2.1.2.2. The addition of mordants
Mordants are often used as additives in dyebaths to improve the binding of natural pigments to fibers. Concerning that, mordants form complexes with natural dyes capable of attaching to the fiber surfaces, improving the exhaustion of dyebaths and the washing fastness of the dyed fabrics. Nevertheless, the various forms and types of mordants can influence the shades and hues of the fabrics, resulting in brighter or darker colors, or even differences in the natural color of the pigment, which can be a beneficial or an unwanted effect [
2,
4]. Moreover, the mordant concentration is also a crucial factor that can cause an increase in the color intensity during the textile dyeing [
4]. Therefore, the effect of the addition of mordants, like FeSO
4 and L-Cys, on the
K/S values and
dE of the dyed fabrics was investigated at three different concentrations (1.0%, 3.0%, and 5.0%
owf),
Figure 2 and
Table 2.
To achieve bright and strong colors with natural dyes, metallic mordants such as the conventional FeSO
4, that is known as a blue-green vitriol water-soluble dulling mordant, have been commonly used [
4]. However, the solubility of the FeSO
4 mordant in the aqueous crude gel prodigiosin pigment bath was low, resulting in a heterogeneous coloration at a rate directly proportional to the increase in mordant concentration,
Figure 2. Similar results were previously reported by Burkinshaw et al. and Mongkholrattanasit et al., who observed a shade of dark greyish-brown in the fabric of relatively low
K/S when FeSO
4 mordant was added [
28,
29]. Such occur essentially due to the ability of the pigment molecules to form a metallic complex with positively charged ions (Fe
2+), as previously described by Uddin [
30]. Hence, when the FeSO
4 mordant was added to the crude gel prodigiosin dyebath solution different shades of color were observed in the distinct fibers and a blackening of the color shades was revealed when the mordant concentration increases of 1.0%
owf to 5.0%
owf,
Figure 2. Similar observations have also been reported by other researchers in the literature [
4]. Moreover, the lower concentration of FeSO
4 (1.0%
owf) resulted in a smoother and similar dyeing among the fabrics, while a higher concentration of FeSO
4 (5.0%
owf) presented a deep but uneven dyeing,
Figure 2 and
Table 2.
In addition, the crude gel prodigiosin pigment with 1.0% and 3.0%
owf of FeSO
4 exhibited the highest affinity for nylon and wool fibers (
Table 2), resulting in the highest
K/S values (
K/SNylon_1.0% FeSO4 = 1.39;
K/SNylon_3.0% FeSO4 = 2.02;
K/SWool_1.0% FeSO4 = 1.47;
K/SWool_3.0% FeSO4 = 2.44), as well as, lower
dE (
dENylon_1.0% FeSO4 = 0.09;
dENylon_3.0% FeSO4 = 0.09;
dEWool_1.0% FeSO4 = 0.10;
dEWool_3.0% FeSO4 = 0.11).
On the other hand, bio-mordants, like L-Cys have been regarded as a sustainable and ecologically alternative to metallic mordanting. The dyeing of the fabrics with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment using L-Cys as bio-mordant resulted in different tones of pink. These different tones were similar for the three different concentrations of prodigiosin,
Figure 2. Nevertheless, nylon and wool displayed a better color strength (K/S
Nylon_1.0% L-Cys = 1.12; K/S
Nylon_3.0% L-Cys = 1.72; K/S
Nylon_5.0% L-Cys = 1.61; K/S
Wool_1.0% L-Cys = 1.69; K/S
Wool_3.0% L-Cys = 2.08; K/S
Wool_5.0% L-Cys = 2.48), and an improved dyeing equalization (dE) in the presence of 3.0% owf of L-Cys (dE
Nylon_3.0% L-Cys = 0.02 and dE
Wool_3.0% L-Cys = 0.04).
Therefore, as an efficient dyeing depends on the color intensity of dyed fibers and a good equalization, 3.0% owf of L-Cys should be chosen to achieve a better dyeing process with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment.
Nevertheless, bacterial pigments, such as prodigiosin are sensitive to pH alterations, resulting in color changes. Namely, pink prodigiosin pigment at acidic pH changes to blue-purple and at alkaline pH's to orange-yellow, respectively [
24,
26]. Thus, in order to analyse the effect of dyebath pH on the color characteristics, two different pH values (pH = 4.0 and pH = 8.3) were studied in the various types of fiber under different conditions (without and with simultaneous mordanting of 3.0% owf of FeSO
4 and L-Cys),
Figure 3 and
Table 3.
At pH = 4.0, the crude gel prodigiosin pigment dyeing of the fabrics with the metallic mordant (FeSO
4) was favour in comparison with the dyeing process with bio-mordant (L-Cys) and without the addition of mordant, revealing a greater pink color strength (K/S), less fiber oxidation, and more efficient dyeing,
Figure 3. Moreover, the dyeing with FeSO
4 demonstrated a superior stability of the pink color of crude gel prodigiosin pigment in the different fibers, particularly in nylon and wool (K/S
Nylon_3.0% FeSO4_pH=4.0 = 3.30; K/S
Wool_3.0% FeSO4_pH=4.0 = 3.22; (dE
Nylon_3.0% FeSO4_pH=4.0 = 0.13; dE
Wool_3.0% FeSO4_pH=4.0 = 0.35). Therefore, the acidic pH provided more efficient dyeing in the presence of the metallic mordant, increasing its solubility and improving its equalization (dE),
Table 3. Similar data were reported by Uddin, who revealed that mordants’ metal ions act as electron acceptors for electron donors and produce coordination bonds with the dye molecules, making them insoluble in water [
30]. In this way, metallic mordants, such as FeSO
4, can improve the dye uptake and retention, resulting in a higher depth of shade and greater color fastness properties. Furthermore, Alihosseini et al. showed that prodigiosin pigments produced from a strain of Vibrio sp. isolated from marine sediments were able to dye wool, nylon, acrylics, and silk fibers [
23]. However, Alihosseini et al. found enhanced dyeing characteristics. The reason for this was because different prodigiosin-producing strains were used and the prodigiosin pigments exhibited different levels of purification [
23]. Thus, the bacterial pigment color can be influenced by their nature and consequently, various shades of the same pigment can be obtained on similar fabrics [
2].
On the other hand, the infeasibility of dyeing with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment at acidic pH for the fibers dyed simultaneously with L-Cys and without the addition of mordant was confirmed with the high values of dE and consequently in a lower equalization of dyeing.
In turn, at pH = 8.3, the dyeing process with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment was favoured in the three different conditions (without the addition of mordants, with the addition of L-Cys, and FeSO
4), although this pH aid the dyeing with the bio-mordant, because pH = 8.3 is related to the pKa of L-Cys. The fibers dyed with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment in the presence of L-Cys and without the addition of any auxiliary revealed similar and efficient dyeing,
Figure 3 and
Table 3. Moreover, the dyeing was homogeneous when L-Cys was added, revealing good equalization values (dE
Acetate_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.11; dE
Cotton_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.13; dE
Nylon_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.05; dE
Polyester_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.11; dE
Acrylic_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.11; dE
Wool_3.0% L-Cys_pH=8.3 = 0.27).
However, when the FeSO
4 was used, the oxidation of the fibers increased, mainly in the wool and nylon due to the higher adsorption to the surface of fibers. Nevertheless, although a stronger color strength of the nylon and wool fibers was obtained (K/S
Nylon_3.0% FeSO4_pH=8.3 = 3.67; K/S
Wool_3.0% FeSO4_pH=8.3 = 3.11), the dE was higher (dE
Nylon_3.0% FeSO4_pH=8.3 = 0.11; dE
Wool_3.0% FeSO4_pH=8.3 = 0.33)
Figure 3 and
Table 3.
Hence, the choice of the ideal conditions for the dyeing process with the crude gel prodigiosin pigment depends on the color intensity and the uniformity of the dyes. So, it was decided to proceed with 3.0% owf L-Cys at pH = 8.3 for dyeing the nylon and wool fabrics.