This section may be divided by subheadings. It should provide a concise and precise description of the experimental results, their interpretation as well as the experimental conclusions that can be drawn.
3.1. Structure and stability
The monolayer
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te) can be constructed from
-AX (A=Pb, Sn and X=S, Se, Te) monolayer by replacing one layer of chalcogen Pb/Sn atoms with another layer of chalcogen Sn/Pb atoms in the middle side, showing a hexagonal lattice structure with a
space group (
Figure 1). The calculated lattice constants of
-PbSnS
,
-PbSnSe
, and
-PbSnTe
are a = b = 3.96 Å, 4.11 Å, and 4.37 Å, respectively. The specific crystal structure parameters are shown in
Table 1.
We verified the structure stability of monolayer
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te).
Figure 2(a-c) shows the phonon dispersion curve of
-PbSnX
. Each unit cell of the
-PbSnX
monolayer has 4 atoms, with 3 acoustic and 9 optical branches. The phonon frequencies of the
-PbSnX
monolayer are all positive, indicating the dynamic stability of the
-PbSnX
monolayer. They all have very low phonon frequencies and lead to a decrease in their phonon frequencies as the atomic mass of sulfur group elements increases. More interestingly, an apparent coupling occurs between optical and acoustic phonon modes in
-PbSnX
monolayers, which might lead to a low lattice thermal conductivity because of the anharmonic scattering. Moreover, we used ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations to determine the stability of
-PbSnX
at 900 K. The simulation results of AIMD are shown in
Figure 2(d-f). The total energy is almost unchanged at a temperature of 900 K for 10 ps. These results indicate that
-PbSnX
has a stable structure at 900 K.
3.2. Electronic band structure
Figure 3 shows the electronic band structures of
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te) monolayers calculated by the PBE and HSE06 exchange-correlation functionals, respectively. The corresponding band gap values are given in
Table 2. They are both indirect band gaps with conduction band minimum (CBM) at the high symmetry point
(0, 0, 0) and valence band maximum (VBM) between the high symmetry points
(0,0,0) and K (1/3, 1/3, 0). The band gap calculated by HSE06 is large than that calculated by PBE. It is noted that the PBE functional often underestimates the band gap value, while the HSE functional can give a reliable band gap value compared with experiment. The band gap of
-PbSnS
,
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
are 0.86 (1.37) eV, 0.63 (1.08) eV and 0.61 (0.98) eV, respectively. The band gaps calculated by all the methods gradually decrease as the atomic number of the substituted chalcogenide element (S, Se, and Te) increases. Such moderate bandgaps indicate that thermoelectric properties of the
-PbSnX
monolayer can be easily optimized at a reasonable doping concentration for 2D materials. Except for the band gap, there is no significant change in the type and shape of their energy bands, so we next to calculate the effective mass and carrier mobility of these materials by using the PBE generalization function. The partial density of states (PDOS) of the
-PbSnX
is shown in
Figure 3(d-f), with the valence bands closer to the Fermi energy level. The valence bands around the Fermi level originate from the S, Se and Te atoms, and the conduction bands are jointly contributed by Sn or Pb, S, Se and Te atoms.
Figure 3(d-f) shows that
-PbSnS
,
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
all have very sharp density of state peaks at the Fermi energy level attachment, where
-PbSnS
has a higher density of state peak than
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
.
3.3. Carrier mobility and relaxation time
We use the BoltzTraP-package based on the semi-classical Boltzmann transport equation to estimate the electrical properties of the monolayer
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te). Before that, we need to calculate the relaxation time of the carriers of the material, because the result calculated by BoltzTraP-package needs to be multiplied by the relaxation time. Here, carrier mobilities and relaxation time of 2D materials are calculated using deformation potential theory[
45,
46,
47]:
where
is the carrier mobility,
is the elastic constant,
is the effective mass,
is the average effective mass,
is the deformation potential energy, and
is the relaxation time.
Table 3 shows the results of the electric and hole carrier mobilities calculated with the theory of deformation potential at 300 K. Among them,
-PbSnS
and
-PbSnSe
have ultra-high hole carrier mobility, especially,
-PbSnS
has the highest hole mobility of 4.04×10
cm
V
s
, which is significantly higher than that of other two-dimensional semiconductors, such as MoS
( 285 cm
V
s
)[
48], SnS
( 756 cm
V
s
)[
49], SnSe
( 462 cm
V
s
)[
49],
-PbX
( 780 cm
V
s
) [
36] and
-SnX
( 1364 cm
V
s
)[
35]. Such high carrier mobility of
-PbSnS
and
-PbSnSe
is due to a combination of low effective mass and deformation potential energy. The high hole carrier mobility indicates that
-PbSnS
and
-PbSnSe
are potential p-type semiconductors. In addition, Hung et al. showed that high carrier mobility is one of the important parameters for screening thermoelectric materials[
50,
51]. Such ultra-high carrier mobility indicates that
-PbSnX
possesses excellent hole transport properties and thus are good thermoelectric materials.
3.4. Thermoelectric properties
We investigated the thermoelectric properties of the materials in the temperature range of 300 K to 900 K. As shown in
Figure 4(a-c), all three materials have a high Seebeck coefficient at 300 K. Among them, the Seebeck coefficient of
-PbSnS
,
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
are 1400
V/K, 800
V/K and 900
V/K , respectively, which is much higher than that of most common 2D materials, such as SnTe (600
V/K) [
52], MoSe
(427
V/K)[
53] and WS
(328
V/K)[
54]. The Seebeck coefficient of
-PbSnS
is higher than
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
. This is because
-PbSnS
has a higher density of states peak than
-PbSnSe
and
-PbSnTe
near the Fermi energy level (as shown in
Figure 3), and the Seebeck coefficient is proportional to the density of states peak:
. The high density of states peak near the Fermi energy level indicates that the material will have a higher Seebeck coefficient. Such a high Seebeck coefficient indicating that these materials may have high thermoelectric properties.
Figure 4(d-f) shows the electrical conductivities
obtained by multiplying
by
, where
is calculated using BoltzTraP-package and
is the relaxation time calculated by the deformation potential theory. The electrical conductivity of
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te) exhibits similar behavior at different temperatures and decreases as the temperature increases. This is caused by the enhanced lattice vibrations and electron scattering at high temperature. The electric conductivity of
-PbSnX
gradually decrease as the atomic number of the substituted chalcogenide element (S, Se, and Te) increases. And the value of the conductivity is related to the chemical potential. The conductivity of
-PbSnX
is higher in the negative chemical potential range, which shows the characteristics of P-type semiconductors. It’s worth noting that the electrical conductivity of
-PbSnX
reached the same order (10
-10
/
m) as that of metals due to its ultra-high carrier mobility. The high Seebeck coefficient and conductivity indicate that they have a high power-factor (
), which is important for thermoelectric devices. With the Seebeck coefficient and electrical conductivity, we evaluate the power factor (
) of
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te), as show in
Figure 4(g-i). All three materials have the same trend of power factor, which decreases with the increase of temperature. The
-PbSnS
has the highest
because of its highest Seebeck coefficient and electrical conductivity. And the
values of these materials are maximum in the negative is due to their p-type properties. The
is one of the important factors in evaluating the performance of thermoelectric materials, so a high
predicts that the material may have high thermoelectric properties.
Materials with high thermoelectric properties require low thermal conductivity in addition to high power-factor.
Figure 5 shows the phonon transport properties of
-PbSnX
(X=S, Se, Te), the results show that both
-PbSnX
have a very low thermal conductivity, which is about 6-8 W/mK at room temperature and the value of lattice thermal conductivity decreasing with the increasing of temperature. In order to understand the lattice thermal conductivity of the monolayer
-PbSnX
, we explore the phonon-related properties such as phonon group velocity and anharmonic scattering rates. As shown in
Figure 5(a-c), the three acoustic phonon branches (ZA/TA/LA) get entangled and strong coupling occurs between the optical and acoustic phonon modes, which can strengthen the phonon scattering mechanism and thus lower
.
Figure 5(d-f) shows the phonon group velocities of
-PbSnX
, and it can be seen that they are both low, and low group velocities can lead to low lattice thermal conductivity. The inverse of the phonon relaxation time in the relaxation time approximation (RTA) is equal to the total scattering rate, which is the sum of the isotopic scattering rate (
), the boundary scattering rate (
) and the anharmonic scattering rate (
). In general, higher indicates stronger phonon-phonon scattering and lower phonon relaxation time, which is beneficial for reducing the lattice thermal conductivity. As shown in
Figure 5(g-i), the
-PbSnX
monolayer exhibits high phonon-phonon scattering rates (anharmonic scattering rates) and they are relatively close to each other. In addition, the value of the lattice thermal conductivity increases with the atomic number of the elements (S, Se, Te), which is mainly due to the increase of the atomic mass and the decrease of the phonon frequency. In conclusion, the strong coupling between phonons, lower phonon group velocities and higher scattering rates lead to lower lattice thermal conductivity, indicating that
-PbSnX
may be suitable thermoelectric performance materials.
After all transport coefficients were obtained, the dependence of
on the chemical potential of
-PbSnX
monolayer at different temperatures was calculated, as shown in
Figure 6. All of
-PbSnX
exhibited the maximum thermoelectric properties in the negative chemical potential range due to their higher hole mobility. The
values for all three materials showed the same trend, increasing with increasing temperature. Among them, the
value of
-PbSnTe
is lower, reaching a maximum of only 1.4 at 900 K, which is due to its low power factor. And,
-PbSnS
and
-PbSnSe
reached ultra-high
values of 2.65 and 2.96 at 900 K due to a combination of their low lattice thermal conductivity and high power-factor. Such ultra-high
values of
-PbSnX
are contributed to their low thermal conductivity along with their high power-factor. Such high
values indicates that
-PbSnS
and
-PbSnSe
are good performing high temperature thermoelectric materials.