1. Introduction
Donor human milk (DHM) is considered the best feeding option for preterm infants when their mother´s own milk is not available. Its use is increasing in neonatal units, primarily for infants at high risk of developing necrotizing enterocolitis or feeding intolerance, such as those weighing <1500 g and/or those at less than 32 weeks of gestational age (GA), infants with congenital heart disease, or those with severe intestinal disorders [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5]. These infants are in a situation of "nutritional emergency"; therefore, knowledge of the essential nutrients in DHM and research into the factors contributing to its composition should be a priority.
According to studies carried out in different geographical areas of the world, there is evidence that the content of fatty acids (FAs) and some micronutrients in human milk (HM) depends on the maternal deposits of each nutrient at the end of gestation and maternal intake during the lactation period [
6,
7,
8,
9]. However, most studies have assessed the FA profile while information on micronutrients is much more limited.
In this respect, micronutrients can be classified in a simplified way into two groups with respect to their secretion patterns in milk in relation to maternal intake and maternal status and the response to supplementation. In general, water-soluble vitamins (except folate), fat-soluble vitamins, iodine, and selenium are considered to belong to a group of micronutrients for which their secretion into HM is dependent on maternal intake or status, and maternal supplementation may increase their concentrations in milk [
8,
9,
10,
11]. Accordingly, priority nutrients for breastfeeding women include thiamine, riboflavin, vitamins B6, B12, vitamin A, and iodine [
12]. The behavior of vitamin E is somewhat different, as neither plasma or serum concentrations nor the maternal intake of vitamin E by ingesting the usual diet affects the vitamin E concentration in HM, although studies have shown increased levels of alpha-tocopherol in colostrum in situations of supplementation [
7,
13]. On the other hand, the concentration in the HM of folate and other minerals and trace elements remains relatively unaffected by maternal intake or status, although the mother may become depleted when her nutrient intake is lower than necessary; maternal supplementation with the nutrients of this second group is particularly beneficial for the mother rather than for her infant [
8,
9,
10,
11,
12]. Nevertheless, the results of the different surveys on this topic were not always concordant [
7], and the authors of two systematic reviews on this topic [
8,
9] highlighted the small sample size and the large heterogeneity of the studies.
In addition, women's diets vary over time and according to the country in which they live and their cultural environment [
14,
15,
16,
17]. For this reason, it is essential to have updated references in each country on the nutrients in HM.
Moreover, HM is a very complex and dynamic fluid, and its nutritional composition depends not only on maternal or infant factors but also on the chronobiology of HM (i.e., it varies with the stage of lactation, the time of day, the length of time elapsed between feedings, the time within the feeding, and the circadian rhythm) [
7,
18,
19,
20,
21]. All these factors can act as confounders when studying changes in HM content in relation to diet or maternal nutritional status, which interferes with the interpretation of the data.
Furthermore, the findings in breast milk should not be extrapolated to DHM [
22]. Firstly, HM donors constitute a particular population for several reasons. Milk donors comprise a heterogeneous population of breastfeeding mothers in terms of the duration of pregnancy and stage of lactation. Studies carried out in Spain and other countries showed how the sociodemographic characteristics of donor women differ from that of the general population [
23]. Also, in addition to breastfeeding their own child, donors express surplus milk for donation, which might lead to increased maternal nutritional needs and a different nutritional milk profile. Secondly, DHM is subjected to procedures that may alter its nutritional profile [
22]. Therefore, because of the great importance of nutrition in the development of very preterm or critically ill newborns, it is essential to have information on the nutritional composition of the DHM and the factors that may influence it, such as diet, in order to improve our recommendations to donors. However, to our knowledge, the only study in which a dietary assessment of milk donors was performed is a randomized controlled trial of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) supplementation in human milk donors conducted in the United States [
24].
Hence, the aim of this study is to determine not only the composition of raw DHM but also the associations of dietary intake and nutrient status with micronutrient and lipid composition in the breast milk of a population of donors from a human milk bank in Madrid, Spain.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Study Design and Subjects
This is part of a cross-sectional observational study conducted at the Regional Human Milk Bank Aladina MGU (RHMB) at the “12 de Octubre” University Hospital in Madrid, Spain.
One of the main aims of this work was to study the correlations between intake, nutritional status, and human milk nutritional composition of lactating mothers. For this purpose, we recruited 3 groups of women: a) milk donors who donated milk to the RHMB at least once in the last 2 months, b) healthy vegetarian/vegan lactating mothers with a milk expression routine who were lactating 3 weeks or more postpartum, and c) mothers of very preterm and/or very low-birth weight infants—i.e., babies < 32 weeks gestational age and/or < 1500g—who were admitted to the neonatal unit of the “12 de Octubre” University Hospital at the time of the study and more than 3 weeks had elapsed after birth.
It was calculated that a sample of 115 participants (85 milk donors, 15 healthy lactating women on a vegetarian/vegan diet, and 15 mothers of preterm infants admitted to the neonatal unit) would guarantee estimates with sufficient precision for the models of the global study, in which 10 predictors of interest were included, the need of at least 10 cases per predictor was assumed, and an additional 5% was considered for possible losses.
Participants were recruited between August 2017 and February 2020. In the present manuscript, we report the data and results of the group of milk donors.
The study procedure was endorsed by the “12 de Octubre” University Hospital Clinical Research Ethics Committee (protocol code 15/269) and all participants provided written informed consent, which could be withdrawn at any time. Furthermore, the study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki.
2.2. Protocol Study
To date, two articles based on this project have been published, and they include further results, with one focusing on the study of iodine in the DHM [
25] and the other focusing on the comparison of the results of milk donors with those of vegetarian/vegan lactating women [
26]. Thus, the full study protocol and laboratory studies have been previously described in detail [
25,
26].
In summary, the study of participating donors comprised a health and socio-demographic survey; somatometric measurements; blood and urine determinations to study their nutritional status; a dietary study comprising a food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) and a 5-day weighed dietary record, taking into account the intake of pharmacological nutrient supplements; and a detailed study of the nutritional composition of their milk.
Within the following 15 days after blood and urine sample collection for assessment of baseline nutritional status, the 5-day dietary recording and the collection of the 5-day milk samples were carried out almost concomitantly for 6 days in a row, with milk collection starting 1 day after the start of the dietary recording and ending 1 day after the end of the dietary recording. As the purpose was to reproduce the conditions of the donors’ routine in terms of daily milk pumping, participants were asked not to change their expression routine, no request was made for a time schedule, and the same transparent glass containers were used as for donations. Milk could be expressed from one or both breasts, with the only requirement being a complete emptying of the breast. A 25 ml milk sample from each expression from days 2 to 5, which was collected in a transparent bottle under sterile conditions, and the complete milk extraction from the last day (day 6) without handling, were frozen at −20 °C at the donors' home. The only exception was the 3 donors with premature babies admitted to the neonatal unit, and they carried out an instance of 24-hour milk collection, taking an aliquot from each milk extraction from days 2 to 5. On day 6, they collected and froze one complete milk extraction in the same way as the other participants. Donors were requested to bring their dietary records and milk samples to the RHMB within the following 15 days after the study’s completion. Different milk samples of the same day were mixed and aliquoted at the RHMB, but the milk of different days was not mixed as the composition of the milk on each day was analyzed individually. After processing at the RHMB, plasma, erythrocytes, urine, and milk samples were frozen at −80 °C until analysis. The milk samples collected from days 2 to 5 were used for the study of vitamins and minerals, and the complete milk collection sample from day 6 was used for the integral characterization of the lipid fraction.
The data on the intake of food, beverages, and pharmacological nutrient supplements obtained from the 5-day dietary record were analyzed using DIAL® software (DIAL.EXE Version 3, February 2014, Alce Ingeniería, Madrid, Spain) to calculate the daily energy and nutrient intake [
27].
2.3. Nutrients Analysis
A full description of the analyses carried out for each of the nutrients is available in a previous paper, as mentioned above [
26]. The techniques used for the most important nutrients for this study are outlined below.
2.3.1. Fatty Acids Analysis
Lipid analyses were conducted by the Food Lipid Biomarkers and Health Group at the Institute of Food Science Research (CIAL, CSIC-UAM).
Fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) were directly prepared from the plasma and erythrocyte samples, without prior lipid extraction. However, in the case of the milk samples, previously obtained lipid extracts were used. Two independent derivatization processes were carried out for each sample following the direct acid–base methylation method. FAMEs analysis was performed by GC-MS using an Agilent 6890 series gas chromatograph, which was coupled to an Agilent 5973 series mass spectrometer (Agilent Technologies Inc., Palo Alto, CA, USA).
The lipid class profile, such as the distribution of neutral and polar lipids, the relative composition of phospholipids, and the molecular species of triacylglycerols, were determined in the milk samples from a randomly selected subgroup of 20 donors. After fat extraction from human milk samples, the separation and quantification of lipid classes was accomplished by using an HPLC evaporative light-scattering detector (ELSD), and the determination of TAG molecular species was carried out using GC-FID.
2.3.2. Vitamins and Minerals Analysis
Vitamins and mineral analyses were conducted by the NUTREN-Nutrigenomics Group of the Department of Experimental Medicine at the University of Lleida, Spain.
Water-Soluble Vitamins and Vitamin-B12-Associated Biomarkers
Water-soluble vitamins were studied in plasma, erythrocytes, and milk. Cobalamin was analyzed using a competitive immunoassay method (Ref. 33000, Acces B12 assay, Beckman Coulter, Brea, CA, USA). Plasmatic holotranscobalamin was determined by an immunoassay using an Active-B12 (Holotranscobalamin) ELISA kit (Ref. AX53101, IBL-International Gmbh, Hamburg Germany). The plasmatic homocysteine was determined by an enzymatic assay kit (Ref. 41057, Spinreact, Barcelona Spain). Methylmalonic acid was determined directly in the diluted urine samples by UPLC-MS/MS, following the procedure described by Boutin et al. (2020) [
28]. The glutathione reductase activity in erythrocytes was determined by an Abcam ab83461 assay kit (Abcam, Cambridge, UK). Ascorbic acid was determined by HPLC-DAD. The rest of the analysis for water-soluble vitamins was performed by UPLC–MS/MS.
Fat-Soluble Vitamins
Fat-soluble vitamins were studied in plasma and milk samples. The concentrations of retinol, α-tocopherol, and γ-tocopherol were analyzed by HPLC with a fluorescence and UV detector. Vitamin D metabolites were determined by UPLC electrospray ionization/tandem MS.
Minerals
Minerals were studied in urine and milk by ICP-MS.
2.3.3. Blood Biochemistry, Hemoglobin, and Urine Creatinine
Blood biochemistry was determined by the NUTREN-Nutrigenomics Group via enzymatic kinetic colorimetric methods. The total cholesterol, HDL and LDL cholesterol, and triacylglycerols were analysed via enzymatic assays (Refs. 1001090, 1001096, 41023, and 1001310, respectively; Spinreact, Barcelona, Spain). Hemoglobin was determined by the Drabkin colorimetric method following the manufacturer’s instructions from the commercial assay kit (Ref. 1001230, Spinreact, Barcelona, Spain). Urine creatinine was determined via the Jaffé colorimetric kinetic method using a commercial assay kit (Ref. 1001110, Spinreact, Barcelona, Spain).
2.4. Statistics
Statistical analysis was performed with the STATA 14 program.
For descriptive analysis, qualitative variables were reported as absolute and relative frequencies, and quantitative variables were reported as medians and interquartile range (IQR) or as means and standard deviation (SD), according to their distribution established by carrying out the Shapiro-Wilk normality test.
For the multivariate analysis of associations, multiple linear regressions (MLRs) were performed using each of the macro- and micronutrients in DHM as dependent variables; the independent variables were as follows: the clinical characteristics; the level of nutrients in donors’ plasma, erythrocytes, and urine; the results of intake from the FFQ; and the average intake of nutrients recorded by donors in the 5-day dietary record. The independent variables that had significant associations (p<0.05) with milk content in the bivariate analysis were entered into the models. Once the independent variables and their probable interactions were introduced in each of the models, the variables with p > 0.05 were removed, and confounding variables were evaluated until the most parsimonious model was obtained. Each model was diagnosed, and some outliers were removed to improve the fit.
4. Discussion
This cross-sectional study investigates the associations between lipids and micronutrients in raw DHM and the diet as well as the nutritional status of 113 milk donors from the Regional Human Milk Bank in Madrid, Spain. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in which these associations have been evaluated in the context of a human milk bank. For this purpose, donors completed an FFQ, provided a 5-day weighed dietary record, and collected milk for 5 consecutive days. In addition, somatometric measurements and nutrient determinations in donors’ erythrocytes, plasma, urine, and milk were performed.
One of the most important contributions of the present study is the demonstration of the association between donors’ DHA intake and donor’s DHA plasma levels, and the DHA content of the raw DHM. This finding is important because, in a recent study, the DHA levels were significantly lower in DHM than in the mother's own milk for preterm infants born before than 32 weeks of gestation, concluding that DHM provides an insufficient supply of DHA to very preterm infants [
77], which comprise an already DHA-deficient population [
78]. Our results are in line with the only study that determined the DHA content of DHM in relation to the DHA intake of milk donors. In that randomized controlled trial conducted in Ohio and published in 2013 [
24], milk donors supplemented with an algal-derived product providing a DHA dose of 1 g/day had significantly higher DHA content in their milk than baseline samples, and DHA content was more than four times higher than the placebo group after 14 days of supplementation. However, the sample size was very small, and the dietary intake of DHA at baseline was only 23 mg/day. In our observational study, the median donor’s DHA intake was 310 mg/day, and for every 1 g/day of DHA intake, the adjusted percentage of DHA in relation to fat in DHM increased by 0.38%. This increase is rather smaller than that reported by Makrides in 1996 [
79] in a randomized clinical study of maternal supplementation with preformed algae-derived DHA at different doses, where the DHA content of breast milk increased by 0.1% (g/100 g of fat) at approximately every 0.1 g DHA intake. In this sense, our approach adds information with respect to the real operating conditions of a milk bank without modifying the dietary and supplementation habits of the donors. Since pasteurization does not significantly affect the DHA content of DHM [
80,
81], it could be inferred that increasing donors’ DHA intake is a feasible strategy to achieve a higher DHA content in pasteurized DHM. In addition, we found a positive association between DHA intake and the percentage of omega-3 in the DHM. Enhanced donors’ DHA intake can be achieved by both increasing oily fish intake and/or pharmacological supplementation [
82]. In our previous study comparing the nutritional milk composition of vegetarian or vegan lactating women vs. omnivore human milk donors, the milk DHA content was one half in the vegetarian/vegan women group in relation to their lower intake of DHA [
26]. The availability of DHA supplements from algal oil offers vegetarian or vegan donors the possibility to increase their DHA intake from a plant-based source. On the other hand, we found no association between the content of DHA in DHM and the intake of its precursor, such as ⍺ -linolenic acid. In a previous study, supplementing mothers with flaxseed oil, which is very rich in linolenic acid, did not increase the DHA content of their milk [
83]. Thus, with the evidence available at present, it could be deduced that a method for increasing the DHA content of DHM from vegetarian/vegan mothers is the intake of algae-derived DHA supplements.
The association found between PUFA maternal intake and the PUFAs content in DHM was previously reported in the mature breast milk of non-donors during the first month of lactation [
84]. However, other correlations found in this study regarding lipid contents had not been identified before. The DHM linoleic acid content increased with its erythrocyte content as well as, interestingly, the combined intake of meat, fish, and eggs. The proportion of DHM MUFAs increased with plasma MUFA levels and the erythrocyte C17:1 level. The proportion of DHM SFAs increased with erythrocyte DMA content, plasma stearic acid, TFA intake, and breastfeeding time, but decreased with erythrocyte margaroleic acid content.
In terms of micronutrients, various associations were found between the donors’ diet/nutritional status and the DHM composition.
Regarding B-group vitamins, we found associations with the content of free thiamin, free riboflavin, and pyridoxal in milk. We were not able to demonstrate positive associations between the milk content of other B-group vitamins and maternal intake or plasma levels, although all of them (except folate) are considered to be dependent on diet and maternal stores [
11]. Free thiamine in DHM was positively associated with plasma thiamine levels and negatively associated with breastfeeding time and the daily intake of milk and milk product servings. Free riboflavin in DHM was positively associated with riboflavin intake and vitamin B2 supplementation during lactation. Pyridoxal in DHM was positively associated with vitamin B6 supplementation during pregnancy and negatively associated with breastfeeding time. In the literature, the content of these three vitamins in breast milk is strongly associated with maternal intake [
7,
8,
9,
85]. However, the influence of maternal nutritional status on milk content depends on whether the mother has adequate or poor status in the case of thiamine; it is controversial in the case of riboflavin, and it is positive in the case of vitamin B6 [
7]. Our donor population showed low plasma thiamine levels and riboflavin deficiency data of 28% according to the erythrocyte glutathione reductase activity coefficient study, but nevertheless the population showed adequate levels of plasma riboflavin. The content of these three vitamins in DHM can be considered low compared to previously published data [
61,
62,
65], considering that free thiamine should comprise about 30% of the total thiamine content in HM [
7], free riboflavin should comprise about 39% of the total riboflavin content, and pyridoxal is the predominant form of vitamin B6 in breast milk [
10]. In addition, both plasma nicotinamide levels and milk levels in our donor population were low [
63]. It remains uncertain whether the low content of free thiamine, free riboflavin, nicotinamide, and pyridoxal in DHM is due to a deficient maternal status; prolonged average breastfeeding time; or the depletion of vitamins exposed to photodegradation, freezing, and storage. On the other hand, the levels of cobalamin in DHM were adequate with respect to the reference values in HM [
64,
66] and donors' intakes and plasma levels of this micronutrient were also adequate. Available evidence suggests a positive association between maternal vitamin B-12 intake and milk concentration in marginally nourished women [
7,
9,
86]. It is possible that in a population such as ours, with adequate cobalamin intake and stores, the usual diet is not reflected in the cobalamin content of milk.
Donors' fruit consumption was associated with dehydroascorbic acid content in DHM. One of the most consistent findings of the two systematic reviews conducted about the impact of diet and maternal nutrition on the composition of breast milk [
8,
9] was the association between vitamin C intake and its content in milk, although the total number of studies in which this result was found was only three [
85,
87,
88]. Interestingly, the study published by Hoppu in 2005 [
88] reported that the vitamin C content in the milk of mothers with atopic disease was associated with their vitamin C intake but not with vitamin C supplementation. We also found no association between vitamin C supplementation and vitamin C content in DHM. It should be noted that both our study and Hoppu's (2005) were observational studies in which the rates of the use of vitamin-C-containing supplements were 43.5% and 50%, and the median daily doses of vitamin C supplementation were 80 mg and 75 mg, respectively.
For fat-soluble vitamins, associations were found only with vitamin D. Their content in DHM was withing the reported values for HM and donors’ status was deficient at a very high percentage (87.7%). The content of cholecalciferol in DHM was positively correlated with the plasma cholecalciferol levels (but not with plasma 25(OH)D
3 levels) and the daily consumption of milk and dairy products. Furthermore, the content of 25(OH)D
3 in DHM increased with the intake of vitamin D supplements during lactation. These findings are in line with observations from previous studies [
7,
9]. Neither retinol nor vitamin E in DHM was associated with donors’ intake or status. In the case of vitamin A, donors’ stores were adequate and it has been reported that both maternal intake and maternal status influence milk content when maternal stores are depleted [
7]. The α-tocopherol content of DHM was adequate in relation to the reference values for HM, although the status of the donors was deficient. Both the maternal status and intake of this vitamin with respect to the usual diet did not affect the vitamin E concentrations in HM in most of the studies, although some surveys have shown increased levels of alpha-tocopherol in colostrum in situations of supplementation [
7,
13].
Finally, among the studied minerals, only a positive association was found between the iodine content in DHM and the donors’ intake of iodine supplements, and this finding is in accordance with the literature [
89]. The results on iodine were previously published in a document dedicated to this nutrient [
25]. The selenium content in DHM was not associated with dietary intake in the present study, although it is known that the diet influences selenium HM contents [
90]. Calcium and selenium contents in DHM were low, and phosphorus content was adequate, according to the reference values in HM [
65,
73,
74,
75].
In summary, we have studied the factors that might influence the nutritional content of DHM, and we highlight the following as strengths: a detailed study of the supplementation habits of donors since gestation, the 5-day weighed dietary record, and the determination of nutrients in donors’ erythrocytes, plasma, and urine. In addition, the dietary study was carried out concomitantly with the collection of milk for 5 consecutive days. Milk was not pooled between donors or days to allow us to establish relationships between the content of each nutrient in DHM and donors’ intake, status, and characteristics. However, our study has some limitations. It should be noted that the studied DHM comprised raw milk, and although the effect of pasteurization on the concentration of nutrients in DHM has been previously studied [
91,
92], we do not know if all the associations observed will remain after the pasteurization of milk. Nevertheless, although we controlled for an important number of covariates that could act as confounders, the large number of factors that can influence the nutritional content of human milk, as well as the complexity of nutrient metabolism—which is also influenced by the genetics of the mother-infant dyad itself—makes it very difficult to study interactions between maternal diet and milk composition. Given that the behavior of some nutrients in human milk with respect to the maternal diet is different depending on the socio-economic status of lactating mothers, access to food, and maternal nutritional status, the findings from our population of donors that exhibit a high educational level and that live in a developed country, may not be generalizable to other environments.
However, we consider that the results obtained in this study are relevant since we have shown that there are associations between the nutritional composition in DHM and the diet as well as the nutrient deposits of donors, despite the heterogeneity of donors regarding the duration of pregnancy and breastfeeding time, and the procedures to which raw DHM is subjected, which can affect the content of DHM; for example the use of glass containers that do not protect photosensitive vitamins from light, freezing, mixing, and storage [
93,
94].
The study of the composition of DHM and the factors that influence it is essential. Children receiving DHM are in a state of nutritional emergency, and it would therefore be desirable that the milk they receive is in accordance with their needs. On the other hand, the development of personalized medicine will allow us to better understand the variability in the composition of DHM and the different needs of children. It is probably in this new field that we will find answers to open questions.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, N.U.-V., D.E.-V., N.R.G.-L. and C.R.P.-A.; methodology, N.U.-V., D.E.-V., J.F., M.V.C., J.M.-T. and J.S.; formal analysis, N.U.-V. and A.M.-P.; investigation, N.U.-V., K.K, D.E.-V., J.F., M.V.C., J.M.-T. and J.S.; writing—original draft preparation, N.U.-V. and A.M.-P.; writing—review and editing, N.U.-V., A.M.-P., K.K., D.E.-V., J.F., M.V.C., J.M.-T., J.C.E.S., N.R.G.-L., C.R.F. and C.R.P.-A.; project administration, N.U.-V., N.R.G.-L. and C.R.P.-A.; funding acquisition, N.U.-V., D.E.-V., N.R.G.-L. and C.R.P.-A. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.