1. Introduction
Plant-parasitic nematodes (PPNs) are a large group of soil-borne roundworms that primarily attack underground plant parts, leading to stunted growth and endangering nutrient supply from the soil, and causing a first-hand globally annual yielding loss of over
$157 billion [
1]. These nematodes also increase the susceptibility of plant roots to other pathogenic fungal and bacterial infections and serve as vectors for certain plant-pathogenic viruses [
2]. Although various chemical nematicides and agricultural managements have been the typical implements for controlling PPNs for a long time, integrated biological control has gained increasing incentive as a prioritized approach to combating PPNs due to its sustainability and eco-friendly nature [
3,
4].
A variety of soil-borne bacteria, mainly belonging to several genera including
Bacillus [
5,
6],
Pseudomonas [
7,
8],
Pasteuria [
9], and
Burkholderia [
10], etc., have been confirmed the significant nematicidal activity. These bacteria have developed various strategies, such as the production of external toxins, invasive enzymes, or other active substances to trap and kill nematodes; and/or acting as external parasites by utilizing extracellular proteases to digest the nematode cuticle [
11]; or producing nematode-toxic metabolites after entering the nematode's body, for instance, the Cry proteins from a nematicidal bacterium
Bacillus thuringiensis formed lytic pores in the cell membrane of intestinal epithelial cells upon ingestion [
12].
Chemotaxis is a conventional behavior by bacteria to sense chemical cues in their surroundings, enabling them to relocate to favorable niches away from toxic substances. The methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs) are a family of chemoreceptors responsible for the chemotactic behaviors of many bacteria [
13]. Structurally, MCPs consist of a typical C-terminal cytoplasmic signaling domain (SD), two membrane-spanning helices, and an N-terminal periplasmic ligand-binding domain (LBD). The highly conserved SD domain contains methylated glutamate residues that interact with downstream signaling components, while the less conserved LBD typically contains signal peptide sequences that act as transmembrane segments in mature proteins [
14]. Most MCPs also contain a histidine kinases, adenylate cyclases, methyl-accepting proteins, and phosphatases (HAMP) domain that propagates signals from the sensing domain to the cytoplasmic domain [
15]. Upon perceiving an external environmental signal, MCP undergoes a conformational change by adopting a hairpin structure, where a series of sensor kinases (such as CheA, CheB, and CheW, etc.) were phosphorylated or self-phosphorylated to stepwise activate the response regulator CheY, which enables phosphorylating the flagellar matrix, resulting in a change in the direction of flagellar rotation [
14]. Moreover, chemotaxis is also involved in the pathogenicity of various bacterial pathogens, including
Vibrio cholera [
16],
Coronobacter sakazakii [
17],
Campylobacter jejuni [
18],
Pseudomonas aeruginosa [
18], and
Pseudomonas syringae [
19]. The connection between chemotaxis and pathogenicity relies on the detection of pathogenicity-related signal molecules in the hosts by MCPs, which play a critical role in regulating certain cellular activities, such as biofilm formation, toxin production, exopolysaccharide production, flagellum biosynthesis, cell survival, motility, pathogenicity, and antibiotic resistance [
20].
The conventional phytopathogen
P. syringae has been identified significant nematicidal activity against the model nematode
Caenorhabditis elegans [
21,
22], and a recent genome-wide prediction analysis of nematicidal factors in a
P. syringae wild-type strain MB03 revealed significant nematicidal virulence potential of an MCP (namely MCP03) against
C. elegans [
23]. However, the nematicidal activity and action mechanism of MCP03 remain understudied. In the current study, we investigated the nematicidal activity and action receptor protein of MCP03 for elucidating its pathogenic mechanism. Owing to the current technical limitations of molecular genetic studies on PPNs,
C. elegans was used as a target nematode due to its well-characterized genetic background [
24]. We identified a subunit of a COP9 signalosome (CSN) that served as a receptor protein (namely CSN-5) of MCP03 in
C. elegans, which associatively exerted destructive effects on the intestinal tract and the ovary, enabled lethal and detrimental effects on the egg-laying, growth, and surface cuticle formation by downregulating the expression of genes relative to these activities. Thus, a putative outline mechanism underlying the nematicidal action of MCP03 following the binding with CSN-5 was proposed.
4. Discussion
This study aimed to investigate the action mechanism underlying the nematicidal activity of MCP03, a methyl-accepting chemotaxis protein, in the
P. syringae MB03-
C. elegans infection model. We evaluated not only the direct nematicidal activity of MCP03 against
C. elegans, but also the detrimental effects on the growth, brood size, and external and internal morphology of
C. elegans. We identified CSN-5 as an MCP03-binding protein in
C. elegans. Although the role of MCPs as key players in chemotaxis and pathogenicity has been well-characterized in different bacteria [
14], this study for the first time provides new insights into the nematicidal activity and action mechanism of a bacterial MCP against nematodes.
In
P. syringae MB03 genome, total of 46 MCP-encoding genes (chemoreceptor genes) were annotated. Interestingly, the genome-wide prediction of nematicidal genes of
P. syringae MB03 showed the nematicidal potential of MCP03 among these MCPs [
23]. In consistent with this prediction, the bioassays of heterologously expressed MCP03 exhibited a significantly lethal activity again
C. elegans, with an LC
50 of 124.47 (99.22~147.47) μg mL
–1, and multiple detrimental effects on the growth, reproduction, and morphology of
C. elegans. Although the activity is relatively lower than that of Cry5Da1, a well-known eminent bacterial nematicidal toxin of
B. thuringiensis with an LC
50 of 36.69 μg mL
–1 against
C. elegans [
46], given the multifaceted nematode-toxic activities, MCP03 still holds promise as a potential nematode-pest control agent for pursuing in agricultural, horticultural or forestry applications.
A subunit of COP9 signalosome, CSN-5, is primarily localized in the cytoplasm and nucleus as its interacting partner.
C. elegans contains seven CSN subunits; CSN 1, 2, 3, 4, and 7 possess PCI domains that promote protein-protein interactions and have nucleic acid binding properties [
47]. In contrast, CSN-5 and CSN-6 possess an MPN domain with a JAMM (Jab/MPN/Mov34) sequence and exhibit metalloproteinase activity [
48]. CSN-5 is also involved in ubiquitin-dependent protein degradation, regulation of the cell cycle, and also regulate multiple signal transduction processes [
49]. In the current study, CSN-5 was identified as the binding receptor of MCP03 through multiple
in vitro and
in vivo experiments. The data shown in
Figure 2 indicate that MCP03 targeted the intestinal tissues of N2, and caused severe destructive impairment on the integrity of epithelial junctions and other organs (such as the ovary). We currently presume that these pathological changes could be the main lethal determinants of MCP03 treatment, as these changes definitely associated with other stepwise pathological processes, such as the decrease of food intake, the collapse of substance and energy metabolisms, the occurrence of septicemia, among others, which ultimately led to the death of
C. elegans. However, whether these pathological processes were related to the binding of MCP03 and CSN-5 remained unknown. Further studies are required to elucidate the role and action mechanism of the MCP03-CSN-5 binding complex in the pathogenesis of MCP03 targeting the intestinal tract of worms.
Several investigations have demonstrated that CSN-5 interacted with UNC-98 and UNC-96 involved in the assembly and maintenance of myofibers [
42]. The outer surface of MCP03-treated N2 was severely shrunk (
Figure 2C), the expression of
col-117 and
unc-98 was significantly downregulated (
Figure 7), and the CSN-5 RNAi-silenced worms retrieved surface cuticle integrity to an extent (
Figure 6D). These results suggest that MCP03 interacts with CSN-5, resulting in the downregulation of the expression of collagen and certain muscle-related proteins, and causing the severely depressed wrinkles of the worms' surface. Additionally, MCP03 also suppressed the brood size to a lesser extent (
Figure 2A), and RNAi with
csn-5 significantly reduced the spawning rate of N2 (
Figure 6C), confirming the critical role of CSN-5 in regulating the fertility activity of
C. elegans, which could be attributed to the downregulation of the
kgb-1 expression, as CSN-5 and KGB-1 are capable of regulating the expression of GLH-1 which is crucial for the fertility of
C. elegans [
41]. It is noteworthy that the expression of
csn-5 in N2 remained unchanged following MCP03 treatment. We speculate that MCP03 was bound to CSN-5, and enabled inhibiting its activity to some extent without significantly reducing the protein's expression. However, it is possible that MCP03 has other but undetected receptors in
C. elegans, owing to the coverage limitations of the cDNA library and insufficient screening processes in the current study.
Based on the results obtained in this study, we propose the following outline for the pathogenicity of MCP03 against
C. elegans. Following the entry of MCP03 into the intestinal tract of
C. elegans by feeding, MCP03 entered the intestinal epithelial cells, thereby triggering the physiological and pathological changes of the epithelial cells, leading to a series of lesions such as intestinal perforation, disruption of osmotic balance, and destruction of partial intestinal tissues, ultimately causing the death of
C. elegans worms. Meanwhile, MCP03 bound to its receptor protein CSN-5 to form an MCP03-CSN-5 complex in some target cells, thereby activating multiple signaling pathways, including downregulating the genes
col-117,
kgb-1 and
unc-98, and upregulating other genes including
mpk-1, among others. The activity changes ultimately lead to adverse effects on the fertility capability, growth, and cuticle integrity of
C. elegans. Of these continuous signaling pathways, some behind signaling molecules, such as DAF-16, MPK-1, and GLH-1, etc., which activating various subsequent pathological lesions following the MCP03-CSN-5 binding are conducive for pathogenesis. In fact, DAF-16 has been proved to be positively regulated when worms were infected and the epidermis were damaged [
50]; MPK-1 was able to promote resveratrol-mediated nematode lifespan in a non-dependent manner through the SIR-2.1/DAF-16 (closely related to regulating nematode lifespan and immunity) pathway by regulating the accumulation of SKN-1 in the nucleus [
44]. It is therefore of particular interest to further investigate the signaling pathways underlying the interactions of these proteins that function as signaling molecules to actuate the pathogenesis of
C. elegans worms; such an investigation is now one of our primary goals.
Figure 8.
The proposed action mechanism underlying MCP03 pathogenicity against C. elegans.
Figure 8.
The proposed action mechanism underlying MCP03 pathogenicity against C. elegans.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, L.L., L.X. and J.L.; methodology, J.L., H.D., A.B. and Z.W.; validation, J.L. and H.D.; formal analysis, H.D., Y.A. and A.B.; investigation, J.L., H.D., A.B., Z.W. and X.Y.; data curation, J.L., H.D., A.B., Y.A. and L.L.; writing—original draft preparation, J.L., H.D. and A.B.; writing—review and editing: L.L. and X.Y.; supervision, L.L. and L.X.; funding acquisition, J.L and L.L. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.