1. Introduction
The
Sry-related HMG-box (
Sox) family is a group of transcriptional regulators defined by the presence of a highly conserved high-mobility group (HMG) domain that mediates DNA binding [
1]. This domain was first identified as a male determinant in eutherian mammals, which is called the sex-determining region on the Y chromosome (
Sry) [
2,
3]. Since then, numerous
Sox proteins were identified and analyzed, and the presence of
Sox genes has now been established in almost all metazoans [
4]. Based on homology within the HMG domain and structural features outside the domain, the
Sox gene family can be subdivided into groups A to K [
5]. It has been shown extensively in vertebrates and invertebrates that the
Sox family genes are involved in the regulation of many important developmental processes, such as sex determination and differentiation, cell type specification, neurogenesis, and organogenesis. [
4,
6]
Among the many functions of
Sox genes, regulation of sexual development has been the focus of much attention for aquatic animals, particularly in fish. This is not only because aquatic animals often have diverse reproductive strategies and sex determination systems, but also because they exhibit substantial sexual dimorphism, which is closely linked to several economic traits, including growth rate and body size [
7]. To date, multiple
Sox genes have been implicated in the regulation of sex determination, sex differentiation and gonadal development in fish, although their specific roles may vary between species [
6]. Most of these
Sox genes showed sexually dimorphic expression in the gonads, and in some cases, sex reversal could be achieved through the genetic manipulation of a single
Sox gene [
8,
9,
10].
The most extensively studied
Sox genes in fish are probably the members of group E, represented by
Sox8,
Sox9, and
Sox10 [
6]. In mammals,
Sox9 has been proposed as a gene downstream of
Sry because it is capable of determining male sex in the absence of
Sry [
11].
Sox8 resembles
Sox9 in its expression profile and biochemical properties, and can partly substitute for
Sox9 [
12].
Sox10 is also involved in male determination with the ability to activate the transcriptional target of
Sox9 [
13]. Despite the diverse sex-forming mechanisms, numerous studies have shown that
Sox8 and
Sox9 are also important for male development in fish [
6].
Sox9 is specifically expressed in testis in many gonochoristic fish species [
14,
15,
16], and in the sequentially hermaphroditic orange-spotted grouper
Epinephelus coioides, the
Sox9 mRNA increased during the female-to-male transition, suggesting a role in testis differentiation [
17]. So far, reports of
Sox10 in fish are very limited, but it seems to be a multifunctional gene that is expressed in the gonads of both sexes [
18].
As another important group of aquatic animals, crustaceans also have variable sex determination systems, although the mechanisms involved are poorly understood. Nevertheless, it has been widely accepted that the male differentiation of crustaceans is controlled by an insulin-like androgenic gland hormone (IAG) secreted by the male-specific androgenic gland (AG) [
19]. Several transcriptional binding sites for
Sox were predicted upstream of IAG genes in the oriental river prawn
Macrobrachium nipponense [
20,
21], implying the involvement of
Sox genes in the sexual development of crustaceans. Similar to mammals and fishes, the
SoxE members was also proposed as sex-related factors in crustaceans. The mRNA of a
SoxE gene was mainly located in oocytes and spermatocytes of oriental river prawn, and its expression in males was significantly higher than in females during post-larval development [
22]. In the mud crab,
Scylla paramamosain,
Sox9 was shown to positively regulate the expression of vitellogenesis-inhibiting hormone (VIH) by directly binding to the promoter region, and its RNA silencing resulted in significant decrease of VIH as well as increase of vitellogenin expression in ovary and hepatopancreas of a mature female [
23]. However, the regulatory relationship between
SoxE and IAG has not been demonstrated previously.
The swimming crab, Portunus trituberculatus, is an economically important crab species in southeast China, and has been extensively artificially propagated and cultivated. Elucidating the mechanism of sex development will be beneficial to develop sex control technology, which is essential for the aquaculture industry. In the present study, a male-specific SoxE was characterized in P. trituberculatus, and its transcriptional interaction with IAG was revealed using RNA interference and mock IAG treatment. In addition, the putative role and mechanism of SoxE on testicular development was investigated.
4. Discussion
In this study, a
Sox family gene sequence hallmarked with a HMG domain was identified in the swimming crab,
P. trituberculatus. Multiple sequence alignment showed that the obtained DNA sequence shares high identities with the known
SoxE family sequences of crustaceans, and that their HMG domains are highly conserved, thus designating the focal gene as
PtSoxE. We noted that many
SoxE sequences of crustaceans were designated as
Sox9, but this may not be rigorous. In vertebrates, the
SoxE subfamily mainly consist of
Sox8,
Sox9, and
Sox10, whereas in invertebrates, only one or two
SoxE sequences were identified within a species. In an early report, the
Drosophila Sox100B gene was clustered into
SoxE branch but separated from mouse
Sox8,
Sox9, and
Sox10 [
6,
8,
28]. Our phylogenetic analysis supports the separation of vertebrate and invertebrate
SoxE proteins, and apparently, invertebrate
SoxE genes can be referred as orthologues of vertebrate
Sox8,
9, and
10, but cannot be specifically classified into any one of these groups.
Tissue distribution analysis showed that
PtSoxE was expressed exclusively in male tissues of
P. trituberculatus, suggesting that it may play an important role in male sexual development. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of male-specific expression of the
SoxE gene in crustaceans. In two other reports, the
SoxE genes from the mud crab
S. paramamosain and the oriental freshwater prawn
M. nipponense were expressed in both sexes, and both ovarian- and testicular-related roles were proposed [
22,
29]. This difference in expression and function seems difficult to explain given that the highly conserved DNA-binding domains (HMG domains) may lead to similar transcriptional regulatory mechanisms. However, it is the case that the expression patterns and physiological functions of fish
SoxE genes also varies considerably across species. For instance, in the gonochoristic fishes, many studies have shown that
Sox9 is expressed specifically in testis, but its biased expression in ovaries has not been uncommon [
6].
The
PtSoxE transcripts were found to be most abundant in AG, which gives rise to the possibility that it may be related to the IAG. Although potential transcription factor binding sites for Sox proteins had been predicted in the 5'-flanking region of
M. nipponense IAG [
20,
21], the regulatory effect of
Sox members on IAG was not previously reported. The siRNA treatments in the present study showed that
PtSoxE silencing led to reduction in IAG expression in AG and testis, which suggested the
PtSoxE might be an upstream regulator of IAG. As an insulin-like peptide, it has been widely accepted that the molecular action of IAG achieved through the classical IIS pathway [
30,
31,
32]. In our previous report, treatment with IAG dsRNA caused significant decrease in the expression of several IIS pathway genes, such as
IR,
IGFBP-rp,
Akt, and
mTOR [
24]. In AG explants, these IIS pathway genes were also down-regulated by
PtSoxE silencing. One explanation for this might be the reduction in IAG signaling induced by siRNA treatment, but firm conclusion requires the demonstration of whether
PtSoxE has a direct regulatory role on these IIS pathway genes.
In its annual pattern of expression,
PtSoxE in AG was highly expressed in August and October, and the AG was in the secretory phase during this period [
33]; as the same time, the August and October also are the peak periods of testis development [
24], that suggest
PtSoxE may have an important regulatory role in male reproductive development. However, according to a previous study by our group, the highest expression of
PtIAG occurs during the synthesis phase of AG, which is the time period from May to July [
34]. This inconsistency suggested that other mechanisms may be involved in the regulation of IAG expression, but also raised the question about whether IAG affects
PtSoxE expression. Treatments with AG homogenate and rIAG (35 nM) showed a stimulatory regulation of IAG on
PtSoxE, and the induced expression of IIS pathway genes inferred a putative activation mechanism. Interestingly, high concentrations of IAG (350 nM) exhibited no effect on
PtSoxE expression. Since the hemolymph titer of IAG in
P. trituberculatus has not been reported, the physiological significance of this result is unclear.
Although tissue distribution analysis did not show high levels of
PtSoxE in the testis, the annual pattern of expression suggested that this may be related to the period in which the samples were collected. High expression of
PtSoxE was observed in August and October, a period of rapid spermatogenesis and testicular development. The result was similar to that for
Sox9 from
S. paramamosain, whose mRNA level was most abundant at the spermatid stage during testicular development [
29]. In mammals and fishes, the
SoxE family genes have shown their involvement in differentiation and development of testis [
6,
12], and in crustaceans, this function seems to be conserved. Our results showed that silencing of
PtSoxE led to the downregulation of several reported spermatogenesis-related genes, including
KIFC-1 [
35],
Vasa [
36],
CyclinB [
37] and
Cdc-2 [
38], and vice versa when
PtSoxE expression was activated, providing molecular evidence of the testicular development role of
PtSoxE.