2.2. Application to Organic Reactions
To verify the catalytic activity of the prepared Fe3O4@PDA-Cys@Cu platform, it was initially employed in the Sonogashira coupling reaction, a cross-coupling reaction involving aryl acetylenes and aryl halides.
Before the general application of the Fe
3O
4@PDA-Cys@Cu platform, we conducted a preliminary search for optimal parameters for the Sonogashira coupling reactions using phenylacetylene (
1a) and 4-iodoanisole (
2a) as standard substrates (
Table 1).
At first, the model reaction was carried out using excess equivalent (1.2 eq) of phenyl acetylene (1a) with 60 mg of Fe
3O
4@PDA-Cys@Cu platform in DMSO at 100 ℃, affording the desired coupling product (3a) in 84% isolated yield (
Table 1, Entry 1). Significantly, a remarkable improvement in isolated yield (up to 99%) was achieved by increasing the amount of the catalytic platform (up to 80 mg) employed under the same conditions (
Table 1, Entry 2). Subsequent trials were conducted to identify a more versatile solvent system, which demonstrated the high efficiency of both ethanol and water as reaction media. For practical convenience, we chose to employ EtOH as the reaction solvent for further investigation. Decreasing the amount of the platform to 60 mg did not significantly affect the isolated yield (
Table 1, Entries 5 and 6). Further attempts with 50 mg of Fe
3O
4@PDA-Cys@Cu platform demonstrated relatively lower catalytic efficiency under similar conditions (
Table 1, Entry 7). The use of equimolar amounts of 1a and 2a resulted in a slightly disappointing outcome (
Table 1, Entry 8). Interestingly, reaction temperature turned out to be a critical factor for the successful completion of the reaction (
Table 1, Entry 9).
With the optimization tests, the scope and applicability of the novel catalytic platform was further explored using various substrates (
Table 2). Firstly, the investigation was conducted using 1a and aryl halides containing C–I bond in the presence of Fe
3O
4@PDA-Cys@Cu platform under standard conditions. Initially, 2-iodotoluene (2b) was reacted with 1a, resulting in the formation of 1-methyl-2-(phenylethynyl)benzene (3b) with an isolated yield of 91% (
Table 2, Entry 1). Additionally, the reaction of 1a with 3-fluoro-iodobenzene proceeded well, yielding the corresponding coupled product (3c) in excellent isolated yields (
Table 2, Entry 2). In contrast to these positive outcomes, relatively lower performance was observed in the coupling reactions with 4-chloroiodobenzene (2d) and 3-cyano-iodobenzene (2e). Interestingly, a polar functional group (OH) on aryl iodide (2f) was well tolerated, yielding the desired product (3f) in excellent yield (
Table 2, Entry 5).
The substrate scope of acetylene was also investigated using various arylacetylenes (
1b –
1f) under the standard conditions. Overall, the reaction outcomes were consistent with those observed for
1a, confirming the catalytic efficiency of the developed reaction platform. Entries 6 and 7 in
Table 2 demonstrate that 3-iodoaniline (
2g) and 3-fluoro-iodobenzene (
2c) were effective substrates for the synthesis of their respective asymmetric acetylene derivatives (
3g and
3h) from 1-ethynyl-4-methylbenzene (
1b) using the optimized Sonogashira coupling (
Table 2, Entries 6 and 7). Similar catalytic performance was observed when various arylacetylenes, such as 4-ethynylbenzonitrile (
1c) and 1-ethynyl-4-methoxybenzene (
1d), were used. The corresponding products (
3i and
3j, respectively) were effectively obtained with excellent yields (
Table 2, Entries 8 and 9). Furthermore, the presence of bromine (
1e) and hydroxyl (
1f) groups on the arylacetylene rings did not affect the reaction outcome (
Table 2, Entries 10 and 11). The reaction conditions used in this study were well tolerated to provide the final coupling products (
3k and
3l) in an excellent manner.
To further extend the scope of this green protocol, we studied the coupling of
1a with various aryl halides bearing a C–Br bond, including 4-bromobenzonitrile, 2-bromothiophene, and 2-bromopyridine. Unfortunately, the reactions proceeded sluggishly or resulted in unseparable mixtures (
Table 2, Entries 12–14).
Next, the recyclability of the novel catalytic platform was explored to ensure its advantage as a heterogeneous catalytic system (
Table 3). Following standard procedures, a recycling test was carried out using
1a and
2a. After each cycle, the catalyst was effortlessly retrieved using an external magnet, washed consecutively with fresh water and acetone, and subsequently dried in air. The results from the recycling test indicate that the present platform demonstrates high potential as a recoverable and reusable heterogeneous catalytic system for Sonogashira coupling under mild conditions.
As mentioned before, we previously disclosed a novel heterogeneous copper catalyst immonbilized on polydopamine-coated magnetite for click reaction [
49]. In our previous study, the catalyst was prepared by immobilizing Cu(OAc)₂ salt onto polydopamine-coated magnetite (denoted as Fe
3O
4@PDA@Cu). The catalytic activity of the resulting Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu platform was investigated in a click reaction, utilizing three-component reactions of azide, alkyne, and benzyl surrogates in water, which provided the corresponding 1,2,3-triazoles in high yields. Despite the positive outcomes using the Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu platform, unsatisfactory results were observed in recycling tests (see
Table 5).
Despite numerous approaches utilizing magnetite-based copper catalytic systems for click reaction [
50], there remains a need for versatile routes that focus on catalyst recyclability and reusability. Here, to expand the library of click reactions catalyzed by magnetic nanoparticle-supported copper catalysts and conduct a comparative study, we further carried out click reactions using various substrates in the presence of our newly designed Fe₃O₄@PDA-Cys@Cu platform. For simple comparison, the results were disclosed in parallel with those obtained using our previous Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu platform, as shown in
Table 4.
In general, no significant differences were observed in the overall reactivity when using Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu and Fe₃O₄@PDA-Cys@Cu as catalysts in the click reaction, respectively. In both cases, cyclization proceeded smoothly, providing 1,4-disubstituted-1,2,3-triazoles in excellent yields regardless of the functionality on acetylenes or benzyl halides. As evidenced by the yield of the target product, each catalyst system exhibited highly effective catalytic activity in the click reaction.
Next, the recyclability of the novel catalytic platform in click reaction was explored to ensure its advantage over our previous non-modified Fe
3O
4@PDA@Cu platform. Following standard procedures, a recycling test was carried out as depicted in
Table 5. The isolated yields of the coupling products obtained from both recycling tests are comparatively displayed, clearly indicating the effectiveness of the Fe
3O
4@PDA-Cys@Cu catalyst over the Fe
3O
4@PDA@Cu catalyst used in our previous study.
Table 5.
Reusability test using the Fe3O4@PDA@Cu and Fe3O4@PDA-Cys@Cu platforms.
Table 5.
Reusability test using the Fe3O4@PDA@Cu and Fe3O4@PDA-Cys@Cu platforms.
|
Recycling |
0 |
1st |
2nd |
3rd |
4th |
5th |
6th |
7th |
Yielda |
98% (5 h) |
97% (7 h) |
72% (7 h) |
51% (7 h) |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Yieldb |
99% |
99% |
96% |
96% |
95% |
95% |
95% |
90% |
As shown in
Table 5, the catalytic activity of the two platforms (Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu and Fe₃O₄@PDA-Cys@Cu) in recycling tests for the click reaction exhibited significant differences. We hypothesized that these differences could be attributed to the variation in copper content retained within the recycled platforms after use. To verify our assumption, we performed ICP analysis to quantify the decrease in copper content before and after use. In our previous study with Fe₃O₄@PDA@Cu, the copper content dropped from 5.01% to 0.04%. Interestingly, in the current study using Fe₃O₄@PDA-Cys@Cu, the reduction in copper content was notably less, decreasing from 18.96% to 17.41% after seven recycling cycles.
Furthermore, a similarly modest reduction in copper content was also observed during the Sonogashira coupling reaction using Fe₃O₄@PDA-Cys@Cu, and confirmed by EDX analysis (
Figure 4).