1. Introduction
Microneedles (MNs) are microstructural tools designed to carry a variety of drugs and agents locally and painlessly into the tissue [
1,
2,
3]. Because of their small size, they do not reach the network of the nerves, and consequently, they cause no pain during insertion [
4,
5,
6,
7,
8]. Developing local drug administration is of great interest to many fields [
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14]. Drug transport modeling can provide significant insights into MN drug delivery and promote this technology to achieve more desirable results [
15].
Based on drug delivery mechanisms, MNs are categorized into solid MN, coated MN, hollow MN, and hydrogel MN (HMN) [
16]. Solid MNs are applied as micro punchers to increase tissue permeability. After punching the skin, the drug will be used in the lotion, gel, or liquid form on the surface of the pierced skin [
17,
18]. Coated MNs are solid MNs that are coated with particular drugs or reagents [
19]. When the coated MN is inserted into the tissue, the coating material absorbs the interstitial fluid (ISF) and then the loaded drug on the coating will be released [
20]. Hollow MNs are miniaturized forms of conventional needles in medical injections [
21]. They are used to deliver liquid reagents. There is another group of MNs fabricated of hydrogel materials in which the drug is embedded [
22]. This type of MNs is the main focus of this study.
In HMNs, the drug is loaded within the MN body, as shown in
Figure 1A. When the MN is inserted into the tissue,
Figure 1B, the MN absorbs the ISF, and the drug is released and penetrates the deeper layer of the tissue,
Figure 1C. Before insertion into the skin, the HMN is solid. When the HMN is inserted into the skin, it adsorbs ISF and becomes a liquid or gel. After that, the drug begins to diffuse inside the HMN and then penetrates through the tissue. After drug delivery, the HMNs are removed from the tissue [
22]. Remaining MN long time in the tissue may cause undesired side effects. So it is crucial to know how much time is required for complete drug diffusion from the MN to the tissue, which is called Total Diffusion Time (TDT) in the present paper. TDT predicts the required time for HMN to be removed from the skin.
We can divide the drug delivery by the HMN into four phases as shown in
Figure 1C: 1) ISF adsorption immediately after insertion into the skin,
Figure 1C-i, 2) ISF interaction with the HMN and changing phase into liquid or gel from the solid form,
Figure 1C-ii, 3) The drug diffusion inside the HMN body,
Figure 1C-iii, and 4) Drug penetration from the HMN boundary to the deeper region of the tissue,
Figure 1C-iv.
Phase 1 and Phase 2 were studied by several researchers experimentally and analytically [
23,
24]. The fourth phase is the same for all types of MNs and was studied more than the other phases in the literature [
15,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29]. Those works investigated drug diffusion within the tissue, and the MN was only simulated as the drug release source. For example, Olatunji et al. [
25] investigated the impact of various geometrical parameters of the MN, such as the tip, base radius, and penetration depth of the MN, on the drug permeability in the skin from a coated MN. Ronnander et al. [
27] studied drug permeation across the skin tissue from a pyramid-shaped microarray fabricated of dissolvable material experimentally and analytically. They incorporated the effect of MN dissolution on the distribution of the drug concentration in the skin in their mathematical model. Zoudania and Soltani [
28] simulated the HMN dissolution in a porous medium. They evaluated the effects of the initial drug concentration and the size of the MNs pitch on the dissolution process and the drug concentration profile in the skin. Castilla-Casadiego et al. [
29] assessed drug diffusion through the cow skin at different MN penetration depths into the skin.
In the previous works, the skin was modeled as the computational domain, phase 4, and the drug diffusion was investigated through the skin where the MN was inserted [
30]. To the best of our knowledge, there is no publication that considers the transport mechanisms inside the MN body, i.e., phase 3 in
Figure 1C-iii. The advancement of microneedle drug delivery technology requires more understanding of the transport mechanisms occurring within the MN body. For HMN it is critical to know how drug diffuses inside the MN body, especially in optimizing controlled drug release systems. Such information also can promote the therapeutic effects of the drug.
In the present work, drug diffusion inside the body of the HMN is simulated. We focus on the third phase of HMN drug delivery, which has received less attention in the literature. Accordingly, a comprehensive 3D model of the tapered MN is developed. Time-dependent drug diffusion inside the HMN is simulated for a given initial loaded drug. The effect of the MN geometrical parameter, such as height, base diameter, and drug diffusion coefficient, on the total diffusion time (TDT) is investigated. Based on the obtained results, a nonlinear relation for predicting the TDT as a function of the MN height and base diameter is developed for the tapered HMN. The obtained data are helpful for the optimal design and fabrication of HMN for controlled drug release systems.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, H.M. and N.K.; methodology, H.M. and N.K.; software, H.M.; validation, H.M.; formal analysis, N.K..; investigation, H.M.; resources, H.M.; data curation, H.M.; writing—original draft preparation, H.M.; writing—review and editing, N.K.; visualization, H.M.; supervision, H.M. and N.K..; project administration, H.M and N.K..; funding acquisition, H.M. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Figure 1.
Drug delivery by the HMN. A) HMN loaded with the drug before insertion into the skin. B) HMN inserted into the skin. C) Drug diffusion process. i) ISF absorption, ii) HMN interaction with ISF. iii) Drug diffusion inside MN. iv) Drug penetration of the skin and diffusion into deep layers.
Figure 1.
Drug delivery by the HMN. A) HMN loaded with the drug before insertion into the skin. B) HMN inserted into the skin. C) Drug diffusion process. i) ISF absorption, ii) HMN interaction with ISF. iii) Drug diffusion inside MN. iv) Drug penetration of the skin and diffusion into deep layers.
Figure 2.
The generated mesh inside the MN. A sample MN with a height of 500 µm and base diameter of 250 µm, is discretized into 34,000 elements using finer mesh in the software.
Figure 2.
The generated mesh inside the MN. A sample MN with a height of 500 µm and base diameter of 250 µm, is discretized into 34,000 elements using finer mesh in the software.
Figure 3.
Drug diffusion inside the tapered MN. The contours of drug concentration in the base plane and the middle slice of the sample MN are shown at different time intervals. The sample MN has a base diameter of 250 µm and a height of 500 µm. The dimensions are in µm. Those parts of the MN with the drug concentration lower than 10% of C0 are shown with the white color boundary. The remaining parts are demonstrated as the legend.
Figure 3.
Drug diffusion inside the tapered MN. The contours of drug concentration in the base plane and the middle slice of the sample MN are shown at different time intervals. The sample MN has a base diameter of 250 µm and a height of 500 µm. The dimensions are in µm. Those parts of the MN with the drug concentration lower than 10% of C0 are shown with the white color boundary. The remaining parts are demonstrated as the legend.
Figure 4.
The height and base diameter reduction of the drug region of the MN. The data is plotted for h and d, which are respectively, the instantaneous height and diameter of the drug region during drug diffusion.
Figure 4.
The height and base diameter reduction of the drug region of the MN. The data is plotted for h and d, which are respectively, the instantaneous height and diameter of the drug region during drug diffusion.
Figure 5.
The ratio of the instantaneous height to base diameter, h/d, versus dimensionless time for two different cases during diffusion. Dimensionless time is defined as the time divided by the TDT. Case one is an MN with d0s=250 µm and h0s= 500 µm, and case two is an MN with d0=500 µm and h0=1000 µm.
Figure 5.
The ratio of the instantaneous height to base diameter, h/d, versus dimensionless time for two different cases during diffusion. Dimensionless time is defined as the time divided by the TDT. Case one is an MN with d0s=250 µm and h0s= 500 µm, and case two is an MN with d0=500 µm and h0=1000 µm.
Figure 6.
Contours of drug diffusion in MN with different aspect ratios. a) Case 1 is an MN with a base diameter of d0s=250 µm and a height of h0s=500 µm. b) Case 2 is an MN with the same base diameter but a height of two times larger (d0=d0s, h0=2h0s), and c) Case 3 is an MN with d0=2d0s, h0=2h0s.
Figure 6.
Contours of drug diffusion in MN with different aspect ratios. a) Case 1 is an MN with a base diameter of d0s=250 µm and a height of h0s=500 µm. b) Case 2 is an MN with the same base diameter but a height of two times larger (d0=d0s, h0=2h0s), and c) Case 3 is an MN with d0=2d0s, h0=2h0s.
Figure 7.
Total diffusion time for the MNs with h0/d0=1,2,3 and 4 for d0/d0s= 0.25 to 2. Here h0 and d0 are the initial height and base diameter of the MN.
Figure 7.
Total diffusion time for the MNs with h0/d0=1,2,3 and 4 for d0/d0s= 0.25 to 2. Here h0 and d0 are the initial height and base diameter of the MN.
Figure 8.
The parameter V/td in which V is the MN volume and td is the TDT. The data are plotted for various h0/d0, and different values of d0/d0s. Here h0 and d0 are the initial height and base diameter of the MN and d0s=250 µm is the initial base diameter of the MN of case 1.
Figure 8.
The parameter V/td in which V is the MN volume and td is the TDT. The data are plotted for various h0/d0, and different values of d0/d0s. Here h0 and d0 are the initial height and base diameter of the MN and d0s=250 µm is the initial base diameter of the MN of case 1.
Figure 9.
The effect of diffusion coefficient on total diffusion time for
is the diffusion coefficient of meloxicam gel in a rat skin [
29].
Figure 9.
The effect of diffusion coefficient on total diffusion time for
is the diffusion coefficient of meloxicam gel in a rat skin [
29].