4.1. Mycological contamination
Mycotoxins are considered one of the most serious contaminants of foodstuffs because of the risk of disease which they pose to both humans and animals. The issue of mycotoxin contamination is addressed in Commission Regulation (EC) No 2023/915, which sets out maximum levels for specific contaminants in food. Specifically, this regulation covers the most significant mycotoxins: AFB1, AFB2, AFG1, and AFG2; deoxynivalenol (DON); the fumonisins B1 (FB1) and FB2; zearalenone (ZEA); the T-2 and HT-2 toxins; and ochratoxin A (OTA) [
28]. Two decades prior to this regulation, AFs were not even identified as a concern for primary production in Europe [
22,
23]. However, in the year 2003, the first alarming contamination of maize was reported in Italy [
28].
With regard to specific crops, our findings showed that maize was contaminated at a higher rate compared to wheat. For the three main mold genera, Aspergillus, Penicillium, and Fusarium, a similar pattern distribution was exhibited in both crops. However, we found a different situation for the Alternaria and Cladosporium genera; in both cases, wheat samples were more likely to be affected than maize samples, with incidence percentages of 19.7%, and 2.90%, respectively.
4.2. AFB1 presence in maize and wheat
Climate change has introduced aflatoxigenic species and increased the incidence of AFB1 in crops grown in Europe, especially southern Europe [
30]. Climate-change scenarios involving an increase in temperature of only 2°C suggest an increased probability of aflatoxin contamination—from low to medium—in European countries like France, Italy, and Romania where maize is expected to be cultivated [
4,
12]. One report on the incidence of AF in maize from the western Balkans found high levels of incidence and contamination during the harvesting season of 2013 [
31]. The hot and dry conditions necessary for Aspergillus flavus infestation of maize mainly prevail in Europe at latitudes below 45° N [
32]. As a country in southern Europe, Albania has faced climate modification in the last decades. Previous publications indicate that mycotoxin contamination in crops presents a critical food safety issue in the country [
33,
34]. The study of aflatoxin B1 in crops which may also be used as feed is especially important because feed contaminated with the AFB1 metabolite may result in the milk of lactating animals being contaminated with AFM1, another regulated mycotoxin; indeed, the presence of AFM1 in milk produced in Albania has already been reported in the literature [
35]. Being toxic, carcinogenic, and immunosuppressive, aflatoxins can produce acute liver toxicoses, liver cancer, and growth impairment in children. Because of this, they are now the subject of ongoing monitoring and evaluation of the risk they pose to consumers worldwide [
36].
Maize is used extensively as feed in poultry and cattle farming. In the present study, it was found that 32.35% of Albanian maize samples exceeded the MRL for the use of maize as animal feed (20 μg/kg). In contrast, just 2.1% of samples were found to exceed this level in a previous study of AFB1 in feed in Europe [
37]. In addition, compared with data on the incidence of AFB1 from the years 2014 and 2015, we found that samples from 2023 exhibited a much lower level of incidence compared with 2014 (a mean value of 464 μg/kg), but a similar level compared with 2015 (a mean value of 55.7 μg/kg) [
34]. This suggests that aflatoxin production may be dramatically influenced by annual climatic fluctuations.
In several regions, mycotoxin concentrations in maize have shown a pronounced year-to-year variation that could be explained by rainfall or temperature conditions during sensitive periods of grain development. Gruber-Dorninger and colleagues (2019) found that, globally, the incidence of AFB1 in maize was 24%. They also found that a large percentage (64%) of maize grains exhibited co-contamination involving two or more mycotoxins. The most frequently observed combinations were mixtures of fusarium toxins, e.g., a combination of deoxynivalenol zearalenone and fumonisins. Co-contaminations with fusarium and aspergillus toxins, e.g., fumonisins and aflatoxin B1, were also reported. In another study carried out in Serbia, an incidence level of 52.5% was reported for AFB1, with total concentrations of AFs in a range of 1–70.3 µg/kg [
38],
In the present study, we analyzed wheat samples from three regions: Fieri, Elbasani, and Korça (Table 2). AFB1 was found in only three out of sixty-one samples, giving an incidence level of less than 5%. In these positive samples, concentrations ranged from 0.221-0.401 μg/kg, with a mean of 0.312 μg/kg, indicating that no sample exceeded the MRL (2 μg/kg) [
39]. All the contaminated wheat samples originated from the Fieri region. Similar rates of contamination was found in a previous survey of Albanian wheat, with figures of 6.0% and 0.0% reported for the years 2014 and 2015, respectively [
34].
Our data indicate a figure for AFB1 incidence in wheat, which lies in the same range as data previously reported in the literature. In a review paper published by Gruber-Dorninger and colleagues (2019), a worldwide AFB1 incidence of 10% was reported. Our data also indicate a level of contamination which is lower than the global referred median (1.0 μg/kg) or maximum (161 μg/kg) values. Compared with data from other countries in southeast Europe, we found a lower level of wheat contamination than that reported for Romania (45.4%) [
40], but a similar level to that reported for Serbia [
38], Croatia [
28], and Italy [
41]. Finally, AFB1 has been found to be more prevalent in southern Europe than in other European regions (28.9% compared to 5.9–17.0% positive samples) [
37] and in China [
42].
Considering different AFB1 contamination levels among maize and wheat samples, the climate conditions are the main factor in the pre-harvesting stage. The wheat commodity cropped in the Summer season, June-July, allowing the crop to reach a moisture level below 12%. In contrast, the maize harvesting stage during the Autumn season, September-October, depended on the climate, exposure to rains, ensuring proper conditions, aw and increased temperatures, favouring the fungi growth.
This study presents mycological contamination on two main grains grown in the country while also giving their aflatoxin B1 contamination. Battilani and colleagues (2016), and Leggeri and colleagues (2021) have proposed prediction models on aflatoxin maize contamination for southern European countries like Italy. This study on aflatoxin contamination will help to develop prediction models for Albania. Fusarium sp., are common fungi in temperate regions, indicating fusarium toxins presence in the cereals. Further study needs to focus on giving evidence of co-contamination of corn grains with toxins produced from Aspergillus, Fusarium, and Penicillium genera.
The globalization of trade in food commodities has indirectly increased the possibility that consumers in developing countries will be exposed to mycotoxins, with consequent impact on health and quality of life. Ongoing monitoring of exported food products will ensure that products which do not comply with global food-quality standards will be distributed in local markets. Developing countries still need better monitoring and safety standards [
43].