inertial migration of particles with circulatory flows induced by periodic diagonal ridges on opposite channel walls. A hybrid approach was employed to model the multi-component system of a fluid-filled ridged microchannel and various-sized solid particles. This approach integrates LBM for fluid dynamics with a lattice spring model (LSM) for modelling solids. FSI is captured through appropriate boundary conditions at the solid-fluid interface. Simulations proved to be crucial for designing the ridged microchannel. Optimization for separating neutrally buoyant microparticles by size relied heavily on understanding the complex FSI within a microchannel.
Figure 11C(ii) shows the results of this study. The geometry of the microchannel induces unique fluid flow patterns, and the resulting FSI between these patterns and the particles is the key to high-resolution separation.
Figure 11.
Cell separation and micromixers. (A) Illustration of considering RBC and WBC as suspended particles in plasma to capture fluid-particle and fluid-wall interactions; (B) RBC discretisation to investigate the change in deformability of cells caused by malaria parasites. reproduced with permission from Hosseini
et al. [
156]; (C)(i) Setup for particle sorting in microchannels, (ii) Particle separation. reproduced with permission from Mao
et al. [
155]; (D) DLD device for separating CTCs within blood stream; (E) Mixing with magnetic actuated artificial cilia; (F) Passive mixing with flexible baffles.
Figure 11.
Cell separation and micromixers. (A) Illustration of considering RBC and WBC as suspended particles in plasma to capture fluid-particle and fluid-wall interactions; (B) RBC discretisation to investigate the change in deformability of cells caused by malaria parasites. reproduced with permission from Hosseini
et al. [
156]; (C)(i) Setup for particle sorting in microchannels, (ii) Particle separation. reproduced with permission from Mao
et al. [
155]; (D) DLD device for separating CTCs within blood stream; (E) Mixing with magnetic actuated artificial cilia; (F) Passive mixing with flexible baffles.
Khodaee
et al. [
157] carried out a numerical FSI study of fluid-particle interaction in a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) microfluidic device for effective separation of circulating tumor cells (CTC ) in bloodstreams. Numerical simulations, incorporating FSI using FEM to model deformable cell behaviour, guide the design of a typical DLD array for separating CTCs and leukocytes (white blood cells) under various flow conditions.
Figure 11D illustrates the discretization of this method. This study focused on how coupled FSI phenomena, specifically related to flow conditions, stress, and cell deformability impact cell separation in DLD devices. This model provides essential data for optimising DLD devices, enhancing efficiency, and protecting cell viability. The model quantifies the cellular stress experienced during separation and maps the distribution of effective stress at peak deformation.
FSI also plays a fundamental role in accurately simulating cell deformations within a complex environment. Cells are not rigid bodies and respond dynamically to the fluid forces surrounding them. These forces can cause cells to stretch, compress, and change shape. In turn, deformed cells alter the flow field around them. FSI models are essential for capturing this intricate interplay. FSI simulation provides realistic predictions of how cells deform under various conditions. This has far-reaching implications in biomedical research, understanding disease processes where cell deformation plays a role. For instance, Hosseini
et al. [
156] carried out FSI analysis on RBCs and investigated the change in deformability of cells caused by malaria parasites. Numerical simulations incorporating FSI were employed to investigate this phenomenon. The cell membrane was represented as a collection of interconnected, elastic particles,
Figure 11B. The cytosol is modelled as a Newtonian fluid using smoothed particle hydrodynamic techniques (SPH). More importantly, the malaria parasite was treated as a rigid structure, capturing its influence on the overall behaviour of the cells. Healthy RBCs are remarkably flexible, but the presence of the rigid malaria parasite within the cell significantly increases its stiffness. In response to the fluid forces present in the bloodstream, the deformability of infected cells declines. These findings underscore the potential of using cell deformability as a diagnostic marker and highlight the value of FSI simulation in understanding disease-induced cellular changes.
4.3. Micromixers
Mixing fluids in the microscale presents unique challenges and opportunities. Due to the dominance of laminar flow and the lack of turbulence in the microscale, traditional mixing strategies often become ineffective. This challenge has spurred the development of innovative microfluidic mixing approaches, relying on strategies such as chaotic advection, diffusion enhancement, or the integration of active micromixers. Micromixers are broadly categorised as active and passive types [
158]. Active micromixers enhance mixing by introducing external perturbations that disrupt the typically laminar flow regime. Methods include pressure-driven actuation (e.g., pulsatile flows), electrokinetic manipulation (e.g., electroosmotic flow), magnetic actuation (e.g., ferrofluid mixing), or acoustic streaming [
159,
160,
161,
162,
163,
164,
165]. These techniques offer rapid mixing, tunability, and adaptability, but come with increasing system complexity. In contrast, passive micromixers rely on microchannel geometry to promote mixing. Complex channel geometries induce chaotic advection, increasing interfacial contact area through lamination, splitting, or droplets [
166,
167,
168,
169,
170,
171]. Passive mixers excel in simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and minimal sample perturbation, but may have longer mixing times and less adaptability than their active counterparts.
FSI plays a vital role in both active and passive micromixers. In active micromixers based on FSI, flexible elements interact with the fluid flow, creating complex patterns that disrupt the laminar flow for fast and efficient mixing. This FSI approach allows for customised flow control, works with various fluids, and potentially uses less power than other active mixing methods. Examples include employing deformable membranes to create chaotic advection or integrating oscillating microstructures to induce localised mixing zones. While less common than active FSI micromixers, passive designs can also exploit FSI to enhance mixing. These mixers often incorporate flexible or deformable elements within the microchannel that respond to the inherent fluid forces. Examples include flexible micro-posts that sway in response to flow, membranes that deform under pressure, and integrated microvalves whose operation is triggered by fluid forces.
Much work has been done in optimising the design of micromixers using FSI-based numerical simulation. For example, Lin
et al. [
172] carried out an FSI analysis for precise flow manipulation in a micromixer using magnetic actuation. The team employed microstructures with embedded magnetic particles (
Figure 11E). A CFD approach, utilizing FSI modelling, was employed to simulate the flow patterns generated by the actuated structures. The model revealed the impact of different actuation modes on mixing performance. The 'zigzag' pattern proves to be superior in achieving rapid and complete mixing. Further analysis demonstrated how these structures disrupt and blend the flow, with vorticity calculations pinpointing regions of high vorticity in the flow field. The enhanced vorticity strongly correlates with improved mixing. The study features the power of combining experimental and numerical analyses to understand the FSI mechanisms responsible for effective flow mixing. These findings hold significant value for designing future high-performance micromixers, where speed and thorough mixing are essential. Moreover, Talebjedi
et al. [
173] exploit the FSI phenomenon in passive micromixers using flexible baffles,
Figure 11F. This research explores the use of deformable baffles in the mixing process, aiming to improve performance compared to traditional rigid baffles. Modelling the FSI provides insight into how deformable baffles change shape under fluid pressure, and how this affects flow. The results show a significant reduction in pressure drop with deformable baffles, indicating less stress on mixed materials. More importantly, this improvement is achieved with only a minor decrease in mixing efficiency as compared to rigid baffles. This suggests that deformable baffles offer a promising way to optimise mixing processes, where reducing stress on the materials being mixed is vital.
4.4. Modelling Cardiovascular Systems
In the realm of micro elastofluidics, computational methods for FSI unlock a deeper understanding of the complex interplay between biological fluids and the flexible tissues they encounter. The complex dynamics of blood flow, coupled with the flexible nature of heart valves and arterial walls, necessitate FSI simulations for a comprehensive analysis of the cardiovascular system. FSI models provide critical insights into heart valve function, including leaflet deformation, flow patterns, and stress distribution, leading to better diagnostics for heart diseases and improved designs for prosthetic replacements [
174,
175,
176,
177,
178]. Similarly, FSI models applied to artery flow provide insights into the development of arterial diseases like atherosclerosis, uncovering potential risks for aneurysm formation, and contribute to the optimization of medical devices such as stents [
179,
180,
181,
182,
183].
Heart valves play a critical role in maintaining blood flow direction. Artificial valves are treatment options, but their design and performance require careful analysis. Laha
et al. [
174] investigated bi-leaflet mechanical heart valve dynamics through FSI modelling with Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH).
Figure 12 illustrates the schematic model. The team explored a method for simulating a bi-leaflet heart valve using an SPH open-source code. By incorporating FSI, the SPH technique analysed hemodynamic abnormalities associated with valve dysfunction. The study considered normal and abnormal flow behaviour, valve movement under blockage scenarios, and potential risks associated with blockages. The findings demonstrate the effectiveness of this SPH/FSI approach for capturing the dynamic behaviour of bi-leaflet valves. The versatility of this computational model suggests its potential application to more complex cardiovascular problems.
Figure 12.
Bi-leaflet mechanical heart valve dynamics through FSI Modelling with Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH); (A) Illustration of mechanical heart valve; (B) Opening and closing position of valve; (C) Illustration of smoothed particles for simulation; (D) Inlet velocity profile to mimic the real pulse; (E) Simulation results. reproduced with permission from Laha
et al. [
174].
Figure 12.
Bi-leaflet mechanical heart valve dynamics through FSI Modelling with Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH); (A) Illustration of mechanical heart valve; (B) Opening and closing position of valve; (C) Illustration of smoothed particles for simulation; (D) Inlet velocity profile to mimic the real pulse; (E) Simulation results. reproduced with permission from Laha
et al. [
174].
Sodhani
et al. [
175] carried out an FSI study on an artificial aortic heart valve that was reinforced with textile. In this study, an in-silico FSI model was developed using the immersed boundary method to mimic the in-vitro experiment. The model assessed the geometric orifice area and flow rate over a single cycle, while also incorporating the material properties of the implant. The model employed fixed boundary conditions for the structural part. This involved fixing the bottom and stitched regions of the device in all directions, preventing movement in those areas. For the fluid domain, transvalvular pressure is incorporated as a boundary condition at the inlet and a zero-pressure condition at the outlet. Transvalvular pressure, measured in the corresponding in-vitro test.
Figure 13 shows the model of the heart valve. The FSI simulation provided valuable insights into device performance i.e. pressure distribution, velocity field, recirculation zones, vortices, and potential leakage points. This work demonstrated the effectiveness of FSI simulations for validating material property determination techniques and predicting the kinematics and flow behaviours of the device.
Figure 13.
An artificial aortic heart valve. (A) Effect of asymmetry on valve closure (right) and comparison with a similar tex-valve (left); (B) Illustration of test setup for FSI simulations; (C) Simulation results. reproduced with permission from Sodhani
et al. [
175].
Figure 13.
An artificial aortic heart valve. (A) Effect of asymmetry on valve closure (right) and comparison with a similar tex-valve (left); (B) Illustration of test setup for FSI simulations; (C) Simulation results. reproduced with permission from Sodhani
et al. [
175].
Arterial diseases, including atherosclerosis and aneurysms, pose significant health risks due to their potential to cause serious cardiovascular events such as heart attacks and strokes. By accurately simulating the dynamic interactions between blood flow and arterial walls, FSI models provide invaluable insights into mechanical forces that contribute to disease progression. For example, Valente
et al. [
184] carried out the numerical investigation of Ascending Thoracic Aortic Aneurysm (ATAA) through FSI simulations using the open-source software package SimVascular.
Figure 14A and
14B illustrate the mesh model and results, respectively. The simulations are based on patient-specific geometric models reconstructed from Computed Tomography (CT) scans. The analysis incorporates specific outlet conditions and temporal flow variations at the model inlet. By assigning prestress, the aorta model accurately reflects the in vivo stress state during the cardiac cycle. The process begins with a CFD analysis on the fluid domain, followed by structural analysis in the solid domain, using the pressures from the CFD phase as boundary conditions. The results from both CFD and Computational Structural Mechanics (CSM) were used as initial conditions for further analysis. The hemodynamic and structural behaviour of ATAA was studied, focusing on the velocity, displacement magnitudes, and wall shear stress distribution during the first cardiac cycle. The results confirm the effectiveness of the simulation in capturing the complex dynamics of ATAA, highlighting its potential for enhanced precision in biomechanical assessments.
Figure 14.
Numerical investigation of Ascending Thoracic Aortic Aneurysm (ATAA) through FSI simulations. (A) Mesh discretisation of patient-specific geometric ascending thoracic aorta model reconstructed from CT scans; (B) Simulations results reproduced with permission from Valente
et al. [
184].
Figure 14.
Numerical investigation of Ascending Thoracic Aortic Aneurysm (ATAA) through FSI simulations. (A) Mesh discretisation of patient-specific geometric ascending thoracic aorta model reconstructed from CT scans; (B) Simulations results reproduced with permission from Valente
et al. [
184].