1. Introduction
The term NAFLD dates back more than 40 years and encompasses a broad spectrum of diseases ranging from simple HS with low mortality risk to NASH with progression to cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) [
1]. Worldwide, NAFLD represents the most common liver disease with a prevalence of 25% and is closely related to T2DM and obesity. The association of this disease with T2DM increases the likelihood of developing steatohepatitis, which is characterized by the presence of lobular inflammation and hepatocellular ballooning. This combination poses an increased risk of progression to advanced stages of the disease [
2,
3]. Current evidence suggests that the overall burden of NAFLD is closely related to the occurrence of extrahepatic complications, such as cardio-metabolic pathologies including diabetes, dyslipidemia, metabolic syndrome (MS), and cardiovascular disease (CVD) which are the leading cause of death among NAFLD patients [
4,
5,
6].
The relationship between T2DM and NAFLD is supported by numerous studies, and there is a complex bidirectional relationship that pejoratively affects the prognosis and outcome of both pathologies [
7,
8,
9]. Patients with NAFLD and diabetes develop advanced forms of the disease, even in the absence of other risk factors for advanced fibrosis such as age, dyslipidemia, hypertension, and an inherited history of NAFLD-associated cirrhosis [
10].
The diagnosis of NAFLD is typically confirmed through liver biopsy puncture (LBP), an invasive procedure associated with various complications, including bleeding, pain, and abdominal discomfort, which limit its practical utility. Non-invasive techniques such as computed tomography (CT), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and liver ultrasonography, are commonly included in the diagnosis of NAFLD. Among these techniques, liver ultrasonography is the most frequently used method in medical practice due to its simplicity and non-invasive nature. It can detect steatosis when it affects around 20-30% of hepatocytes [
11]. To facilitate the diagnosis of the disease, experts have introduced a range of blood biomarkers into medical practice. Currently, the fatty liver index (FLI), hepatic steatosis index (HSI), and liver fat score (LFS) have been validated for diagnosing HS [
12]. HS is generally considered to have a benign clinical course while NASH has the potential to contribute to progressive liver fibrosis, eventually leading to cirrhosis, liver failure, and HCC [
13]. Thus, it is necessary to distinguish between fatty liver and NASH (inflammation with or without fibrosis). Given the prevalence of hepatic steatosis, a liver biopsy cannot be considered for all patients. Indeed, in a recent study by an Italian group, fatty liver regressed in 50% of all examined cases and had a benign evolution [
12,
14]. Therefore, there have been efforts to determine predictive markers of fibrosis and/or steatohepatitis to avoid biopsies [
15]. For the diagnosis of NASH, the American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) recommends considering an initial stage of biochemical suspicion, characterized by a moderate increase in transaminase levels, reaching up to five times the upper limit of normal [
16]. Additionally, elevated levels of gamma-glutamyltransferase (GGT) have been observed in these patients and are associated with advanced fibrosis and higher mortality rates. GGT is included as a biomarker in several non-invasive tests used to assess liver fibrosis, such as FibroTest and Hepascore [
17].
Chronic inflammation plays a crucial role in the development of the disease, involving various cell types such as neutrophils, lymphocytes, monocytes, and platelets. The leukocytes are assessed through a range of biological markers that evaluate the inflammatory status, including the neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio (NLR), monocyte-to-lymphocyte ratio (MLR), and systemic inflammatory index (SII) [
18]. Platelets also actively contribute to the inflammatory process by facilitating the recruitment of leukocytes and their morphology changes in patients with T2DM and MS. Therefore, mean platelet volume (MPV) and platelet distribution width (PDW) serve as biological markers for platelet activation and are associated with the presence of insulin resistance (IR) and the severity of its complications [
19]. Other inflammatory markers used in current medical practice are serum C-reactive protein (CRP), C-reactive protein/albumin ratio (CAR), and neutrophil percentage-to-albumin ratio (NPAR). NPAR is a cost-effective, easy-to-calculate biomarker initially used to calculate the prognosis of cancer patients and for cardiovascular disease prognosis, but it has been reported to have predictive value in NAFLD as well [
20,
21]. The present study aimed to determine which biological markers ("surrogate" biomarkers), other than aminotransferases (alanine aminotransferase (ALT) and aspartate aminotransferase (AST)), differentiate the two forms of liver disease in NAFLD (HS from NASH), with emphasis on inflammatory factors.
4. Discussion
The increase in aminotransferases in patients with NAFLD is the result of the interaction between IR, obesity and MS components [
29]. In our study, the factors that were associated with the progression of NAFLD in T2DM patients were: gender, advanced age, and MS components. Diabetes is a well-known factor in the progression of the disease, thus identifying biomarkers other than ALT and AST that differentiate the two forms of the disease is an important step for stratifying the risk of the disease. In both groups of patients, the male gender was predominant; in the group of patients with HS and T2DM, the incidence was 52.27%, while in the group of patients with NASH and T2DM, the incidence was higher, 73.33%. NAFLD is known as a sex-dysmorphic pathology, with a higher incidence for the male sex compared to the female sex, at least during the fertile period. After the onset of menopause, the incidence is comparable. The same higher incidence for the male gender, but lower compared to our study (51.8%) was present in a Chinese study that investigated the factors of progression to fibrosis in patients with NAFLD and T2DM. [
30]. Regarding the mean age of the patients, it was higher in patients with HS and T2DM compared to the group of patients with NASH and T2DM. Age is recognized as a factor that contributes to the progression of the disease, an aspect that was also present in our study. Also, in the study by Lamonaco et al., it was observed that the mean age of patients with HS and T2DM was higher compared to the mean age of patients with NASH and T2DM [
31]. Both patients with HS and those with NASH and T2DM mostly came from the urban environment. The incidence of urban patients in the literature is lower (34.1%) compared to our study [
32].
The main risk factors of the progression of NAFLD to NASH and subsequently to advanced stages of the disease are represented by MS components. T2DM is one of these factors through IR and compensatory hyperinsulinemia that favors the deposition of lipids in the liver [
32]. Lonardo et al [
33] and Popescu et al [
34] also stated that hepatic steatosis and fibrosis are the consequences of IR. In our study, the inclusion criteria required the presence of diabetes, resulting in a 100% incidence of diabetes in both patient groups. Regarding the comorbidities of the patients included in the study, patients with NASH and T2DM had a higher incidence of arterial hypertension (93.33%), while patients with HS and T2DM presented a higher incidence of obesity (93.18%), dyslipidemia (81.81%) and MS (94.45%). The incidence of arterial hypertension in the study by Bazick et al. [
35] was lower (40.7%) compared to our study, while Chen's study only reported a higher incidence of dyslipidemia (84.44%) in patients with HS and T2DM, the incidence of obesity and MS being lower (68.89% respectively 63.63%) compared to the results of our study [
36].
The analysis of carbohydrate metabolism parameters revealed a higher value of both blood glucose and HbA1c in patients with NASH and T2DM compared to the group of patients with HS and T2DM. IR is known as the most important pathogenic stage of MS but is also the main factor in the development and progression of non-alcoholic liver disease. Currently, the risk factors associated with the development of fibrosis in patients with NAFLD and T2DM are not fully known. To emphasize these factors and their prevalence in patients with T2DM, Julian's study which included 930 patients with NAFLD and T2DM, showed lower mean blood glucose values in patients with HS and T2DM (148±45 mg/dL) compared to patients with NASH and T2DM (151±50 mg/dL). Regarding the mean value of HbA1c, patients with HS (7.0±1.2%) had lower values in comparison to patients with NASH (7.1±1.3%), without statistically significant differences [
37].
The analysis of lipid metabolism parameters demonstrated the presence of dyslipidemia with statistically significant higher values (in the case of triglycerides) in patients with NASH and T2DM. The mechanisms of dyslipidemia are related to the appearance of hepatic and peripheral insulin resistance associated with disorders of hepatic glucose metabolism and lipoproteins [
38]. In our study, both the mean value of cholesterol and triglycerides were higher and statistically significant in the case of triglycerides (p=0.05) in patients with NASH and T2DM. The mean values of the two components of lipid metabolism were documented in a study made up of 204 patients with NAFLD and T2DM that examined the prevalence of risk factors in these patients. Both the mean values of cholesterol and triglycerides were higher but statistically insignificant in patients with NASH and T2DM (190.56±44.02 mg/dL respectively 173.51±68.84 md/dL) compared to patients with HS and T2DM (183.97±48.84 md/dL respectively 147.37±74.86 mg/dL) [
39]. The analysis of protein metabolism demonstrated a lower mean value of albumin in patients with NASH and T2DM compared to patients with HS and T2DM. Albumin levels can fall in patients with inflammatory disorders and other conditions. This may be due to downregulated production of albumin mRNA by the liver, leading to reduced synthesis, increased albumin catabolism, and increased vascular permeability [
40]. In a study made up of 1249 patients that explored the determinants of fibrosis in patients with NAFLD and T2DM, the mean value of albumin was also lower in patients with NASH and T2DM (4.15±0.41 g/dL) compared to patients with HS and T2DM (4.21±0.43 g/dL) [
32].
The analysis of the enzymatic parameters of the liver functions highlighted significantly higher mean values of liver cytolysis enzymes, ALT and AST (p=0.0001 respectively p=0.005) in patients with NASH and T2DM, compared to patients with HS and T2DM. Most patients with NAFLD are asymptomatic and are typically identified when abnormal liver studies are noted on routine laboratory assessment. In particular, the liver enzymes, ALT, and AST levels are elevated. However, these enzymes may not be elevated in all cases of NAFLD, and the level of aminotransferases may not reliably predict the extent of inflammation and cirrhosis [
41]. In a study by Mandal et al., an independent association between liver enzymes, particularly ALT, and NAFLD in a population of individuals with T2DM was observed [
42]. Mandal et al. also found that 40.4% of the diabetic population had elevated ALT levels, while increases in AST and ALP levels were observed in only 17% and 16% of diabetic individuals, respectively [
42]. Similar findings were reported by Shrestha and Bhatt in Nepal, where they also observed a statistically significant elevation in ALT levels among diabetic patients compared to the control groups [
44]. Furthermore, a higher prevalence of abnormalities in liver function tests has been linked to individuals with T2DM compared to those without T2DM [
45]. Also, the enzyme of hepatic cholestasis syndrome, GGT presented a higher and statistically significant mean value (p=0.002) in patients with NASH and T2DM compared to patients with HS and T2DM. GGT plays a crucial role in the breakdown of glutathione, facilitating the transfer of the glutamyl component and preserving intracellular balance against oxidative stress [
45]. Previous research has established connections between serum GGT levels and various chronic conditions, including NAFLD, cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, and MS [
46]. The mechanisms underlying elevated GGT levels in NAFLD patients involve oxidative stress, inflammatory response, and excessive hepatic fat accumulation, all of which contribute to impaired insulin signaling and IR [
47].
The analysis of the mean values of the hematological parameters highlighted a statistically significant higher mean hemoglobin value (p=0.03) in patients with NASH and T2DM. In the literature, the mean value of Hb in a study that investigated the association between glycated albumin (GA) and glycated hemoglobin (GA/HbA1c) ratio and the grade of NAFLD in patients with NAFLD and T2DM, who were ultrasonographical evaluated, was also statistically significant lower (p<0.001) in patients with HS and T2DM (12.5±2.2 g/dL) compared to patients with NASH and T2DM (13.8±1.6 g/dL) [
48]. The mean value of the parameters of the leukocyte series was different in the two groups of patients, without statistically significant differences being evident. Thus, the mean value of WBC was higher in patients with HS and T2DM compared to patients with NASH and T2DM. In Bazick's study, which investigated the determinants of fibrosis in 1249 patients with NAFLD, of which 435 (34.8%) had been diagnosed with diabetes, the mean value of leukocytes in patients with HS and T2DM (7180±230 mm3) was statistically insignificant lower, compared to the group of patients with NASH and T2DM (7230±210 mm3) [
35]. Regarding the percentage of neutrophils (NP), their mean value was higher in patients with HS and T2DM compared to patients with NASH and T2DM. Instead, the mean value of the percentage of lymphocytes (LP) was lower in patients with HS and T2DM compared to patients with NASH and T2DM. The mean values of the percentage of neutrophils and lymphocytes have been studied by many authors, as well as the relationship between the value of the NLR ratio and the severity of the degree of steatosis in patients with NAFLD and T2DM. The mean value of the NP in Kahraman's study, which included 143 patients with NAFLD and T2DM, evaluated by liver ultrasonography, reported a lower value in patients with NAFLD and mild fatty liver (59.2± 8.2%) compared to patients with NAFLD and severe fattening (68.6±7.9%). The mean LP varied significantly, with patients diagnosed with NAFLD and mild fatty liver (30.8±8.6%) exhibiting a higher mean value compared to patients with NAFLD and severe fatty liver (22.3±6.4%) [
49].
The mean value of the inflammatory indices derived from the leukocyte series in our study was lower in patients with HS and T2DM compared to patients with NASH and T2DM. NLR is known as an easily obtained blood biomarker that evaluates both the inflammatory state and the severity of liver fibrosis in patients with NAFLD. This aspect was suggested in Kahraman's study which concluded that NLR increased with the degree of obesity in patients with T2DM [
49]. To determine the severity of fibrosis in patients with NAFLD and T2DM, a Chinese study investigated the association between NLR, NPAR, and the presence of NAFLD or advanced liver fibrosis in a group of 3991 patients with T2DM, of which 1355 (33.95%) had NAFLD and T2DM, while 162 (4.05%) patients had T2DM and advanced liver fibrosis. In this study, it was concluded that the NLR is an easily measurable inflammatory marker, that correlated significantly and positively with the degree of steatosis and fibrosis [
20]. Another blood biomarker used to assess the inflammatory state in patients with NAFLD is MLR, which has not yet been studied in patients with T2DM. It has been used as a blood biomarker in several studies in patients with different degrees of steatosis. In this regard, a recent study that consisted of 81 patients with NAFLD and associated comorbidities, including diabetes and obesity, reported a higher mean value of MLR in patients with mild steatosis (0.25) compared to patients with severe steatosis (0.19), results differing compared to our study [
50]. The platelets count and their characteristics were also investigated as another hematological parameter in the study. In our study, the average value of the PLT was higher in patients with HS and T2DM compared to the group of patients with NASH and T2DM. The role of platelets in the inflammatory process in NAFLD is well known, as they are included in numerous scores that evaluate the process of non-invasive fibrosis. Thus, a study that included 565 patients with NAFLD and diabetes, and aimed to highlight the factors that are associated with liver fibrosis in these patients, showed a statistically significant (p<0.01) higher average value of platelets in NAFLD without liver fibrosis patients (a mean value of 226.000/mmc, with limits of 211.000-279.000/mm3) compared to those with NAFLD and liver fibrosis (a mean value of 201.000/mmc, with limits of 173.500-238.000/mmc) [
51]. Related to the characteristics of platelets, in our study, the average value of PDW was higher in the group of patients with HS and T2DM, compared to the group of patients with NASH and T2DM. The same behavior was found in the case of MPV, where the average value in the group of patients with HS and T2DM was higher compared to the group of patients with NASH and T2DM. To demonstrate the diagnostic accuracy of platelets and platelet indices, a study by Alempijevic et al. consisting of 98 patients with NAFLD and associated risk factors (diabetes, MS), divided according to the presence or absence of liver fibrosis proven using non-invasive tests, showed a statistically significantly (p<0.01) higher average PDW distribution in patients with fibrosis (16.91±0.35) compared to patients without fibrosis (16.55±0.77). In another study, a different behavior was found in the case of MPV, where the average value in patients with liver fibrosis (9.21±1.05 fL) was higher but statistically insignificant compared to the group of patients without liver fibrosis (9.04±1.46 fl) [
52].
In our study, we observed that patients diagnosed with both NASH and T2DM had higher levels of all inflammatory markers compared to those with HS and T2DM. Particularly noteworthy was the mean NPAR, which exhibited significantly elevated values (p=0.03) in patients with NASH and T2DM, in contrast to patients with HS and T2DM. Chi-Feng Liu et al. also conducted a study that revealed significant connections between the NPAR, NLR, and the presence of NAFLD or advanced liver fibrosis. They found that incremental increases in both the NLR and NPAR were linked to a higher risk of developing NAFLD. Furthermore, among individuals with T2DM, a notable and independent correlation existed between higher NPAR levels and the likelihood of having NAFLD. Based on the findings, the NPAR demonstrates promise as a reliable predictive biomarker for NAFLD. As far as we know this is the only study besides ours that has looked at the association between NPAR and NAFLD [
20]. The NPAR has also been employed as a predictive tool for systemic inflammation in various medical conditions, including unresectable pancreatic cancer [
53]. Furthermore, NPAR has been linked to all-cause mortality in critically ill patients with acute kidney injury [
54] and septic shock [
55]. It is well known that chronic inflammation plays a crucial role in the progression of NAFLD, which encompasses a spectrum ranging from simple steatosis to NASH, advanced liver fibrosis, cirrhosis, and ultimately end-stage liver disease and hepatocellular carcinoma [
56]. Consequently, NAFLD represents a significant contributor to chronic and progressive liver damage, emphasizing the importance of noninvasive diagnostic and monitoring methods for progressive liver disease. The findings of Chi-Feng Liu et al. indicate that an elevated NPAR level is significantly linked to an increased risk of NAFLD, surpassing the effectiveness of albumin, neutrophil percentage, and NLR as biomarkers for predicting NAFLD [
20]. Additionally, the relationship between the NPAR and NAFLD was influenced by the presence of T2DM, a recognized risk factor for NAFLD development and progression [
57]. Furthermore, T2DM itself is associated with systemic inflammation [
58]. Hence, it is plausible that the presence of concurrent T2DM might conceal the correlation between the NPAR and NAFLD [
20].
In our study, we also observed a statistically significant rise (p=0.003) in the average serum ferritin (SF) level among patients diagnosed with NASH and T2DM compared with patients with HS and T2DM. Previous studies have shown that the level of SF, which is the main storage form of iron in the body, is correlated with T2DM and NAFLD [
59,
60,
61]. A study by Yan et al. revealed that individuals with T2DM and NAFLD displayed notably higher levels of serum ferritin when compared to T2DM patients without NAFLD. Moreover, as SF levels increased, the proportions of NAFLD cases also showed a significant rise. Thus, SF was identified as an independent risk factor for NAFLD among patients with T2DM [
62]. Research has indicated that elevated levels of SF without corresponding high transferrin saturation can serve as an indicator of glucose or lipid metabolism dysfunction [
63]. Increased iron levels may contribute to the development of diabetes by triggering oxidative stress, inflammation, insulin resistance, insulin insufficiency, liver impairment, and other factors [
64]. Conversely, diabetes itself can disrupt the balance of iron metabolism and lead to iron overload, thereby establishing a detrimental cycle [
65]. IR stands as a prominent characteristic of NAFLD [
66]. Under conditions of IR, the β-oxidation process of free fatty acids becomes impeded, which subsequently fosters the accumulation of fat within the liver [
67] Mayneris-Perxachs et al. also documented a positive association between SF levels and the extent of hepatic fat accumulation [
68]
Furthermore, we assessed the clinical utility of C-reactive protein (CRP) as a diagnostic tool for NAFLD. CRP displayed a higher mean value in our study in patients with NASH and DM2, though statistically insignificant, compared to patients with HS and DM2. Several studies have suggested a potential association between elevated serum CRP levels and NAFLD [
69,
70,
71]. Since CRP has a short half-life of approximately 18 hours, an increase in its serum levels typically indicates its synthesis in response to a pathological process. As a result, CRP is regarded as a valuable non-specific biochemical marker for chronic inflammation [
72]. Oruc et al. further validated that elevated circulating CRP levels can serve as an indicative marker for the presence of NAFLD. However, it is important to note that due to its limited specificity, interpreting CRP values accurately requires consideration of all other clinical and laboratory information. Consequently, it was proposed that serial CRP measurements could prove beneficial in the clinical management and ongoing monitoring of NAFLD patients [
73]. Ndumele et al. conducted a study involving 2388 individuals, both diabetic and non-diabetic, without known coronary heart disease, which revealed a significant correlation between hepatic steatosis, as detected by ultrasound, and elevated levels of high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hs-CRP). HS was associated with higher hs-CRP levels, irrespective of obesity status, presence of metabolic syndrome, or absence. Notably, obesity and MS were independently linked to increased hs-CRP levels, as expected [
74]. It is important to mention that the liver plays a crucial role as the main producer of CRP. Previous research suggests that the level of hepatic steatosis and inflammation, as determined by histology, is linked to the systemic levels of inflammatory biomarkers. In a study involving 85 patients, it was observed that higher grades of hepatic steatosis, necroinflammation, and fibrosis in biopsy samples were associated with progressively elevated hs-CRP levels, reaching the "high risk" range [
75]. Additional studies have discovered a direct correlation between the severity of NAFLD and the expression of inflammatory mediators in hepatocytes [
74,
76].
The results of our study provide evidence supporting an independent association between NASH and systemic inflammation in patients with T2DM. Nevertheless, further research is required in the future to explore the link between inflammatory factors and NAFLD in patients with diabetes. This is crucial since the existing studies on this subject are limited in number.