A trace boron addition, up to 0.1%, provided an effective refinement of the prior
β grains. A mean grain size decreased more than three times. The grain refinement effect of 0.02-0.2% boron is well known for unalloyed Ti [
41], several Ti-based alloys [
16,
42], and Ti-Ni [
43,
44] and Ti-Al [
45,
46,
47] intermetallic alloys. The difference in the grain size between 0.1 and 0.4 wt.% B was insignificant. The boron at the same content of ~0.1% was effective for the grain refinement in the studied Ti-Al-Mo-V alloy. The mechanisms of the B effect for as-cast grain refinement are attributed to the formation of boride particles, which can inhibit grain growth in a
β phase field [
16,
48] or B segregations at the front of solidification due to its extra-low solubility in Ti and distribution coefficient <1 [
48,
49]. In addition, increasing boron content leads to a decrease in the liquidus temperature of the alloys and a narrowing of the solidification range (
Figure 1). This effect should increase the crystallization rate and stimulate nucleation kinetics. A similar grain refinement effect with increasing alloying element content was observed for Al-Mg alloys [
50] and Ni-Cu alloys [
51]. For the studied hypoeutectic alloys, it was demonstrated that the grain refinement effect disappeared at high boron content of 1-2% B. The mechanism of the phenomenon is unclear. With an increase in boron content from 0.1 to 1-2% the fraction of TiB particles significantly increased and, considering the similar mean size of the boride particles, the Zener pinning effect [
25] during cooling in a
β-phase field should be stronger and finer grains should be formed. Meanwhile, grains were coarser at a high borides fraction. Similarly, the effect of segregation of boron at the periphery of
β dendrites during their growth in a liquid phase should be stronger at higher B content. The microstructure and boride morphology suggested the same origin of the TiB phase precipitation via eutectic transformation for 0.1%B and 1-2%B. A similar B concentration in eutectic point is observed for Ti-B alloys [
30] and slightly smaller ~1.6%B for Ti-6Al-4V-B alloys [
32]. The solidification range decreases with the increase of boron from 0.1 to 2% and became narrow for the eutectic concentration of ~2%B. Thus, the nature of the degradation of grain refinement effect for high-boron hypoeutectic alloys is unclear and requires explanations and further investigations. The observed phenomenon also suggests that further clarification of the grain refinement mechanism for prior
β-grains via trace boron additions is required. The possible explanation is as follows. First, considering the widely acceptable constitutional supercooling effect, trace boron addition refines the
β-phase dendrites, and the change of the crystal growth type from dendritic to eutectic bicrystal with colonies of two phases eliminates this effect. At a high boron content and a high fraction of
β phase of eutectic origin, the effect disappeared due to extra-rapid simultaneous growth of TiB and
β colonies. At minor concentrations, boron atoms in the liquid may stimulate the nucleation of the
β phase due to a decrease of the liquid–solid interphase energy or a decrease in the critical size of nuclei due to B atomic segregations [
16,
42]. A segregation effect is the most pronounced at the minor content of alloying element or impurity and the distribution of the elements became more homogeneous at its high content [
16]. Second, the widely accepted theory for grain refinement during solidification for various alloys is still the inoculation effect, e.g. Ti with B in Al [
52], Zr in Mg, or Al [
53]. This mechanism seems impossible for hypoeutectic Ti-B alloys when
β-phase grains are solidified before the eutectic-originated TiB phase [
54]. Meanwhile, the ingots of the studied alloys were re-melted five times, and for low-boron alloys with a high liquidus temperature, high-temperature borides may incompletely dissolute during the re-melting process and provide a heterogeneous nucleation effect. This effect has been noted in [
23] as Larson’s theory. At a high fraction of Ti+TiB eutectic, TiB colonies rapidly dissolute due to a short-range diffusion and narrow solidification range, smaller liquidus temperature with a higher overheating degree. Third, for low-boron alloys, the precipitation of primary B-induced metastable phases due to non-equilibria solidification or other unconsidered phases with interstitial impurities in a liquid phase may provide heterogeneous nucleation of the
β-phase during solidification of the studied alloy. Even a small fraction of such phases is enough to stimulate inoculation. The formation of the thermodynamically stable borides simplifies in the high-boron 1B and 2B alloys and no inoculation effect was observed.
Trace boron alloying also significantly changed the as-annealed microstructure of the thermomechanical processed alloys. The B-free alloy demonstrated an inhomogeneous structure with elongated and equiaxed grains and a high fraction of LAGBs. Alloying with 0.1%B provided a globular microstructure in the alloy and twice decreased LAGB fraction. A similar effect was found due to alloying of Ti-Al-Mo-V alloy by both Fe and B [
39]. Thus, boron plays a key role in the acceleration of the recrystallization and further globularization of the grains. These results are consistent with [
55] indicating that TiB particles accelerate the microstructure globularization due to particle stimulation nucleation of the α phase [
56]. The B atomic segregations at the
α/β interfaces, which were recently found in [
16], also may facilitate recrystallization and globularization of the microstructure during annealing. As the result, the reference 0B alloy, which was similar to conventional Ti-4Al-1V-3Mo alloy [
36,
38], exhibited higher flow stress and a stronger softening than alloys with 0.01-0.1% B. The formation of equiaxed grains with high-angle grain or interphase boundaries at the initial stage of deformation facilitated grain boundary sliding and decreased flow stress during superplastic deformation [
57]. The boron influence on the deformation behavior was significant at a low deformation temperature of 775 °C (
Figure 8 d,e). Thus, alloying with trace boron is an effective strategy to improve the superplasticity of Ti-based alloys at low temperatures, which is of high practical importance for the superplastic forming process. Along with this, the trace B addition decreased the post-forming yield strength of the alloys owing to a higher recrystallized fraction and larger mean grain size than B-free alloy.
Due to a high fraction of borides, an increase in B content to 1% increases room temperature strength but weakens superplastic properties and decreases ductility at both elevated and room temperatures. The same influence of boron on the room temperature properties was observed for Ti-6Al-4V alloy [
58]. Authors of [
15,
59] observed an increased strength but decreased ductility and fracture toughness for the alloys with 0.4-2%B. To increase ductility and toughness the morphology of borides should be changed from whiskers to spherical shapes. Notably, that thermo-mechanical treatment of the alloy with 2%B provided refinement of TiB particles during high-temperature deformation and contributed to the formation of more compact particles. Particle refinement may be the result of both mechanical breaking [
60,
61] and fragmentation and spheroidization processes during hot deformation at an elevated temperature of 900 °C. The same processes occur during the spheroidization of cementite in steel [
62,
63] or intermetallic particles in aluminum-based alloys [
64,
65]. Despite the size of about 1 µm, the TiB particles induced a drop in ductility and led to an embrittlement effect in 2%B alloy. Meanwhile, the alloy with 1%B demonstrated an acceptable combination of high-temperature superplasticity at 875 °C and a high room-temperature tensile strength. To avoid embrittlement, the high boron alloys alloy the sheet processing technologies should be focused on the morphology of borides.