The high demand for accelerated skin healing during medical treatment of skin wounds is not fully met by the therapeutic effects of a single polymeric-based material. Incorporating additional functions, such as promoting cell growth and antimicrobial properties, into the scaffold would significantly simplify the clinical process and shorten the time required to achieve better therapeutic outcomes for skin wound healing.
Based on a literature search, we have compiled a list of research articles that have explored the clinical potential of SF and Ker films loaded with different active compounds to produce or increase a specific effect on the wound. These articles have been classified into groups based on their therapeutic effects.
3.1. Films with Antimicrobial Function
Bacterial infection is one of the primary issues associated with impaired wound healing and, although SF and Ker based dressings have significant positive effects on wound repair and healing, they do not possess inherent antibacterial properties to address this problem, and could provide a good base layer for bacterial growth. Therefore, given fibroin and keratin versatility and ability to be combined with other substances,[
35,
36] incorporating antibacterial functions into biopolymer scaffolds is a promising strategy to improve their clinical use in treating open wounds and to decrease the risk of infections at the site. It is worth noting that, unlike SF, Ker already displays a mild antimicrobial effect, primarily due to the interaction between the positively charged amino groups in Ker and the negatively charged bacterial cell wall, which results in the inhibition of bacterial growth.[
37,
38] This is demonstrated, for example, in a study conducted by Sahil Goyal et al.[
39] The addition of Ker extracted from wool conferred antibacterial properties against
S. aureus and
K. pneumoniae to polymer films containing alginate and pectin, which showed no clear growth inhibition zone in the absence of the keratin.
Over the past decade, researchers have investigated various approaches to create antimicrobial SF and Ker based biomaterials. In this contest, a practical method is to develop infection-resistant biomaterials by integrating specific antibiotics into the protein matrix. This can be achieved by effectively blending antibiotics into aqueous or organic protein solutions before casting, resulting in antibiotic-loaded protein films. Aparna Yerra et al.[
40] evaluated the addition of 11 different antibiotics to a SF solution, which was then used to produce thin films tested against specific pathogenic strains. The resulting antibiotic-based SF films demonstrated antimicrobial effectiveness, successfully carrying and delivering the drugs to the attached microbial cells releasing them through passive diffusion. The localized drug delivery from biocomposite films offers a promising alternative to systemic antibiotic treatment, especially given the increasing concerns about microbial drug resistance that are important in clinical settings. In fact, this approach can provide a more targeted delivery, optimize pharmacokinetics, and reduce the required dosing frequency of drugs.
In response to the demand for effective alternatives, numerous studies have investigated the incorporation of various nanoparticles, microparticles, and natural compounds (including inorganic substances, honey, plant extracts, and natural polymers) as potential antimicrobial agents in wound dressings to improve their antimicrobial properties.
So far, researches demonstrated that integrating small amounts of biocompatible nano-sized components such as metal and metal oxide nanoparticles, within SF scaffolds can not only promote various cellular and molecular mechanisms that support the wound environment, but also hinder bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation, thereby facilitating a more expeditious healing process.[
4,
41] Compared to antibiotics, the development of resistance in bacterial cells toward these nanomaterials is more challenging due to their multiple mechanisms of action. Inorganic nanomaterials primarily eliminate invading bacteria by generating reactive oxygen species (ROS), since high ROS levels can overwhelm the bacteria's antioxidant defence mechanisms, causing oxidative damage to essential cellular components such as enzymes, proteins, DNA, and lipids. Besides ROS generation, inorganic nanomaterials employ additional bactericidal mechanisms, including disrupting the cell wall, damaging chromosomes and DNA, and interfering with the metabolic activities of microorganisms.[
41,
42] Priyanka P. Patil et al.[
43,
44] developed nanocomposite films made of SF-polyvinyl alcohol embedded with ZnO NPs for use as a dressing material.
In vitro evaluation showed that these films exhibited antimicrobial activity against both model Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. In addition, the zone of inhibition (ZOI) increased with higher ZnO nanoparticle content in the composite films (
Figure 2). Silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) are also a type nanoparticle that has attracted considerable attention due to their excellent electrical conductivity, remarkable chemical stability, and powerful catalytic and antibacterial properties. Smita Patil et al.[
45] reported the development of antibacterial SF films containing
in situ synthesized AgNPs with antimicrobial properties and activity against both sessile and planktonic
S. aureus as well as against biofilm formation of antibiotic resistant
E.coli. In addition, also AuNPs functionalized with 4,6-diamino-2-pyrimidinethiol (DAPT) were combined with fibroin to prepare films that demonstrated excellent antibacterial capabilities for wound healing applications.[
46]
Particularly relevant is the use of a natural compound such as honey as an antimicrobial agent. Honey is a concentrated, viscous solution of floral sugars, proteins, enzymes, and amino acids derived from the bee crops. Nowadays, there is a more comprehensive scientific understanding of how honey's beneficial properties facilitate wound healing and regeneration. Specifically, the well-documented antibacterial property can vary across different types of honeys and it is influenced by various factors working either singularly or synergistically.[
47] In most honeys it can be attributed to the action of the endogenous enzyme glucose oxidase from the bee's crop. This enzyme slowly breaks down glucose into gluconic acid, lowering the pH of honey and producing hydrogen peroxide, which sterilizes the wound and stimulates vascular endothelial growth factor production.[
48,
49,
50] In the study conducted by Monika Rajput and colleagues[
51] self-standing patterned and flat SF membranes containing honey were fabricated. It was observed that honey altered the physical properties of the membranes, specifically, its hydrophilic nature enhanced their wettability and water absorption capacity, resulting in increased swelling. This high degree of swelling indicates the membranes' potential to absorb nutrients from the surrounding media, which can nourish the cells and promote favourable cell adhesion and proliferation. Indeed, biocompatibility assay suggested that incorporation of honey into SF membranes increased the adherence, proliferation and viability of cells at higher honey concentrations and also enhances cell–cell and cell–matrix interaction. Furthermore, honey serves as a nutritional factor, as it is gradually released from the membranes into the surrounding environment, providing nourishment to the cells. Another research study conducted by N. Sukumar et al.[
52] focused on combining SF with honey and with the epidermal growth factor (rhEGF) in order to promote the process of healing of diabetic wounds. The authors demonstrated once more that honey exhibits an extraordinary ability to promote the wound-healing process and great antimicrobial activity against
E. coli and
Staphylococcus epidermidis (S. epidermidis).
An alternative approach to achieve films with antibacterial properties is combining different antimicrobial natural polymers. For example, in the work of P. Ganesan et al.,[
8] honey was combined with SF, wool Ker, and chitosan (CS) to produce, using a casting technique, curative films able of acting as drug-releasing agents on the wound surface and protecting the wound from secondary bacterial infection. Indeed, all the different dressings demonstrated good antimicrobial activity against both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria such as S
taphylococcus aureus and
Escherichia coli. In the work of Meghann Rosewald et al.,[
53] chitosan was used alongside cellulose to produce Ker composites. These materials have demonstrated the ability to maintain antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties provided by the Ker and CS components. Furthermore, the composites have exhibited enhanced mechanical properties, including a significant increase in tensile strength, which allows them to be utilized in a broader range of practical and general applications. Additionally, Chieu D. Tran et al.[
54] evaluated whether composites made of Ker, cellulose, and/or CS could encapsulate and control the release of a broad-spectrum antibiotic as ciprofloxacin (CPX). All three biopolymers were able of encapsulating the drug and subsequently releasing it at different rates, depending on the composition of the single, two, or three component systems. Particularly, it was found that the drug release rate can be controlled and adjusted at any desired rate by carefully selecting the appropriate concentration of Ker in the composite materials. This is due to keratin's structurally denser nature, in contrast with the more porous structure of cellulose and chitosan, which leads to a much faster drug release rate from those materials. By combining all three components into a composite, it is possible to integrate their respective properties and create a high-performance dressing that can effectively heal wounds, kill bacteria, and deliver drugs for the treatment of chronic ulcerous wounds in diabetic patients.
Polymeric scaffolds can be functionalized also by incorporating various phenolic compounds derived from diverse plant extracts, which have been reported to be used in the development of bactericidal protein based biomaterials.[
55]
Additionally, antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), which are produced by bacteria, insects, plants, invertebrates, and vertebrates, are gaining attention as alternatives to traditional antibiotics. To decrease their cytotoxicity and improve their antimicrobial stability, AMPs are often immobilized on the surfaces of specific materials. SF and Ker are considered some of the most promising candidates for surface functionalization due to their rich variety of active groups, such as carboxyl, hydroxyl, and amine. For example R. Si et al.,[
56] developed a novel wound dressing by immobilizing the marine-derived antimicrobial peptide actinomycin X2 onto SF fibers and subsequently developing a versatile SF film (ASF) with intrinsic antibacterial and angiogenic properties.
In vivo experiments on bacterially infected wound healing showed that the antimicrobial films (AMFs) prevented wound inflammation, facilitated repair, and enhanced the wound microenvironment, demonstrating that ASF film could be a promising candidate for skin wound healing (
Figure 3).
Another promising alternative to conventional antibiotic-based therapy is antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (APDT). This approach combines the use of visible light, photosensitizers, and oxygen to generate singlet oxygen and other reactive oxygen species, which can effectively kill bacteria. Aluigi et al.[
57]selected methylene blue, a highly effective antimicrobial photosensitizer, to dope Ker films and create new biodegradable, biocompatible materials for tissue engineering and wound healing. It was demonstrated that these materials can exert antimicrobial photodynamic activity when exposed to visible light (
Figure 4).
3.2. Films with Antioxidant Function
Over the past few decades, by combining knowledge from biomaterials and skin tissue regeneration, researchers have developed intelligent wound dressings with antioxidant properties that regulate reactive oxygen species (ROS) and facilitate skin tissue recovery. These biomaterials have emerged as innovative solutions for medical applications, particularly in treating skin injuries. While physiological levels of ROS are beneficial for timely wound healing, excessive production can negatively impact the healing process. Under non-physiological conditions, the persistent overproduction of ROS, which is not adequately balanced by the body's antioxidant defenses, results in uncontrolled oxidative stress and has been linked to impaired healing in chronic, non-healing wounds.[
58,
59]
Antioxidant compounds can help prevent or inhibit oxidation by stabilizing, deactivating, or scavenging free radicals that can damage cells. Therefore, integrating antioxidants into polymeric biomaterials, which typically have limited radical-scavenging abilities, offers a promising strategy to inhibit molecular oxidation and restore normal physiological levels of reactive oxygen species. Furthermore, this approach aims to improve the efficiency of these antioxidants, which often suffer from low bioavailability and bioactivity when directly administered onto the wound.[
60] These compounds are present in various plants and may accelerate wound healing, as demonstrated in a study conducted by Tingting Luo et al.[
61] In this study, three natural antioxidants, vitamin C (VC), epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), and curcumin, were physically incorporated into three types of silk films. The strong interaction between SF and the antioxidants not only preserved the structural integrity of the films but also stabilized the antioxidants, maintaining their activity for up to 14 days at 37 and 45 °C, compared to controls with free antioxidants in solution.
In this scenario, numerous studies have investigated the feasibility of developing various topical formulations loaded with curcumin, to overcome the poor bioavailability observed when this compound is directly applied to wound sites.[
62] The wound healing potential of this natural polyphenolic molecule is primarily attributed to its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. This is due to its ability to position itself within the cell membrane and act as a potent scavenger of various reactive oxygen species, including hydroxyl radicals and nitrogen dioxide radicals.[
63,
64] Moreover, curcumin exhibits strong antimicrobial properties,[
65] both on its own and in synergy with antibiotics, thereby protecting wound tissue from bacterial infections. Curcumin also promotes cell proliferation, aiding in the repair and reconstruction of damaged tissue.[
66] Thus, given the proven ability of this compound to effectively accelerate the wound healing process by targeting various stages of the natural wound healing cascade, developing a curcumin-based wound dressing represents a promising strategy to optimize the targeted delivery and therapeutic benefits of this compound for skin wounds.[
62,
67] In this contest, Zhang and co-workers[
32] prepared sustained-release film by blending curcumin with SF using the solution casting method (
Figure 5). The results of this study indicate that the curcumin-loaded SF film is highly suitable for wound healing applications. It not only creates a moist environment for wound areas but also demonstrates effective sustained-release performance and impressive antibacterial activity against
S. aureus, thereby protecting the wound from microbial invasion. Furthermore, in the study of Chunmei Li et al.[
68] it is reported that curcumin, when physically bound to SF films, significantly enhanced the proliferation and differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells when compared to free curcumin (in monomer or aggregate form) in cell culture medium.
Recently, our research[
69] has demonstrated that bioactive and eco-sustainable films made by combining SF with antioxidant compounds extracted from pomegranate waste have a high capacity to reduce oxidative stress in cells. The transparent and flexible films have shown biocompatibility with the main skin cells (keratinocytes and fibroblasts) and were able to release bioactive compounds in a controlled manner, based on Fickian diffusion.
An important cause of ROS generation is the photochemical interaction of UVA radiation with biological materials, specifically with intracellular chromophores. To address this issue, Binbing Chen et al.[
70] demonstrated that incorporating wool Ker into silk sericin films led to a microstructural transformation and a reinforcement of the molecular network, which conferred the films an improved UV absorption and excellent anti-UV light property. It must also be considered that the exposure to oxidizing agents like UVA or certain pathological conditions can severely disrupt intracellular iron homeostasis, which plays a key role in both oxidative stress and photo-induced skin damage.[
71,
72] In this regard, Anastasia Anceschi et al.[
73] developed novel bioactive films capable of binding iron in chronic wounds. These films were created by casting an aqueous solution of wool-derived keratosis (the soluble fraction of keratin), and their stability and water insolubility were increased through a thermal cross-link treatment. The utility of these dressings stems not only from their iron-binding ability, but also from their capacity to swell and remove exudate from the wounds.
3.3. Films with Growth Factors
Growth factors are essential signaling molecules that play a key role in wound healing by enhancing wound closure, promoting the formation of granulation tissue, and facilitating the development of new blood vessels. Although the body naturally produces various growth factors, certain pathological conditions, like diabetes, which is marked by impaired microcirculation, hinder the effective delivery of these bioactive compounds needed for chronic wound healing. This results in the development of chronic non-healing wounds where re-epithelialization fails to occur. Consequently, it is generally believed that providing a continuous supply of growth factors to the localized wound area through a slow-release drug delivery system would be advantageous for chronic wound therapy and for the clinical applications of tissue engineering.[
74] However, the delivery of these compounds is challenging, as many exhibit a relatively short half-life
in vivo, presumably due to enzymatic degradation within the wound bed. For this reason, to maintain an effective concentration of these growth factors, a formulation combining them with a suitable protein-based drug delivery system is recommended. In particular, SF has demonstrated excellent biocompatibility as a delivery platform, and functionalization of different SF forms with growth factors provides a synergistic approach to improve wound healing. This combination takes advantage of both the structural support provided by the SF matrices and their capability to extend the half-life of the growth factors complexed with them, as well as their biological activity. This approach can accelerate the healing process by promoting tissue regeneration and reducing healing time.
A study conducted by Eun Seok Gil et al., reports on the incorporation of epidermal growth factor and silver sulfadiazine, a widely used topical antimicrobial agent for preventing and treating wound infections, into silk biomaterials to assess their impact on wound healing.[
75] Three types of silk biomaterials (porous films, electrospun mats, and non-porous silk films) were developed using two different drug functionalization techniques to assess the influence of silk material architecture and drug functionalization on wound healing. The study showed that silk biomaterials, likely due to their natural biocompatibility, ability to incorporate growth factors, controlled release properties, and potential to form porous structures, were able to improve the wound healing process. Additionally, Meng-Jin Lin et al. investigated the potential benefits of locally administering and sustaining the release of insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) from a SF film for patients with chronic, hard-to-heal wounds.[
76] In fact IGF-1 is a well-known stimulator of keratinocyte growth and migration, which are crucial characteristics for the re-epithelialization of wounds. SF films demonstrated an excellent ability to deliver IGF-1, moreover, the cell growth-promoting activity of IGF-1 was maintained even after it is complexed with the SF films, which also significantly prolong its half-life (
Figure 6).
In addition to the direct incorporation, research has recently moved toward other methods that provide significant supply of silk material containing growth factors, using genetic engineering technology, as investigated in the study of Sheng-Lan Wang et al.[
77] Specifically, advancements in transgenic technology have enabled silkworms to express human growth factors (FGF, TGF-β1, PDGF, VEGF, and EGF) within their silk glands, allowing them to synthesize genetically engineered cocoons that can be processed into a range of functionalized silk-based biomaterials.
On the other hand, literature data suggest that keratin-based products have a stimulatory beneficial effect on their own, accelerating wound healing particularly in terms of re-epithelialization. This is achieved by enhancing keratinocytes migration and the production of basement membrane proteins, such as types IV and VII collagens.[
78]
3.4. Films with Anti-Inflammatory
While inflammatory responses by immune cells are essential for protecting against infections, excessive inflammation can be harmful. Macrophages, in particular, play a critical role in tissue injury and repair, significantly affecting the dynamics of wound healing. Their polarization into either an inflammatory (M1) or anti-inflammatory (M2) phenotype is crucial for pathogen clearance and promoting wound repair. However, chronic activation of either macrophage type has been linked to various diseases, highlighting the need for localized treatments to address chronic macrophage activation.
In this context, the design of wound dressings is particularly important. For example Doudou Hu et al. demonstrated that the physical properties of medical materials, especially their surface topography, play a crucial role in modulating intracellular signaling in macrophages.[
79] In fact, SF films with varying and tunable surface roughness, produced by slow-drying casting and salting out techniques, were able to induce differential macrophage polarization (
Figure 7). This established a direct connection between the specific surface morphology of the SF films and the macrophage response, subsequently influencing tissue regeneration. Mechanically, the rough surface of SF film enabled a positively-curved membrane of macrophages, promoting the internalization and degradation of integrin αV and thus inhibiting the integrin-NF-κB signaling pathway. While SF film with low roughness activates the integrin-NF-κB signaling pathway. Another approach to control the polarization of macrophage and the biological response, optimizing regenerative needs while reducing inflammatory pathways, was shown in a study of Andrew R.D. Reeves et al.[
80] The authors used silk protein to fabricate biopolymer films that released either IFN-γ or IL-4 to modulate macrophage polarization. By varying the duration of the films' exposure to water vapor, they were able to tune the solubility of the SF films and regulate their β-sheet content, enabling a short-term release of the respective cytokine. The released IFN-γ or IL-4 induced polarization of THP-1-derived macrophages into the M1 or M2 phenotypes, respectively.
Furthermore, to modulate the inflammatory process, SF films can be designed as a delivery system for neurotensin (NT), a neuropeptide that acts as an inflammatory modulator in wound healing but is easily metabolized in biological environments.[
81] Incorporating neurotensin into a SF film could be beneficial, as the film can protect the neuropeptide from degradation and sustain its release, prolonging its therapeutic effects. Notably, NT has been shown to effectively reduce the inflammatory status of wound and promote fibroblast migration to the wound site, ultimately facilitating the expression of extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins essential for skin repair.[
82]The study by Camila Nunes Lemos et al.[
83] developed SF films that successfully protected the peptide from rapid degradation, allowing it to have the desired effect. Additionally, the application of iontophoresis in the reported films promoted a rapid release of NT, ensuring its immediate availability for action and providing a high concentration of the drug in the wound environment at the beginning of the treatment.
Another approach to address this issue is to formulate drug-loaded films capable of managing inflammation and pain. For instance, our research [
84] described the development of transparent and free standing organic-inorganic hybrid films for drug delivery purpose. Specifically, the researchers created a matrix of Ker extracted from wool filled with ZnAl hydrotalcites (HTlc) nanoparticles that had intercalated diclofenac, member of the non-steroidal anti-inflammatory (NSAID) group of drug (
Figure 8). Previous studies have also shown that diclofenac-incorporated formulations have antimicrobial activity, to some extent, against various bacterial strains.[
85,
86,
87] The composite films were characterized and evaluated
in vitro as drug delivery systems, since the incorporation of the anionic drug into the lamellar structure of the hydrotalcites enabled its protection and controlled release from the polymer matrix.
The work of Li Cui et al.[
88] also involved the preparation of Ker films loaded with diclofenac. In order to maintain the mechanical strength and to improve the chemical stability of the materials, Ker was cross-linked with transglutaminase (TGase). In fact, this treatment led to the formation of new covalent bonds between the keratin proteins, resulting in increased tensile strength of the films, along with decreased elongation at break and reduced solubility in various solvents. Furthermore, the enzyme treatment resulted in a lower drug release rate from the films.
Films with antimicrobial function
|
Mechanism of action |
REF |
Antibiotics |
Antimicrobial activity |
[40] |
Metal and metal oxide nanoparticles /inorganic nanomaterials |
Avoid bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation through ROS generation |
[41,42,43,44,45,46,89,90,91] |
Honey |
Sterilization Foster endothelial growth |
[47,48,49,50,51,52,92,93,94,95] |
Chitosan |
Antimicrobial and drug release agent |
[8,53,54,96] |
Phenolic compounds from plant extracts |
Inhibit microbial proliferation |
[55] |
Antimicrobial peptides |
Antibacterial Angiogenic |
[56,97] |
Photodynamic therapy |
Antimicrobial through ROS generation |
[57] |
Films with antioxidant function
|
Mechanism of action |
REF |
Vitamin C (VC), epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), and curcumin |
Preservative Stabilizing |
[61] |
Curcumin |
PreservativeStabilizing ROS scavenging Enhancing cellular proliferation and differentiation |
[22,62,63,64,65,66,67,68,98] |
Pomegranate extract |
Drug release agent Reducing oxidative stress in cells |
[69] |
Chromophore |
UV absorption |
[70] |
Keratoses |
Iron-binding ability |
[73] |
Growth factors
|
Mechanism of action |
REF |
EGF |
Increase keratinocyte proliferation and migration |
[75] |
IGF-1 |
Activation of the IGF1R pathway |
[76,99,100] |
Transgenic technology |
Silkworm cocoons genetically engineered to produce human growth factors |
[77] |
Keratin-based products |
Enhancing keratinocyte migration and collagen production |
[78] |
Films with anti-inflammatory function
|
Mechanism of action |
REF |
Modulation of films’ surface topography |
Inducing differential macrophage polarization |
[79] |
Cytokines IFN-γ and IL-4 |
Modulating macrophage polarization |
[80] |
Neurotensin |
Reducing the inflammatory status Promoting fibroblast migration |
[82,83] |
ZnAl HTIc-DIK |
COX-1 and COX-2 inhibition Antimicrobial activity |
[84,85,86,87] |
DIK |
COX-1 and COX-2 inhibition Antimicrobial activity |
[88] |