Research on healthy ageing shows that lifespan reductions are often caused by mitochondrial dysfunction. Thus, it is very interesting that the deletion of mitochondrial matrix peptidase LonP1 was observed to abolish embryogenesis, while deletion of the mitochondrial matrix peptidase ClpP prolonged survival. To unveil the targets of each enzyme, we documented the global proteome of LonP1^+/- mouse embryonal fibroblasts (MEF), for comparison with ClpP^-/- depletion. Proteomic profiles of LonP1^+/- MEF generated by label-free mass spectrometry were further processed with the STRING webserver Heidelberg for protein interactions. ClpP was previously reported to degrade Eral1 as a chaperone involved in mitoribosome assembly, so ClpP deficiency triggers accumulation of mitoribosomal subunits and inefficient translation. LonP1^+/- MEF also showed Eral1 accumulation, but no systematic effect on mitoribosomal subunits. In contrast to ClpP^-/- profiles, several components of the respiratory complex I membrane arm were accumulated, whereas the upregulation of numerous innate immune defense components was similar. Overall, LonP1 as opposed to ClpP appears to have no effect on translational machinery, instead it shows enhanced respiratory dysfunction; this agrees with reports on the human CODAS syndrome caused by LonP1 mutations.