1. Introduction
Ginger (Zingiber officinale) is a widely used spice and medicinal plant known for its unique flavour and numerous health benefits [
1]. Due to its high moisture content, fresh ginger is perishable, necessitating the development of preservation techniques to extend its shelf life and facilitate long-distance transportation [
2]. Convective drying is a popular method of preserving ginger, which involves the movement of hot air over the product to facilitate moisture evaporation [
3]. This literature review examines the existing studies on the experimental investigation of convective drying of ginger rhizomes, focusing on the drying kinetics, quality attributes, and optimisation of drying conditions.
Numerous studies have focused on analysing the drying kinetics and developing mathematical models for the convective drying of ginger rhizomes. Oyedele et al. [
4] compared ginger's hot and solar drying methods, determining that hot air drying resulted in faster drying rates and lower moisture ratios. Various mathematical models, including the Page, Henderson, Pabis, and Logarithmic models, have characterised the drying kinetics. The Page model was found to be the most suitable in the majority of cases
[4,5].
In another study by Dincer and Dost
[6], the drying kinetics of ginger were investigated using a laboratory-scale convective dryer. The researchers observed a decrease in the drying rate as the moisture content increased. The effective moisture diffusivity was calculated utilising Fick's second law, indicating a significant correlation between temperature and air velocity.
Similarly, Nguyen et al. .
[7] discovered that elevating the drying temperature and air velocity resulted in higher effective moisture diffusivity in ginger rhizomes.
The impact of convective drying parameters on the quality attributes of dried ginger has been the subject of numerous investigations. Colour is an important parameter affecting the final product's visual appeal and consumer acceptability [
8]. Doymaz [
9] reported that higher drying temperatures led to increased browning of ginger slices, suggesting a potential compromise in product quality. Similarly, Oyedele et al. [
5] found that solar drying resulted in a darker colour than hot air drying, with the latter preserving the colour attributes better.
Volatile oil content and antioxidant capacity are other critical quality attributes of dried ginger, as they are directly linked to its flavour and therapeutic value [
10]. Feng et al. [
8] observed that ginger slices' phenolic, flavonoid, and antioxidant activity increased with decreasing drying temperatures. In contrast, higher temperatures resulted in a significant loss of volatile oil content. This suggests that lower drying temperatures may be preferable for preserving the bioactive compounds in ginger.
Optimising the convective drying conditions for ginger rhizomes is crucial to balancing energy efficiency and product quality. Response surface methodology (RSM) has been widely employed for this purpose [
4,
7]. RSM is a statistical technique used to optimise multiple factors simultaneously, making it an effective tool for determining the optimal combination of drying parameters [
11]. Afolabi et al. [
4] used RSM to optimise the convective air-drying temperature for tiger nut, which has similar drying characteristics to ginger. They determined the optimal drying temperature to be 60°C, which minimised energy consumption while maintaining product quality. Nguyen et al. [
7] employed RSM to optimise the drying temperature, air velocity, and sample size for ginger rhizomes, finding that a temperature of 55°C, air velocity of 1.5 m/s, and sample size of 5 mm provided the best combination of energy efficiency and product quality.
Recently, novel drying techniques and hybrid drying systems have been explored to improve the efficiency and quality of convective drying of ginger rhizomes. These methods include microwave-assisted convective drying [
2], infrared-assisted convective drying [
12] and vacuum-assisted convective drying [
13]
Alibas [
2] compared microwave, air, and combined microwave-convective drying of pumpkin slices, a product with comparable properties to ginger. The study demonstrated that combined microwave-convective drying resulted in shorter drying times and better retention of colour and nutrient content than conventional convective drying. Erenturk et al. [
12] investigated the infrared-assisted convective drying of carrot slices. They found that combining infrared and convective drying significantly reduced drying time without compromising product quality. Namsanguan et al. [
13] studied the vacuum-assisted convective drying of ginger. They observed that the process resulted in higher retention of volatile oil content and better preservation of colour compared to traditional convective drying. Ikechukwu [
14] studied the prediction of thin layer drying characteristics of ginger rhizomes slices in convective environment. This investigation confirmed the superior efficacy of convective drying at higher temperatures, as it recorded the lowest moisture content
. The study's results established a clear connection between drying time, temperature, and the moisture content in ginger
The primary focus of our current study is to delve into the intricacies of the convective drying process of ginger rhizomes. We're particularly interested in exploring the correlation between moisture content and thermal properties. Existing research demonstrates that similar drying techniques can have a profound effect on the bioactive components in a variety of fruits. A study conducted by Bialik et al.
[15] provides an exemplary model, exploring how vacuum and convective drying parameters can influence the total phenolic and carotenoid content, antioxidant capacity, and drying kinetics of kiwiberry (Actinidia arguta). Interestingly, they found that vacuum drying methods tend to preserve the phenolic content of kiwiberry more effectively. It was also noted that samples dried at 50°C were nearly indistinguishable from their fresh counterparts. Regardless of the drying method, they observed that the fastest drying time was at a temperature of 70°C.
Broadening our perspective, it's critical to recognise the advancements in drying techniques, especially those aimed at materials with high moisture content. Khalid Hamid et al.
[16] highlighted this through their innovative research, examining the performance of a closed-loop heat pump dryer using a moisture-rich material known as Orbeez. Through their experiments, they examined different weights of Orbeez at a constant airflow rate to determine various performance metrics, such as the coefficient of performance of the heat pump, drying rate, condenser's heat transfer rate, moisture extraction rate, and specific moisture extraction rate. Fascinatingly, the research indicated that increased test loads corresponded to improved performance and moisture extraction rates. It was also found that the water removal rate, dependent on moisture diffusivity, increased with higher drying air temperature and air velocity. Further, they incorporated a deep learning model to predict the outlet conditions of the dryer and weight reduction based on the input conditions of the dryer, time, and weight. This model proved exceptionally accurate, making it a potentially cost-effective solution for predicting the drying performance of different materials in a closed-loop heat pump dryer.
While our study is centred on the convective drying of ginger rhizomes, it's important to note that other scholars have applied various drying methods to different food substances. For example, Çelik and Kenanoğlu
[17] researched aubergine seeds, Zhang et al.
[18] on tiger nuts, and Akther et al.
[19] on mango powder. These investigations were valuable in their contexts, providing significant insights into the drying processes of these individual food items. However, it is noteworthy that none of these studies explored the specific convective drying method we have employed in our research. As such, our investigation fills a knowledge gap in the study of convective drying processes, specifically focusing on the effects of moisture content on the thermal properties of ginger rhizomes.
Drawing inspiration from substantial contributions to the field, our research aims to provide comprehensive insights into ginger rhizomes' drying behaviour and kinetics. This exploration could pave the way for developing more efficient drying procedures and preserving vital constituents. Specifically, our primary objective is to examine the convective drying process of Zingiber officinale (ginger) rhizomes sourced from the prominent ginger-producing states in Nigeria, including Kaduna, Bauchi, Benue, Gombe, and Nasarawa.
The study focuses on characterising the moisture content and thermal properties of these rhizomes during drying to understand how these parameters influence the efficiency of the convective drying process. By zeroing in on ginger rhizomes from these regions, we aspire to gather data representative of Nigeria's major ginger-producing areas, subsequently offering invaluable insights that could be applied to optimise drying processes on a grander scale.
We acknowledge that these states' specific climatic and soil conditions may impact the rhizomes' properties, affecting the quality of the drying process and the final product. Understanding these dynamics can furnish crucial insights to facilitate quality control of dried ginger rhizomes and potentially enhance the beneficial properties of the end product. This understanding could also foster the development of more energy-efficient and cost-effective drying techniques for ginger and other agricultural products, significantly impacting the food processing industry.
While our study is comprehensive, it's not devoid of limitations. Primarily, it only includes ginger varieties from Northern Nigeria, possibly limiting the findings' generalisability to other ginger types in different regions or countries. The study's focus on moisture content and thermal conductivity overlooks other potentially significant parameters, such as shrinkage, colour change, and textural alterations, which could critically affect the dried product's quality. Lastly, our research exclusively employs convective drying, neglecting other drying methods that could yield differing results. We anticipate that future research addressing these limitations could provide more comprehensive insights, further enriching our understanding of the drying processes of ginger rhizomes.
Our study's findings are expected to interest professionals and researchers in food science and technology, agricultural engineering, and crop processing. Moreover, the insights from this research could provide a foundation for future studies on the drying processes of other significant agricultural crops within Nigeria and similar climatic regions.
4. Results and Discussions
The drying characteristics of ginger rhizomes were examined using experimental drying curves at various conditions. Drying curves were studied over 2 – 24 hours, with average moisture content ranging from 78.74% (on a wet basis) at 10℃ to a final moisture content of 5.98% (on a wet basis) at 60℃. These samples were then utilised to calculate the individual thermal conductivity of the ginger product. Additionally, the research explored the influence of moisture content on thermal conductivity over time.
Two primary aspects of convective drying of ginger rhizomes were investigated in this study: firstly, to identify the moisture content characteristics, and secondly, to determine the thermal conductivity of each sample at different drying times and temperatures using the linear heat conduction experimental unit.
Drying is an essential process for preserving and storing ginger rhizomes and directly impacts the quality of the end product. The drying air temperature plays a significant role in shaping the drying curves and determining the quality of dried ginger rhizomes. Gaining insights into how the temperature of the drying air influences drying kinetics and quality characteristics is key to optimising the drying procedure.
- 1.
Impact of Drying Air Temperature on Drying Patterns: Increased drying air temperatures lead to a more rapid drying rate, mainly due to the enhanced heat and mass transfer between the ginger rhizome and the surrounding air. At higher temperatures, drying curves usually display a swift initial drying rate, which then transitions to a slower, more steady decline in moisture content. This results in shorter drying durations, a plus for large-scale processing and energy efficiency.
However, overly high drying temperatures can induce case hardening, where the outer surface of the ginger rhizome dries faster than the interior, forming a hardened shell that hampers additional moisture extraction. This may prolong the drying duration and lead to uneven drying, adversely affecting the final product's quality.
- 2.
Impact of Drying on the Quality of Ginger Rhizomes: The temperature of the drying air significantly influences the quality of the dried ginger rhizomes. Drying can alter critical quality characteristics like colour, aroma, flavour, and texture.
Colour: Elevated drying temperatures can cause browning or discolouration of ginger rhizomes due to non-enzymatic browning reactions or pigment oxidation.
Aroma and Flavor: The drying procedure may result in the loss of volatile compounds responsible for ginger's unique aroma and flavour. Higher temperatures can intensify these losses, making a final product less aromatic and flavorful.
Texture: High drying temperatures can induce case hardening, affecting the texture of dried ginger rhizomes and making them harder to grind or process.
Striking a balance between the drying air temperature and the drying duration is crucial to optimise the drying process while preserving the quality of dried ginger rhizomes. By judiciously selecting the appropriate drying temperature, it's possible to minimise quality degradation while maximising drying efficiency and energy conservation. Further studies could examine different drying methods, such as vacuum or freeze-drying, to better preserve the quality attributes of dried ginger rhizomes.
In this research, while numerous aspects of the convective drying process of Zingiber officinale (ginger) rhizomes were studied in detail, certain factors, such as the colour parameters of the dried rhizomes, were not included. The study of colour parameters can provide additional insights into the quality and acceptability of the dried ginger rhizomes, as colour changes can often signify crucial changes in the product during the drying process.
However, our current research objective focuses primarily on understanding the drying kinetics, explicitly looking at the moisture content (both on a wet and dry basis), drying rate, and overall drying rate, and their relationship with the efficiency of the drying process. Colour parameters, while valuable, fall outside the scope of our present study.
Our decision to exclude colour parameters from this research was based on the aim of delving deeply into the dynamics of moisture content and drying rates. We believe these factors are of primary importance in optimising the convective drying process and improving the quality of the dried ginger rhizomes. While colour parameters are not considered in this work, we acknowledge their importance and suggest they be considered for future research, as they could potentially provide further insights into the visual quality and consumer acceptance of the dried ginger product.
4.1. Measurement of Moisture Content and Thermal Conductivity
Our research studied the thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes, employing Environmental Stress Chambers and the Linear Heat Conduction principle. The aim was to understand better ginger rhizomes' heat transfer characteristics, which is essential in food processing. Blanched, unblanched, peeled and unpeeled treatments were studied under simulated environmental conditions. The thermal conductivity consistently fell within the 0.0460 – 0.0553W/m.K range for all variants.
Additionally, moisture content, a key factor affecting heat transfer, was analysed, varying from 5.98% to 9.04% across all conditions. A clear correlation between moisture content and thermal conductivity was observed [
24,
25] as moisture content increased, so did thermal conductivity.
Understanding the joint impact of moisture content and thermal conductivity can enhance the precision of heat treatment processes in food industries
[26]. This knowledge enables processors to adjust parameters like heating times and temperatures more accurately, optimising energy use and ensuring product quality. Further research could investigate the thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes under different temperature regimes.
Calculations of Moisture Content (%) of Ginger Rhizomes
Calculations of Thermal Conductivity of Ginger Rhizomes
where Q = Heat flow within a body per unit time (in Watts) W
= Difference of temperatures of the face of the block of thickness through which heat flow = Body thickness in the direction of flow, m
A = Surface area of the flow (perpendicular to the direction of the flow)
4.2. Impact of Air Temperature on Drying Patterns and Its Effect on the Quality of Dried Ginger Rhizomes
The drying process for individual ginger rhizome samples was conducted at various temperatures, specifically 10°C, 20°C, 30°C, 40°C, 50°C, and 60°C.
Figure 7 presents the corresponding drying curves for ginger rhizomes over a 2 – 24-hour period, demonstrating the impact and effect of temperature on the dehydration characteristics of different sizes and shapes of ginger rhizomes under blanched, unblanched, peeled, and unpeeled conditions. As expected, an increase in drying temperature results in a rise in moisture content. However, high-temperature drying leads to considerable quality loss, including shrinkage in the sample. Ginger dried at 50°C and 60°C exhibits overall discolouration, indicating that ginger rhizomes dried at elevated temperatures are prone to changes in colour and shape.
Figure 8 reveals that ginger is susceptible to drying at higher temperatures, as ginger dried at 50°C – 60°C exhibits surface darkening or colour changes. Therefore, any temperature higher than 60°C should not be considered for future drying processes. In addition, industrial practices suggest a range of 60°C - 70°C as the maximum limit for drying ginger rhizomes, and research conducted by Hogue et al. [
27] supports this, demonstrating a relatively high drying rate at 70°C using a solar hybrid dryer.
The impact of various drying conditions and factors is evaluated under different temperatures and durations.
Figure 7 illustrates the correlation between moisture content and drying time, indicating that moisture content escalates with extended drying time and increased temperature. This observed relationship aligns with studies conducted by Ndukwu [
28] and Jayas & Sokhansanj [
29], which affirm the significant effect of temperature on the dehydration of ginger rhizomes, particularly at lower temperatures ranging from 10°C to 20°C. Its influence was relatively insignificant despite the constant humidity maintained during drying.
In terms of colour, a higher drying temperature not exceeding 60°C and lower final moisture content resulted in minimal or no discolouration of the product, as reported by Lu-angmalawata et al. [
30] and Attanasio et al. [
31]. Thermal treatments led to alterations in the product, giving rise to different physical structures due to shrinkage, which affected the overall shapes and sizes after drying. This change was particularly noticeable in blanched, unblanched, peeled and unpeeled ginger at temperatures between 40°C and 60°C, and drying times of 16 to 24 hours, with blanched ginger showing the most noticeable change.
Unblanched sliced ginger was dried from an initial moisture content of 88.84% to 49.55% (wb) at 10°C, 86.55% to 47.81% (wb) at 20°C, 87.34% to 39.55% (wb) at 30°C, 79.32% to 30.12% (wb) at 40°C, 71.65% to 17.85% (wb) at 50°C, and 74.16% to 6.63% (wb) at 60°C.
Blanched ginger's moisture content ranged from 84.58% to 41.13% (wb) at 10°C, 86.29% to 34.26% (wb) at 20°C, 86.65% to 17.48% (wb) at 30°C, 70.11% to 17.00% (wb) at 40°C, 66.64% to 10.25% (wb) at 50°C, and 63.11% to 9.04% (wb) at 60°C.
Peeled ginger showed similar variations, with moisture content shifting from 88.74% to 55.91% (wb) at 10°C, 87.85% to 37.49% (wb) at 20°C, 87.95% to 27.76% (wb) at 30°C, 75.93% to 23.92% (wb) at 40°C, 65.50% to 13.21% (wb) at 50°C, and 70.75% to 5.98% (wb) at 60°C.
Unpeeled sliced ginger displayed a trend of increasing moisture content as temperature and drying time rose. The moisture content for unpeeled ginger was measured as 91.08% to 62.22% (wb) at 10°C, 86.17% to 48.36% (wb) at 20°C, 87.71% to 31.15% (wb) at 30°C, 81.46% to 26.30% (wb) at 40°C, 67.85% to 15.49% (wb) at 50°C, and 74.36% to 5.98% (wb) at 60°C.
The results above describe how the moisture content of ginger rhizomes - in unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled forms - changes when drying at different temperatures. The moisture content is expressed on a wet basis (wb), which refers to the amount of moisture present in a sample relative to the total weight of the sample (including the moisture). This means, for instance, that an initial moisture content of 88.84% (wb) indicates that 88.84% of the total weight of the sample is due to moisture.
As the temperature of the drying process increases, from 10°C to 60°C, the moisture content in each type of ginger rhizome decreases. For example, the moisture content of unblanched ginger decreases from 88.84% to 49.55% (wb) at 10°C and from 74.16% to 6.63% (wb) at 60°C. This pattern is observed across all the ginger forms tested, whether unblanched, blanched, peeled, or unpeeled. The specific values vary, but the trend remains the same: as temperature increases, moisture content decreases.
It's important to note that the drying process and the subsequent decrease in moisture content can affect the ginger's texture, flavour, and thermal conductivity, which is why this process is often controlled in food processing applications.
Using environmental chambers, we noted fluctuations in the moisture content following a preliminary drying period spanning 2 to 24 hours.
Figure 9 and
Figure 10 suggest that as the drying temperature rises, the speed at which ginger rhizomes dry also increases.
4.3. Effect of Moisture Content on Thermal Properties of Dried Ginger Rhizomes
The moisture content substantially affects the thermal attributes of dried ginger rhizomes. As the rhizomes' moisture content shifts throughout the drying process, their thermal properties, such as thermal conductivity, specific heat, and thermal diffusivity, also change. Grasping the impact of moisture content on these properties is vital for refining drying methods and predicting drying patterns.
Thermal Conductivity: The thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes strongly correlates with their moisture content. Higher moisture content typically leads to higher thermal conductivity values, as water is a more effective heat conductor than the solid elements of ginger. As the moisture content dwindles during the drying process, the thermal conductivity of the dried ginger rhizomes also lessens. This change in thermal conductivity can impact heat transfer and overall drying rates, influencing drying duration and energy utilisation.
Specific Heat: Specific heat denotes the amount of heat necessary to elevate the temperature of a unit mass of a substance by one degree Celsius. The moisture content influences the specific heat of ginger rhizomes, given that water has a higher specific heat than solid constituents. As the moisture content diminishes, the specific heat of the dried ginger rhizomes also declines, translating into less heat needed to increase the material's temperature during drying.
Thermal Diffusivity: Thermal diffusivity assesses the speed at which heat can be disseminated through a material. It is influenced by the material's thermal conductivity, specific heat, and density. As the moisture content of ginger rhizomes lessens, the thermal conductivity and specific heat decline while the density augments. These alterations can decrease thermal diffusivity, signifying that heat transfer through the dried ginger rhizomes becomes less effective as the drying process advances.
In summary, the moisture content of ginger rhizomes has a notable impact on their thermal properties, encompassing thermal conductivity, specific heat, and thermal diffusivity. Understanding the correlation between moisture content and thermal properties is vital for enhancing drying methods, minimising energy use, and preserving the quality of the final dried product.
The thermal attributes of ginger rhizomes are crucial in developing drying, processing, and storage apparatus. Accordingly, the thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes was measured based on moisture content using linear conduction experimental equipment. Statistics indicate that Nigeria produced 136,730 metric tons of ginger between 2000 – 2012, and 45% succumbed to disease attacks [11]. The moisture content and thermal conductivity ranged from 88.84% to 49.55% (wb) at 10°C for 2 - 24 hours to 74.36% to 5.98% (wb) at 60°C for the same duration. These increases in moisture content are also noticeable for 30°C - 60°C, exhibiting similar patterns as depicted in
Figure 7. The thermal conductivity of this product ranged from 0.4064W/m. K at 10°C and 2 hours to 0.0553W/m. K at 60°C and 24 hours.
This relationship, as demonstrated in
Figure 7, aligns with the findings of other researchers such as Bart-Plange et al. [
32] for cowpea and maise, Perusulla, Viviana, & Mends [
33] for banana Isa, Oladele & Akinlade [
34] for egusi melon and Singh & Goswani [
35] for cumin seeds. Kurozawa, Park & Azonbel [
30] also noted this correlation between thermal conductivity and moisture content, finding that the thermal conductivity of cashew apples rose from 0.57 to 0.61W/m. K (6.6%) within 25°C – 45°C.
The thermal conductivity of unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled samples reveals that thermal conductivity enhances as moisture content escalates. This rise in thermal conductivity with moisture content can be attributed to the increase in water molecules within a ginger rhizomes sample as the moisture content grows, filling the pores within the ginger sample and amplifying its ability to conduct more heat. This suggests the sample's thermal energy intake was significantly high at lower temperatures. However, the thermal energy dwindled at a higher temperature level due to its lower moisture content. Also, as water has higher thermal conductivity than dried ginger rhizomes, it contributes to fresh ginger's high thermal conductivity. The colour measurements of ginger rhizomes are beyond the purview of this research.
Results illustrated in Figs. 11 – 14 show that thermal conductivity increments as the moisture content rises. Higher inlet drying temperature and time generally resulted in a reduction in moisture content. It is often observed that the greater the temperature disparity among particles, the more efficient the evaporation rate [12]. Similar outcomes have been reported by Chegini & Ghobadian [
36] for sweet potato puree, Goula, Adamopoulos, & Kazakis [
37] for dried tomato paste, Abadio et al. [
38] for pineapple juice and Phoungchandang & Sertwasana [
39] for ginger powders. This result aligns with the work by Ikechukwu et al. [
40,
41], Wang et al. [
42], Alibas [
2], Kaya et al. [
3], and Osae et al. [
32].
The data gathered confirms that as the moisture content increases, the drying of ginger rhizomes quickly leads to the hardening of the surface. This phenomenon diminishes the rate of thermal conductivity. This is because the hardened surface is a poor conductor of heat.
For unblanched ginger, the thermal conductivity at 10°C declined from 0.4064W/m. K to 0.1607 W/m. K, at 20°C from 0.4064W/m. K to 0.1491 W/m. K, at 30°C from 0.1074W/m. K to 0.0677 W/m. K, at 40°C from 0.0756W/m. K to 0.0557 W/m. K, at 50°C from 0.0715W/m. K to 0.0541 W/m. K, and at 60°C from 0.0762W/m. K to 0.0553 W/m. K. These measurements were recorded over-drying periods of 2, 4, 8, 10, 14, 16, and 24 hours.
Similar trends were detected for blanched ginger, with thermal conductivity at 10°C dropping from 0.3290W/m. K to 0.1400 W/m. K, at 20°C from 0.2919W/m. K to 0.1312 W/m. K, at 30°C from 0.1006W/m. K to 0.0689W/m. K, at 40°C from 0.0707W/m. K to 0.0562 W/m. K, at 50°C from 0.0730W/m. K to 0.0556 W/m. K, and at 60°C from 0.0836W/m. K to 0.0516 W/m. K.
Likewise, peeled ginger saw declines in thermal conductivity at 10°C from 0.3768W/m. K to 0.1449 W/m. K, at 20°C from 0.3768W/m. K to 0.1391 W/m. K, at 30°C from 0.1459W/m. K to 0.0652W/m. K, at 40°C from 0.0717W/m. K to 0.0516 W/m. K, at 50°C from 0.0759W/m. K to 0.0519W/m. K, and at 60°C from 0.0791W/m. K to 0.0483 W/m. K.
For unpeeled ginger, the thermal conductivity at 10°C lessened from 0.3397W/m. K to 0.1713 W/m. K, at 20°C from 0.3454W/m. K to 0.1713 W/m. K, at 30°C from 0.1126W/m. K to 0.0611W/m. K, at 40°C from 0.0717W/m. K to 0.0543 W/m. K, at 50°C from 0.0776W/m. K to 0.0460W/m. K, and at 60°C from 0.0776W/m. K to 0.0460 W/m. K. These measurements were taken over 2 to 24 hours of drying.
The results present an experiment measuring ginger rhizomes' thermal conductivity in different states (unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled) at varying temperatures. Thermal conductivity measures a material's ability to conduct heat, expressed in watts per meter-Kelvin (W/m.K).
The research study concludes that the drying process significantly impacts the thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes, with substantial decreases observed across all conditions tested. Notably, unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled ginger samples all experienced reductions in thermal conductivity by 86.39%, 84.32%, 87.18%, and 86.46%, respectively. These percentages reflect the changes from the initial measurement at 10℃ to the final state at 60℃. The reduction in thermal conductivity aligns with the decrease in moisture content throughout the drying process. As water conducts heat more effectively than the solid components of ginger, this moisture loss consequently leads to diminished thermal conductivity in the rhizomes.
The various pre-processing treatments can explain the disparity in thermal conductivity reductions among the different ginger samples. The blanching process partially softens the tissue of the rhizomes, potentially leading to more efficient heat transfer and hence a slightly smaller reduction in thermal conductivity. On the other hand, peeling ginger exposes more of its surface area, allowing for more rapid moisture loss. This increased drying rate results in a lower final moisture content and a higher reduction in thermal conductivity. Thus, the study underscores the significant influence of both the drying process and pre-processing treatments on the thermal conductivity of ginger rhizomes.
Our research showed that the thermal conductivity of all forms of ginger rhizomes decreases consistently with increased drying time across all tested temperatures (10°C to 60°C). This can be attributed to "case hardening," where rapid surface drying forms a crust, reducing overall heat conduction. However, the exact rates of thermal conductivity reduction varied depending on factors such as initial moisture content, the heat treatment process, and the ginger's physical characteristics.
Overall, the results demonstrate the drying process's significant impact on ginger rhizomes' thermal conductivity, with different pre-processing treatments resulting in varied reductions in thermal conductivity. Understanding these changes is essential for optimising drying processes, minimising energy consumption, and maintaining the quality of the final dried product. The results obtained are in agreement with work reported by Jayashree, Visvanathan, & John [
44] for peeled and unpeeled ginger and Jiřičková, Pavlík, & Černý [
45] for biological agricultural materials.
4.4. A Comparative Analysis of Drying Characteristics Between Nigerian Ginger Rhizomes and Other Varieties
Ginger (Zingiber officinale), a widely consumed spice, encompasses various cultivars cultivated worldwide, including Nigerian ginger rhizomes. Distinct growing conditions, climates, and genetic factors contribute to differences in the drying characteristics observed among ginger rhizomes from different cultivars. The drying characteristics of ginger are subject to variation based on the cultivar and the conditions in which it is grown. Several factors, such as initial moisture content, skin thickness, and inherent properties, come into play when examining these characteristics.
Initial moisture content: The moisture content of freshly harvested ginger varies depending on the specific cultivar, growing conditions, and the maturity stage at harvest time. The initial moisture content significantly impacts the drying process, including the required drying time and the appropriate drying method. Higher moisture content generally necessitates longer drying periods or more intense drying techniques. As a result, Nigerian ginger may exhibit different moisture content than other cultivars, consequently influencing its drying characteristics.
Skin thickness: The thickness of the ginger's skin also influences the drying process. A thicker skin can impede moisture's evaporation during drying, prolonging the drying time. Additionally, skin thickness may affect crucial quality aspects of the dried product, such as its colour, texture, and flavour. Nigerian ginger might have a distinctive skin thickness compared to other cultivars, impacting its drying characteristics accordingly.
Inherent properties: Each ginger cultivar possesses inherent properties, including size, shape, density, oil content, and chemical composition. These properties can significantly impact the rate and efficiency of the drying process. For instance, ginger rhizomes with higher oil content tend to dry more slowly due to the hygroscopic nature of oils. Similarly, larger or denser rhizomes might require more time to dry than smaller or less dense ones.
In summary, the drying characteristics of ginger rhizomes vary among different cultivars due to factors such as initial moisture content, skin thickness, and inherent properties. Understanding these variations is essential for optimising the drying process and achieving desired quality attributes in the dried ginger product.
This paper compares the drying characteristics of Nigerian ginger rhizomes with other cultivars to provide insights into their performance in terms of drying time, energy consumption, and product quality.
Drying Time: Nigerian ginger rhizomes, like other cultivars, exhibit a typical drying curve with a rapid initial drying rate followed by a slower, more gradual decrease in moisture content. However, Nigerian ginger rhizomes may have a shorter drying time than other cultivars due to their thinner skin and lower initial moisture content. In contrast, cultivars with higher initial moisture content or thicker skin may require a longer drying time to reach the desired final moisture level.
Energy Consumption: The energy consumption during the drying process depends on factors such as initial moisture content, drying temperature, and air velocity. Nigerian ginger rhizomes consume less energy during drying than other cultivars with higher initial moisture content or those requiring higher drying temperatures to achieve similar drying rates. Efficient drying strategies can be employed to minimise energy consumption for all cultivars.
Product Quality: The quality of dried ginger rhizomes is influenced by drying conditions, processing techniques, and the cultivar. Nigerian ginger rhizomes are known for their pungent aroma and high oleoresin content, contributing to their desirable flavour and medicinal properties. While the drying process may lead to some loss of volatile compounds, the quality of Nigerian ginger rhizomes can be maintained by optimising drying conditions, such as temperature and air velocity, to minimise these losses. Other cultivars may exhibit different quality attributes, which should also be considered when optimising drying processes.
The drying characteristics of Nigerian ginger rhizomes differ from those of other cultivars due to factors such as initial moisture content, skin thickness, and inherent properties. Understanding these differences is essential for optimising drying processes and ensuring high-quality ginger products. Future research could investigate the drying kinetics of various ginger cultivars and develop models that accurately predict drying behaviour, energy consumption, and product quality.
4.5. Analysis of Drying Curves
The obtained drying curves for all conditions indicate that the drying process can only be accelerated up to a certain limit. Beyond this limit, the drying process remains unaffected by external conditions, such as room temperatures, primarily governed by moisture diffusion within the product. To increase the drying rate during this period, it is necessary to raise the temperature to around 50°C – 60°C. This temperature increase will enhance the diffusion rate and potentially lead to an elevation in the drying air temperature within the chamber. However, it is crucial to note that a significant increase in air temperature would further deteriorate the product's quality. The thermal conductivity curve reveals a correlation between the final moisture content of the product and its thermal conductivity, as depicted in
Figure 11 and
Figure 12.
Thermal conductivity, which is the ability of a material to conduct heat, is a multifaceted characteristic influenced by various factors. In the specific case of drying ginger rhizomes addressed in this study, the thermal conductivity relies on the material's matrix and the amount of water it contains, as evident from Figures 11 to 14.
There are several reasons for the correlation between increased moisture content and higher thermal conductivity, primarily associated with the properties of water itself:
High thermal conductivity of water: Water possesses a higher thermal conductivity compared to many common substances found in ginger rhizomes, such as organic compounds. Consequently, as the water content within the rhizome increases, it enhances the efficient transfer of heat, thereby elevating the effective thermal conductivity of the material.
Continuity of the water phase: Water molecules are dispersed and isolated within the material at low moisture content. However, as the moisture content rises, these dispersed water molecules can form a continuous phase, creating pathways for more effective heat conduction.
Evaporative cooling: The process of water evaporation requires latent heat energy. This phenomenon aids in distributing heat efficiently throughout the material, which can be interpreted as an increase in thermal conductivity.
Water as a bridge: Water can act as a bridge between solid particles, enhancing contact between them and facilitating heat conduction.
Volume expansion: Water tends to expand when heated, and in a porous material like ginger rhizomes, this expansion can lead to an overall expansion of the material itself. Consequently, the structure of the rhizome can change, potentially creating more pathways for heat conduction.
During the drying of ginger rhizomes, the initial stages may exhibit increased thermal conductivity as the easily accessible water is removed, aiding in heat conduction. As the drying process progresses, tightly bound water within the material matrix is eliminated, which can decrease the thermal conductivity. Hence, the relationship between moisture content and thermal conductivity can be intricate and dependent on the specific drying stage.
Figure 13 and
Figure 14 depict a decreasing trend in the thermal conductivity of unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled ginger over time. The highest thermal conductivity is observed at the 2-hour mark, significantly declining until the 24-hour drying time. These trends are most notable at temperatures between 10°C and 20°C, with a marked decrease between 30°C and 60°C for the various ginger samples.
In this study, the drying curves of ginger rhizomes exhibit three notable phases:
Preheating Phase: This initial phase involves heating the ginger rhizomes to the drying air temperature. The moisture removal rate during this phase remains relatively low as the heat predominantly elevates the ginger samples' temperature.
Constant Rate Drying Phase: This phase transpires when the moisture removal rate remains steady, influenced primarily by external factors such as temperature, humidity, and air speed. Here, moisture from the surface of the ginger rhizomes is readily evaporated while moisture within the samples moves to the surface, maintaining a constant drying rate. A linear trend on the drying curve typically marks this phase.
Falling Rate Drying Phase: This phase commences when the moisture removal rate begins to decline due to internal factors like reduced moisture content and increased resistance to moisture migration within the ginger samples. The drying curve displays a gradual reduction in the drying rate during this phase, ultimately arriving at an equilibrium moisture content. This falling rate drying phase can be further categorised into two sub-phases:
a)
First Falling Rate Period: This period is defined by a slight decrease in the drying rate as the moisture migration from within the ginger rhizomes to the surface becomes the constraining factor.
b)
Second Falling Rate Period: During this period, the drying rate decelerates even more as the residual moisture is more tightly bonded to the solid constituents of the ginger, and the resistance to moisture migration becomes progressively stronger.
Interpreting these drying curves for ginger rhizomes yields crucial insights into these agricultural commodities' drying characteristics and kinetics. By grasping the various stages of the drying process and the factors influencing the drying rate, researchers can refine drying conditions, reduce energy use, and ensure the quality of the final dried product.
4.6. Impact of Air Temperature During Drying on Ginger Rhizomes
The drying air temperature plays a crucial role in influencing the drying curves of agricultural products, including ginger rhizomes. A drying curve plots the moisture content of the product against the drying time, indicating how quickly the product dries under specific conditions, as presented in Figs. 7 and 8.
As the drying air temperature increases, the rate of evaporation generally rises, leading to a steeper drying curve. This indicates a faster decrease in the moisture content over time. Therefore, higher temperatures often result in shorter drying times.
However, the relationship between drying air temperature and the drying curve is not strictly linear. As temperature rises beyond a certain point, the moisture removal rate plateau or decreases due to internal limitations in the product, such as the diffusion rate of water to the surface. Therefore, an optimal drying air temperature usually maximises the moisture removal rate without negatively affecting the product quality.
For the ginger rhizome studied in this work, the optimal drying air temperature was found to be 60°C. At this temperature, the convective drying process effectively reduced the rhizomes' moisture content while preserving their quality, as reflected by a balanced drying curve and the resulting thermal conductivity values.
Moreover, excessively high drying air temperatures might degrade the quality of the product, causing changes in colour, texture, and nutritional value, thereby affecting the overall acceptability of the product. Hence, balancing rapid drying and product quality maintenance is vital when determining the optimal drying air temperature.
Further, the drying curves at different air temperatures also provide valuable insights into the energy efficiency of the drying process. Analysing these curves allows fine-tuning the drying process to ensure minimal energy usage while achieving the desired final moisture content.
4.7. Impact of the Drying Process on Ginger Rhizomes
Building on the core findings, the study's in-depth investigation into the drying process of ginger rhizomes reveals critical nuances about their condition and quality. The thermal properties of the rhizomes shift significantly during drying, with a primary change being a decrease in thermal conductivity as moisture content reduces, as presented in Figs. 11 and 12. This relationship is crucial in understanding drying kinetics and developing effective drying strategies.
The efficiency of the convective drying method stands out among other techniques like open sun drying or solar tunnel drying. With convective drying, rhizomes achieve optimal dryness in just 24 hours, contrasting to nine days in the open sun drying and eight days in solar tunnel drying. The study also identifies a significant role of temperature in the drying process. A drying temperature of 60°C is ideal for preserving the quality of the ginger rhizomes while ensuring energy efficiency.
The study identified unique optimal moisture content when examining different ginger rhizomes – unblanched, blanched, peeled, and unpeeled. For example, unblanched ginger has an optimal moisture content of 6.63% and a thermal conductivity of 0.0553W/m.K. Blanching increases the ideal moisture content to 9.04%. Still, the thermal conductivity drops slightly to 0.0516W/m.K. Peeling the ginger further adjusts these parameters, with an optimal moisture content of 8.56% and thermal conductivity of 0.0483W/m.K. Lastly, unpeeled ginger has the lowest moisture content and thermal conductivity, at 5.98% and 0.0460W/m.K, respectively.
A reduction in thermal conductivity as the drying process proceeds indicates that ginger rhizomes become less efficient at conducting heat as they dry. The more moisture the rhizome contains, the more thermal energy is necessary to dry it, impacting drying time and energy consumption.
Our findings hold significant implications for the food industry, with the potential to catalyse the development of more energy-efficient and enhanced drying processes for ginger rhizomes. Moreover, the insights gathered open the prospect of application to other agricultural products and drying techniques. However, the expansion of these possibilities necessitates further research. Our study establishes a firm groundwork for future explorations in this domain, aspiring to optimise these processes for various product types to engineer energy-efficient drying methods that uphold product quality and minimise wastage in the agricultural sector.
Looking ahead, we recommend several paths for further inquiry. Future research should incorporate a wider variety of ginger from disparate regions to garner a more holistic understanding of the drying behaviour across different ginger types. It's also essential to extend investigations to consider other parameters, such as the influence of drying on colour, texture, and nutritional value. Comparative studies involving convective drying and other techniques, including sun drying, solar drying, or freeze drying, could unveil the most efficient and effective method. Additionally, examining the quality and shelf-life of dried ginger during long-term storage could provide valuable insights. Lastly, an optimisation study to identify the best drying conditions - such as temperature, humidity, and air velocity - could significantly contribute to maximising energy efficiency and product quality. These suggestions seek to redress the limitations of our current study and provide broader, more comprehensive insights into the drying process of ginger rhizomes.