4.2. Serum, Ig, CSF Evidence
There is overwhelming direct and indirect evidence that patient antibodies, serum, and CSF interact with calcium channels in ALS. A thorough search found 36 papers [
60,
61,
62,
63,
64,
65,
66,
67,
68,
69,
70,
71,
72,
73,
74,
75,
76,
77,
78,
79,
80,
81,
82,
83,
84,
85,
86,
87,
88,
89,
90,
91,
92,
93,
94,
95].
In 18 of these papers, the interaction directly involved increased calcium. Patient antibodies and sera induce the following effects: (most of these results are MTNs) increased P-VGCC currents (and open time) in cerebellum Purkinje cells [
67], extracellular calcium-dependent cell death in MTN-neuroblastoma hybrid cell line (VCS4.1), prevented by N- or P-VGCC (but not L-VGCC) antagonists [
68], increased calcium and vesicle number in spinal MTNs [
72], increased Ca
2+
currents in a hybrid MTN VCS4.1 cells [
71], increased extracellular calcium entry via VGCCs leading to higher intracellular calcium in hybrid MTN VCS4.1 cells [
77], increased Ca
2+ influx via P/Q-VGCC, N-VGCC (only weakly via L-VGCC) in cortical synaptosomes [
81], development of L-VGCC (but not P/Q-VGCC-)-induced transmitter release in the neuromuscular junction (NMJ) [
84], increased presynaptic Ca
2+ in MTNs, along with golgi patholgoy and increased golgi Ca
2+ [
82], faster H-VGCC current activation in MTNs [
85], MTN degeneration and significantly increased number of Ca
2+-containing golgi, mitochondria, and rough endoplasmic reticulum (ER) [
86], potentiation of transmitter release from MTN via influx through N-VGCC [
88], necrosis, MTN degeneration, swelling and Ca
2+ of golgi endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria [
87], increased muscle miniature end-plate potential frequency, NMJ ACh release, which are significantly decreased in P/Q-VGCC (but not N-VGCC) KO [
89], intracellular Ca
2+ release in astrocytes via IP3 (intracellular stores) [
91], high rather than oscillating L-VGCC-mediated intracellular Ca
2+ in mouse islets (in ALS patients with type 2 diabetes) [
92], MTN degeneration, inclusion-like IgG accumulation, increased intracellular Ca
2+ [
93], increased number of synaptic and Ca
2+ elevation in MTN terminals [
94], and increased cytoplasmic calcium, cell death in mice MTNs [
95] (the last two results are with serum of patients with identified mutations).
In 8 of the 36 papers, the interaction resulted in directly decreased Ca
2+. This includes decreased charge movement, peak calcium current, and slower channel inactivation in skeletal muscle L-VGCCs [
63], decreased mean skeletal muscle L-VGCC open time with stabilization to a smaller amplitude [
65], decreased peak L-VGCC current with increased tail current deactivation rate in mammalian skeletal muscle fibers [
66], decreased charge movement and peak L-VGCC currents in isolated muscle fibers [
70], depressed inward Ba
2+-mediated (high threshold) VGCC currents in rat cerebellum granule culture [
69], suppressed intracellular Ca
2+ increase via P/Q-VGCCs (but not N-, L-VGCC) influx in cultured neurons [
74], decreased H-VGCC peak and faster and more hyperpolarized inactivation in mice DRG neurons [
76], and inhibition of L-VGCC-mediated dopamine release [
79].
In 8 of the 36 papers, the reported results indirectly support increased calcium, including increased NMJ presynaptic ACh release frequency following 4 hour and 4-12 week incubation [
60,
61], increased NMJ miniature end-plate potential frequency (resting quantal ACh release) [
62], enhanced excitatory transmission in hippocampus culture via presynaptic glutamate release [
75], increased CSF glutamate [
78], increased NMJ spontaneous transmitter release and quantal content, with similar effects produced by caffeine via Ca
2+ [
80], increased spontaneous NMJ ACh release in 3/4 cases [
83] (this paper also reported decreased spontaneous NMJ ACh release in some cases, indirectly supporting decreased calcium), and endoplasmic reticulum stress in spinal MTNs [
90] (this result is with sALS CSF). These results only provide indirect support, because although increased neurotransmitter release can stem from increased calcium, it can also be due to other reasons.
The presence of VGCC antibodies was reported in several papers, including antibodies to L-VGCC [
64,
70,
83] and P-, Q-, and N-VGCC [
73]. Patient IgGs were found to be present in MTN axon terminals [
96].
Many of these results were done in the same lab (Appel), but more than half of them were done by unrelated labs, over more than two decades. A technical argument was raised against the initial wave of these results [
97], but it has been refuted [
87].
It should be emphasized that this evidence is from ALS patients, not from animal models, which are not valid for sALS (according to the present paper).
4.6. Other Tissue
It can be argued that a general H-VGCC impairment cannot be the core cause of ALS, because this would cause a much wider impairment than the MTN one seen in ALS. However, ALS patients actually do show wide impairment, which overlaps the distribution of H-VGCCs. In addition to MTNs and skeletal muscle issues, ALS patients show cognitive deficits [
105,
106], cardiorespiratory and cardiovascular damage [
107,
108,
109,
110,
111,
112], skin neuropathy [
113,
114,
115], pain in all disease stages, sometimes before motor symptoms [
116], impaired insulin secretion [
117,
118], Purkinje cell damage [
119], and immune system dysregulation (excessive inflammation coupled with inefficient immune responses) [
120]. The affected tissues are precisely those with high H-VGCC expression. In addition, calcium is significantly increased in patient blood lymphocytes [
121].
The beta cell evidence is especially relevant. Like the calcium evidence, both increased and decreased insulin release have been reported [
117]. The decrease is of early phase secretion [
118].
The question why MTNs are more sensitive than the other tissues is discussed below.
In summary, there is overwhelming evidence for calcium dysregulation in ALS, pointing to chronic calcium.
4.7. Explanatory Power for ALS Facts
Studying the sALS literature, several major pathological phenomena can be identified: muscle use problems, muscle wasting, muscle spasms (fasciculation, twitches) (the three main clinical symptoms); symptom appearance with aging (the main epidemiological datum); degeneration of spinal or bulbar (but not ocular) MTNs (the main pathological datum); aggregation of the TDP43 protein [
122], oxidativestress [
123,
124,
125,
126,
127,
128,
129], and mitochondria dysfunction [
130] (the main cellular data); hypermetabolism in motor areas [
131] (the main imaging datum); and toxicity of patient serum/Ig/CSF (much of it related to calcium, as detailed above).
Chronic intracellular calcium can explain all of these data points. It can cause muscle spasms because intracellular Ca
2+ elevation is what induces muscle contractions [
132]. Hypermetabolism is identified using PET via increased glucose uptake capacity. Chronic calcium would yield a chronic activation of calcium pumps (PMCA, SERCA), which consume ATP [
133]. Relative ATP deficiency activates AMPK, which increases Glut4 translocation to the cell surface [
134] and thus glucose uptake capacity. Increased activated AMPK is indeed present in patient MTNs [
135,
136]. Chronically high ATP consumption can also account for muscle wasting (see also insulin discussion below).
Chronic calcium induces oxidativestress (mainly H2O2), mitochondria permeability pore opening, and ER stress [
137,
138,
139,
140,
141,
142]. oxidativestress and H2O2 induce and are enhanced by the cellular stress responses, including the unfolded protein and heat shock responses, and can lead to apoptosis [
143,
144,
145]. TDP43 is a major protein recruited by cellular stress responses [
122]. Cellular stress and oxidativestress (specifically H2O2) induce TDP43 aggregation, and its localization in stress granules [
146,
147,
148,
149,
150,
151]. TDP43 is strongly related to ALS, both due to intracellular aggregates in almost all patients [
152,
153] and to mutations in 10% of fALS patients [
122]. In our view, it is not causal in sALS, since the parsimonious account of its aggregation is chronic activation by stress responses. Chronic cellular stress eventually activates the death arms of cellular stress responses [
154,
155], explaining MTN degeneration and muscle use problems.
The late onset age of ALS can be explained by the fact that normal aging involves increased calcium currents [
156,
157] and reduced calcium buffering [
158], making aged cells more susceptible to abnormal Ca
2+ 1.
The specific vulnerability of non-ocular MTNs in ALS has been explained by the fact that these MTNs express very low levels of calcium binding proteins [
159,
160] (although there are also conflicting results [
161]). Eye movements and the cerebellum might be relatively preserved because the level of these proteins in oculomotor neurons and Pukinje cells are 5-6 and 15 times higher, respectively [
160,
162]. Moreover, sensitive MTNs (tongue) express 3 fold higher levels of H-VGCC currents than ocular MTNs [
163]. In addition, MTNs have long axons and high energy requirements, making them more sensitive to chronic ATP consumption and oxidativestress.
High pre-onset physical activity is strongly associated with increased ALS risk [
164,
165,
166,
167,
168,
169,
170] (although there are also neutral results [
171,
172]). High calcium increases muscle contraction capacity and performance, explaining this datum.
In summary, chronic calcium is toxic to cells and can account for the salient data of ALS.