4.1. Polyploid tissues in C. elegans
At least two tissues are polyploid in
C. elegans: the intestine and hypodermis (part of the nematode epidermis) [
90]. The intestine is a tube responsible for digestion and makes up nearly a third of the animal’s body. All intestinal cells are derived from a single blastomere (E) starting at the eight-cell embryo stage [
131,
132]. The intestine of a newly hatched embryo has twenty diploid cells. When the L1 larvae hatch, they have 20 intestinal cells that have 20 diploid nuclei [
90]. Of these nuclei six do not divide nor replicate their DNA, four nuclei may or may not replicate their DNA or divide, and 10 nuclei replicate and divide by endomitosis cells with two diploid nuclei each. Therefore, by the end of the L1 stage the 20 cells of the intestine have 30-34 diploid nuclei. Prior to the transition molt to the L2 stage all nuclei of the intestine endoreduplicate their DNA (4C each nucleus). Nuclei continue to endoreduplicate prior to the molts into the L2 (8C each nucleus), the L3 (16C), and finally the L4 (32C) larval stages. Thus, the adult intestine is composed of 20 cells with a total of 30-34 nuclei, each with 32C ploidy [
90]. The hypodermis has many roles in development including establishment of the basic body plan in the embryo such as body shape and size, regulation of cell fate specification, and guidance of migrating axons and cells [
133,
134,
135]. The hypodermal cell hyp7 is a multi-nucleated syncytium that encases most of the adult animal body (the tail and head of the animal are covered by smaller hypodermal cells) [
90]. The hyp7 syncytium contains 139 nuclei in the adult and arises from many cell fusions (during embryogenesis 23 cells fuse to hyp7 and post-embryonically 116 cells also fuse to it) [
90,
136]. The embryonically-derived nuclei in hyp7 remain diploid, whereas the ~98 cells generated post-embryonically endoreduplicate to become tetraploid [
90,
136]. Most of these nuclei undergo up to 2 more endoreduplication cycles that result in the hypodermal nuclei having an average 10.7C ploidy by the fully grown adult stage [
91]. The ploidy of the hyp7 cell is key for adult animal size regulation, (see section on allometric studies, below) [
137].
In diploid cells, coordination of the centrosome and cell cycle ensures a single duplication of the centrosome per mitotic cycle, which is crucial to prevent supernumerary centrosomes accumulation that can lead to genomic instability [
138,
139]. Thus, the regulation of the centrosome in polyploid tissues is equally important for maintaining genome stability [
140]. The endopolyploidy of the intestine and hypodermis of developing
C. elegans allowed for comparative studies of how tissues respond to this challenge. In both the polyploid intestine and the hypodermis V1 cell nuclear lineages of the hyp7 syncytium, loss of PCM correlates with an apparent lack of centriole duplication resulting from uncoupling of the centrosome cycle in the first endo-cycle followed by progressive centriole elimination [
141]. The SPD-2 protein with a normal dynamic localization to the PCM and the centrioles is key in for centriole duplication. An
spd-2 phosphomimetic mutant, SPD-2
S545E that can be phosphorylated
in vitro by CDK1 and CDK2 [
141] leads to supernumerary centrosomes in the intestinal cells [
141]. This supports the hypothesis that the putative CDK phosphorylation site at S545 is a part of the molecular mechanism preventing centriole duplication during the endo-S phases of the intestine [
141]. Since the SPD-2
S545E mutation does not affect centriole number in the hypodermal cells, this regulation appears to be specific to intestinal cells. A different putative phosphomimetic SPD-2
S375E mutation, affects a Polo Like Kinase-1 (PLK-1 in
C. elegans) consensus phosphorylation site, and results in the persistence of SPD-2 on centrioles at the L2 stage that agrees with the observed delay in centriole elimination in some of the intestinal nuclei of this mutant. Surprisingly however, PLK-1 does not seem to regulate SPD-2 stabilization nor centriole elimination [
141]. Instead, knockdown of the
proteasome b-subunit (pbs-3) results in both SPD-2 persistence indicative of a lack of centriole elimination in many of the intestinal cells. This finding implicates ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis in the uncoupling of the endocycle and centriole cycle in the intestine [
141].
One question that arose when looking at polyploid tissues is whether there is a biologically-significant functional difference between mononucleated polyploidy (restricted to a single nucleus) and multinucleate polyploidy (in more than one nucleus) [
12,
142]. The developing intestine in
C. elegans was used to address this question by converting the normally binucleated intestinal cells into mononucleated cells of identical ploidy using auxin- induced degradation [
143] of either a regulator of mitotic entry (e.i. CDK-1) or a kinetochore protein required for chromosome partitioning in mitosis (i.e. KNL-1) to block endomitosis [
49]. Whereas absence of CDK-1 prevents entry into mitosis and essentially converts the endomitosis into an endocycle, degradation of KNL-1 allows for entry into mitosis but prevents chromosome partitioning into two nuclei [
49]. Neither knock-down affects cell size or morphology, but the mononucleated intestinal cells have reduced nuclear to cytoplasmic ratio given that their nuclei more than double in size [
49]. Transcriptome analysis revealed that all of the
vitellogenin genes (
vit-1 to vit-6) are downregulated in mononucleated intestines. Vitellogenins are yolk proteins that are required for lipid transport and lipid loading onto oocytes and embryos and promote progeny fitness. Accordingly, the embryos from mothers with mononucleated intestines have reduced survival. Similarly, decreasing
vitellogenin expression in binucleated gut cells phenocopies the impact on progeny fitness and increasing
vitellogenin expression, by overexpressing their transcriptional activators, results in mothers siring progeny with similar fitness regardless of whether they had mono- or bi-nucleated intestines [
49]. Importantly, many of the genes that are downregulated in animals with mononucleated intestines normally increase in expression during the L4 to adult transiition, implicating a major role for binucleation at this developmental stage [
49].
4.2. Biological size and scaling (allometry)
Regulation of cell size and scaling of tissues and organs are critical for development and influence homeostasis, metabolism, and function [
45]. Polyploidization has been generally associated with increases in cell and organism size. For example, genome size and ploidy correlate linearly with cell volume in yeast [
144,
145,
146]. However, effects of polyploidy are cell-type specific in many multicellular organisms, with different cell types having a nonlinear relationship between ploidy and cell size [
147]. For instance, in plants there is a strong correlation between ploidy and cell volume in epidermal pavement cells, but the volume of palisade mesophyll cells remains at a constant size despite changes in ploidy [
148]. These and other observations [
45,
149] make it apparent that the DNA mass does not fully explain the effect of ploidy on cell (and nuclear) size [
45,
149,
150,
151,
152]. In most polyploidization models, including plants, interpreting the direct effect of ploidy is complex because the increase in cell size in tissues and organs is balanced by a reduction in cell number [
45,
150,
153,
154,
155]. The invariant cell lineage in
C. elegans simplifies the identification of mechanisms underpinning correlations between ploidy and scaling of cells, tissues and organs.
Allometry studies related to the effects of ploidy in
C. elegans have been performed for cells and animals [
25,
26,
91,
98,
120,
156,
157,
158,
159]. Nigon (1949) [
99] reported that, compared to the 1300 µm long diploid hermaphrodites, 4A;3X hermaphrodites were on average 1360 µm and the 4A;4X hermaphrodites were 1560 µm long. The more profound increase in 4A;4X hermaphrodites containing 24 chromosomes (See
Figure 3) compared to the 4A;3X hermaphrodites (23 chromosomes) is surprising and suggests that gene expression from the X chromosome may contribute to animal size significantly more than gene expression from autosomes.
The hypodermis secretes the cuticle forming the exoskeleton that houses the nematode’s internal organs and nervous system. There is a proportional relationship between the size of the
C. elegans body and the size of the hypodermal cells (seam cells and the syncytium hyp7) [
156,
160,
161]. Comparison of 12 nematode species from the order
Rhabditida revealed a weak correlation between the number of nuclei and hypodermal volume (hyp7 in
C. elegans), suggesting that body size was at least partly independent of cell number [
91]. A significant correlation between animal size and the product of the number of nuclei and the ploidy was observed across species. Therefore, unlike most organisms where the evolution of body size relies in changes in cell number, in nematodes body size evolution was likely driven by the size of the hypodermal syncytium [
91]. Comparison of a tetraploid strain and its diploid revertant revealed a 39% increase in the adult body size of tetraploids [
25]. The unexpected 1.4-fold increase in volume (instead of the expected 2-fold) in tetraploids is at least in part explained by the lower-than-expected ploidy in the hyp7 cell (16.7C instead of 22C) and the small reduction in the number of cells (by less than two nuclei) [
25]. However, one should be careful in making conclusions from this comparison because it is likely that the reverted diploid differed from the original, but these were not examined. Multiple independent tetraploid strains from nearly any diploid strain provides the possibility of conducting this comparison more rigorously. Levels of endoreduplication in the hyp of
C. elegans was found to be important in regulation of the adult animal size. When
C. elegans young adults were exposed to the DNA replication inhibitor, hydroxyurea (HU), endoreduplication of the hyp7 nuclei was inhibited and a reduction in body size was observed [
25]. Cyclin E is required for endoreduplication in mice and
Drosophila [
162,
163]. Null mutants carrying mutations the
C. elegans homolog of Cyclin E,
cye-1, have an ~1.8-fold reduction in size of the hyp7 syncytium and are 35-54% the size of wild-type worms [
25].
Many signaling pathways and genes affecting diploid animal size have been characterized in
C. elegans. These include pathways that only regulate embryo size, that regulate multiple developmental stages, and that influence adult body size. The TGF/BMP signaling pathway has a major role in the response to ploidy as it regulates both adult size and hyp7 ploidy [
25,
137,
160,
161,
164,
165]. The TGF signaling pathway that regulates body size in
C. elegans includes the DAF-4 type two receptor, the DBL-1 ligand, and the downstream SMADs (SMA-2, SMA-3, SMA-4, and SMA-6) [
166]. DBL-1, the human ortholog of human BMP7
, is required for post-embryonic growth animal [
91,
159,
167]. Whereas DBL-1 overexpression results in longer-than-normal animals (Lon phenotype) [
164], mutations in the
dbl-1 gene cause a dwarf phenotype (Sma) and reduced hypodermal ploidy [
25,
164]. Interestingly, as with the
cye-1 mutant, exposure of
dbl-1 mutants to hydroxyurea neither further reduced hyp7 ploidy nor affected its body size, suggesting that the DBL-1 normally promotes hyp7 endoreduplication [
25]. Together these and other findings [
25,
161] suggest that DBL-1 regulates adult growth in a dose dependent manner [
158,
164] by promoting endoreduplication in the adult hypodermis (hyp7) [
161], likely via the CYE-1 cyclin [
25].
The regulation of body size by DBL-1 pathway is complex. Many of the molecular components in the DBL-1 pathway and other pathways affecting endoreduplication in the hypodermis have been identified, and their localization and molecular or genetic interactions described. For instance, overexpression of LON-1, a member of the conserved PR-protein superfamily [
157,
168], causes hypo-endoreduplication and absence of LON-1 protein causes hyper-endoreduplication in the hypodermis [
157]. Specifically, the levels of
lon-1 transcript depend on the dosage of the
dbl-1 gene and TGF signaling. Other genes and processes affecting diploid animal size are also likely to play important roles in this process. These include cuticle collagens, ß-H Spectrin, TOR kinase, MAPK signaling, Hippo-Warts signaling, and the insulin signaling pathway [
159,
169,
170,
171,
172,
173,
174,
175,
176,
177,
178]. These genes are expected to show altered expression in polyploid animals [
45,
51,
179,
180]. Global metabolic genes, such as rRNA or tRNA genes, are likely also involved in regulating biological scaling in polyploid animals [
45,
181]. Whether these pathways contribute equally to growth regulation in polyploids remains an open question.