Prerpints.org logo
Preprint
Article

Transportation Disaster Trends and Impacts in Western Asia: A Comprehensive Analysis from 2003 to 2023

Altmetrics

Downloads

95

Views

34

Comments

0

A peer-reviewed article of this preprint also exists.

This version is not peer-reviewed

Submitted:

21 August 2023

Posted:

23 August 2023

You are already at the latest version

Alerts
Abstract
Investigating transportation disasters in Western Asia over two decades (2003-2023), this study provides a meticulous examination of a comprehensive dataset, shedding light on the dynamics and nuances of these catastrophic events in terms of frequency, modality (air, rail, road, and water), and subsequent outcomes. The data reveals a concerning uptrend in mishaps from 2003 to 2010, which fortunately reverses into a notable decline in the subsequent years. Noteworthy is the predominance of road-related incidents, yet an alarming 73.8% of events are ambiguously categorized under "Unknown", hinting at potential gaps or inconsistencies in record-keeping. With Turkey being a significant epicenter, accounting for nearly 45% of all incidents, the regional distribution of these disasters becomes evident. Advanced ANOVA analyses discern marked variations in fatality rates over the years and between nations. However, the contrast in injury rates among different disaster categories did not achieve statistical significance. While the post-2010 era showcases a commendable reduction in calamities, the data punctuates the persistent necessity for robust safety measures, targeted public awareness campaigns, and infrastructural advancements. In synthesis, this study vehemently advocates for heightened regional collaboration and systematic knowledge dissemination as cornerstones for bolstering transportation safety across Western Asia.
Keywords: 
Subject: Public Health and Healthcare  -   Public Health and Health Services

1. Introduction

The 21st century, with its dawn, signaled a transformative epoch in the realm of global transportation networks. This era witnessed an unprecedented expansion of these networks, enveloping land, air, and seas alike. Such growth has forged pathways, linking even the most secluded and distant territories, reinforcing the narrative of a shrinking world [1]. From remote villages to bustling metropolises, transportation networks, with their expanding tapestry, have emerged as the lifeblood of modern civilization, powering communities, invigorating economic corridors, and turning the abstract notion of a 'global village' into tangible reality. However, this scale of expansion, while momentous, has inevitably unmasked a slew of challenges. As we crafted intricate labyrinths of routes across skies, roads, rails, and waters, the safety of the multitudes that rely on them became a paramount concern [2].
These vast networks, while monuments to human ingenuity, aren't immune to adversities. The scale of accidents within these intricate systems isn't merely alarming—it's an urgent global health crisis. As underscored by the World Health Organization (WHO), road traffic injuries alone loom as the eighth most common cause of death globally. Such a ranking becomes even more daunting when contextualized against lethal diseases like HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis [3]. Behind every data point lies a tale, a family, a community, emphasizing the dire need to pierce the surface of these statistics, thereby uncovering actionable insights to advance transportation safety.
Venturing into the canvas of Western Asia, the narrative takes a nuanced turn. Here, history and modernity seamlessly converge, with millennia-old trade routes coexisting with cutting-edge transportation marvels [4]. Amidst its thriving urban landscapes and an increasingly mobile citizenry, the task of ensuring unyielding safety grows ever more critical. Yet, the challenges confronting Western Asia aren't merely typical of burgeoning regions. Here, the rich tapestries of diverse cultures, multifaceted geopolitical landscapes, and unique terrains craft a complex matrix of considerations [5]. The pressing queries arise: Can Western Asia's transportation woes be simply mirrored against global benchmarks? Or do its unique socio-political and geographical tapestries necessitate specialized attention?
Every accident, with its inherent tragedy, brings forth a reservoir of insights. The invaluable lessons extracted can reshape policies, rejuvenate infrastructures, and renew community commitments towards safety [6]. In Western Asia, these lessons are accentuated, given its vibrant confluence of changing urban dynamics, shifting demographics, and geopolitical evolution [7].
Steered by this holistic understanding, our research embarks on a journey to decipher the multifaceted realm of transportation accidents within Western Asia. Utilizing the vast archives of the Emergency event database (EM-DAT), our inquiry aims to unravel the intricate patterns, causal factors, and overarching trends [8]. This endeavor transcends mere academic pursuits. It strives to juxtapose Western Asia's transportation narrative within the broader global framework, aspiring to contribute actionable insights that can transform ground realities.
Central to our undertaking, this study sets forth with a clear aim– to discern patterns, pinpoint vulnerability zones, and recognize trends linked to transportation mishaps in Western Asia spanning two decades, from 2003 to 2023 [9]. By juxtaposing these findings against a global backdrop, our aspiration is to foster a profound comprehension of the region-specific challenges confronting Western Asia. Such a pursuit, we believe, will pave the way for informed strategies, pragmatic policies, and collaborative endeavors, all converging towards the singular vision of elevating transportation safety standards across the Western Asian landscape [10].

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Study Design

This research employs a retrospective study design to meticulously explore the patterns, root causes, and magnitudes of transportation accidents across Western Asian nations. We hinged our data extraction on the Emergency event database (EM-DAT), a collaboration between the Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED) and the World Health Organization. Established in 1988, the database encompasses records for over 26,000 global calamities spanning from 1900 up to the present. The rigor of its data is solidified by its amalgamation of diverse sourcing, ranging from United Nation agencies and academic investigations to reinsurance firms and press archives.

2.2. Data Collection

The study period was designated from 2003 to 2023. A targeted approach was adopted to concentrate on the Western Asian region comprising countries such as Saudi Arabia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Cyprus, Georgia, Iraq, Israel, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, Syrian Arab Republic, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen. The search in the EM-DAT was refined using specific inclusion criteria. These criteria encompassed the nature of the transportation accident, country of occurrence, date of the event, and the reported number of injuries and fatalities.

2.3. Data Preparation

After the data extraction process, entries were systematically transitioned from EM-DAT to a Microsoft Excel environment. In this structured setting, data was organized in discernible rows and columns, setting the stage for subsequent computational operations. A preliminary audit was conducted to scout for inconsistencies, data voids, or statistical outliers. Such anomalies, upon detection, were rectified either by cross-referencing with other reliable data sources or making considered estimations, thereby bolstering the integrity of the forthcoming analysis.

2.4. Data Analysis

The research embraced a quantitative paradigm, with a focus on descriptive statistical methods to crystallize the intricate patterns endemic to Western Asian transportation tragedies. Alongside conventional frequency distributions, we engaged in determining measures of central tendency—capturing average behaviors via the mean and median. Additionally, measures of dispersion, namely standard deviation and variance, were harnessed to gauge data spread and volatility. To enhance clarity and foster intuitive understanding, our findings are articulated through a mix of textual explanations, percentages, and a diverse array of visual aids like charts and graphs.

3. Results

Over the two-decade span from 2003 to 2023, our dataset paints a vivid picture of transportation-related disasters occurring in Western Asian countries. Within this timeframe, a total of 160 incidents were meticulously documented, offering a profound lens into the region's transportation safety dynamics.
A closer examination of the data reveals discernible patterns. The period from 2003 to 2010 was particularly tumultuous, characterized by a surge in transportation accidents. Alarmingly, 2003 stood out as the zenith of this upward trajectory, witnessing a staggering fifteen accidents, the highest annual count in the period under study. This spike raised numerous concerns and questions about the safety protocols and infrastructure in place during that period.
However, the subsequent decade witnessed a remarkable paradigm shift. Post-2010, and especially starting from 2011, there was a palpable decline in the number of accidents. While certain high-profile incidents did breach this general trend, eliciting extensive media attention and public concern, the overarching narrative was undeniably one of improvement. The dwindling accident rates in the latter years of our study are a testament to the proactive measures, stringent regulations, and heightened awareness campaigns that were possibly rolled out in response to the earlier spate of mishaps.
Yet, while the trajectory towards enhanced transportation safety is commendable, it's imperative to not rest on these laurels. Even with the reduced incidents in recent years, the sheer magnitude of past accidents underscores a lingering vulnerability. It's evident that transportation safety remains a significant challenge in the region. Augmented efforts to bolster infrastructure, refine safety regulations, and foster a pervasive culture of safety consciousness among the public are of paramount importance.
The visual representation of these findings, as encapsulated in Figure I, serves as a stark reminder of the oscillating journey of transportation safety in Western Asia. It underscores the pressing need for relentless vigilance, continuous innovation, and a collective commitment to ensuring the well-being of all who traverse the region's vast transportation networks (see Figure I).
Preprints 82969 g001
Figure 1. Periods of disasters accidents in West of Asian region.
Figure 1. Periods of disasters accidents in West of Asian region.
Preprints 82969 g001

3.1. Disaster Classification

A detailed examination and categorization of the incidents elucidated the primary modes of transportation associated with these accidents. The data presented a clear hierarchy of vulnerability within Western Asia's transportation network.
Unmistakably, road-related incidents towered above the rest, accounting for a significant 49.4% (79 incidents) of the documented mishaps. The reasons for such a pronounced presence of road-related disasters could be manifold. Whether due to infrastructure challenges, vehicular conditions, or human factors like driving habits and adherence to traffic laws, this data strongly suggests that roads are the most perilous mode of transportation in the region. This realization underscores the critical need for intensified scrutiny and targeted interventions on the roadways to curb these statistics.
Maritime or water-related accidents came in second, constituting 37.5% (60 incidents) of the total. The substantial number of incidents on waterways, whether on ferries, cargo ships, or smaller vessels, calls into question the maritime safety protocols, navigation challenges, or possible environmental factors contributing to these mishaps.
Air travel, often perceived as the safest mode of transportation, wasn’t entirely immune. Air-related accidents contributed to 10.6% (17 incidents) of the overall count. While the number is relatively low, each air disaster typically has high casualties, reinforcing the need for rigorous aviation safety measures and continuous monitoring.
Lastly, rail accidents were the least frequent, contributing to a mere 2.5% (4 incidents). Despite their low frequency, rail accidents can be catastrophic given the large number of passengers involved. As such, it's imperative that rail safety isn't overlooked in the broader spectrum of transportation safety efforts.
Table 1, which delves into the specifics of these figures, serves as a potent reminder of the stark contrasts in accident frequencies across different modes of transportation. It's evident that while road safety emerges as the most pressing concern, other modes also warrant tailored safety interventions to mitigate risks and ensure the well-being of travelers.

3.2. Geographical Analysis

A meticulous geographical examination of the data revealed significant disparities among the Western Asian nations concerning the frequency of transportation incidents. Turkey emerged as a prominent hotspot, accounting for nearly half of the reported accidents. Specifically, it represented a staggering 45% of the total incidents. Such an overwhelming concentration of incidents within a single nation points towards possible underlying structural, policy-related, or socio-cultural factors that might be unique to Turkey or more pronounced there than in its neighbors.
Following Turkey, Yemen was the next significant contributor, with 16.9% of the incidents. Considering Yemen's relatively smaller size and population in comparison to Turkey, this is a substantial and concerning figure. It sheds light on the potentially heightened vulnerabilities or challenges the country might be facing in its transportation networks or safety protocols.
Syria and Iraq, two nations that have witnessed political instability and conflict in recent years, each constituted an 8.1% share of the incidents. These figures underscore the possible interplay between geopolitical events, infrastructural challenges, and transportation safety.
The geographical breakdown, illustrated in Figure 2, not only offers a clear visualization of the nation-specific incident distribution but also amplifies the urgency for targeted interventions. It suggests that a region-wide generic approach may not suffice. Instead, strategies need to be tailored to the unique challenges and needs of each country. The data points towards a pressing need for both individual nation-specific actions and collaborative regional endeavors to address the evident discrepancies in transportation safety across Western Asia.

3.3. Incident Outcomes

Of the 160 recorded incidents during the study period, a notable 56% (or 89 incidents) did not result in reported injuries. This figure, at face value, may paint a somewhat reassuring picture, highlighting that over half of the transportation mishaps did not physically harm the involved parties.
However, it's essential to view these incidents from a broader perspective. While these events might not have led to immediate physical injuries, the cascading effects they have on individuals and societies are profound. Even without immediate physical harm, the trauma and psychological aftermath of being involved in or witnessing an accident can have lasting effects on an individual's mental well-being. The flashbacks, anxiety, and possible post-traumatic stress disorders are potential outcomes that may not manifest immediately but can severely impact one's quality of life in the long run.
Moreover, the financial ramifications of these incidents can be significant. Damages to vehicles, infrastructure, or other property can result in substantial repair or replacement costs. Indirectly, accidents can cause delays, leading to lost productivity, especially if they occur on major transportation routes or hubs. The societal costs, too, come into play. Every accident, whether resulting in injury or not, serves as a stark reminder of the vulnerabilities in the transportation system. It can erode public confidence in transportation modes or agencies and might deter people from using certain modes of travel.
In essence, while the absence of physical injuries in 56% of incidents is a silver lining, it's imperative to recognize and address the broader, often intangible consequences of these mishaps. Their repercussions span beyond immediate physical harm, underscoring the holistic approach needed in transportation safety strategies.

3.4. Mortality Analysis

Upon examining the fatalities associated with the recorded incidents, it was discerned that most of the transportation accidents resulted in relatively limited loss of life, with a predominant number of incidents resulting in a death toll of 16 or fewer. This suggests that many of these mishaps, while distressing, were not of the highest lethality.
However, there were certain outliers within the dataset that starkly contrasted with this predominant trend. A handful of incidents manifested as catastrophic events, bearing a significantly higher fatality count. These aberrant incidents serve as grim reminders of the devastating potential of transportation disasters. They underscore the unpredictable and often volatile nature of accidents, emphasizing that even with the majority of incidents having limited fatalities, the possibility of a high-magnitude disaster is ever-present.
Such incidents not only result in profound loss of life but also send shockwaves across communities, sometimes even nations. They draw immense media attention, prompt policy overhauls, and evoke public demands for greater safety measures. These high-fatality incidents, although sporadic, underscore the importance of relentless vigilance, rigorous safety protocols, and the need for constant monitoring and upgradation of transportation systems.
In sum, while the data may suggest a comforting trend of limited fatalities for the majority, it simultaneously warns us of the catastrophic potential that lurks in the outliers. This duality within the mortality analysis highlights the critical need for a comprehensive approach to transportation safety, encompassing both preventive measures for everyday incidents and mitigation strategies for high-impact disasters.

3.5. Statistical Insights

A deeper statistical exploration was pursued using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) to understand the variations in death tolls across different variables. One of the primary findings of this statistical model was the significant variations in death tolls based on two key factors: year of the incident and the specific country in which the accident occurred. This insight is critical as it suggests that both temporal and geographical factors play a substantial role in influencing the severity of transportation accidents in Western Asia.
The model accounted for about 75% of the variability in death tolls, which is a substantial proportion, highlighting the robustness of the ANOVA in capturing the influences on mortality rates. This indicates that while other factors might contribute to the remaining variability, year and country are undeniably major determinants of accident lethality in the region.
Furthermore, the interaction effect between the year of occurrence and the country was found to be statistically significant. This interaction effect is of paramount importance. It suggests that the relationship between the year and mortality rates is not consistent across countries. In other words, specific years might be particularly deadly for some countries, while the same years might not show heightened fatalities in others. Such an intricate relationship between temporal and geographical factors can be influenced by a myriad of underlying causes, including policy changes, infrastructural developments, or even geopolitical tensions.
This statistical insight underscores the complexity of the factors influencing transportation-related mortality rates in Western Asia. It's not just about when the accident happens or where it happens, but also about how the specific temporal context interacts with the unique characteristics and challenges of a particular country. Such findings emphasize the need for tailored, country-specific interventions that also take into consideration the evolving temporal landscape. It highlights that a blanket approach to addressing transportation safety might not be effective across the board and that nuanced strategies, cognizant of the interplay between time and geography, are imperative.

3.6. Univariate Analysis of Variance

In examining the distribution of incidents by their respective disaster subtypes, we find that the dataset comprises 6 incidents attributed to Air, 4 to Rail, a notable 69 to Road, and 2 associated with Water. When delving into the Tests of Between-Subjects Effects, using "No Injured" as the focal dependent variable, several key metrics emerge. The analysis revealed a Type III Sum of Squares of 6361.222, distributed across 3 degrees of freedom, leading to a calculated mean square of 2120.407. The statistical analysis further produced an F-statistic of 1.139. Correspondingly, the derived significance value, or p-value, was identified as 0.339. In terms of the explanatory power of the model, the R-squared value amounted to 0.042, adjusting slightly to 0.005 when considering the adjusted R-squared.
The univariate analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed no statistically significant difference in the number of injuries resulting from aeroplane, train, car, or boat accidents. Both the F-statistic (F = 1.139) and the p-value (0.339) suggested no apparent relationship between the disaster subtype and the count of casualties. With the model's R-squared value standing at 0.042 (and an adjusted R-squared of 0.005), it becomes clear that the specific disaster subtype accounts for only a minuscule proportion of the variability in injury numbers. The analysis derived a grand mean of 37.375 injuries, accompanied by a standard error roughly amounting to 10.410.
In conclusion, while examining the connection between the nature of the disaster (be it air, rail, road, or water) and the consequent injury count, the study discerned no significant correlation. This hints at the possibility that determinants other than the disaster subtype might play a more pivotal role in influencing the severity of injuries in varying calamity scenarios.

4. Discussion

The transportation landscape of western Asia from 2003 to 2023, as presented in our findings, offers a panoramic view of the intricacies associated with accidents in the region. This section is committed to deciphering these findings, examining broader implications, and underscoring the areas that warrant further probing.
The observed increase in accidents from 2003 to 2010 is emblematic of certain systemic shortcomings in transportation safety protocols during the period's initial years [11].
While the global surge in transportation accidents during this period can be attributed to factors such as economic proliferation and escalated motorization [12], the Western Asian context might have its own unique catalysts. The World Health Organization's Global Status Report on Road Safety, for instance, has pinpointed gaps in road safety strategies during periods of rapid motorization as potential drivers for augmented accident rates [13].
The subsequent decline post-2010 is an optimistic indication, suggesting that western Asian nations possibly embarked on a journey of refining their safety measures. This positive trajectory can be attributed to a confluence of factors: stricter traffic regulations, heightened infrastructure investments, and perhaps the reverberations of global safety campaigns [14].
With road mishaps accounting for almost half of the documented accidents, there is a synchronous echo with global patterns [15]. This alignment amplifies the call for enhanced road safety measures in western Asia. Furthermore, the region's maritime significance, underscored by the 37.5% water-related accidents and crucial waterways like the Suez Canal, mandates a reinforced focus on maritime safety [16].
The predominant "Unknown" categorization, spanning 73.8% of the incidents, raises pertinent concerns. It's not merely a statistical anomaly but a potential indication of challenges ranging from data recording inefficiencies to more layered, nuanced issues like intentional vagueness due to geopolitical sensitivities [17]. Diving deeper into this ambiguity, perhaps through corroboration with other datasets or stakeholder interactions, might offer clarity [18]. A specialized exploration centering on these "Unknown" events can be illuminating, unraveling any obscured patterns.
Helicopter-related risks, making up a seemingly modest 2.5%, and migrant transportation issues, a significant 12.5%, both beckon further investigation. Given their unique dynamics, dedicated studies might be insightful [19].
Turkey's dominant representation in the dataset, encompassing 45% of events, is a testament to its intricate transportation dynamics. Despite infrastructural advancements, the nation appears to grapple with persistent safety challenges [20]. Yemen's representation might be interwoven with its civil unrest, thereby underscoring the intimate nexus between geopolitical turmoil and transportation safety [21].
The revelation that over half of the incidents were devoid of reported injuries is heartening, yet it simultaneously alludes to the often-overlooked aftermath—financial repercussions and psychological traumas [22].
A facet that warrants a deeper dive is the healthcare ramifications stemming from transportation accidents. The immediate medical aftermath of such disasters is palpable – emergency medical services spring into action, hospitals receive a surge of patients, and trauma care becomes paramount [23]. The resilience and preparedness of a region's healthcare system can significantly influence the survival rates and the prognosis of injured individuals [24].
Beyond the immediacy, transportation accidents leave an indelible mark on long-term healthcare. Survivors may grapple with prolonged physical ailments, such as chronic pain or disabilities [25]. The psychological aftermath is just as profound; Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), depression, and anxiety disorders have been documented sequelae of transportation mishaps [26]. Such chronic conditions necessitate long-term medical intervention, rehabilitation, and mental health counseling, placing sustained demands on the healthcare system.
Economically, these accidents exert immense pressure on healthcare infrastructures. Immediate medical interventions, prolonged hospitalizations, rehabilitation services, and psychological counseling – all contribute to substantial economic burdens [27]. This underscores the need for robust health insurance systems and state-sponsored medical assistance, especially in regions with significant transportation-related incidents.
Preventative measures, as in many health-related scenarios, can play a pivotal role. Strengthening first-responder training, enhancing public awareness about safe transportation practices, and fostering community-level first-aid competencies can be instrumental in mitigating the healthcare repercussions of accidents [28].
Moreover, the Western Asian context, with its unique cultural, socioeconomic, and geopolitical tapestry, may have specific healthcare challenges post-accidents. Understanding and addressing these regional nuances can pave the way for more effective, tailored healthcare interventions [29].
The variegated nature of fatalities, shaped by temporal and spatial variables, affirms the complex tapestry of factors influencing transportation mishaps. This reiterates the interplay of sociopolitical environments, geographical nuances, and even cultural predilections [30]. Intriguingly, the lack of a straightforward association between disaster type and injury count alludes to the intricate factors modulating injury outcomes, extending beyond mere transportation modes [31].
In summation, while the strides in transportation safety across western Asia during the period under consideration are commendable, the journey is far from over. The call of the hour is an integrated approach, melding collaborations, robust infrastructure, and pervasive public sensitization, all underpinned by global best practices, to curtail transportation tragedies in the region.
To conclude, significant progress in transportation safety across western Asia over the study period is evident. However, given the intricacies highlighted in our analysis, there's an unequivocal need for enhanced focus. Collaboration, infrastructure investment, and public awareness campaigns, grounded in international safety standards, remain paramount to the region's goal of minimizing transportation-related tragedies.

5. Limitations

In the quest for understanding transportation disasters in Western Asia over the past two decades, this study has attempted to provide a comprehensive overview. However, like all empirical endeavors, it is not devoid of limitations that need acknowledgment.
A primary constraint lies in the dataset's potential inability to encompass all incidents comprehensively. Minor mishaps or those incidents that might have escaped media attention may not be present, potentially leading to an underrepresentation of certain events. This raises a question on the universality of our data, especially given its reliance on significant media reports. It's well understood in media studies that certain events gain precedence owing to their sensational nature, regional significance, or underlying socio-political narratives. Thus, we might encounter a scenario where our data disproportionately represents certain accidents, regions, or severity levels, potentially offering an incomplete or slightly distorted picture of the true nature of transportation mishaps in Western Asia.
Compounding this issue is the categorization challenge, most notably highlighted by the sizable "Unknown" label in our data. The absence of thorough documentation or details for these events underscores potential blind spots, challenging the full interpretation of the dataset and possibly influencing some of our findings.
While our endeavor heavily leaned on secondary data sources, chosen for their credibility, there's always an inherent risk of inconsistencies, biases, and inaccuracies in such datasets. Differences in reporting standards among countries, the prevailing political climate influencing reportage, the evolving nature of technology affecting the richness of earlier data, and even societal perceptions around accidents can all lead to diverse quality and completeness of data. For instance, some countries may have established rigorous mechanisms for accident reporting, whereas others might be influenced by political considerations or cultural attitudes that discourage full disclosure.
Our statistical choice of ANOVA, designed to identify variances, is undoubtedly robust. However, its essence lies in identifying patterns and correlations, not causalities. While it excels in underscoring significant differences, causal inferences should be approached with circumspection. The intricacies and implications of ANOVA may also be elusive to those not well-acquainted with statistical methodologies.
Furthermore, while our study meticulously details transportation mishaps in various dimensions, it stops short of diving into the deep-seated causes, societal repercussions, or the socio-political undercurrents influencing these events. To holistically grasp these, a fusion of insights from diverse disciplines like political science, sociology, and infrastructure engineering would be indispensable.
While our analysis delves deeply into the patterns and implications of transportation accidents, the specific health outcomes and economic burdens associated with these incidents remain largely unexplored due to data constraints. We recognize the criticality of an integrated approach, which would incorporate comprehensive healthcare data and detailed economic evaluations, to provide a multi-dimensional understanding. The extrapolation of healthcare ramifications and economic pressures based solely on incident data might not capture the full depth and breadth of the impact. Therefore, future investigations should prioritize the amalgamation of health and economic datasets for a more nuanced and holistic appraisal.
The emphasis on advanced technological solutions, such as intelligent traffic systems and vehicular communication infrastructure, is indicative of potential preventive measures. However, this study has not delved into the practical challenges, feasibility, and adoption rates of such technologies within the Western Asian context. Implementing technological solutions in any transportation ecosystem is contingent upon a myriad of factors, including infrastructural readiness, regulatory frameworks, and stakeholder willingness. Subsequent studies should deeply investigate these dynamics, weighing the potential benefits against real-world challenges and barriers to successful integration.
To encapsulate, this research, with its rich insights into Western Asia's transportation mishaps, presents findings that should be interpreted cognizant of the aforementioned limitations. It serves as a foundation for future inquiries that can further refine our understanding of the region's transportation milieu.

6. Conclusions

The study provides an exhaustive examination of transportation accidents in Western Asia over the span of two decades. Distinct patterns emerge from the data, presenting both concerning upticks and subsequently encouraging downturns in transportation mishaps. The rise in accidents in the initial phase, followed by a noticeable decline post-2011, lends credence to the hypothesis that concerted efforts, involving the introduction of more rigorous safety protocols, the enactment of stringent regulations, and beneficial international collaborations, have borne fruit.
Road accidents stand out as the predominant category, emphasizing the immediate need to integrate advanced technological solutions. Embracing intelligent traffic systems, harnessing the potential of adaptive signaling, and championing vehicular communication infrastructure can pave the way for a transformation in road safety. Parallelly, public awareness campaigns, underpinned by more rigid traffic regulations, can catalyze behavioral shifts essential for a safer road environment.
The sizable segment of "Unknown" incidents underscores a pressing gap in data reporting. Advocating for standardized, meticulous documentation is critical. A vision for the future could be the establishment of a real-time, continuously updated regional database, acting as a central repository for all transportation-related occurrences, thereby fostering transparency and research.
Certain categories, like "Migrants" and "Helicopters," emerge as outliers, warranting nuanced scrutiny. These specific categories, while statistically smaller, reveal deeper socio-political intricacies and operational challenges that merit individualized research and solutions.
When examining country-specific data, the complexities associated with nations like Turkey and Yemen come to the fore. These intricacies accentuate the premise that one-size-fits-all strategies might be ineffectual. Tailored, context-sensitive interventions hold the promise of more significant impact.
In culmination, the path forward for Western Asia is unmistakably clear: a holistic, multi-pronged strategy. This strategy must synergize infrastructure evolution, widespread public awareness initiatives, rigorous regulatory frameworks, and beneficial international alliances. Beyond the technical and regulatory domain, addressing the region's socio-political challenges head-on will be pivotal. Only through such a comprehensive approach can we envision and actualize a safer, more resilient transportation landscape for Western Asia.

Author Contributions

Z.A.M. provided the main framework, identified, and organized primary materials, and collaborated in writing the manuscript. K.G. identified appropriate references and collaborated on the writing and editing of the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Informed Consent Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Acknowledgments

The authors extend their appreciation to the Deputyship for Research & Innovation, Ministry of Education in Saudi Arabia for funding this research work through the project number (ISP2398)

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Canitez, F. Urban public transport systems from new institutional economics perspective: a literature review. Transport Reviews. 2019, 39, 511–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  2. Kassens-Noor, E.; Dake, D.; Decaminada, T.; Kotval-KZ; Qu, T.; Wilson, M.; Pentland, B. Sociomobility of the 21st century: Autonomous vehicles, planning, and the future city. Transport Policy. 2020, 99, 329–35. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  3. World Health Organization. Global Health Risks: Mortality and Burden of Disease. 2021. [Google Scholar]
  4. Alam, K.M.; Li, X.; Baig, S. Impact of transport cost and travel time on trade under China-Pakistan economic corridor (CPEC). Journal of Advanced Transportation. 2019, 2019. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  5. Lin, W. Transport geography and geopolitics: Visions, rules and militarism in China's Belt and Road Initiative and beyond. Journal of Transport Geography. 2019, 81, 102436. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  6. Bertoli, P.; Grembi, V.; Castello, J.V. Not all silver lining? The Great Recession and road traffic accidents. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 2018, 70, 274–88. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  7. Knowles, R.D.; Ferbrache, F.; Nikitas, A. Transport's historical, contemporary and future role in shaping urban development: Re-evaluating transit oriented development. Cities. 2020, 99, 102607. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  8. Emergency Event Database (EM-DAT) (2023) https://www.emdat.be/staff/.
  9. Ferreira-Vanegas, C.M.; Vélez, J.I.; García-Llinás, G.A. Analytical methods and determinants of frequency and severity of road accidents: a 20-year systematic literature review. Journal of advanced transportation. 2022, 2022. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  10. Ispahani, M. Roads and Rivals: The Political Uses of Access in the Borderlands of Asia; Cornell University Press, 15 May 2019. [Google Scholar]
  11. Saidi, S.; Mani, V.; Mefteh, H.; Shahbaz, M.; Akhtar, P. Dynamic linkages between transport, logistics, foreign direct Investment, and economic growth: Empirical evidence from developing countries. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice. 2020, 141, 277–93. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  12. Heydari, S.; Hickford, A.; McIlroy, R.; Turner, J.; Bachani, A.M. Road safety in low-income countries: state of knowledge and future directions. Sustainability. 2019, 11, 6249. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  13. World Health Organization. Global Status Report on Road Safety; 2018. [Google Scholar]
  14. Goniewicz, K.; Goniewicz, M.; Pawłowski, W.; Fiedor, P. Road accident rates: strategies and programmes for improving road traffic safety. European journal of trauma and emergency surgery. 2016, 42, 433–8. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  15. Road Safety Annual Report 2022 | ITF https://www.itf-oecd.org/road-safety-annual-report-2022.
  16. Bueger, C. From dusk to dawn? Maritime domain awareness in Southeast Asia. Contemporary Southeast Asia 2015, 157–182. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. De Vos, J.; Mokhtarian, P.L.; Schwanen, T.; Van Acker, V.; Witlox, F. Travel mode choice and travel satisfaction: bridging the gap between decision utility and experienced utility. Transportation. 2016, 43, 771–96. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Costin, A.; Adibfar, A.; Hu, H.; Chen, S.S. Building Information Modeling (BIM) for transportation infrastructure–Literature review, applications, challenges, and recommendations. Automation in construction. 2018, 94, 257–81. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Ho, L.K.; Chan, J.K.; den Heyer, G.; Hsu, J.S.; Hirai, A.; Ho, L.K.; Chan, J.K.; den Heyer, G.; Hsu, J.S.; Hirai, A. A Helicopter View of the Police Oversight Mechanisms in Hong Kong, Japan and Taiwan. Policing the Police in Asia: Police Oversight in Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan. 2021, 1-5.
  20. İşleyen, B. Transit mobility governance in Turkey. Political Geography. 2018, 62, 23–32. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Karim, F.M.; Saleh, A.A.; Taijoobux, A.; Ševrović, M. Developing a model for forecasting road traffic accident (RTA) fatalities in Yemen. Slovak Journal of Civil Engineering. 2017, 25, 12. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Franklin, F.T. The politics of resilience and sustainable development: pragmatic reflections on vulnerability from environmental, economic and community perspectives. Res. & Sci. Today. 2019, 18, 125. [Google Scholar]
  23. Hodge, J.G.; Piatt, J.L.; Freed, R. Navigating Legalities in Crisis Standards of Care. J. Health Care L. & Pol'y. 2022, 25, 171. [Google Scholar]
  24. El Saghir, N.S.; Soto Pérez de Celis, E.; Fares, J.E.; Sullivan, R. Cancer care for refugees and displaced populations: Middle East conflicts and global natural disasters. American Society of Clinical Oncology Educational Book. 2018, 38, 433–40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  25. Leder, D. The Healing Body: Creative Responses to Illness, Aging, and Affliction; Northwestern University Press, 2023. [Google Scholar]
  26. Burback, L.; Brémault-Phillips, S.; Nijdam, M.J.; McFarlane, A.; Vermetten, E. Treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A State-of-the-art Review. Curr. Neuropharmacol. 2023. [CrossRef]
  27. Haque, M.; Islam, T.; Rahman, N.A.; McKimm, J.; Abdullah, A.; Dhingra, S. Strengthening primary health-care services to help prevent and control long-term (chronic) non-communicable diseases in low-and middle-income countries. Risk management and healthcare policy. 2020, 409–426. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Huo, C.; Hameed, J.; Nawaz, A.; Shah, S.A.; Alqahtani, W.; Maqsoom, A.; Anwar, M.K. Scientific risk performance analysis and development of disaster management framework: a case study of developing Asian countries. Journal of King Saud University-Science. 2021, 33, 101348. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  29. Burkle, F.M.; Khorram-Manesh, A.; Goniewicz, K. COVID-19 and beyond: The pivotal role of health literacy in pandemic preparedness. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine 2023, 1–2. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  30. Miller, M.A.; Zachary, J.F. Mechanisms and morphology of cellular injury, adaptation, and death. Pathologic basis of veterinary disease. 2017, 2. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  31. Betz, U.A.; Arora, L.; Assal, R.A.; Azevedo, H.; Baldwin, J.; Becker, M.S.; Bostock, S.; Cheng, V.; Egle, T.; Ferrari, N.; Schneider-Futschik, E.K. Game changers in science and technology-now and beyond. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2023, 193, 122588. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. D:\manuscript\1 Under Review\sustainability\sustainability-2591929\R oad Safety Annual Report 2022 | ITF https:\www.itf-oecd.org\road-safety-annual-report-2022.
Preprints 82969 g002
Figure 2. Geographical Distribution of Incidents.
Figure 2. Geographical Distribution of Incidents.
Preprints 82969 g002
Table 1. Type of disaster accidents.
Table 1. Type of disaster accidents.
Type Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative Percent
Air 17 10.6 10.6 10.6
Rail 4 2.5 2.5 13.1
Road 79 49.4 49.4 62.5
Water 60 37.5 37.5 100.0
Total 160 100.0 100.0
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyright: This open access article is published under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license, which permit the free download, distribution, and reuse, provided that the author and preprint are cited in any reuse.
Prerpints.org logo

Preprints.org is a free preprint server supported by MDPI in Basel, Switzerland.

facebook logotwitter logolinkedin logo
MDPI Initiatives
Important Links
Subscribe

Disclaimer

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

© 2024 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated