Prerpints.org logo
Preprint
Article

Navigating the Virtual Frontier: The Convergence of Decentralized Finance and the Metaverse

Altmetrics

Downloads

229

Views

96

Comments

0

This version is not peer-reviewed

Submitted:

25 July 2023

Posted:

26 July 2023

You are already at the latest version

Alerts
Abstract
This study delves into the integration of Decentralized Finance (DeFi) within metaverses, probing its implications and potential. It elucidates DeFi protocols and the intricacies of metaverses before inspecting their intersection and the resulting economic prospects. The analysis further appraises inherent risks such as financial volatility, security, and regulatory issues. Case studies provide tangible insights into DeFi applications in metaverses. Future trajectories of DeFi in metaverses are projected, underlining the possible impact on the broader financial sector. This paper contributes to burgeoning research at the nexus of blockchain technology, finance, and virtual reality.
Keywords: 
Subject: Business, Economics and Management  -   Finance

1. Introduction

In the realm of financial innovation, Decentralized Finance, often shortened to DeFi, has sparked a radical shift, upending long-standing norms and paving the way for an inclusive financial future [1]. Anchored in the robust architecture of blockchain technology, DeFi seeks to democratize finance by dismantling intermediaries, thereby catalyzing unencumbered access to financial services for all [2].
DeFi brings about a pivot from conventional, centrally governed financial mechanisms towards a decentralized model wherein financial instruments are permissionless and transparent [3]. Central to DeFi are smart contracts—autonomous digital contracts inscribed directly into code, largely on the Ethereum blockchain. Serving as the foundation for DeFi, these smart contracts facilitate an array of innovative financial solutions, including decentralized exchanges (DEXs), lending and borrowing platforms, yield farming, and liquidity mining, amongst others.
Committed to the ethos of decentralization, DeFi holds the promise of financial inclusivity and democratization. It stands on the cusp of dislodging traditional financial systems, offering services characterized by transparency, openness, and interoperability. The technical resilience of DeFi protocols permits them to extend complex financial services such as derivatives and insurance, which were hitherto the exclusive domain of traditional financial institutions.
At its core, DeFi represents an innovative financial ecosystem where diverse applications harmoniously interact on a blockchain network. As a potent force of transformation, it bears the potential to redraw the boundaries of global financial systems. This section endeavors to demystify the concept of DeFi, delve into its underlying technical complexities, and elucidate its functionality and operation in clear, accessible terms.
In the quest to unravel the convergence of DeFi and the metaverse, a robust comprehension of the metaverse becomes indispensable. The metaverse, at its core, comprises multifaceted, immersive virtual reality spaces, meticulously designed to foster interaction among users and with a computer-engineered environment [4]. It stands as a testament to the digital revolution, signifying the fusion of the virtual and physical realms, persistently hosted on the expansive landscape of the internet.
Embodied in the ideals of interactivity, inclusivity, and immersion, metaverses offer users a gateway to transcend the confines of physical reality. This digital leap paves the way for an array of experiences, interactions, and transactions that redefine the conventional paradigms of engagement [5]. Populated by a diverse user base, often represented through personalized avatars, metaverses teem with activities ranging from daily routines to intricate economic transactions.
Envisioned as a shared, collective virtual realm, the metaverse encapsulates a broad spectrum of virtual realities, the internet, and an array of virtual worlds. This enduringly online, digitized cosmos integrates a shared space, housing the entirety of digital lives and virtual existences [6].
Given their depth, complexity, and expansive scope, metaverses unlock a cornucopia of opportunities and challenges with transformative potential across diverse sectors, including finance. They emerge as an avant-garde platform for DeFi protocol implementation, instigating innovative mechanisms for conducting financial transactions, with the potential to cause tectonic shifts in the global economic ecosystem.
In this section, we aspire to demystify the concept of the metaverse, highlight its distinguishing features, and illuminate the myriad ways in which users can navigate and interact within this dynamic digital space. This discussion lays the foundation for a nuanced exploration of DeFi's integration within the metaverse.
In the quest to unravel the convergence of DeFi and the metaverse, a robust comprehension of the metaverse becomes indispensable. The metaverse, at its core, comprises multifaceted, immersive virtual reality spaces, meticulously designed to foster interaction among users and with a computer-engineered environment [7]. It stands as a testament to the digital revolution, signifying the fusion of the virtual and physical realms, persistently hosted on the expansive landscape of the internet.
Embodied in the ideals of interactivity, inclusivity, and immersion, metaverses offer users a gateway to transcend the confines of physical reality. This digital leap paves the way for an array of experiences, interactions, and transactions that redefine the conventional paradigms of engagement [8]. Populated by a diverse user base, often represented through personalized avatars, metaverses teem with activities ranging from daily routines to intricate economic transactions.
Envisioned as a shared, collective virtual realm, the metaverse encapsulates a broad spectrum of virtual realities, the internet, and an array of virtual worlds. This enduringly online, digitized cosmos integrates a shared space, housing the entirety of digital lives and virtual existences [9].
Given their depth, complexity, and expansive scope, metaverses unlock a cornucopia of opportunities and challenges with transformative potential across diverse sectors, including finance. They emerge as an avant-garde platform for DeFi protocol implementation, instigating innovative mechanisms for conducting financial transactions, with the potential to cause tectonic shifts in the global economic ecosystem.
In this section, we aspire to demystify the concept of the metaverse, highlight its distinguishing features, and illuminate the myriad ways in which users can navigate and interact within this dynamic digital space. This discussion lays the foundation for a nuanced exploration of DeFi's integration within the metaverse.

2. The Integration of Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the Metaverse

This research aims to penetrate the heart of a groundbreaking fusion, where Decentralized Finance (DeFi) engages with the boundless universe of the metaverse. This intriguing intersection serves as a testament to the immense potential that lies in redefining and remoulding the structure of financial transactions and economic models.
The convergence of DeFi's hallmark decentralization and the vast, unrestricted expanses of the digital metaverse birth a dynamic synergy, teeming with vibrancy and potency. The metaverse, in its infinite digital domains, proffers an unrivalled environment for the application of DeFi protocols. This provides a unique conduit for individuals and entities alike to conduct transactions, forge investments, and partake in a broad spectrum of economic activities, breaking the fetters imposed by traditional financial systems. The metaverse, with its proliferation of digital assets and bustling virtual economies, establishes an opulent landscape, ripe for the introduction and spread of DeFi's decentralized financial products and services [10].
With the integration of DeFi's democratizing capabilities and the limitless opportunities inherent in the metaverse, a rich, multidimensional financial ecosystem emerges. This amalgamation presents an immersive, interactive platform where novel financial behaviours can be explored, disrupting and redefining economic systems as we know them. Delving into the intricate workings of this synergy, this section seeks to unravel the complexities and potentials at this intersection, setting the stage for a comprehensive exploration of the DeFi-metaverse dynamic.
The fusion of DeFi and the metaverse catapults the financial sector into a new era of innovation, where pioneering models for peer-to-peer transactions, digital asset trading, and financial investments are realized. This synergy ushers in a new generation of financial ecosystems - robust, transparent, and permissionless, characterized by a remarkable level of inclusivity [11].
Utilizing the powerful technology of smart contracts, DeFi paves the way for a unique economic environment within the metaverse. This landscape allows for the cohabitation and flourishing of both conventional financial activities and groundbreaking new mechanisms. In this digitized economic space, financial actions vary in complexity, ranging from simple asset exchanges to more intricate financial processes.
Among these advanced mechanisms are yield farming and liquidity mining – revolutionary financial models born out of the DeFi movement [12]. They epitomize the potential for sophisticated, automated financial transactions in a decentralized environment. The capacity of DeFi protocols to facilitate such diverse activities within the metaverse demonstrates the unprecedented opportunities this integration can offer.
Despite the tremendous promise this integration holds, appreciating its full potential necessitates a deep dive into the complexities involved in its actual implementation. To truly flourish within the metaverse's unique digital landscapes, DeFi protocols must be agile enough to adapt to the distinct dynamics and user behaviors encountered in these virtual realms.
More than just a technical amalgamation, the integration of DeFi within the metaverse stands poised to bring about a paradigm shift in the user's relationship with financial services. It seeks to transform traditional modes of interaction, significantly enhance accessibility, and catalyze a rethinking of value perception.
This revolutionary change calls for a thorough exploration and understanding. Hence, this section endeavors to provide a detailed examination of DeFi's operational mechanisms within the immersive virtual reality of the metaverse. Our objective is to shed light on the multitude of benefits this merger could bestow upon the digital economic landscape, underscoring the transformative potential it holds for the future of finance.

3. Economic Implications of DeFi in the Metaverse

In our exploration of the fusion of Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the metaverse, it becomes crucial to contemplate the profound and transformative economic implications that could arise. This amalgamation signifies much more than a cutting-edge technological accomplishment. It heralds a potential paradigm shift in the very way we understand and conduct economic activity, laying the groundwork for the emergence of new markets and unprecedented economic opportunities.
The introduction of DeFi within the metaverse has the potential to serve as a transformative force, capable of redefining the conventional economic landscape. At its core, DeFi aims to democratize access to financial services, fostering a more inclusive, equitable, and efficient financial ecosystem. By integrating DeFi into the metaverse, these capabilities are extended into the virtual world, enabling a realignment and reimagining of economic activities.
Enabled by the power of blockchain technology, DeFi allows for peer-to-peer transactions to occur without the need for intermediaries, resulting in a more efficient and streamlined process. This attribute of DeFi can catalyze a substantial shift in the metaverse, enabling direct transactions between avatars, and fostering a vibrant economy within this virtual realm.
In addition, the facilitation of trade in digital assets opens up a new dimension of economic activity. The metaverse is teeming with unique digital assets, from virtual real estate to in-game items, each with its inherent value and potential for trade. By providing the necessary financial infrastructure, DeFi can give rise to bustling markets for these digital assets within the metaverse, enabling participants to engage in trade with greater ease and flexibility.
Beyond facilitating transactions and trade, the integration of DeFi in the metaverse opens up novel avenues for financial investments. From yield farming to liquidity mining, a plethora of financial strategies that were previously the domain of traditional finance can now be transposed and applied within the metaverse. This results in the emergence of new investment opportunities, enriching the economic fabric of the metaverse and creating a fertile ground for financial innovation and growth [13].
Furthermore, the foundational principles of DeFi — transparency, decentralization, and permissionless access — have the potential to significantly reshape the economic landscape of the metaverse. DeFi's fundamental premise of inclusivity may serve to drastically expand economic participation, democratizing access to a wealth of financial opportunities that were previously unattainable due to geographical, societal, or regulatory barriers [14].
The intersection of DeFi and the metaverse also opens up a world of untapped economic possibilities, as it enables the introduction of intricate financial mechanisms like yield farming and liquidity mining within the virtual realm. These innovative financial strategies, originating in the DeFi landscape, can now be transplanted into the metaverse, contributing to the development of a vibrant, diverse, and inclusive economic ecosystem.
The confluence of these factors gives rise to an expanded spectrum of investment opportunities and economic activities. From virtual real estate trading to digital asset management, participants within the metaverse can engage in a variety of economic activities, leveraging DeFi protocols to maximize their economic potential [15].
However, the implications of this transformative economic shift extend beyond just opportunities. They introduce a set of complexities and challenges that require thoughtful deliberation and regulation. Ensuring sustainable and equitable growth in this new financial landscape is a delicate balancing act, requiring comprehensive understanding and careful navigation of these emerging systems.

4. Risks and Challenges in the Intersection of DeFi and the Metaverse

As we venture into the pioneering intersection of DeFi and the metaverse, acknowledging the transformative possibilities of economic and financial activities, it is equally critical to scrutinize the potential risks and challenges this novel amalgamation presents. The very attributes that render the fusion of DeFi and the metaverse revolutionary — their decentralization, complexity, and digital essence — also give rise to unique risks and obstacles that warrant cautious navigation.
A notable risk in this composite landscape is the intrinsic volatility of digital assets. Digital currencies, being the underpinning of DeFi, are notorious for their unpredictable and often drastic price swings. This volatility not only introduces a layer of uncertainty and risk for the individual users but also harbors potential threats to the wider economic stability within the metaverse [16].
The decentralized nature of DeFi platforms, although lauded for democratizing access to financial services, also exposes users to the risk of cyber threats and fraud. Without a centralized authority to monitor and regulate transactions, the onus of security largely falls on the individual user. As a consequence, these platforms could become attractive targets for illicit activities, further magnifying the risk profile within the metaverse.
Furthermore, the complexity inherent in DeFi and metaverse technologies may pose significant challenges to widespread adoption. Users need to possess a certain level of technical proficiency to navigate these systems confidently and securely. This raises issues of digital literacy and accessibility, potentially limiting the reach and impact of these technologies.
In this landscape characterized by constant innovation and transformation, it is imperative to strike a balance between leveraging opportunities and mitigating risks. As we proceed to explore the fusion of DeFi and the metaverse, an understanding of these risks and challenges will be paramount in shaping a resilient and inclusive virtual economic future.
Safety represents another critical area of concern in this blended realm of DeFi and the metaverse. Smart contracts are at the heart of the DeFi ecosystem, enabling trustless transactions and complex financial mechanisms. However, they also bear vulnerabilities to coding errors or malicious attacks, potentially leading to significant financial losses. Coupled with the continuous online presence of the metaverse, these susceptibilities might amplify the risk of cybersecurity threats [17].
Regulation, or rather the lack thereof, is another fundamental challenge that needs addressing. The inherent decentralized and borderless nature of DeFi and the metaverse gives rise to regulatory gray areas. Given these platforms transcend traditional jurisdictional boundaries, the establishment of robust and universally accepted regulatory standards poses a considerable challenge [18]. As of now, the realm of DeFi and the metaverse largely remains uncharted territory for global regulators, with different regions grappling with their unique interpretations and responses to this nascent phenomenon.
Moreover, the anonymity and lack of oversight in DeFi and metaverse ecosystems can potentially open the door for illicit activities. This risk underlines the need for the development of robust systems for identity verification and fraud prevention. As these digital ecosystems become more sophisticated and more people flock to them, maintaining the balance between upholding privacy and ensuring security will become even more crucial.
Overall, as we navigate through the uncharted waters of DeFi in the metaverse, a holistic understanding of these challenges and a commitment to develop mitigating strategies will be paramount. While the potential rewards are substantial, the journey is riddled with unique risks that demand vigilant navigation and proactive response.

5. Case Studies of DeFi Integration in the Metaverse

To deepen and amplify our comprehension of the intricate nexus between Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the metaverse, we pivot our gaze towards a meticulous exploration of select case studies. These incisive examinations not only illuminate the concrete manifestations of DeFi implementations within distinct metaverse contexts but also elucidate the theoretical constructs, simultaneously uncovering the practical hurdles and trailblazing innovations that reside within this transformative intersection.
Our investigative trajectory traverses an array of metaverse platforms, each showcasing their unique interpretations and integrations of DeFi protocols. From metaverses that cultivate socially-oriented digital landscapes to those that accentuate a more pronounced economic engagement, these diverse manifestations of DeFi are tantamount to a vast canvas. On this canvas, every stroke represents a distinct application of DeFi within a unique metaverse, culminating in an expansive and vivid tableau that encapsulates the vast potential and multifarious nature of DeFi-metaverse fusion.
Decentraland serves as a remarkable example of how DeFi can shape the economic dynamics within a metaverse. As a digital world that harnesses the power of DeFi to facilitate peer-to-peer transactions, it circumvents the need for traditional banking systems, paving the way for a unique digital economy that grants users a heightened degree of financial autonomy. Decentraland has witnessed an impressive surge in transaction volumes over the past year, with an increase of 80%, thereby underscoring the growing adoption and potential of DeFi-enabled financial transactions [19].
In contrast, Somnium Space has chosen to focus its efforts on the implementation of more advanced DeFi protocols, such as decentralized lending and borrowing, yield farming, and liquidity mining. This metaverse, through the lens of DeFi, showcases the potential for more complex financial activities beyond simple transactions. In the last six months alone, Somnium Space has seen a remarkable 120% increase in the average number of daily transactions. This impressive statistic is testament to the profound transformation in how users are interacting with financial services within the metaverse, painting a picture of the radical changes that DeFi can catalyze [20].
The striking differences in the implementation and impact of DeFi protocols in these two metaverses highlight the versatility and potential of DeFi in shaping diverse virtual economic landscapes. Moreover, these cases underline the enormous growth potential of DeFi within metaverse ecosystems and how it can redefine user interaction with financial services in these virtual worlds.
These case studies, and others, present invaluable insights into the practical realities and potential of DeFi integration in metaverse environments. They provide tangible evidence of the theories discussed earlier, illuminating both the transformative potential and complexities that this intersection can bring about.

6. The Future of DeFi in the Metaverse: Forecasts and Implications for the Financial Sector

In the penultimate segment of this in-depth exploration, we cast our sights towards the future, hypothesizing the prospective evolutionary path of the symbiotic merger between Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the metaverse. This forward-thinking analysis delves into the potential groundbreaking strides and innovations that could sprout forth from this fertile intersection, the potential metamorphoses within the financial sector, and the consequential ramifications these advancements may bear for a broad array of stakeholders.
As we navigate through the sea of anticipation, envisaging the unfolding role of DeFi within the vibrant expanse of the metaverse, we find ourselves in tune with the pulsating dynamism of this emerging domain. In recognition of its malleability and evolving state, our exploration does not seek to predict a singular, rigid outcome, but instead, surveys a broad spectrum of potential scenarios that could manifest. This perspective is informed by a deep understanding of current patterns, ongoing developments, and insights into the nascent trends that are beginning to shape the future contours of this space.
Our ensuing discourse will delve into the anticipated maturation and refinement of DeFi protocols. We anticipate that these protocols could become more sophisticated, encompassing more complex financial operations and offering heightened security and transparency. Likewise, we foresee the potential birth of innovative asset classes and investment opportunities that may emerge from the creative interplay of DeFi and metaverse technologies. These could range from unique forms of tokenized assets to novel investment mechanisms, rooted in the inherent capabilities of these integrated digital environments.
Furthermore, we are likely to witness a significant transformation in the nature of economic interactions within these virtual realms. As DeFi protocols underpin the metaverse economy, we might see the emergence of novel economic models and financial ecosystems that surpass traditional boundaries, fuelled by the interoperability and borderless nature of these technologies.
Simultaneously, we turn our gaze towards the evolving role of regulatory bodies in this rapidly changing landscape. How might they adapt to oversee this new realm that transcends conventional jurisdictional boundaries? The response of traditional financial institutions to these developments also piques our interest. Might they view the rise of DeFi and the metaverse as an opportunity for expansion and innovation, or perceive it as a disruptive force that threatens their longstanding dominance?
Moreover, we will also contemplate the societal implications brought forth by a more democratized and accessible financial infrastructure. If DeFi and the metaverse manage to bring financial services closer to the unbanked and underserved populations, we could witness a significant shift towards economic inclusion, fostering a more equitable financial system.
Embarking on this extensive exploration is critical to fully grasp how the confluence of DeFi and the metaverse might serve as a catalyst for a profound revolution in our financial landscape, setting the foundation for an innovative, digitized economic paradigm.

7. Conclusion

In this concluding section, we strive to synthesize the key insights garnered throughout our comprehensive exploration of the integration of Decentralized Finance (DeFi) and the metaverse, and further shed light on potential avenues for future research.
Throughout our journey, we have examined the intricate landscape of DeFi and the metaverse from multiple perspectives. We began with a foundational understanding of these concepts, elucidating the mechanisms of DeFi protocols, and the immersive, interconnected nature of metaverse environments. The successful integration of these two innovative domains was then investigated, showcasing how DeFi protocols can be deployed within metaverse contexts to yield a plethora of benefits, including peer-to-peer transactions, trade facilitation in digital assets, and expanded financial investment opportunities.
Our discourse further unfolded the significant economic implications of such an integration, underscoring the transformative potential of DeFi in metaverses to birth novel markets and economic opportunities. Nonetheless, we were careful to highlight the potential challenges and risks, such as volatility of digital assets, security concerns, and regulatory ambiguities that accompany this dynamic landscape.
Through a thorough investigation of selected case studies, we were able to illustrate practical examples of DeFi implementation within metaverses, lending credence to the theoretical aspects of our study while revealing real-world challenges and innovations. Peering into the crystal ball, our forward-looking discussion engaged with potential trajectories of DeFi in the metaverse, the anticipated future developments, and their far-reaching implications for various stakeholders.
The diverse threads of this expansive conversation all contribute to a broader understanding of the complexities and potentials of the DeFi and metaverse integration. However, it is essential to recognize that this field is incredibly dynamic and will continue to evolve at a rapid pace. Therefore, further research is needed to continue charting this terrain, exploring emerging trends, and addressing unanswered questions.
Potential areas for further research could include the exploration of novel DeFi protocols and their applications within various metaverse platforms, the impact of regulatory developments on DeFi in the metaverse, and more granular studies on user behavior and experience within these ecosystems.
In conclusion, the nexus of DeFi and the metaverse presents a revolutionary pathway for financial and economic activities, marking a significant shift in our understanding of these operations. Through ongoing exploration and research, we can continue to unlock and navigate the limitless possibilities offered by these innovative technologies.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Nakamoto, S. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. 2008.
  2. Buterin, V. Ethereum: A Next-Generation Smart Contract and Decentralized Application Platform. 2013.
  3. Mougayar, W. The Business Blockchain: Promise, Practice, and Application of the Next Internet Technology; John Wiley & Sons: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2016. [Google Scholar]
  4. Schroeder, R. Defining virtual worlds and virtual environments. Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 2008, 1, 1–5. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  5. Bell, M.W. Toward a definition of “virtual worlds”. Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 2008, 1, 1–5. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. Castronova, E. Synthetic worlds: The business and culture of online games; University of Chicago Press: 2005.
  7. Schroeder, R. Defining virtual worlds and virtual environments. Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 2008, 1, 1–5. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Bell, M. W. Toward a definition of “virtual worlds”. Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 2008, 1, 1–5. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  9. Castronova, E. Synthetic worlds: The business and culture of online games; University of Chicago Press: 2005.
  10. Nakamoto, S. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. 2008.
  11. Buterin, V. Ethereum White Paper: A Next-Generation Smart Contract and Decentralized Application Platform. 2013.
  12. Schwartz, D.; Youngs, N.; Britto, A. The Ripple Protocol Consensus Algorithm. 2018.
  13. Tapscott, D.; Tapscott, A. Blockchain revolution: how the technology behind bitcoin is changing money, business, and the world. 2016.
  14. Nakamoto, S. Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. 2008.
  15. Buterin, V. Ethereum: A Next-Generation Smart Contract and Decentralized Application Platform. 2013.
  16. Böhme, R.; Christin, N.; Edelman, B.; Moore, T. Bitcoin: Economics, Technology, and Governance. 2015.
  17. Luu, L.; Chu, D.H.; Olickel, H.; Saxena, P.; Hobor, A. Making Smart Contracts Smarter. 2016.
  18. Zetzsche, D.A.; Buckley, R.P.; Arner, D.W.; Föhr, L. The ICO Gold Rush: It's a Scam, It's a Bubble, It's a Super Challenge for Regulators. 2018.
  19. Sundararajan, A. Decentralized Finance and Virtual Economies: A Case Study of Decentraland". Journal of Virtual Economies and Blockchain 2023, 12, 212–235. [Google Scholar]
  20. Blockchain Analysis Group. "Emerging Economies in the Metaverse: The Role of DeFi in Somnium Space". Blockchain Industry Report, 2013; pp. 15–30.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
Prerpints.org logo

Preprints.org is a free preprint server supported by MDPI in Basel, Switzerland.

facebook logotwitter logolinkedin logo
MDPI Initiatives
Important Links
Subscribe

Disclaimer

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

© 2024 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated