Introduction
These days, one of the most important topics in the nutrition of sports horses is how to enhance the energy level in the feeding ration. Grains can be used in the ration to provide energy over the animal's maintenance level, but the consumption of grains in the ration as an energy source has limitations [
1]. Supplying excess energy through a high percentage of grains such as barley or corn in concentrate exposes the animal to dangerous metabolic diseases such as colic, laminitis, and gastrointestinal ulcers that will harm the animal's health and sport activities [
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14].
In numerous surveys, it has proposed that fat supplements in concentrate, using to provide excess energy, for the maintenance of sports horses [
9,
8,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21] or workhorses and ponies [
22,
23,
24,
25,
26] should be consumed. By adding a fat supplement to the diet, the energy level of the ration is concentrated and the animal receives required energy through a smaller meal [
18,
27,
28,
29,
30], and there is no necessity to consume high levels of forage or grains to meet the animal's energy needs, and this improves sports horses’ performance [
21,
25,
31]. Consuming a fat source in the horse nutrition increases glycogen levels in skeletal muscles and liver [
21,
25,
26,
32] that stored glycogen will be used throughout competitions or activities. In fact, intense exercise [
25,
33,
34,
35], and the severe reduction of glycogen resources lead to fatigue and will have detrimental impacts on horses’ performance [
36]. Therefore, it is recommended to add this form of fat supplement (oil) to the concentrate like soybean oil and flaxseed oil, which are known excellent sources of omega-3 [
4,
37].
The consumption of fat supplements at the optimal level, especially supplements rich in omega-3 such as flaxseed oil and fish oil, in addition to providing fat-soluble vitamins, reducing food dust, making the body coat shiny, and improving hair growth in horses [
18], can improve clotting parameters, support immune function, and enhance fertility rate [
2,
38], influence some health criteria including the production of prostaglandins and leukocytes that have anti-inflammatory properties and can improve inflammatory responses by increasing resistance to the membrane of red blood cells affecting the osmotic pressure and reduce the blood cortisol level during stress [
16,
17,
39,
40,
41,
42,
43,
44,
45].
Based on some studies’ results, adding fat supplements in the form of oil to the daily feed of horses increased feed intake. Therefore, it is assumed that adding oil to feed improves palatability [
4]. Melo et al. [
46] showed that consuming oils rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids increases their antioxidant capacity and subsequently improves horses’ performance and also has shown n-3 PUFA have the potential to mitigate the pain and inflammation caused by arthritis, as well as possibly slowing joint degradation [
47,
48,
49]. The advantage of flaxseed oil over other vegetable oils is due to its high content of omega-3, especially polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA), especially alpha-linolenic acid (ALA) [
4,
50,
51]. In addition, flaxseed oil has a very favorable omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, which does not exceed the ratio of 2:1 [
52]. Flaxseed oil also reduces the TC/HDL ratio, which is an excellent index for reducing the risk of the arteriosclerosis and other cardiovascular disorders [
53]. Enriching the diet with omega-3, for example using flaxseed or flaxseed oil, may improve the blood lipid profile playing an vital role in preventing heart diseases [
51,
54] and increase tissue sensitivity to insulin [
17,
55]. Flaxseed or flaxseed oil has also been used as a laxative [
56], treatment of inflammation [
2], and allergic skin diseases [
57]. Flaxseed oil and marine fatty acids supplementation decrease platelet aggregation in different species [
58,
59].
Horses have a low capability to elongate fatty acids, and this issue is crucial in response to inflammatory activities. There are speculations about flaxseed that, as a source of long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, may reduce the symptoms of laminitis by inhibiting inflammatory mediators [
39]. Moreover, in a study due to the consumption of sesame oil, the concentration of red blood cells, hemoglobin and hematocrit increased following the improvement of the level of omega-3 in the blood [
60]. Therefore, there are several reasons for horse breeders to be attracted in using different flaxseed products in horse ration [
15].
The major objective of this study was to investigate the difference between two sources of flaxseed calcium fat powder and flaxseed oil added in the amount of 10% (100 grams per 1 kg of concentrate) per day on feed intake, nutrients digestibility, and evaluate the possible improvement of inflammatory responses due to the consumption of flaxseed as a source of omega-3 fatty acids and its effects on blood metabolites in horses.
Materials and Methods
This study was implemented at Azmoun riding club located on the east side of Azadi sport comlex in Tehran, Iran from August to November 2018. Six adult, medium-sized, castrated Turkmen stallions were allocated to this study. The horses had no movement or health problems and were kept in individual boxes with standard dimensions. All boxes were equipped with automatic water trough and separated mangers. To equalize the initial conditions between experimental treatments, horses were randomly assigned to each treatment in each period.
The bed of each box was filled with wood chips and the feces collected in the box bed of each horse were cleaned daily, and the entire bed cover was changed weekly. Throughout the project, the horses had free access to water and salt block. To neutralize exercise effect on digestibility trait, horses’ exercise was equalized [
62,
63]. In this way, the training schedule of all 6 horses throughout the week consisted of one day of rest, one day of lunge for 15 minutes of trotting, and the remaining five days the horses walked for 10 minutes, trotted for 20 minutes, and slow trotting for 10 minutes by the rider for a total of 40 minutes in the mange.
In the Azmoun riding club, the horses’ daily feeding program included 3 meals of hay, the first meal at 5:30 am, 1:30 pm, and 8:30 pm. To prevent respiratory issues and to reduce the dust from dry forage, in all meals, hay was first completely wet and then given to the horses. All horses were given 4 kg of hay in the morning and evening meals and 2.5 kg of hay in the noon meal (10.5 kg in total).
The composition of the concentrate consumed to feed the horses had minor changes throughout the study. For this reason, at the end of each period, samples were taken from the consumed concentrate (approximate analysis data is given in
Table 1). The concentrates were completely pelleted and nutty, and 1 kg was provided to the horses 1 hour prior to the midday hay meal, at 12 to 12:30.
Horses were randomly assigned to each of the experimental treatments in every period (each treatment 6 repetitions, 3 periods). The design was carried out in the form of a rotating design in 3 periods, and each treatment was repeated twice in each period, and at the end of the study, all 6 horses had fed experimental treatments. The experimental treatments included C) Omega-3-free supplement (control treatment), P) flaxseed calcium fat powder (Persialin fat powder, Kimiya Danesh Alvand Co., Qom, Iran), and R) flaxseed oil (Persianlin flaxseed oil, Kimiya Danesh Alvand Co., Qom, Iran). The nutritional value and chemical composition of the treatments are given in
Table 2. The experimental treatments were weighed using a digital scale (1 mg accuracy), 100 grams of fat powder and 100 grams of oil were weighed in a special container (containing a spray) and used throughout the survey. Flaxseed oil treatment was sprayed on 1 kg of concentrate and then given to the horses. In addition, the fat powder treatment was completely combined with 1 kg of concentrate and given to the horses 1 hour before consuming hay. In previous research, a 3-week period was considered to investigate the effects of fat supplements on horses’ nutrition, and it has been argued that this period is sufficient for changes in metabolism as a result of dietary changes [
21,
25,
26,
32] and this study was also carried out in a period of three weeks. The treatments containing oil and fat powder were fed for 14 days in each period, and after that, blood and feces samples were obtained at the end of the experimental period. 4 days were allocated for the adaptation process (25 grams on the first day, 50 grams on the second day, 75 grams on the third day, and 100 grams on the fourth day). The horses received 100 grams of experimental treatments from the fourth day for 10 days. At the end of each experimental period, 7 days were considered as experimental free-course to make prepared to initiate the next period, when the horses did not receive the oil or fat powder treatments, and their daily ration only included 11.5 kg of hay plus 1 kg of concentrate.
In each experimental period, the concentrate fed in all treatments was the same, and they were kept in the club's feed warehouse. Horses were kept in individual boxes with mangers. To evaluate the palatability index (Delobel et al. method [
4]), during feeding on the last 4 days of each period, the duration of consumption of 1 kg of concentrate was recorded in experimental treatments.
This study evaluates the digestibility of acid detergent insoluble fiber (ADF), crude protein (CP), ether extract (EE), organic matter (OM), and acid insoluble ash (AIA) in feed and feces samples. To measure ADF, Van Soest method [
64] and the Fibertec 1010 device was used. To measure protein and crude fat Kjeldahl and Soxhlet devices were used respectively, and AIA and organic matter of the samples, was measured based on AOAC method [
65]. Due to the lack of standard protocols for collecting partial feces samples, the method of collecting total feces throughout the last 2 days of each period was selected and performed based on the method suggested by Martin-Rosset et al. [
66]. To achieve this purpose, the beds of individual horse boxes were filled with wood shavings, and in the last 2 days of each period, 24 hours before sampling, the feces in the bed were not cleaned. After the first meal of feeding at 7-8 a.m. from a total of 100 to 200 grams of feces collected from different parts of the box bed, samples were taken. After sampling on the first day, the bed of the boxes was cleaned. On the second day, sampling was done in the same way.
At the end of each period samples of consuming concentrate were taken (500 grams), and a sample of alfalfa was taken at the beginning of the study to represent the alfalfa consumed throughout the entire period. To measure the dry matter percentage at the end of the study, the feed and feces samples were placed in an oven with a temperature of 65°C for 72 hours. Within 2 days after drying, the ration and feces samples were completely mixed and ground with a 1 mm sieve, and AIA was used as an internal marker to calculate the amount the nutrients digestibility. Several studies in horses have shown that the digestibility coefficients obtained by AIA marker are statistically similar to those obtained with total collection [
67,
68,
69,
70].
To evaluate blood metabolites (glucose, albumin, total protein, triglyceride, cholesterol, and blood urea nitrogen), at the beginning of each experimental period before applying experimental treatments (as a covariate factor) and at the end of each period (main record), 2.5 hours after feeding hay at 8 a.m. blood samples, from the jugular vein through vacuum tubes containing EDTA, K3 anticoagulant, were obtained. Obtained blood samples were centrifuged at 3,000 × g for 15 min at 4°C to separate plasma. The plasma was poured into 3 ml-microtubes and preserved at -20°C till biochemical analysis. The plasma samples were analyzed to determine concentrations of glucose (GOD-PAP), albumin (Bromocresol Green method), total protein (TP) (Biuret with sample blank), and blood urea N (BUN) (Berthelot) utilizing commercial kits following the manufacturer’s instructions (Pars Azmoon Co.). The ELISA device (Hiperion, MPR4+, Microplate Reader, Germany) of the Physiology Laboratory of the Department of Animal Sciences, University of Tehran was used to evaluate glucose, albumin, total protein, and BUN, cholesterol, and triglyceride were measured using the optical absorption spectrophotometer of the Nutrition Laboratory of the Animal Science Department.
Discussion
Several studies evaluated the acceptability of oil enriched diets [
21,
72,
73] and compared the palatability of various fats and oils [
18]. Previous research investigated the effect of consumption of different sources of oil including soybean oil [
26], corn oil [
74], and even animal fats [
32,
75] on the palatability of the diet and they had no negative effect on the feed intake. In studies on horses, there are very few reports on the effects of flaxseed oil consumption on palatability. The research results of some researchers showed the negative effect of flaxseed oil, as a source of omega-3, on the palatability of consumed food [
44,
76,
77]. In this study, there was no significant difference between the average of the flaxseed oil treatment and the control group, but the fat powder treatment significantly reduced the palatability. The reduction in feed intake may be due to the calcium salts of fatty acids leading to unpleasant taste, and sometimes a decrease in feed intake has been reported in other animals such as cattle. Delobel et al. [
4] reported an insignificant difference in the palatability of the control and the oil treatment group testing the effect of flaxseed oil supplementation on the feed intake.
After realizing the effect of horse sports activities on the digestibility of the diet's dry matter, the speed of material passing through the intestines, and the fermentation capacity of the microbes at the end of the digestive tract, the researchers conducted various experiments to investigate the effects of horse sports activities such as jumping, endurance and running on nutrients’ digestion and absorption. They conducted surveys for the digestibility of various fat supplements and checked varying levels of their consumption and their effects on the digestibility of other nutrients such as crude fiber, crude protein, etc [
4,
6,
78]. Results of numerous researches indicated that the addition of fat supplements to the diet had no effect on the apparent digestibility of cell wall contents [
79,
80], neutral detergent fibre [
14,
30,
79,
80,
81,
82] or acid-detergent fibre [
79]. However, other researchers reported an increase in apparent digestibility [
4,
6,
83,
84,
85,
86,
87] after the feeding diets containing fat. Improving digestibility in horses leads to a reduction in the risk of metabolic diseases such as colic [
8]. The usage of oil in horses’ ration creates a coating on the surface of the forage, which can increase the speed of passage of materials throughout the digestive system, and as a result, the components of the feed and nutrients are exposed less time for the digestion, and the digestion is incomplete and can cause the difference between the 3 experimental treatments. In this study the effect of the experimental treatments (fat powder and flaxseed oil) was insignificant in any of the investigated digestive traits with each other and comparing the control group. The results of experiments conducted by Meyer et al. [
88] and Jansen et al. [
89] indicated that the use of fat sources in horses’ ration decreased protein digestibility. Based on the results obtained by Markey and Kline [
78] horses consuming the control treatment had greater digestibility of DM, OM, total dietary fiber, and GE than did those fed the supplemental fat treatments (10% hydrogenated fat; or 10% soybean oil). According to Meyer et al. [
88] consuming high amounts of fat in the diet may reduce the apparent digestibility in the small intestine due to the higher endogenous nitrogen flow, which is related to the stimulation of digestive secretions. Delobel et al. [
4] reported that the consumption of 80 grams of flaxseed oil significantly increased the digestibility of dry matter (DM), crude fiber (CF), neutral detergent-insoluble fiber (NDF), and crude fat compared to the control treatment and disagree with the results of the current study. However, there was no significant difference between the control group and the oil treatment group for the digestibility of crude protein (CP) and acid detergent-insoluble fiber (ADF), and it is consistent with the results of the present experiment. Rich et al. [
80] reported that ponies consuming a diet containing 10% blended fat had decreased NDF digestibility compared to the control or those consuming 10% corn oil. In another study ponies consuming diets containing 7.5 or 15% peanut oil had increased NDF digestibility compared to ponies consuming the control diet or those consuming corn oil, animal fat, or blended fat at the same levels, and ponies consuming any one of the fat sources had higher ADF digestibility than the control [
80]. Meyer et al. [
88] observed that increasing the daily fat intake from 0.1 to 1 to 2 grams per kilogram of body weight leads to an increase in pre-ileum fat digestibility. According to previous studies, adding fat supplementation have an insignificant effect on the digestibility of the fibrous part of the feed [
6,
14,
32,
79,
80,
85]. Other studies also reported a decrease in the digestibility of crude fiber, ADF, and NDF [
89,
90,
91]. In another study the addition of 10% animal fat to the diet of exercising horses increased NDF digestibility by 12 to 13 percentage units compared to the control [
87].
Lindberg and Karlsson [
92] found that adding fat to horses’ diets increased apparent ADF digestibility and did not affect total fiber digestibility. In horses, the part of the digestive tract where fermentation occurs is located after the small intestine, which probably explains the difference in digestibility between ruminants and horses [
4]. According to Karlsson et al. [
93] replacing fermentable carbohydrates with fat reduced some of the negative effects of starch on fiber digestion, because research has shown that reducing the amount of starch in the diet improves fiber digestion.
The insignificant difference in ADF digestibility of the diet between the 3 treatments of Persialin flaxseed oil, Persialin fat powder, and the control group is an acceptable result because it shows that the consumption of 100 grams of fat powder or Persialin flaxseed oil in the diet does not reduce the digestibility and it is possible to use both supplements. One of the objectives of this study was to investigate the effects of fat powder comparing flaxseed oil on creating the coating on the forage surface and the effect on the digestibility of diet’s nutrients. The results showed no decrease in ADF digestibility between the two experimental treatments compared to the control group. On the other hand, we assumed that the consumption of flaxseed oil, following the increase in the speed of passage of nutrients through the digestive system, will reduce the digestibility of nutrients compared to the two treatments of fat powder and the control group, and maybe lead to a significant difference in digestibility between the control and fat powder treatments with the flaxseed oil treatment, and the flaxseed oil treatment have lower digestibility than the other two treatments. Another assumption was that following the increase in the passage speed of nutrients throughout the digestive tract, a large part of the undigested starch and flaxseed oil reach the caecum of horses, and by creating an acidic environment in the cecum, causing digestive disorders, and the increase in the passage rate reduces the digestibility of CP, EE, and OM. However, since the digestibility of any of the nutrients does not decrease after consuming flaxseed oil, it can be concluded that a ration with high energy level and omega-3 (fat powder and flaxseed oil) can be consumed in the horse's diet without any problem.
In this study the digestibility of DM and OM were not influenced (P > 0.05) by experimental treatments. These results are similar to findings of other researchers [
32,
80]. Previous studies indicated that adding fat to the horses’ diet increased fat digestion [
6,
14,
28,
30,
79,
80,
81,
85,
86] and the results of this study were not in line with the previous study results. Bush et al.[
6] conducted a survey to evaluate the effects of corn oil (5,10,15%) in horses’ diet on CP digestibility and concluded that in contrast to previous work [
80,
87], there was no effect of fat supplementation on CP digestibility. Delobel et al.[
4] showed that the inclusion of flaxseed oil in the concentrate improved the EE digestibility up to 83.7% as opposed to 57.3% for the control ration.
The analysis of blood metabolites in horses is a useful measure to evaluate the health and well-being, nutritional requirements, and appropriateness for selecting the type of activity [
94]. The concentration of blood metabolites is also an efficient tool to show feed efficiency, because it indicates the nutritional conditions of animals [
95,
96]. Most of the results pertain to the analysis of blood metabolites in this study were in the range of the results of the sources specific to horses [
97,
98], which indicated optimal health conditions in them.
Consuming more daily feed and higher digestibility of consumed feed can increase blood glucose concentration [
100]. The consumption of fat supplemented diet (up to 12%) enhances skeletal muscle stores in horses by as much as 51% [
25,
26,
32]. Glycogen provides a significant energy substrate for skeletal muscles through exercise activity, with the amount of glycogen utilization increasing exponentially as exercise intensity increases [
34,
35]. Therefore, a fat-added diet may improve exercise performance through insuring that sufficient glycogen stores are provided and are used to accommodate the elevated glycogen demands occurring during exercise [
21].
There were 2 hypotheses about serum glucose concentration:
1) The consumption of a high omega-3 fat supplement increases insulin sensitivity after feeding omega-3 in horses, and after consuming food blood glucose returns to normal level (close to fasting blood glucose) faster, following that blood glucose decreases compared to the control group.
2) On the other hand, we expected that due to the body use of fat as a source of energy at rest, the glucose absorbed from the food will not be absorbed by the cells and will remain in the bloodstream, causing an increase in blood glucose in the experimental groups compared to the control group.
Similar to the study by Hucko et al. [
101] the experimental groups, fed omega-3 supplements for 4 weeks, had higher blood glucose than the control group. The results of the study by Harkins et al. [
21] indicated that following the consumption of fat in the diet of racing horses, the consumed glucose is stored in the form of glycogen in the muscle tissue, and the blood plasma glucose level increases in the resting case. However, contrary to these two hypotheses, no significant difference was observed between the treatments of fat powder and flaxseed oil on blood glucose, and the treatments of fat powder and flaxseed oil did not show significant increase in blood glucose compared to the control group. O’Connor et al. [
17] indicated that plasma glucose concentrations were not different between groups (fed corn oil and fish oil as fat supplements) during exercise but were lower (treatment × time interaction; P < 0.01) for the fish oil group during recovery. Hodge et al. [
102] reported that both mare and foal plasma glucose and insulin concentrations were not affected by experimental treatments including fish oil and fish oil plus soybean oil as fat supplements.
According to the survey conducted by Long et al. [
103], the concentration of albumin has an inverse relationship with the acute phase proteins (APP), and following the increase in serum albumin the concentration of acute phase proteins decreases. Therefore, it can be concluded that the treatment of Persialin flaxseed oil may have reduced the inflammatory response in the first and third periods in horses by increasing the concentration of serum albumin. But in the second period, no significant difference was observed between any of the experimental treatments.
Following the consumption of fat supplements such as fish oil, many studies reported a significant increase in blood serum triglycerides in horses after exercise. This increase following the consumption of fat supplements can be attributed to 2 processes:
1) Increasing the activity of lipoprotein lipase in the oxidation of fatty acids [
104,
105]
2) Activation of the negative regulation effect (in the direction of reduction) on triglyceride synthesis enzymes by fatty acids [
106]
However, throughout this study, no significant difference was observed between the groups consuming fat supplements because the blood samples were taken from the horses at rest and were not examined before and after daily exercise. For this reason, the insignificant difference between the blood triglyceride concentration of horses in the experimental groups, consuming fat supplements, and the control group is a correct result. Hucko et al. [
101] also did not observe any significant difference between the control group and the fat supplement-consuming group following the consumption of omega-3 supplements in sports horses.
In another study conducted by Monteverde et al. [
107] 70 ml of the fat supplement was used and blood samples were taken from horses before and after exercise, the triglyceride level increased significantly after the horses’ sports activities, and also the consumption of this supplement improved the adaptation of the horse's metabolism to the sports activities by increasing the capacity of consuming fatty acids through the horses’ muscle tissues. The results of Sembratowicz et al. [
108] showed that when flaxseed oil was used in the diet of horses instead of soybean oil, the blood triglyceride concentration and the Atherogenic part of LDL cholesterol reduced, and the percentage of HDL-TC increased. Omega-3 found in unsaturated fatty acids can reduce blood plasma triglyceride concentration by preventing their synthesis in the intestinal wall and liver [
109]. Piccione et al. [
110] reported a significant decrease in triglycerides and NEFAs concentration in experimental groups compared with control groups during both training period and after the simulated events following omega-3 fatty acids supplementation. Decreased serum triglycerides are the most consistently reported result of fish oil supplementation in horses [
111].
Hucko et al. [
101] did not observe a significant difference in blood cholesterol levels between the control and the treated group following the daily consumption of 150 gr of omega-3 supplement obtained from Oenothera oil, which is consistent with the results of this study. In horses, LDL constitutes up to 15% of blood lipoproteins [
112]. LDL contains 42% cholesterol, while high-density lipoproteins contain 21% to 36% cholesterol. LDL is produced by liver lipase of low-density lipoproteins and is responsible for transporting cholesterol to peripheral tissue [
113]. O’Connor et al. [
17] noted that serum cholesterol concentrations were lower in horses receiving fish oil (treatment effect; P < 0.05), but serum triglycerides were not affected by treatment.