1. Introduction
The long pentraxin (PTX3) is produced by macrophages, neutrophils, myeloid dendritic cells and nonimmune cells responding to IL-1, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α and Toll-like receptor agonists [
1,
2,
3]. Its role in the contest of innate immunity has been described in a recent review [
4].
According to its molecular structure, PTX3 presents a unique N-terminal domain [
5] and a conserved C-terminal pentraxin-like domain that allow octamer formation of the secreted PTX3 monomers through inter-chain disulfide bonds [
6]: a more precise definition of its configuration has been only recently achieved thus indicating the possible binding sites and interactions of this multifaceted pattern recognition molecule (PRM) [
7].
PTX3 is suddenly released by neutrophil granulocytes at the local sites of activation, whereas its enduring production is regulated via gene expression in innate immune cells and endothelial cells [
8].
In healthy subjects, PTX3 plasma levels are around 2 ng/ml [
9] and, according to literature, an association between high PTX3 plasma levels, disease severity and mortality has been observed for kidney diseases [
10] and in hemodialysis (HD) patients [
11,
12]. Chronic low grade inflammation induces accelerated senescence in end stage renal disease (ESRD) [
13,
14] and is now accepted the strict correlation between this condition of “Inflammaging”, the uraemic milieu and the comorbidities developed in chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients with the consequent increased mortality rate for malignancies, CVD or infections [
15] thus giving a new declination of the “frailty” concept in kidney disease [
16,
17]. In this setting, PTX3 role could employ a pivotal significance.
The purpose of this review is to focus on the possible role of PTX3 as a valid biomarker in the diagnosis and progression of the renal damage, in the setting of chronic and acute kidney diseases, according to its physio pathological role. Farther, its role as therapeutic and diagnostic tool and its possible function as inflammaging biomarker.
3. PTX3 in Acute Kidney Injury (AKI)
Acute ischemia-reperfusion (I/R) injury is a condition that occurs when blood flow to an organ is temporarily restricted, followed by the return of blood flow and re-oxygenation. The transient lack of oxygen and nutrients during ischemia with the following restored basal condition, results in oxidative damage and a significant inflammatory response causing an exacerbation of tissue damage. This kind of injury is typical of acute kidney injury (AKI) [
84].
Several studies investigated the immunological and molecular mechanisms involved in ischemia-reperfusion injury and found that the TLR4 signalling pathway plays a dominant role in mediating kidney injury [
85,
86]. During ischemic AKI, TLR4, a receptor for Damage Associated Molecular Pattern Molecules (DAMPs) and also the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) receptor, is necessary for early activation of the endothelium, resulting in maximum inflammation and injury. In fact, TLR4 is the main receptor for the maladaptive high-mobility group protein B1 (HMGB1) that is released by damaged renal cells. This binding leads to an increase in the expression of pro-inflammatory adhesion molecules. Without the presence of endothelial TLR4, these adhesion molecules are not expressed, leading to decreased inflammation and improvement in injury outcomes. As shown in the murine model of I/R injury of Chen and coll. [
87] the kidney-intrinsic TLR4 signalling pathway may be an important positive regulator of PTX3. They demonstrated that PTX3 plays a crucial role in the development of ischemic AKI: after 4 hours of reperfusion, PTX3 was upregulated in plasma and kidneys, mainly in endothelial cells of wild-type mice because of to the effect of HMGB1 on TLR4. The expression of PTX3 was further enhanced by the interaction between reactive oxygen species (ROS) and TLR4 ligands such as HMGB1, LPS or stress fibronectin. PTX3 knockout mice, instead, showed reduced expression of cell adhesion molecules in the endothelium after 4 hours of reperfusion, potentially contributing to a reduction in early maladaptive inflammation in the kidneys of these mice. However, at 24 hours of reperfusion, the expression of endothelial adhesion molecules increased in PTX3 knockout mice as regulatory and reparative leukocytes entered the kidney.
Complement has a pivotal role in kidney I/R injury. According to a swine model, Divella and coll. [
88] investigated the role of PTX3 as possible modulator of complement activation and showed that I/R injury induces early PTX3 deposits in peritubular and glomerular capillary. In normal tissue, PTX3 deposits are very limited. However, following reperfusion, there’s a widespread deposition of PTX3 in the tubulo-interstitial area, at peritubular capillaries and at glomerular levels already at 15 minutes after reperfusion. Even one hour after reperfusion, PTX3 deposits are still detectable at the level of peritubular capillaries. By using confocal laser scanning microscopy, they discovered that PTX3 deposits co-localized with CD31+ endothelial cells. Furthermore, PTX3 was observed to be associated with infiltrating macrophages (CD163), dendritic cells (SWC3a), and myofibroblasts (FSP1). Notably, there was a significant PTX3-mediated activation of the classical (C1q-mediated) and lectin (MBL-mediated) pathways of complement. PTX3 deposits were also co-localized with the activation of the terminal complement complex (C5b-9) on endothelial cells, indicating that PTX3-mediated complement activation mainly occurred at the renal vascular level.
These findings suggest that PTX3 could potentially serve as a therapeutic target to prevent complement-induced I/R injury. In a previous observation, the same workgroup, showed how treatment with recombinant C1-INH (rhC1INH), a potent inhibitor of proteases of the classical and lectin complement pathways, C1r, C1s and MASP2, significantly reduces complement activation leading to a decreased recruitment of inflammatory cells and tubulo-interstitial damage [
89]. This finding is consistent with the experience of Delpech and coll., who a few years later, in a swine model of kidney auto transplantation, investigated the benefits of pre-reperfusion treatment with rhC1INH and observed a marked reduction in the deposition of C1q, MASP, and C4d in both glomerular and tubular structures 30 minutes after reperfusion, indicating that C1-INH plays a key role in regulating both classical and lectin pathways [
90].
Organ fibrosis caused by AKI is recognized as an important contributor to the development of CKD [
91]. In a murine model of AKI, Xiao and coll. [
92] showed faster kidney function recovery after PTX3 infusion. Fibrosis was linked to heightened expression of IL-6 and significant activation of Stat3. In vitro, the administration of IL-6 led to increased expression of collagen I and activation of Stat3 in renal epithelial cells undergoing hypoxia-reoxygenation, which was suppressed by PTX3. Furthermore, the reduction in serum creatinine levels and the decreased expression of collagen and smooth muscle actin brought about by PTX3 treatment were reversed by additional administration of IL-6. The decrease in p-Stat3 expression caused by PTX3 was also reversed by the additional IL-6 treatment. These findings indicate that PTX3 counteracts interstitial fibrosis caused by acute kidney injury by suppressing the IL-6/Stat3 pathway.
Even if all data up to here suggest a correlation between AKI injury and PTX3 levels, literature of opposite direction hints a protective role for PTX3.
Always according to a murine model, Lech and coll. found that the absence of PTX3 led to a severe form of post-ischemic AKI, as indicated by widespread tubular necrosis, high levels of TNF and IL-6, and a significant increase in the infiltration of neutrophils and macrophages 24 hours later. This resulted in tubular atrophy, interstitial fibrosis, and shrinkage of the kidney 10 weeks later. In vivo imaging showed increased leukocyte adhesion and migration in post-ischemic micro vessels of mice with a deficiency in PTX3. Administering recombinant PTX3 up to 6 hours after reperfusion prevented kidney inflammation and injury. This suggests that PTX3 release from a group of intra-renal mononuclear phagocytes or late PTX3 treatment can reduce post-ischemic renal inflammation. On the other hand, mutations causing loss of function in PTX3 increase the risk of post-ischemic acute kidney injury and subsequent CKD [
93].
Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are deeply involved in AKI progression [
94]. In the vitro experience of Lee et coll. exogenous recombinant PTX3 protects kidney cells during ischemia and proinflammatory acute kidney injury, decreasing the activity of caspase-3 and PARP-1, thus preserving the stability of the mitochondrial membrane potential and inhibiting apoptosis [
95].
Considering the heterogeneous set of data previously described, PTX3 determinations could helpful not only in determining the beginning of an acute process but, through its serial measurement, particularly in cases of AKI without other comorbidities, be an indicator of “restitutio ad integrum” of the organ or a clinical indicator for effectiveness of performed therapies. Otherwise, as indicator of residual kidney damage, it could shed a light on hindered processes of transition from acute to chronic damage.
4. PTX3 in Kidney Transplantation (KTx)
PTX3 levels in kidney transplant recipients (KTR) are higher when compared to healthy subjects [
96] but, patients previously receiving HD and then successfully transplanted, after a one-year follow-up, show a significant reduction of circulating PTX3 levels thus possibly confirming a pivotal role of adequate renal function and reduced inflammatory status [
97] in PTX3 removal/production.
Opposite data were collected by Garsu and coll. who evaluated PTX3 role as inflammatory marker in KTR before and after kidney transplant, according to the known changes in inflammatory status after kidney transplant. In order to reduce confounding factors such as induction therapies, HLA mismatch, prolonged ischemia time or previous and prolonged different renal replacement therapies (RRT), their observation focused on a specific pool of 40 patients waiting for kidney transplant from living donation. According to their experience, after kidney transplantation, PTX3 is not a useful biomarker of inflammation when compared to high sensitivity C-reactive protein which showed, instead, a stronger correlation with inflammation. This evidence may be related to immunosuppressive drugs which downregulate IL-6 expression and consequently PTX3 production [
98].
Mononuclear cells and dendritic cell are a major source of PTX3 production. Therefore, when corticosteroid therapy is started and kidney transplant is performed, PTX3 production may decrease because of lymphocyte depletion and may increase because of endothelial damage: this hypothesis is consistent with upregulation of PTX3 expression in renal parenchyma after acute kidney rejection episodes [
99].
According to histological evaluation of perioperative renal biopsies, acute rejection and follow-up protocol biopsies, not only PTX3 levels are higher in the early phases of AR but significantly decrease after its treatment. Moreover, according to PTX3 deposition along tubulo-interstitial area, peritubular capillaries and glomeruli, it positively correlates with the degree of allograft dysfunction according to 2009 Banff classification thus suggesting a role as biomarker of severity in histological patterns of acute renal allograft rejection [
99].
Nephrotoxic effect of immunosuppressors such as calcineurin inhibitors (CNIs) are well known mediators of chronic allograft dysfunction through a sustained, low grade, ischemic damage to epithelial cells [
100]. Minimization of these drugs or their avoidance, is considered a first choice for the successful management of transplant recipient [
101] with a possible impact on fatal cardiovascular events [
102]. In 105 kidney transplant recipients under CNI/mTOR immunosuppression, Infante and coll. found both reduced progression of chronic cardiovascular disease and PTX3 expression [
103].
PTX3 is also studied as the main factor, with Fetuin-A, for vascular calcification and inflammation in hemodialysis (HD) and renal transplant (RT) patients: they are associated with increased risk for future cardiovascular morbidity in KTR [
104].
Finally, baseline PTX3 levels is an independent predictor of suppression of viral load below level of detection (LOD) at day 21 in solid organ transplant recipients treated for cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease [
105].
Therefore, serial PTX3 measurements could impact on kidney transplant recipients’ management because it represents an interesting clinical tool: even if it seems not to correlate with patients’ inflammatory status, in the first phases after kidney transplant it does correlate with acute renal allograft rejection and infectious episodes thus providing a tool for more precise immunosuppressive strategies, diagnostic procedures and histological evaluations. During in KTR, it’s established that PTX3 levels should “physiologically” decrease: excluded histological pattern of graft failure, according to PTX3 association with previous clinically impacting features of patient comorbidities’, it could suggest a worsening of these condition with a possible impact on diagnostic procedures. Finally, from a more speculative point of view, serial PTX3 measurement associated with protocol histological evaluations, could add more information about molecular mechanism of accelerated senescence in KTR.
5. PTX3 in peritoneal Dialysis (PD)
Few data are also present in literature about PTX3 role in Peritoneal Dialysis (PD). Continuous exposure to peritoneal dialysis fluids (PDFs) is associated with pathological responses to a persistent micro-inflammation, which leads to ultrafiltration failure on time [
106].
During a single PD exchanges, PTX3 levels tend to increase, because of the contact between peritoneal epithelium and glucose-based PD solutions [
107]. This observation was confirmed by a 2016 Japanese study. Ishimatsu and coll. investigated the in vivo PTX3 expression in the peritoneal membrane of a rat model: treatment performed was continuous peritoneal dialysis (PD), with conventional PDF containing 3.86% glucose for 8 weeks. PTX3 was detected in peritoneal mesothelial cells, macrophages and fibroblasts in the thickened sub mesothelial area and glucose was found to induce PTX3 protein expression in cultured rat peritoneal mesothelial cells (RPMCs) as well as macrophage-like cells and fibroblasts. According to this, glucose may be a major driver for PDF-induced local micro-inflammation in the peritoneum [
108].
As seen before, also in PD patients PTX3 could exert a role as biomarker, particularly specific for peritoneal inflammation and progressive fibrosis leading to functional failure of the replacement treatment. In a 50 patients’ cohort of PD patients, Kanda and colleagues observed PTX3 expression in peritoneal endothelial cells, fibroblasts, mesothelial cells before and after a single PD session. PTX3 levels in peritoneal effluent (PE), at the cessation of PD, was significantly higher than that at the initiation of PD. Of particular interest, effluent PTX3 levels in patients with a history of peritonitis or a PD duration of more than 8 years were significantly higher than those in patients without peritonitis or patients with a PD duration of <8 years thus suggesting an association with chronic inflammation. More to date, PTX3 levels do correlate with matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2) and interleukin-6 (IL-6) levels in PE, as well as the thickness of the sub mesothelial compact (SMC) zone, small vessel vasculopathy and the loss of mesothelial cells [
109].
According to these data, PTX3 could effectively flank clinical evaluations routinely performed in order to define a more comprehensive evaluation of patients conditions and forewarn frequent complications such as peritonitis or peritoneal sclerosis progression.
6. PTX3 in Hemodialysis (HD)
PTX3 pre-dialysis levels above 2.3 ng/ml are associated with arterial stiffness, a mortality predictor in hemodialysis patients [
110] but HD patients show higher PTX levels (about 6 ng/ml) with even more increased PTX3 levels in HD patients with severe cardiovascular disease [
97,
111,
112]. A 3 years, prospective, observational cohort study enrolled 135 HD patients, looking for a correlation between plasma level of PTX3 and arteriovenous fistula (AVF) failure: higher PTX3 levels were associated with higher risks of AVF functional patency loss in chronic HD patients [
113]. These data strengthen PTX3 role as a serological biomarker independently associated with CVD [
114] even in the absence of a precise molecular mechanism [
38].
More than in CKD, in fact, PTX3 levels in HD patients are increased because of the HD patients’ uraemic milieu and frailty status: CVD is a highly common complication and the first cause of death in patients receiving HD and their mortality rate, due to CVD, is 20 times higher compared to general population, considering not only ventricular hypertrophy but also non-traditional risk factors, such as chronic volume overload, anemia, inflammation, oxidative stress, chronic kidney disease–mineral bone disorder or protein energy wasting conditions [
115].
According to its possible role as biomarker, PTX3 is pointed out as the most sensitive inflammatory predictor of all-cause mortality after adjustment for the main confounding factors in HD patients [
116] even according to nutritional, inflammatory and oxidative status [
117].
PTX3 levels do also correlate with obesity, which is a common feature in HD patients. Data from literature point out a survival benefit for HD patients with high BMI, particularly those older than 65 years [
118] suggesting the hypothesis of the “Obesity paradox” in CKD [
119]. Several works show a unique and inverse association between BMI and PTX3 and not for classical inflammatory biomarkers: non-overweight patients, and particularly PEW (protein energy wasting) patients, present not only higher IL-6 and TNF-α concentrations compared to overweight patients but also higher PTX3 levels, [
120,
121] and this association is confirmed even by “in vivo” analysis of fat tissue in CKD and HD patients [
97].
Aside patients’ frailty status related to uraemia, RRT itself promotes inflammation: PTX3 levels could be higher because of the contact with the dialyzer, according to biocompatibility issues, but also for inefficient removal because of its molecular weight, thus mimicking the condition previously described for CKD.
PTX3 levels increase during a single 4-hour treatment reaching basal levels at the end of the intradialytic period with associated, reduced, intracellular PTX3 content in neutrophils [
112,
122,
123,
124]. Neutrophil PTX3 over-expression, instead, happens during a single HD: after a 4-hours treatment not only PTX3 but also ROS production is increased. More to date, flow mediated dilation (FMD) of the brachial artery inversely correlates with PTX3 levels with a worst performance at the end of the dialysis treatment [
125].
More recently, Fukushi and coll. added another piece to the possible role of neutrophil, suggesting that increased PTX3 release could be due to progressive apoptosis of white blood cells because of the combining effects of CKD related chronic inflammation and biocompatibility issues during a 4-hours HD session even if performed with new generation dialyzers [
126].
Recent insight from literature also suggest the possibility that single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in ESRD patients could mimic PTX3 deficiency: even not affecting mortality, the PTX3 (rs2305619) polymorphism in the intron 1 (+ 281A > G) was linked to a much more pronounced inflammatory response with a positive correlation with high specificity C reactive protein (hsCRP) and IL-6 in patients under RRT [
127]. It has been also speculated that PTX3 loss-of-function mutations could promote post ischemic AKI and subsequent CKD [
93] even if, according to renal I/R injury models, there is not actually a unique definition of this mechanism [
128]
PTX3 interacts with several complement molecules such as C1q, ficolins and mannose binding leptin (MBL) thus promoting complement-dependent opsonization and phagocytosis of microbes and apoptotic cells but, at the same time, interacts with regulatory factors of the complement cascade, such as Factor H (FH) and Complement-4 Binding Protein (C4BP), in order to modulate complement-mediated inflammatory response [
4]. All these elements contribute to the activation of the Lectin and Alternative pathway of complement but also, through C3b and C5b opsonizing fragment, to neutrophil upregulation and activation with consequent leukocyte adhesion, inflammatory response and activation of the coagulation cascade. The ending product of complement activation, the membrane attack complex (MAC-C5b-9) complex, exerts consequent endothelial damage [
129,
130].
One of the leading mechanism for complement activation in HD is binding of Ficolin-2 to the dialyzer surface thus inducing lectin pathway activation with a consequent inflammatory stimulus that [
131] enhances, in the short term, a pro-thrombotic milieu and in the long term appearance of cardiovascular events [
132]. It’s also established the relationship between PTX3 levels and consequent complement activation: PTX3 enhances innate immune recognition and complement deposition [
133] and its C-terminal domain has been reported to bind to C1q with consequent complement activation [
134]. Particularly, PTX3 activates the classical complement cascade when interacting with surface-bound C1qand consequent C3 and C4 deposition. Otherwise, in solution, PTX3 downregulates complement cascade blocking interaction sites [
135].
For all these reasons, according to biocompatibility issues [
129] and PTX3 acknowledgment as uraemic toxin [
136], its removal is actually considered a possible and desirable target with new generation dialytic membranes [
137] [
Figure 2].
7. Conclusions
Patients affected by ESRD are worldwide increasing in absolute number and clinical complexity. Their phenotypic uraemic frailty, in accordance with the development and consequent susceptibility to life threatening comorbidities such as CVD, malignancies or infections, is related to accelerated ageing phenomena generally referred to as “Inflammaging” [
138].
In this setting, PTX3 encompasses, better than classic inflammatory biomarkers, the role of “Inflammaging” biomarker, particularly in ESRD and in HD patients. In this patients’ population, PTX3 role could be crucial in order to evaluate not only the most biocompatible membranes or suitable nanostructure but also influence anticoagulation strategies and even dialytic strategies for personalized therapies.
More to date, being more specific than hsCRP and according to its mechanism of release and production, PTX3 defines specific pattern of immune-mediated damage in life threatening conditions such as acute phase GN, vasculitis, TMA and acute rejection providing not only a well-time diagnostic recognition but also a consequent, specific treatment.
Because of the heterogeneity of data collected from literature, particularly in the field of kidney disease, more studies and researches are needed in order to translate in the clinical setting the possible role of PTX3 as a valid biomarker in the diagnosis and progression of the renal damage. Finally, the the knowledge acquired in progression and diagnosis of kidney diseases could help physicians to better understand the molecular mechanism underline the particular phenomena known as accelerated senescence.