3.1. General Characteristics of Pumpkin Cultivars
The cultivated pumpkins are quite similar in terms of their requirements for growth and development, but their fruit morphology (size, shape, color, and pulp structure) is highly variable [
28].
The general characteristics of the pumpkin cultivars tested in this research are presented in
Table 1. For all pumpkins, the flesh had a distinct orange color, while the orange skin was shared by the following cultivars: Butternut, Delica vanity, Violina rugosa, Moscata di Provenza, and Hokkaido; in turn, Delica and Lunga di Napoli pumpkins showed green skin.
Table 2 shows the results of the CIELAB and CIELCH color characteristics of examined pumpkin varieties. Based on these measurements, a wide range of values can be observed: L* (26.98–56.87), a* (2.58-14.98), b* (25.19–49.28), C* (27.28-49.52), and H* (66.21-86.96) parameters. All values of a* and b* were on the positive scales, suggesting that the carotenoid extracts were red and yellow on the first quadrant in the LAB/LCH color space. The value of H* was in the first quadrant of the hue angle (0°–90°) and located in the range of red hue to yellow hue. No statistically different results (p > 0.05) were obtained comparing the color data of the two varieties C. moschata vs. C. maxima species. The results of color parameters (L*, a*, b*, C*, H*) were processed to evaluate the degree of correlation (
Table S1). As regards C. maxima, very good coefficients of correlation (R2 ≥ 0.9171) were obtained, while for C. moschata the most interesting correlation values were reported for L* vs. a* (R
2 = 0.9822) and L* vs. H (R
2 = 0.9919). Other authors have reported a wide variation in the color data
[10,29,30]. Kulczyński et al. (2020) showed for the pulp of pumpkin varieties belonging to C. moschata and C. pepo species the following values: L* (52.00–71.98), a* (−5.44–30.84), and b* (29.24–51.84) parameters [
10]. Other studies [
29] also found differences in the color range between pumpkins belonging to three different species: C. maxima (L* = 36.08, a* = 3.30, b* = 17.60), C. pepo (32.67, a* = −0.13, b* = 1.68), and C. moschata (L* = 35.58, a* = 0.52, b* = 11.24). Paciulli et al. (2019) reported a deep colorimetric characterization of Delica and Butternut pumpkin species as raw samples and after high-pressure treatments, showing interesting color changes [
30]. Also, Norfezah et al. (2011) reported a change in pulp color parameters after pumpkin flour production by cabinet drying (from 67.94 to 75.84 for L*; from 12.29 to 5.77 for a*; from 42.75 to 37.76 for b*) for mature Crown pumpkin (C. maxima) [
31]. C* and H* values ranged respectively from 31.9 to 72.2, and from 77.5 to 99.0 for pumpkin cultivars belonging to C. moschata species [
32]. Pumpkin pulp moisture was also determined and values between 81.65 and 96.86% for C. moschata species and between 83.34 and 89.61% for C. maxima species were obtained. Statistically different results were obtained from the comparison between moisture values of the two species (p < 0.05), but also considering different varieties belonging to the same species (p < 0.01). Other authors have also reported similar values. Norfezah et al. (2011) reported a moisture value of 84.34% for C. maxima species [
31], while Karanja et al. (2014) showed a range from 75.08% to 91.16% for thirteen groups of pumpkins cultivated in Kenya [
33].
3.2. Cell Count and Viability: Acridine Orange/DAPI Double Staining
To evaluate the cytotoxicity of pumpkin carotenoids on neuroblastoma cells, an optimal extraction procedure must be followed, providing both an efficient extraction, and also limiting the chemical decomposition and biological activity modification of bioactive compounds [
34]. Based on a previous paper, an unconventional extraction technique (UAE), and the hexane:isopropanol (60:40 v/v) mixture were used to perform the isolation of carotenoids from pumpkin pulp, belonging to two species/eight varieties [
17]. Neuroblastoma is a solid tumor often diagnosed in childhood. It represents 8-10% of all pediatric tumors and has unfavorable outcomes due to drug resistance and high metastatic potential [
35]. To date, most of the available therapies remain unsuccessful against neuroblastoma and the discovery of new treatment approaches is required for this detrimental disease [
16]. In this study, we evaluated the viability of SH-SY5Y human neuroblastoma cells after exposure to six increasing concentrations of carotenoid pumpkin extracts. In addition, SH-SY5Y cells were challenged with the same concentration of β-carotene used as positive control. Total/dead cell double-staining technique, using AO and DAPI fluorochromes, was employed. Results were expressed as percentage variation of cell viability concerning the untreated control. After 24 h of treatment (
Figure 1A and
Figure 2A), only the highest concentration of Butternut (i.e., 100 μmol/L) caused a significant decrease in viability percentage compared to the untreated control (p = 0.043). On the contrary, after 48 h of treatment (
Figure 1B and
Figure 2B), all extracts promoted cell death at 100 μmol/L concentration (Butternut, p = 0.016; Delica, p = 0.008; Delica Vanity, p = 0.024; Hokkaido, p = 0.001; Lunga di Napoli, p = 0.001; Mantovana, P = 0.035; Moscata di Provenza, p = 0.037; Violina rugosa, p = 0.001; β-carotene, p < 0.0001), whereas both Mantovana and β-carotene showed cytotoxicity at 50 μmol/L (p = 0.038 and p < 0.0001, respectively). Regarding the results reported in
Figure 1A and
Figure 2A, it should be pointed out that at 2-100 μmol/L no significant differences (p > 0.05) were observed.
Our findings are in line with a previous paper in which β-carotene at 60 μmol/L (i.e., 112 μmol/L) was reported to induce apoptosis in SH-SY5Y cells through increasing intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) production [
36]. Indeed, in certain doses, almost all antioxidants can behave as prooxidants, triggering cell death pathways mediated by increased ROS production [
12]. The current study indicates that pulp pumpkin extracts exert cytotoxic action against SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells, laying an attractive basis for further research. Several investigations will be required to determine the mechanism underlying the extract’s anti-cancer activity, which is most likely owing to the synergistic effect of several compounds in the phytocomplex.
3.3. TCC and Antioxidant Activity of Pumpkin Pulp
The tested pumpkin extracts were characterized for their carotenoid content and antioxidant properties.
Table 3 shows the values of the yield of carotenoid extraction, TCC, and in vitro antioxidant activity (ABTS and ORAC assays) of pulp extracts. The percentage of extraction (yield, %), determined by the gravimetric method, was calculated using the equation reported in a previous paper [
24]. It is possible to observe a wide range of values even if the same pumpkin species were considered (i.e., from 1.03% of Delica vanity to 4.15% of Delica). In addition, no statistical differences (p > 0.05) were found between C. moschata and C. maxima species, even if the same extraction method and conditions (solvent, temperature, time, solid/liquid ratio) were used. After that, a spectrophotometric characterization was carried out to determine the TCC and antioxidant properties of the extracts. The TCC results of the considered eight varieties change over the range 161.08 μg/g of Butternut to 443.89 μg/g of Violina rugosa, both varieties belonging to C. moschata species, while for C. maxima the values ranged from 241.32 to 379.36 μg/g (Delica vanity and Delica, respectively). To make an interesting comparison with literature, it must be taken into consideration that TCC values, as well as biological properties, could change from pumpkin variety to variety, or in the same variety, they could change based on the extraction method and conditions and many other variables [
9,
17].
The TCC values reported in this paper are similar to those found by other authors, for example de Carvalho et al. (2012) [
37]. They found a range of TCC from 234.21 to 404.98 μg/g in two landrace pumpkins (C. moschata) cultivated in Brazil. Higher or lower values have been found compared to other papers. For example, Armesto et al. (2020) reported TCC levels of 34.54-39.53 μg/g for Butternut (C. moschata) pumpkin from Spain, extracted by UAE with acetone [
11]. Hussain et al. (2022) reported a TCC value of 35.2 mg/100 g for flesh powder from C. maxima of Pakistan, extracted with 80% methanol, in an orbital shaker for 120 h at room temperature [
38]. Biesiada et al. (2011) reported that the highest content of carotenoids was recorded in a cultivar belonging to C. maxima from Poland, Amazonka (18.40 mg/100 g fresh weight), while the lowest (0.57 mg/100 g fresh weight) for C. pepo, Pyza cultivar [
39]. Azizah et al. (2009) evaluated twenty-two cultivars of C. moschata reporting a TCC ranging from 7.02 to 138.56 μg/g, using ethanol for the extraction by a flask placed in a water bath at 25 °C for 1h [
40].
As regards antioxidant activity results, the ABTS values ranged from 280.91 μg TE/g of Butternut to 1192.11 μg TE/g of Delica, while ORAC values ranged from 1267.86 μg TE/g of Delica vanity to 3996.18 μg TE/g of Delica. Statistically different results were obtained from the comparison between ABTS values of C. moschata and C. maxima species, as well as between ORAC values (p < 0.05), but also taking into consideration different varieties belonging to the same species (p < 0.01). The results of spectrophotometric analyses (TCC, ABTS, ORAC) were processed to evaluate their degree of correlation (
Table S2), and a good positive linear relationship between all parameters (R
2 ≥ 0.5666) was found.
For literature comparison, it is worth noting that some papers reported ABTS and ORAC values of extracts obtained with polar solvents (methanol, water), where the antioxidant activity was probably linked to polyphenols, but not to carotenoids. As an example, Kulczyński et al. (2020) reported for Butternut lower ABTS values both taking into consideration aqueous-methanol extract (126.92 mg TE/100 g), and aqueous extract (138.36 mg TE/100 g) and found the lowest ABTS values for Futsu and Table Queen pumpkin cultivars [
10]. As regards ORAC values, the same authors found the lowest and the highest values for cultivars belonging to the C. pepo (i.e., Table Queen 28.12 μmol TE/g; Delicata 108.3 μmol TE/g). Only a few papers reported the values of antioxidant assays carried out on carotenoid extracts. As an example, Pinna et al. (2022) reported values of 958.88 and 2832.76 μg TE/g for ABTS and ORAC respectively for extracts of C. moschata obtained with hexane:isopropanol (60:40 v/v) [
17].
3.4. Carotenoid Composition of Pulp and Multivariate Statistical Analysis
Established that carotenoid fraction isolated from pumpkin powder showed interesting biological activity, the in-depth profiling of bioactives of extracts was the next key step. The qualitative and quantitative analysis of carotenoids by an HPLC-DAD procedure was performed, taking advantage of a method validated in previous works [
17,
24]. A UHPLC-MS/MS technique was also carried out for the structural confirmation of the analytes.
The quantitation of carotenoids identified in all the investigated extracts was carried out based on calibration curves built up using standard solutions of lutein and zeaxanthin dipalmitate with concentration values in the range specified in
Table S3. The calibration curve of β-carotene and the relative values of linearity and accuracy were reported in a previous paper [
17]. The β-carotene standard was used for the quantification of non-esterified cyclic carotenes (β-carotene and α-carotene), other non-esterified carotenoids (i.e., violaxanthin, antheraxanthin, neoxanthin, lutein, zeaxanthin) were quantified using the regression equation of lutein (expressed as μg LE/g DW), while esterified (mono- and di-) carotenoids (among which violaxanthin and antheraxanthin myristate, lutein and antheraxanthin palmitate, and also violaxanthin di-myristate, antheraxanthin di-laurate and others) were quantified using the regression equation of zeaxanthin dipalmitate (expressed as μg ZDE/g DW). The regression model showed good linearity for both lutein and zeaxanthin dipalmitate (R
2 > 0.996 and 0.994, respectively), revealing useful for predictive purposes. Furthermore, the established RP-HPLC method was validated at a research level in terms of accuracy, precision, limit of detection (LOD), and limit of quantification (LOQ) (
Table S4). This internal validation, performed at a basic level to demonstrate the suitability of the in-house developed method, provided useful results thus ensuring that the process is satisfactory and consistent within the scope of the present study. In
Table S5 the UV-Vis and mass spectral data used for the identification of the carotenoids are shown.
Figure 3A,B shows the data of carotenoid composition, while
Figure 4A,B the content of grouped carotenoids. The most abundant xanthophylls found in pumpkin pulp were monoesterified for C. maxima and diesterified for C. moschata. A study of correlation was carried out between all parameters (spectrophotometric and chromatographic data), and it can be noted that C. maxima data showed always high values of R2 which were between 0.5411 and 0.9907 (
Table S2). The cultivars with the highest β-carotene content were Delica, Violina rugosa, and Moscata di Provenza (134.52-140.38 μg/g), while α-carotene was only detected in pumpkin belonging to C. moschata species (10.29-153.86 μg/g). Generally, it should be noted that carotenoid content varied in a wide range
[8,38,39,41], also considering the dependence of this data from cultivar, variety, harvesting time, storage, and processing. Hussain et al. (2022) reported a β-carotene content of 6.18 mg/100 g for flesh pumpkin (C. maxima) [
38]. de Carvalho et al. (2012) found that all E-β-carotene was the most abundant isomer, varying from 141.95 to 244.22 μg/g, compared to α-carotene (67.06-72.99 μg/g), while 9- and 13-Z-β-carotene isomers were found in low concentrations [
37]. Kreck et al. (2006) reported that pumpkin varieties belonging to C. maxima differ significantly in terms of carotenoids, in fact the concentration of β-carotene ranged from 17 mg/kg to 263 mg/kg [
42]. Murkovic et al. (2002) reported a content of α-carotene from 0.03 mg/100 g for C. pepo (Carneval di Venezia variety) up to 7.5 mg/100 g for C. maxima (Flat White Boer variety) and a content of β-carotene from 0.06 to 7.4 mg/100 g [
43]. Dhenge et al. (2022) reported the content of carotenoids after high-pressure processing (α-carotene 29.2-78.3 μg/g; β-carotene 10.5-20.4 μg/g) [
44]. Recently, Grassino et al. (2023) reviewed the carotenoid content and profiles of pumpkin products and by-products. They reported β-carotene values of 5.70 and 17.04 μg/g for the pulp of C. moschata and C. maxima respectively, while the content of α-carotene was reported only for pumpkin seed oil, puree, juice, and extrudates [
41].
In this research, in addition to cyclic carotenes (α- and β-carotene), other non-esterified carotenoids were detected, among which epoxycarotenoids (neoxanthin, violaxanthin, and antheraxanthin) and hydroxycarotenoids (zeaxanthin and lutein). Delica and Mantovana varieties, belonging to C. maxima species, showed the highest contents (266.195 and 135.23 μg LE/g, respectively), while the Butternut and Lunga di Napoli varieties of C. moschata species showed the lowest content (6.55 and 10.22 μg LE/g, respectively) of this class of non-esterified compounds. However, there was a notable difference among the single compound content (neoxanthin, violaxanthin, antheraxanthin, lutein, and zeaxanthin). As regards lutein content, in this work the values ranged from 5.24 μg LE/g of Butternut up to 119.26 μg LE/g of Delica. Generally, it can be observed that this last variety was the one richest in carotenoid content, in fact it showed the highest content of β-carotene, as well as non-esterified and esterified carotenoids. Kulczyński and Gramza-Michałowska (2019) reported lutein content ranging from 87.20 μg/g for Porcelain Doll to 388.79 for Melonowa Żółta variety, with a value of 130.23 μg/g for Hokkaido. Lutein content from 0.6 to 17.3 μg/g fresh weight was reported by Itle and Kabelka (2009) [
32].
Among hydroxycarotenoids, zeaxanthin was quantified by some authors with a wide range of contents (Kurz et al. (2008); Kulczyński and Gramza-Michałowska, 2019; Hussain et al., 2022). Kurz et al. (2008) reported values of 0.57 μg/g for Halloween pumpkin to 22.45 μg/g for Hokkaido variety, while Kulczyński and Gramza-Michałowska (2019) from 19.57 μg/g for Buttercup to 192.53 μg/g of Melonowa Żółta variety [
8]. In the research of Murkovic et al. (2002), lutein and zeaxanthin were not separated by routine HPLC method, so the authors reported that the content of lutein (+ zeaxanthin) changed from 0.8 to 17 mg/100 g for C. maxima species, and from 0.08 to 1.1 mg/100 g for C. moschata species [
43]. In this deep characterization of carotenoid fraction of pumpkin, it was found that many carotenoids were linked to saturated and long-chain fatty acids, i.e., lauric (C12:0), myristic (C14:0) and palmitic (C16:0) acids.
Among esterified carotenoids, monoesterified carotenoids (i.e., violaxanthin and antheraxanthin myristate, lutein and antheraxanthin palmitate) and diesterified carotenoids (i.e., violaxanthin or lutein di-myristate, antheraxanthin di-laurate, lutein di-palmitate, lutein myristate-laurate, and zeaxanthin myristate-palmitate) were identified and quantified. The presence of fatty esters of xanthophylls especially of violaxanthin (monomyristate) and lutein (monomyristate and monopalmitate) was published for the first time in 1988 by the group of Khachik [
45], but they did not quantify these compounds since no reference materials were available. Recently, Ouyang et al. (2022) studied the stability of carotenoids and carotenoid esters in pumpkin (C. maxima) slices during hot air drying. They identified and quantified six esterified carotenoids, besides free carotenoids. They reported essentially esterified forms of lutein with contents of 20.3 μg/g DW for lutein-stearate-palmitate up to 93.1 μg/g DW for lutein-palmitate-laurate, in addition to 37.8 μg/g DW of violaxanthin-dipalmitate [
46].
The esterification of carotenoids has been correlated with greater stability and potentially higher or equivalent bioavailability compared to free carotenoids; in fact, it has been reported that xanthophyll esters probably need to be hydrolyzed during digestion before absorption and that the in vivo absorption of carotenoids is better if they are esterified rather than non-esterified [47,48]. In conclusion of this section, it must be emphasized that the presence of high content of carotenoids in pumpkin pulp plays an essential role in maintaining a healthy status, due to the broad spectrum of health-promoting effects of these bioactives, having neuroprotective, ophthalmological, antimicrobial, cardioprotective, antiplasmodial, and skin effects. As an example, for age-related eye disease (macular degeneration and cataract), it is sufficient to mention that β-carotene is a precursor of 11-cis retinal, a chromophore of rhodopsin found in rods, receptors enabling vision under low-light conditions, while lutein and zeaxanthin are the main antioxidants of the retina. They can absorb UV radiation and blue light as well as scavenge free radicals and reactive oxygen species. Prevention and treatment of age-related eye diseases include carotenoid supplementation [49,50].
In this paper, to evaluate the possibility that carotenoids could represent valid biomarkers for pumpkin species differentiation (C. moschata vs. C. maxima), principal component analysis (PCA) was applied and the dataset was represented by the carotenoid content obtained by HPLC-DAD analysis.
Based on 2D scores plot (
Figure 5A) and biplot (
Figure S2), the samples were grouped both considering the varieties and the species. In particular, the samples belonging to C. maxima species (on the right) were separated from those of C. moschata (on the left). To explain the variance, the first two principal components (PC1 and PC2) were extracted, which together accounted for 74.9% of the variance (PC1: 53.8%; PC2: 21.1%).
Figure S3 shows the PCA overview with the pairwise score plot for the top 5 PC, while
Figure S4 shows the PCA scree plot, indicating the variance explained by individual PC and the accumulated variance. The HeatMap (
Figure 5B) shows that 17 carotenoids were identified as interesting biomarkers. In particular, Violina rugosa showed lutein di-myristate, lutein myristate-laurate, and lutein myristate-palmitate as overexpressed carotenoids, while lutein palmitate, violaxantin-myristate, violaxanthin, and neoxanthin were overexpressed in Mantovana variety. Antheraxanthin myristate and lutein di-laurate were mainly represented in Hokkaido and Butternut, respectively. Moreover, hierarchical clustering dendrogram (
Figure S5), the branching diagram representing the relationships of similarity among groups, highlighted the clear separation of pumpkin varieties belonging to the two different species (C. moschata vs. C. maxima).