2.1. Phase Composition and Structure of Samples
The phase composition and structure of the prepared samples were studied by X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and electron spin resonance (ESR) methods.
The results of X-ray phase analysis of the synthesized samples are summarized depending on the composition and heat treatment temperature in
Figure 1.
The diffraction patterns (
Figure 1) show reflections characteristic of the spinel phases Co
3O
4 (PDF 42–1467) or MgCo
2O
4 (PDF 2–1073, 81–671) and the rocksalt MgO (PDF 45–946) and CoO (PDF 48–1719) or their solid solution [
15,
21,
25].
All samples, regardless of the Co:Mg ratio, show reflections of spinel phases in the low-temperature range (calcination temperatures 400–800 °C). On Co3O4-based samples in this range no other phases are observed, while magnesia-containing samples, in addition to intense reflections of spinel phases MgCo2O4 or Co3O4, are characterized by the presence of reflections from the rocksalt (Co, Mg)O solid solution phase, the intensity of which gradually increases with the heat treatment temperature.
In the high-temperature range (above 800–900 °C, which corresponds to the thermal decomposition of the Co–Mg spinel) [
21,
26], reflections of the rocksalt solid solution are predominantly observed for the Co–Mg samples, while pure Co
3O
4 contains CoO and Co
3O
4 phases. This phenomenon, caused by the rapid reoxidation of surface CoO species during quenching after heat treatment [
21,
27], is especially evident in the case of pure Co
3O
4 and indicates that the reoxidation of pure CoO proceeds more easily than that of the (Co, Mg)O solid solution.
The averaged lattice parameter values of the spinel and rocksalt phases, calculated from the corresponding diffraction maxima, are presented in the
Table 1 and in the
Figure 2.
The temperature dependence of the lattice parameters of the spinel and rocksalt phases for different Co:Mg ratios is similar. For instance, the lattice parameter of Co
3O
4 in the low-temperature region is approximately constant and slightly higher than the theoretical value of 8.084 Å, probably due to the presence of defects and superstoichiometric oxygen in the lattice [
28,
29]. As the calcination temperature increases further, this value decreases and tends to the theoretical value.
In the case of Co–Mg spinels of various composition, in the low-temperature region, the lattice parameter value also gradually decreases with increasing heat treatment temperature, but at 750–800 °C it increases sharply and, if the spinel phase continues to be observed at higher temperatures, remains approximately constant (
Figure 2). Stoichiometric cobalt-magnesia spinel (Co
2Mg
1) is characterized by a wide spread of lattice parameter values [
21,
22,
23,
30,
31], presumably due to different degrees of spinel inversion, depending on the preparation method. Our data for the low-temperature Co
2Mg
1 samples give an average value of 8.089 Å [
21], meaning a low degree of spinel inversion obtained by the nitrate salts decomposition. At the same time, non-stoichiometric Co
1Mg
1 and Co
4Mg
1 samples are characterized by higher lattice parameter values (8.100 and 8.097 Å, respectively), maintaining the qualitative trend of their variation on the calcination temperature. Presumably, this is explained by their non-stoichiometry, which leads to an increased lattice volume, as well as, probably, by partial inversion of the spinel phases.
The lattice parameter values of the rocksalt phase in the low-temperature range depend little on the composition and are equal to 4.225 ± 0.005 Å. As the heat treatment temperature further increases, this value increases sharply and at 900 °C diverges for different compositions, increasing linearly with increasing cobalt content. The dependence of the lattice parameter on composition for selected calcination temperatures is shown in
Figure 3.
As is known, the lattice parameter values of Co–Mg solid solution obey Vegard’s law [
32,
33,
34]. Here, for high calcination temperatures this dependence is approximately true. The proximity of the lattice parameter values of the samples of different compositions at low temperatures is probably explained by the fact that under these conditions the rocksalt phase is predominantly comprised of magnesia, which is saturated with Co
2+ only during the thermal decomposition of the spinel, forming a solid solution with a composition corresponding to the initial cobalt loading. The higher value of the lattice parameter of low-temperature MgO relative to the theoretical value (4.2112 Å) is confirmed in [
35] and is explained by the paracrystalline structure of anion-modified low-temperature oxide systems [
36]; this phenomenon can also be explained by the presence of microstresses and strain in the structure [
28,
29]. The characteristic decrease of the lattice parameter values of both the spinel phase in the 400–750 °C range and the rocksalt phase formed during spinel thermal decomposition in the 900–1100 °C range is presumably explained by the stress relaxation together with decomposition of anionic residues in the phase structure.
In order to determine the influence of the Co:Mg ratio and heat treatment temperature on the crystallite sizes of the phases under study, the average values of the coherent scattering domains (c.s.d.) were calculated from the X-ray diffraction data, presented in
Figure 4.
The calculations show that, in the case of crystallites of the spinel phase at low calcination temperatures, a gradual particles enlargement is observed, associated with an increase in their crystallinity, while at 900 °C the particle sizes of spinel crystallites sharply decrease due to the formation of a solid solution from spinel, with the small size of the spinel phase at higher temperatures referring to surface species reoxidized during quenching. Rocksalt phase particles retain approximately constant size values up to the decomposition temperature, where they also decrease, presumably due to a change in the composition of the rocksalt phase of the solid solution, and at higher temperatures particle growth occurs due to their sintering.
The sizes and morphology of the sample particles were also studied by scanning electron microscopy. Typical micrographs of spinel and solid solution are shown in
Figure 5 and 6.
According to SEM data, the initial spinel phase (
Figure 5 (
a), (
d)) is comprised of poorly crystallized irregular plate-type particles with sizes of 0.7–2.0 μm, connected into aggregates with sizes up to 10–15 μm. The rocksalt solid solution formed during heat treatment is comprised of faceted octahedral crystallites with sizes ranging from 0.5 μm, which are also prone to aggregation into structures up to 20 μm in size (
Figure 5 (
b), (
e)). This is consistent with previously obtained data on the structure of particles in the Co
2Mg
1 system [
21]. Reoxidation of the solid solution has little effect on the size of the crystallites, but reduces their crystallization, making the latter more similar to spinel particles (
Figure 5 (
c), (
f)).
It is significant that, in contrast to Co–Mg samples, in the case of Co
3O
4, secondary aggregates of spinel and rocksalt phases are formed by particles of much smaller sizes (
Figure 6 (
a), (
d)), presumably due to the absence of magnesia. As Co
3O
4 transforms into CoO, the secondary aggregates' sizes do not change, although the primary particles become larger and more faceted, but do not reach the sizes characteristic of Co–Mg samples (
Figure 6 (
b), (
e)).
The results of the study of the samples' structure using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) are presented in the
Figure 7 and in the
Table 2.
In the case of pure Co
3O
4 (
Figure 7), in the range corresponding to the Me–O stretching vibrations, two intense absorption bands (a.b.) are observed at 665 and 575 cm
–1. These bands (ν
1 and ν
2 Me–O, respectively) are commonly associated with vibrations of bonds between cations in octahedral sites (O–B
3) in the case of ν
1, and with vibrations of bonds between cations in tetrahedral and octahedral sites (A–B–O
3) in the case of ν
2 [
37,
38]. As shown in [
39], the IR spectrum of the AB
2O
4 cubic spinel is characterized by four a.b. (ν
1, ν
2, ν
3, ν
4), where ν
3 and ν
4 are typically in the far range of the spectrum. For the spinel Co
3O
4, the a.b. values of 672, 590, 392 and 220 cm
–1 are given, further confirmed by similar values of 667, 580 and 385 cm
–1 in [
27,
37].
As the heat treatment temperature increased, splitting of the ν
2 band at 575 cm
–1 was observed, with formation of a shoulder 555–557 cm
–1 that at higher temperatures becomes an individual band, and another shoulder at 587–589 cm
–1. As is known, generally the IR spectrum consists of longitudinal and transverse bands (LO and TO respectively). In the case of thin films, the spectrum consists predominantly of TO a.b., while for powders with a given particle size distribution, LO a.b. are more pronounced, with the LO/TO intensity ratio decreasing as the mean particle size increases [
40]. In this regard, the appearance of shoulders at 575 cm
–1 with increasing calcination temperature is explained by the sintering of Co
3O
4 particles. Preservation of spinel a.b. at heat treatment temperatures of 900 °C and higher is associated with CoO reoxidation during quenching [
27]; in this case, a shift of a.b. positions is observed to 664 and 568–571 cm
–1.
There is a distinct lack of IR studies of the CoO phase and its characteristic a.b., with the exception of [
37], which gives a value of 507 cm
–1 not confirmed by our data. Due to large CoO absorption in the IR range, the majority of known IR spectra of CoO were recorded not by transmission, but rather by reflection. According to [
41,
42], the main CoO a.b. is observed in the far region of the spectrum (a.b. at 375 cm
–1). Our data show a shoulder of a broad peak with a rise from approx. 610 cm
–1, qualitatively confirming the literature data.
The IR spectra of Co–Mg samples show similar spinel a.b. (
Figure 7). Changes in characteristic a.b. positions are presented in
Figure 8.
An increase in the magnesia content significantly changes the shape of the IR spectrum: the spinel a.b. 660–670 and 560–575 cm
–1 broaden, while a wide a.b. at 420–430 cm
–1 appears due to stretching vibrations of the Me–O bond in the MgO or (Co, Mg)O solid solution phase [
21]. As the magnesia content increases, this a.b. shifts from to 445–460 cm
–1. Spinel a.b. also shift with increase of magnesia content: in the range of Co:Mg ratios from 2:1 and higher, corresponding to the Co
3O
4–MgCo
2O
4 system, this change occurs to a smaller extent, while excess MgO leads to a more significant a.b. shift. Similarly, in the case of samples calcined at 900–1100 °C, in the range of Co:Mg from 2:1 and higher, the position of the Me–O a.b. corresponding to the solid solution formed during spinel thermal decomposition remains virtually unchanged, but a further increase of magnesia content leads to a strong shift to shorter wavelength values.
To study the state of Co cations, the electron spin resonance (ESR) method was used. The results of the study are presented in
Table 3 and
Figure 9.
Co
2+ ions at tetrahedral sites of the Co
3O
4 structure are paramagnetic and thus give a wide isotropic singlet in the ESR spectrum with
g = 2.25 [
38,
43,
44]. The structure of both normal and inverse MgCo
2O
4 spinel does not contain paramagnetic Co
2+ ions and thus gives no ESR signal. However, in a CoO–MgO solid solution, Co
2+ ions occupying octahedral vacancies give a signal with
g = 4.23–4.28, though observed only at –153 °C or lower due to strong broadening related to the Jahn–Teller effect [
45,
46,
47]. Thus, the presence of an ESR signal from Co
2+Td may indicate the presence of Co
3O
4 species in the samples. This ESR signal can only be observed for isolated ions, because at higher concentrations, spin-spin interaction causes signal quenching, complicating the estimation of their absolute concentration. This may explain why, according to the ESR data of Co–Mg samples (
Figure 9), with increasing Co content the mean intensity decreases, increasing only in the case of Co
3O
4 samples, which is probably due to the complete absence of magnesia.
The change in signal intensity with increase of the calcination temperature allows to assess the influence of the latter. At lower temperatures (up to 750 °C), an increase in signal intensity is observed in all samples, with a sharp decrease at 800–900 °C. This behavior is typical for the thermal decomposition of both Co3O4 and MgCo2O4. The small residual signal in the range above 1000 °C is due to partial CoO reoxidation of Co3O4 after quenching. The abnormally high signal intensity of high-temperature Co1Mg1 samples may be caused by the higher cobalt dispersion and the preferred formation of Co3O4 rather than MgCo2O4 spinel during reoxidation.
2.2. Oxygen Reactivity of the Samples
It is known that surface and lattice oxygen play a special role in the structure of deep oxidation catalysts [
21]. Oxides such as Co
3O
4 catalyze combustion of hydrocarbons, especially methane, on active centers involving lattice oxygen [
9,
10,
11], while CO oxidation on oxides proceeds according to both Langmuir–Hinshelwood and Mars–van Krevelen mechanisms involving surface and lattice oxygen, respectively [
48,
49]. In this regard, samples were studied using temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) and temperature-programmed desorption (TPD).
Figure 10 shows the TPR profiles of the synthesized samples for different heat treatment temperatures.
The Сo
3О
4 TPR profiles consist of two peaks: a narrow low-temperature peak and a wider one with a flat top. The first peak corresponds to the reduction of Co
3+ to Co
2+, the second – Co
2+ to Co
0 [
24,
25,
37,
49,
50,
51]. These peaks remain in up to calcination temperature of 800 °C, slowly merging and drifting to higher temperatures as the calcination temperature increases. This is explained by gradual sintering of Сo
3О
4 crystallites (
Figure 4) and the strengthening of diffusion inhibition. As shown earlier, Co
3O
4 is also present at higher temperatures as reoxidized Co
3+ surface species with smaller particle sizes compared to the initial spinel crystallites, which presumably correspond to small low-temperature peaks, compressed due to the removal of diffusion inhibition.
The characteristic flat-top shape of the second peak, corresponding to Co
2+ → Co
0, is due to a complex set of reactions occurring during the reduction of CoO, discussed in detail by Rabee et al. [
50]. According to these authors, initially reduction proceeds to the stoichiometric mixture (CoO + Co
0), which is then completely reduced to Co
0. Based on the analysis of TPR profiles, the authors suggest that during this second stage of CoO reduction, Co
0 with a small amount of Co
5O charged clusters is formed. This conclusion is based on the presence of a shoulder at approx. 820 °C, and is not otherwise substantiated. In the case of our samples, such a shoulder appears on the TPR profiles at 650 °C and higher (
Figure 10), increasing in area as the calcination temperature increases. From 900 °C onward, this shoulder turns into a wide triangular peak with
Tmax = 783–802 °C, similar to the peak described in [
37] and corresponding to the reduction of well-crystallized CoO (with crystallite sizes more than 36 nm,
Figure 4).
In order to study in detail the reduction of the spinel phase, TPR with stopping at certain temperatures was carried out.
Figure 11 and
Figure 12 present the results of the SEM and XRD study of samples obtained with partial and complete reduction.
During Co
3O
4 TPR up to 430 °C (an intermediate temperature between two reduction peaks) SEM micrographs show no significant changes in the aggregates sizes, however, their surface is shown to become more porous (
Figure 11 (
b), (
e)). This effect is due to the rapid decomposition of Co
3O
4 structure during reduction accompanied by the release of a gas product and preservation of the initial aggregate framework. XRD patterns show a wide halo corresponding to the X-ray amorphous phase appears, with partial amorphization observed even at 380 °C (
Figure 12 (
b), (
c)). This is further supported by the results of calculations of the c.s.d. sizes of CoO phase in these samples, which give the value of 12 nm for both reduction temperatures, showcasing the difference between CoO formed during reduction and during heat treatment (
Figure 12 (
d)), noted in [
21].
After TPR up to 1100 °C, with oxygen corresponding to the second TPR peak removed, large grains corresponding to metallic cobalt are visible in SEM micrographs (
Figure 11 (
c), (
f)), however, XRD patterns also show a characteristic halo, indicating a low degree of Co
0 crystallization. Analysis of SEM micrographs suggests that the surface of these large grains contains small (0.2–1.0 μm) nuclei of the Co
0 phase, presumably giving reflections in the diffraction pattern (according to calculations, mean c.s.d. size of Co
0 is 44 nm).
TPR profiles of cobalt-magnesia samples are similar to those of Co
3O
4 in the low-temperature range (
Figure 10), however, their first peak maxima are shifted to higher values by 30–50 °C, while their second peak becomes wider, which is confirmed by the literature [
16,
18,
24,
25]. In this range, as the calcination temperature increases, there is a tendency for the second peak to narrow, especially in the pre-calcination range of 750–800 °C. For all sample compositions, the limiting temperature for the presence of spinel TPR peaks is 800 °C.
The high-temperature profiles closest to each other in shape are those corresponding to the stoichiometric spinels Co
3O
4 and MgCo
2O
4, with a clearly defined single peak of CoO or (Co, Mg)O solid solution, with the solid solution reduction temperature shifting to 1014–1076 °C, similar to [
16].
The reduction of Co
1Mg
1 sample calcined at 800 °C gives a single peak with
Tmax = 452 °C corresponding to the Co
3+ → Co
2+ transition. This indicates a decrease in the thermal stability of spinel structures when they are diluted with magnesia exceeding the MgCo
2O
4 stoichiometry. However, high-temperature Co
1Mg
1 samples are characterized by a very wide range of solid solution reduction with maxima above 1100 °C, i.e., the (Co, Mg)O phase formed under these conditions is extremely stable (
Figure 10). In this regard, the behavior of high-temperature Co
4Mg
1 is unexpected, with their TPR profiles showing a separate peak with
Tmax = 758–806 °C from CoO after Co
3O
4 thermal decomposition and a further wide peak with
Tmax > 1100 °C. That is, in contrast to stoichiometric spinels Co
2Mg
1 and Co
3O
4, in the case of non-stoichiometric samples the characteristic reduction peak of the rocksalt phase is not observed. At the same time, high-temperature samples of different compositions show a noticeable decrease in the intensity of the reoxidized Co
3O
4 reduction peaks with increasing magnesia content.
The observed patterns of formation and decomposition during heat treatment and reduction can be partly explained by different rates of decomposition of cobalt and magnesium nitrate salts. According to thermal analysis data, cobalt nitrate has a lower decomposition temperature range (up to 300 °C) than magnesium nitrate (up to 450 °C) [
52], and thus the initial formation of Co–Mg spinel occurs during the reaction of cobalt oxide crystal nuclei with magnesium salts. Such a process allows the formation of an amorphous oxide phase, which, as the heating temperature increases, gradually forms a well-crystallized spinel. Its restructuring requires a fairly high temperature, consistent with TPR data for low-temperature Co–Mg samples (up to 650 °C), where its anion-modified, paracrystalline structure is preserved, and only above this temperature the lattice begins to rearrange, transforming into a “true” spinel. The full transformation into the spinel phase under these conditions is impossible due to its decomposition at 800–900 °C with the transition of spinel phases into the rocksalt solid solution and the loss of lattice oxygen of the spinel.
To clarify the process of this process, the temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) method was employed. TPD profiles of Co
3O
4 samples calcined at different temperatures are presented in
Figure 13, while data on oxygen evolution are given in
Table 4.
From the data shown in
Figure 13 and
Table 4, it follows that the release of oxygen occurs predominantly in three regions: 150–300, 600–700 and 700–900 °C. The most oxygen is released in the 3
rd region, corresponding to Co
3O
4 decomposition with CoO formation, compared to the 1
st and 2
nd regions, corresponding to the desorption of superstoichiometric oxygen of different nature. The 2nd region is observed for low-temperature samples, and starting from 650 °C it becomes a shoulder and is not observed further. The oxygen release in the 700–900 °C range for low calcination temperatures is characterized by small fluctuations in peak temperatures (854–873 °C) and released oxygen volumes (2075–2092 μmol/g). No oxygen evolution is observed at temperatures above 900 °C, which theoretically should indicate the absence of peaks after calcination at 900 °C and above. However, as shown earlier, reoxidation and partial regeneration occur during the sample quenching [
27], with the resulting surface spinel formed on the surface of rocksalt phase (
Figure 11). The amount of oxygen released from the surface spinel gradually decreases with increasing calcination temperature. This is explained by sintering of the samples, reducing the possibility of reoxidation, further confirmed by the shift of TPD peaks to lower temperatures with increasing calcination temperature.