1. Introduction
Cancer associated fibroblasts (CAFs) found in the tumor microenvironment are functionally and phenotypically distinct from normal fibroblasts found in non-cancerous tissues [
1]. Immuno-histochemical studies performed by Chesa
et al. revealed that CAFs in several different primary and metastatic carcinomas, including colorectal, breast, ovarian, bladder, and lung carcinomas, overexpress a transmembrane glycoprotein called fibroblast activation protein (FAP) [
2]. FAP is a cell surface serine hydrolase shown to have dipeptidyl exopeptidase and endopeptidase activities [
3]. FAP has a restricted normal tissue distribution including normal fibroblasts, but is overexpressed in the reactive stromal fibroblasts of > 90% of human epithelial carcinomas (breast, lung, colorectal etc.) [
2,
3,
4,
5]. Moreover, its enzymatic activity is considered crucial for the promotion of tumor growth [
6]. FAP’s constrained expression combined with its role in invasion and tumor metastasis, makes it a promising target for developing FAP-targeted radiopharmaceuticals for imaging and therapy of carcinomas. In this regard, several different strategies including use of antibodies [
7,
8], CAR T-cells [
9,
10] and FAP vaccines [
11] and most significantly small-molecule inhibitors [
6,
12,
13,
14,
15], have been explored for FAP-targeting.
The two most noteworthy groups exploited for the development of small-molecule based FAP inhibitors are either 2-cyanopyrrolidine derivatives or 2-pyrrolidinylboronic acid derivatives (boroPro). Additionally, most of the research so far has been directed towards identifying inhibitors that are selective for FAP over dipeptidyl peptidases (DPPs), with which it shares exopeptidase specificity, and over cytosolic prolyl endopeptidase (PREP), with which it shares endopeptidase specificity [
16].
Interestingly, FAP has been reported to exhibit an absolute requirement for glycine at P2 position as an endopeptidase [
17,
18]. This may explain why most small-molecule FAP inhibitors are based upon an X-Gly-Pro sequence. Jansen
et al. presented
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-Gly-(2-cyanopyrrolidine) as an extremely potent FAP inhibitor (IC
50 = 10.3±0.4 nM), with high selectivity indices (SI) over both DPPs (> 10
3) and PREP (> 83-fold) [
19]. Remarkably, substitution of the nitrile on the P1 pyrrolidine ring with a more electrophilic boronic acid warhead yielded
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-Gly-boroPro that demonstrated 2.8-fold higher FAP binding affinity (IC
50 = 3.7±0.2 nM) than the former. Moreover, it retained selectivity over DPPs (> 10
3) with a ~ 3-fold selectivity over PREP [
14].
Contrary to the notion that FAP exhibits an absolute requirement for glycine at the P2 position, two different groups identified small-molecule FAP inhibitors bearing a P2 D-alanine. Tran
et al. were the first to show FAP’s tolerability for a P2 D-alanine [
20]. They reported
N-acetyl-D-Ala-boroPro to exhibit a modest potency with a K
i(FAP) of 350 nM, compared to
N-acetyl-Gly-boroPro that possessed a K
i(FAP) of 23 nM. In the study published by Bachovchin and co-workers,
N-acetyl-D-Ala-boroPro was also shown to have a modest FAP binding potency (IC
50 = 2900±600 nM) [
21]. Importantly, in the same study,
N-(pyridine-4-carbonyl)-D-Ala-boroPro (ARI-3099) was identified as a highly potent FAP inhibitor with an IC
50 of 36±4.8 nM. Its P2 glycine congener was reported to have ~75-fold higher FAP binding affinity. Notably, compared to
N-(benzoyl)-D-Ala-boroPro (IC
50(FAP) = 54±2.9 nM),
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-D-Ala-boroPro (IC
50(FAP) = 6.4±1.4 nM) performed superiorly with ~8-fold higher FAP binding affinity. The FAP/PREP selectivity values were 160 and 33 for the quinoline- and benzoyl-based inhibitors, respectively, indicating that the quinoline-based inhibitors are more selective for binding to FAP. Nevertheless, the findings from the two studies validated FAP’s ability to tolerate a P2 D-alanine in the context of an X-boroPro-based inhibitor.
The radiolabeled small-molecule FAP inhibitor called [
125I]MIP-1232 (
Figure 1) was reported in 2015 and was based on (
R)-(1-(benzoylglycyl)pyrrolidin-2-yl)boronic acid framework [
22]. Although the probe did not serve its primary purpose of atherosclerosis imaging, the authors presented its relevance as a radiotracer for imaging FAP-positive tumor tissues. [
125I]MIP-1232 was reported to strongly accumulate in FAP-positive SK-Mel-187 melanoma xenograft in vitro.
Recently, a new SPECT tracer [
99mTc]Tc-HYNIC-D-Ala-boroPro ([
99mTc]Tc-iFAP,
Figure 1) targeting FAP was reported to exhibit 7.05±1.13 %ID/g tumor uptake and 11.18±1.54 %ID/g kidney uptake in an induced Hep-G2 tumor model in mice at 30 min post injection (pi) [
23]. The tumor and kidney uptake values reportedly dropped by ~ 27% (5.18±0.82 %ID/g) and ~ 33% (7.46±1.02 %ID/g), respectively, at 2 h pi with minimal uptake in most normal organs. In its clinical study, [
99mTc]Tc-iFAP was seen to accumulate in the primary tumors and lymph node metastases of patients with different cancers [
24]. The mean radiation equivalent dose for the kidney (5.2±0.8 mSv) was stated to be more than twice the effective dose (2.3±0.4 mSv) after administrating 740 MBq of the tracer. The authors concluded the study by declaring the need for additional clinical studies to further validate the performance of [
99mTc]Tc-iFAP.
The development of targeted radiotracers by Haberkorn group is one of the most significant and clinically relevant applications of FAP inhibitors to date. By expanding on the framework previously outlined by Jansen
et al. they generated a panel of specific and high affinity FAP inhibitors (FAPIs), undergoing almost complete internalization of the ligand-enzyme complex [
25,
26,
27]. These derivatives were synthesized using different chemical modifications to attach various chelators via a linker to the quinolinoyl moiety in
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-Gly-(2-cyanopyrrolidine). Of these,
68Ga-labeled FAPI-02 [
28], FAPI-04 (
Figure 1) and FAPI-46 [
29],
99mTc-labeled FAPI-34 [
30], and
18F-labeled FAPI-42 [
31] and FAPI-74 [
32] are the most advanced and validated in clinical studies for cancer imaging.
Most recently, [
68Ga]Ga/[
177Lu]Lu/[
225Ac]Ac-PNT6555 were presented as highly potent FAP-targeted theranostic pairs in two different conference abstracts [
33,
34]. PNT6555 (
Figure 1) is a DOTA-conjugated FAP-targeted ligand based on a (
R)-(1-((4-(aminomethyl)benzoyl)-D-alanyl)pyrrolidin-2-yl)boronic acid scaffold. [
177Lu]Lu-PNT6555 was reported to show little retention in normal tissues but a high level of tumor retention (>10 %ID/g) was observed up to 168 h pi. A single dose of [
177Lu]Lu/[
225Ac]Ac-PNT6555 was reported to exhibit a dose-dependent anti-tumor efficacy in a HEK-mFAP murine tumor model, and a phase I clinical trial of [
177Lu]Lu-PNT6555 is currently underway [
35]. No peer-reviewed publications on imaging or ex-vivo biodistribution analysis of [
68Ga]Ga-, [
177Lu]Lu- and/or [
225Ac]Ac-PNT6555 are currently available.
There are varying preclinical and clinical reports on the association between uptake intensity of radiolabeled FAPIs and FAP expression. For example, while [
68Ga]Ga-FAPI-04 is observed to have high uptake in the bone and muscle in mice, the former is not observed in humans [
26,
36,
37,
38,
39,
40]. However, non-tumor-specific uptake of [
68Ga]Ga-FAPI-04 and [
68Ga]Ga-FAPI-46 was recently reported in muscles and degenerative lesions mostly associated with joints and vertebral bones [
39]. Although having additional clinical studies would help ascertain these ambiguous associations, efforts towards development of FAP-targeted inhibitors with improved pharmacokinetic properties and enhanced FAP specificity compared to the already existing FAPIs is warranted.
Compared to nitrile, the boronic acid warhead has been reported to have a higher FAP binding affinity [
14,
19], possibly due to its stronger electrophilic character, and could have a faster pharmacokinetics in vivo due to its highly hydrophilic nature. Furthermore, previous findings confirm that FAP can tolerate a P2 D-alanine apart from a P2 glycine [
20,
21]. Lastly, a P3 quinolinoyl moiety has been previously optimized for developing radioligands for FAP targeting by Haberkorn
et al. [
25,
27]. With this aim in mind, we designed two novel boronic acid-based DOTA-conjugated FAP-targeted ligands; [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 and [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 (
Figure 1), bearing a
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-Gly-boroPro and
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-D-Ala-boroPro pharmacophores, respectively. Addition of chelator DOTA via a piperazine-based linker (
Figure 1) allowed formation of stable complexes with the PET isotope
68Ga. We posited that these novel boronic acid-based tracers may exhibit higher tumor uptake by virtue of their more potent FAP inhibition and demonstrate superior pharmacokinetics by undergoing quick clearance from all the non-target organs/tissues and serve as PET imaging agents with excellent imaging contrast. Both tracers were subjected to a thorough preclinical evaluation including in vitro FAP binding assays, in vivo stability testing and, PET/CT imaging and ex vivo biodistribution studies using HEK293T:hFAP tumor xenograft mouse model. The results were then compared with those obtained from [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 which is currently been evaluated in the clinic [
35].
3. Discussion
The FAP binding affinity of
natGa-SB02055 (0.41±0.06 nM) was found to be ~ 190-fold higher than
natGa-PNT6555 (78.1±4.59 nM), whereas that of
natGa-SB04028 (13.9±1.29 nM) was ~ 5.6-fold higher than
natGa-PNT6555 in the rhFAP enzymatic assays (
Figure 2). This is consistent with previous reports demonstrating bicyclic heteroaromatic quinolinoyl-based FAP inhibitors to be more potent than their monocyclic homoaromatic benzoyl-based congeners [
13,
14,
19,
21,
45]. Additionally, FAP seems to prefer P2 glycine (SB02055) over a P2 D-alanine (SB04028). It is to be noted that, P2 glycine bearing
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-Gly-boroPro was observed to exhibit an IC
50(FAP) of 3.7±0.2 nM by Jansen and co-workers [
14]. Interestingly its P2 D-alanine analogue,
N-(4-quinolinoyl)-D-Ala-boroPro, was shown to exhibit an IC
50(FAP) of 6.4±1.4 nM only by Bachovchin
et al. [
21] in a separate study and hence cannot be pitted head to head for comparison.
Surprisingly, findings from the in vitro enzymatic assay for
natGa-SB02055 were not in concordance with the data from PET/CT imaging and biodistribution analysis of its radioactive counterpart obtained from HEK293T:hFAP tumor-bearing mice at 1 h pi. [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 exhibited a nominal tumor uptake (1.08±0.37 %ID/g) close to the background levels that was ~ 6-fold lower than [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 (6.38±0.45 %ID/g) and primarily underwent renal excretion (
Figure 3 and
Figure 4 and
Table S1). However, uptake in normal organs, particularly the blood (3.13±1.25 %ID/g), pancreas (2.07±0.83 %ID/g), bone (1.14±0.37 %ID/g) and thyroid (1.49±0.47 %ID/g) was greater than the background muscle uptake (0.63±0.20 %ID/g).
We initially suspected lack of in vivo stability of [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 to be a reason for its nominal tumor uptake. Upon subjecting it to
in vivo stability testing at 15 min pi, we found no intact [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 in the mouse plasma. Interestingly, the urine samples collected at the same time presented with > 93% intact [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 (
Figures S1 and S2). The low tumor uptake at 1 h pi could possibly be a consequence of [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 undergoing quick clearance from the blood and rapid renal excretion into the urine in ≤ 15 min of injecting the tracer in vivo. Furthermore, an unidentified highly hydrophilic
68Ga-labeled species accounting for > 99% plasma fraction was observed at 15 min pi during the stability testing. The higher than background level uptake in the blood could supposedly be attributed to this uncharacterized
68Ga-labeled species. Further investigation of [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 in this regard is currently underway.
Next, encouraged by earlier findings regarding FAP’s ability to tolerate a P2 D-alanine in the context of an X-boroPro-based inhibitor [
20,
21], we sought to evaluate the effect of substituting the P2 glycine in [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 with a D-alanine to yield [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028. [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 differed from [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055 in only the P2 amino acid residue, while rest of the molecular structure was kept alike.
The PET/CT imaging data was consistent with the data from the biodistribution analysis performed at 1 h pi in HEK293T:hFAP tumor-bearing mice. [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 demonstrated > 1.5 fold higher tumor uptake (10.1±0.42 %ID/g) than [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 (6.38±0.45 %ID/g) (
Figure 3 and
Figure 4 and
Table S1) and concordant with the findings from FAP inhibition assays where
natGa-SB04028 was realized to be more potent than
natGa-PNT6555. Additionally, high accumulation of both [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 and [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 in the bladder indicated their renal excretion. The uptake of [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 in most normal organs/tissues was minimal and comparable to [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555, particularly in the muscle (0.13±0.01 vs 0.12±0.02 %ID/g), blood (0.97±0.03 vs 0.60±0.04 %ID/g), kidney (2.10±0.33 vs 2.29±0.43 %ID/g) and bone (0.24±0.09 vs 0.45±0.12 %ID/g) (
Figure 4 and
Table S1). However, since the tumor uptake of [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 was considerably greater than [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555, the corresponding tumor/organ uptake ratios for [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 were found to be significantly higher than [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 (tumor/muscle: 79.9±7.50 vs 52.6±5.86; tumor/kidney: 4.89±0.72 vs 2.87±0.59; tumor/bone: 48.1±20.5 vs 14.9±3.34), except tumor/blood ratios (10.4±0.70 vs 10.7±1.29 %ID/g), which were equivalent for the two (
Figure 5 and
Table S1). In general, [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 demonstrated superior tumor/background contrast ratios compared to [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555 as evident from both PET/CT imaging (
Figure 3) and biodistribution analysis (
Figure 5 and
Table S1).
Imaging and biodistribution analysis of mice co-injected [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 with FAPI-04 (0.5 mg/mouse) revealed a ~ 97% reduction in the tumor uptake (10.1±0.42 %ID/g vs 0.30±0.04 %ID/g) substantiating
in vivo FAP specificity of our lead candidate [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 (
Figure 3 and
Figure 4,
Table S1). Moreover, as anticipated since there was no significant reduction observed in the kidney uptake of [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 (2.10±0.33 %ID/g vs 2.53±0.57 %ID/g), we can conclusively state that retention in the kidneys is by virtue of the our tracer’s propensity to undergo renal elimination and is not FAP-mediated.
Unlike its P2 glycine analogue [
68Ga]Ga-SB02055, [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 with a P2 D-alanine residue was found to be relatively more stable during in vivo stability testing. Strikingly, > 47% of [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 remained intact in the mouse plasma at 15 min pi (
Figures S3-S4). The remaining fractions corresponded to currently uncharacterized but highly hydrophilic
68Ga-labeled species. The urine samples from the mouse presented with > 54% intact tracer, with the remaining portions co-eluting more or less with the uncharacterized
68Ga-labeled species found in the plasma samples for [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028.
The exact nature and identity of the
68Ga-labeled species eluting prior to each of the intact tracer during in vivo stability testing has not been characterized. However, it has been shown that boronic acids under basic (physiological) conditions could be converted to other species including: (1) Degradation products formed under physiological pH conditions due to the inherent susceptibility of boronic acids to undergo oxidation [
46,
47]. The empty p orbital of boron in boronic acid is prone to attack by nucleophilic oxygen of reactive oxygen species (ROS), resulting in formation of labile boric esters and/or oxidative de-boronation products. Notably, it is the same attribute that allows boronic acid-based ligands to react with the nucleophilic hydroxyl of the catalytic serine residue of FAP and form reversible covalent adducts. (2) Anionic boronic acid/ hydroxyboronate anion formed under more basic conditions as a result of hydroxyl (OH
-) attack on the highly electrophilic boron atom [
48]. Naturally these ionic species will have a tendency to elute before the neutral boronic acid forms. (3) Boronate esters formed under aqueous conditions at a physiological pH of ~7.4 [
48]. Efforts are underway to characterize these species.
The goal of the present work was to develop novel boroPro-based PET imaging agents with superior pharmacokinetics properties and excellent imaging contrast for easy and reliable diagnosis of FAP-overexpressing carcinomas. Although our lead candidate [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 demonstrated superior tumor/background contrast ratios compared to [
68Ga]Ga-PNT6555, there is still some scope for further optimization: (1) A 4,4-difluoro substituent at the (2
S)-2-cyanopyrrolidine ring was previously reported to enhance FAP inhibitory activity compared to that of unsubstituted analogue [
12,
13,
14]. It would be interesting to generate a difluorinated derivative of [
68Ga]Ga-SB04028 for preclinical investigation, although its synthesis might be a bit challenging; and (2) In terms of diagnostic radiopharmaceuticals,
99mTc is the most widely used with SPECT imaging accounting for > 70% of all the imaging procedures performed in the field of nuclear medicine. Replacing DOTA with a suitable chelator to allow radiolabeling with
99mTc is definitely worth exploiting.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, K.-S.L. and S.B; methodology, S.B., H.-T.K., H.M., Z.Z. and A.A.W.L.W.; validation, S.B., H.-T.K., H.M., Z.Z. and A.A.W.L.W.; formal analysis, S.B., H.-T.K., Z.Z. and A.A.W.L.W; investigation, S.B. H.-T.K., H.M., Z.Z. and A.A.W.L.W.; resources, F.B. and K.-S.L.; data curation, S.B., H.-T.K., Z.Z. A.A.W.L.W. and K.-S.L.; writing—original draft preparation, S.B.; writing—review and editing, K.-S.L.; visualization, S.B.; supervision, K.-S.L. and F.B.; project administration, K.-S.L.; funding acquisition, K.-S.L. and F.B. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.