1. Introduction
Atlantic salmon (
Salmo salar) is a major commercial species in the salmonid family, produced in large numbers in Norway, Chile, the UK, and Canada. Norway’s long shoreline and cold, clean seawater provide excellent conditions for its aquaculture. However, superficial hyperpigmented areas on salmon fillets, called “black spots (BS),” represent a major problem for the commercial aquaculture of Atlantic salmon. BS in white skeletal muscle of farmed Atlantic salmon can appear initially as red spots (RS) characterized by hemorrhages and acute inflammation and progress into BS characterized by chronic inflammation and accumulating pigmented immune cells called “melanomacrophages” [
1]. RS and BS are also known as “red focal changes (RFC)” and “melanized focal changes (MFC)” in the fillet, respectively [
2] (
Figure 1).
These discolorations cause large economic losses since fillets with pigmented abnormalities are commercially downgraded because of reduced attractiveness. A study found that in the production period of 59 weeks after the transfer of juvenile salmon (smolts) to sea, MFC first appeared with low frequency but then became more frequent, whereas the RFC maintained a constant low prevalence of about 4% [
3]. Over time, the prevalence of MFC on fillets of Norwegian sea-reared salmon has increased substantially, from 7% in 2003 to 20% in 2015 [
4]. Hence, the seafood farming industry is paying great attention to this problem and is seeking to understand the underlying causes of the dark discolorations on salmon fillets.
MFC can occur mainly in three locations: internal organs, the peritoneum, and the muscle fillet. Most MFC are up to 3 cm in width and a few mm thick, and are located in the front part of the fillet (
Figure 1 and see below). Interestingly, although MFC are common in farmed harvest-sized Atlantic salmon all along the Norwegian coast, there have not been reports that such spots are very common in wild fish [
1].
Melanomacrophage centers in teleost fish are distinctive groupings of phagocytic, melanin pigment-containing, immune cells that are generally found inside the stroma of tissues with immune functions, but these centers can also develop in association with inflammation elsewhere in the fish body [
6,
7]. Melanomacrophages are particularly concentrated in teleost fish spleen, kidney, and liver, and can also be found in spleen and liver of amphibians and reptiles [8-15]. In salmon, in some cases of granulomatous inflammation of the muscle, areas with pigmented melanomacrophages penetrate the peritoneum from the muscles, leading to externally visible pigmentation [
5]. In case of Piscine orthoreovirus 1 (PRV-1) infection, the appearance of melanomacrophages was coincident with—and provided a likely explanation for—the transformation from the late phase of RFC into MFC [
1,
2,
4,
16]. However, melanomacrophage accumulations have also been found in cases of chronic inflammation initiated by trauma without specific causative agents [
17]. It has been proposed that melanomacrophages may contain several pigments, such as melanin, lipofuscin, and hemosiderin [
7,
18], and the presence of melanin pigment in salmon melanomacrophases was suggested through Fontana Masson staining [
19]. Gallone et al. [
20] described that the melanin produced in the liver-pigmented macrophages of the frog
Rana esculenta L. was a 5,6-dihydroxyindole (DHI)-rich eumelanin (EM) similar to
Sepia melanin. However, to the best of our knowledge, there have not been reports regarding a biochemical and chemical analysis of melanin in melanomacrophages in fish. Gene expression studies, including the finding of tyrosinase expression in a cell line believed to represent melanomacrophages, support that melanin synthesis is the source of the dark pigment in salmon melanomacrophages and MFC [
5,
17,
21,
22]. However, although MFC in fillets have been associated with accumulations of melanomacrophages, they have not yet been examined by detailed chemical methods as to whether the focal changes do involve melanin and the nature of that melanin.
Melanin pigments, composed of black to dark brown EM and yellow to reddish-brown pheomelanin (PM), are widely distributed in vertebrates [
23]. While much is now understood about the nature of melanin synthesized in higher vertebrates, little is known about melanin produced by aquatic animals including aquacultured fishes. Red seabream (
Pagrus major), which in Japan is one of the commercially most valuable fish species, is usually found at around 20-m depth of seawater, and its skin is bright scarlet. However, their skin turns dark when bred in net cages–fish farmers call these seabreams “suntanned”–and this darkening severely reduces their market value. Adachi et al. [
24] demonstrated that the cause of this suntanning is the production of melanin, and they were the first to chemically quantify melanin in fish. They reported that the skin of suntanned seabream accumulated five times higher levels of EM than the corresponding parts of shaded and wild red seabream, while PM was below detection limits in these fish [
24].
Both EM and PM are derived from a common precursor, 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine-quinone (DOPAquinone), that is produced from tyrosine by the action of the melanogenic enzyme tyrosinase [25-28]. In the absence of thiol compounds, DOPAquinone undergoes an intramolecular cyclization of its amino group [
29] to produce DOPAchrome, which is then spontaneously and gradually converted to DHI or 5,6-dihydroxyindole-2-carboxylic acid (DHICA) by tyrosinase-related protein 2 [30-32] or by copper ions [
33]. DHI and DHICA are then further oxidized and polymerized to produce EM. Sulfhydryl compounds such as cysteine, if present at sufficient levels (> 0.13 µM), may enter a route different from the normal EM pathways to give thiol adducts of DOPA,
that is, 5-
S-cysteinyldopa (5SCD) along with a minor isomer 2-
S-cysteinyldopa [
26]. Further oxidation of these thiol adducts leads to the formation of benzothiazine and benzothiazole intermediates, which then are converted to PM. In vertebrates, melanin synthesis, called “mixed melanogenesis” because it produces both EM and PM, is biochemically controlled by tyrosinase activity and cysteine concentration. The casing model of mixed melanogenesis implies that PM is always produced first, after which EM is deposited on the preformed PM [
27]. To characterize melanins and melanogenesis, in the early 1980s, we developed a microanalytical method to analyze EM and PM [
34] based on the chemical degradation of melanin pigments followed by analysis of the degradation products using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Later, we established a novel, more convenient method for the simultaneous measurement of EM and PM using alkaline hydrogen peroxide oxidation (AHPO) and hydroiodic acid (HI) hydrolysis [
28,
35,
36] (
Figure 2).
The AHPO generates the specific markers pyrrole-2,3,5-tricarboxylic acid (PTCA), pyrrole-2,3-dicarboxylic acid (PDCA), thiazole-2,4,5-tricarboxylic acid (TTCA), and thiazole-4,5-dicarboxylic acid (TDCA). PTCA is a specific biomarker of DHICA units or 2-substituted DHI units in EM, whereas PDCA is a specific biomarker for DHI-derived units in EM, while TTCA and TDCA are specific biomarkers for benzothiazole-derived moieties in PM. Analysis of benzothiazine-derived moieties in PM is performed using HI hydrolysis to yield 4-amino-3-hydroxyphenylalanine (4-AHP) and its isomer 3-amino-4-hydroxyphenylalanine (3-AHP) [
28,
34,
35].
As mentioned above, previous reports have suggested that the black pigments of MFC in salmon fillets may be melanin [
2,
6,
19], but this assumption has been lacking chemical analysis other than histological staining [
19], which, amongst others, cannot distinguish between eumelanin and pheomelanin. Therefore, for the present study, we performed the chemical analysis of MFC and RFC in salmon fillets using the chemical degradation methods for melanin pigments to help understand the character of MFC and RFC. The results revealed that the MFC are derived from EM while RFC contain little or no EM or PM. The results of analyzing RFC suggested that they include melanogenic metabolites derived from oxidized proteins produced by DOPAquinone and/or DOPAchrome binding to salmon proteins. We could find support for this hypothesis by performing tyrosinase oxidation of DOPA in the presence of salmon fillet proteins.
In short, the present study provides novel insights into the biochemistry and origin of MFC and RFC, which form a serious quality problem in the production of Atlantic salmon.
3. Discussion
The results of the present study clearly indicate that the black pigment of the MFC is EM derived from DOPA. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that this is clearly shown by detailed chemical analytical methods. This EM is probably derived from melanomacrophages which are immune cells that may have entered the muscle for a number of possible reasons. We are not aware that there has been a proper biochemical characterization of the black pigment of fish melanomacrophages yet. Although we did not investigate isolated melanomacrophages directly, our study suggests that their pigment is EM because they are believed to give the black color to MFC.
In contrast, the origin of pigment of the RFC was less obvious. The levels of 4-AHP, HI-DOPA and PB-5SCD in RFC were higher than in MFC and were proportional to the degree of coloration (
Figure 6). Based on these results, the red pigment appeared to include conjugations of DOPAquinone and/or DOPAchrome with salmon fillet proteins. To prove this hypothesis, we performed an experiment mimicking the process of RFC production. The exposure of salmon fillet proteins to DOPAquinone (or to DOPAchrome) resulted in the suppression of melanin production and the production of pigment producing PDCA, 4-AHP, HI-DOPA and PB-5SCD. Thus, we observed the characteristic features of RFC in the mimicking experiment except for the PDCA production, which remains puzzling. The production of 4-AHP (and 3-AHP) may be explained by Schiff’s base formation between DOPAquinone and the amino group in lysine residues in salmon proteins [
41]. PM was detected only at trace levels in MFC, irrespective of size, indicating that MFC contain little or no PM. This may be because salmon muscle tissue has little cysteine levels compared to other amino acids [
43,
44], so the availability of cysteine in muscle tissue is limited. Since cysteine is required for the production of pheomelanin, low cysteine levels in salmon muscle are thought to lead to decreased PM production. This is consistent with the previous results that PM in red seabream was below the detection limits [
24].
The absolute values of HI-DOPA and PB-5SCD were 40–100 times higher in the salmon + DOPA group than in RFC (
Figure 9d). These differences may be ascribed to the fact that DOPA is rapidly oxidized by tyrosinase in the mimicking experiment, whereas in RFC in salmon, the oxidation (production of pigment of RFC) only gradually progresses over a long period of time. The level of PDCA in the salmon + DOPA group in the mimicking experiment was 2-fold higher than from the DOPA alone and the salmon alone groups combined (
Figure 9b). This PDCA may arise from DHI-protein conjugates formed via cyclization of protein-bound CD. The reason why PTCA and PDCA values in RFC are similar to those of the control is unknown, but this may also be due to secondary changes of DHI-protein conjugates giving a reddish coloration of RFC (
Figure 8).
The spectrum of RFC in Soluene-350 showed a significant increase in absorption below 550 nm, and the absorbance at 400 nm was 5-fold greater than the control at 400 nm (
Figure 5). As Soluene-350 has a large absorption below 400 nm, the maximum of absorption spectrum could not be measured, but the large absorption of RFC at 400 nm indicates the existence of quinone with an absorbance maximum at 400 nm or DHI-protein conjugates with nearly 400 nm.
Knowing that MFC pigment consists of melanin may help to reduce MFC numbers by reducing melanin synthesis. For example, from studies in mammals it is known that unsaturated fatty acid decrease melanin synthesis and tyrosinase activity whereas saturated fatty acids increase those activities [
45,
46]. In a recent study, salmons fed a diet with increased n-3 long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acid, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), had a lower occurence of black spots [
47,
48].
The etiology of the focal melanization in the white muscle is complex and probably can include a variety of reasons that induce tissue damage (which can cause intramuscular bleeding) and/or immune responses (which can cause melanomacrophages to infiltrate the muscle). The aquaculture industry has also suggested a correlation between RFC (also known as “bleedings”) and MFC, and transient forms have been observed [
4]. Our experimental results, however, do not support a possibility that the melanin pigment of MFC is a final product of the pigment found in RFC, which agrees with the common idea that RFC and MFC are derived from different cell types, namely erythrocytes and melanomacrophages. Our current hypothesis is that, in regard to the biochemistry of their melanogenic metabolites, MFC and RFC branch into two chemical pathways in a common biosynthetic pathways of melanogenesis that leads to the production of EM in MFC and melanogenic metabolites derived from protein-bound DOPAquinone and/or DOPAchrome in RFC (shown schematically in
Figure 8).
Lastly, we will consider the involvement and role of ascorbic acid and red blood cell (RBC) oxidation on living organisms. To reduce lipid oxidation, researchers have explored adding antioxidants like vitamin E to fish diets or injecting mixtures of antioxidants (ascorbic acid, citric acid, and selenium) into fish fillets. Interestingly, the reaction of ascorbic acid and protein has been reported to produce a red color under aerobic conditions, which was shown to result from an amino-carbonyl reaction of oxidized ascorbic acid (dehydroascorbic acid) [
49]. Iron in hemoglobin may contribute to changes in pigment intensity in RFC. It is known that RBC are exposed to reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, which can lead to the production of oxidants [
50]. Oxyhemoglobin in RBC can undergo autoxidation to form active oxygen (superoxide, hydrogen peroxide, and so on). Free hemoglobin is particularly toxic and this is evident in several RBC diseases [
51]. This oxidation process can also cause the oxidation of tyrosine residues, leading to the formation of dityrosine, dopamine, dopamine quinone, DHI, and other related products [
52]. When considering the production of RFC, it is important to note that the above further research and experiments may be necessary to fully understand and confirm these reactions and their implications.
4. Materials and Methods
4.1. Fish material
The fish examined were clinically healthy farmed Atlantic salmon from two different populations. From both populations (Material #1 and #2), fillets were selected from the processing line, specifically focusing on focal discoloured spots located in the cranio-ventral part of the fillets. Stained tissue was carefully excised, and adjacent unstained muscle tissue located 3 cm posterior to the discoloured area was also cut out and utilized as a control. Samples within the same category were combined, frozen at -80°C and shipped to Fujita Health University in Japan in March, 2020, for chemical characterization.
Materials #1: Atlantic salmon with known pedigree, were obtained from the breeding nucleus of Benchmark Genetics, Norway (average body weight 4.2 kg). Out of the 2,005 registered fish at Austevoll Laksepakkeri, Norway, 32 % had focal dark spots on at least one of their fillets. In total, dark stained tissue samples were collected from 636 fillets.
The pigmented areas had various degrees of pigmentation. According to the color, black and red spots were separated. Pigmented spots with the same macroscopic appearance were divided into three groups (small, medium, and large) depending on the pigment intensity and pooled: controls, MFC (BS-small, BS-medium, BS-large), RFC (RS-small, RS-medium and RS-large) (
Figure 6). Three pellets of pigmented areas from each group of MFC and RFC were dried in a desiccator (dry weights, 90 to 160 mg) and were homogenized at a concentration of 20 mg/mL in water using a Ten-Broeck glass homogenizer. Aliquots of 200 µL (4 mg) were subjected to AHPO to measure PTCA and PDCA [
36], to HI hydrolysis to measure 4-AHP, 3-AHP, and HI-DOPA [
35,
39] and to solubilization in Soluene-350 to measure A500 and A650 [
37]. PB-5SCD was analyzed after precipitation of proteins with 0.4 M HClO
4 followed by HCl hydrolysis, as described in [
40].
Materials #2: Atlantic salmon (average weight 4 kg) farmed in open commercial-sized sea-cages (Lerøy Midt AS, Gjemnes, Norway) [
53]. The fish were filleted at the Lerøy processing plant on Hitra island, Norway. Salmon fillets, dissected from melanized or RFC (31 spotted samples and 2 controls; 250 to 350 mg) were dried in a desiccator (dry weights, 90 to 160 mg) and homogenized at a concentration of 20 mg dry weight/mL in water using a Ten-Broeck glass homogenizer. Aliquots of 100 µL (2 mg) were analyzed as described for Materials #1.
Mushroom tyrosinase (1,715 U/mg) and L-DOPA were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St Louis, MO, USA). Soluene-350 was purchased from PerkinElmer (Waltham, MA, USA). Other chemicals are of the highest purity commercially available.
4.2. HPLC conditions
A HPLC system consisting of an analytical UV/VIS detector, a JASCO pump (JASCO Co., Tokyo, Japan), a C18 column (Capcell Pak MG; 4.6 x 250 mm; 5 µm particle size, Osaka Soda, Osaka, Japan) and a JASCO UV-visible detector (JASCO Co., Tokyo, Japan) was used to measure PTCA, PDCA, and TTCA [
36]. The mobile phase was 1 mM tetra-
n-butylammonium bromide in 0.1 M potassium phosphate buffer (pH 2.1): methanol, 83:17 (v/v) [
54]. Analyses were performed at 40°C at a flow rate of 0.7 ml/min. UV-visible spectra were measured using a JASCO V-630 UV-VIS spectrophotometer (JASCO Co., Tokyo, Japan). For the assay of 4-AHP, 3-AHP, and DOPA (HI-DOPA) in the HI hydrolysate, a Catecholpak C18 column was used with 4-AHP buffer – methanol, 98:2 (vol ⁄ vol) at 35°C, with an electrochemical detector set at +500 mV versus an Ag/AgCl electrode. The AHP buffer consisted of 0.1 M sodium citrate buffer, pH 3.0, containing 1 mM sodium octanesulfonate and 2% EDTA.2Na [
35]. PB-5SCD was analyzed as described for serum 5SCD [
40]. High-resolution MS spectra were obtained using a 6220 TOF mass spectrometer (mode: electrospray ionization-time-of-flight, negative; ESI (-)-TOF)(Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA).
4.3. Preparative isolation of PTCA from MFC
Preparative scale AHPO was performed. MFC from Materials #2 (wet weight 2.0 g) were combined and homogenized in 50 mL 1 M K2CO3, to which 10 mL 30% H2O2 was added. After stirring for 20 h at 25°C, 1.5 g Na2SO3 and 23 mL 6 M HCl were added to stop the oxidation and acidify the mixture to pH <2. After removal of proteins by filtration, the oxidation mixture was extracted 3 times with 100 mL ethyl acetate. The ethyl acetate was removed in vacuo and the residue was dissolved in 0.4 M HCOOH:MeOH, 90:10, and injected into a C18 column (Capcell Pak MG; 20 x 250 mm; 5 µm particle size, Osaka Soda, Osaka, Japan). HPLC separation was performed with a mobile phase of 0.4 M HCOOH:MeOH, 90:10 at a column temperature of 45°C and a flow rate of 7 mL/min. Fractions containing PTCA were recovered in a total yield of 18 µg. A PTCA standard (30 µg) was also injected into the HPLC and the fraction containing PTCA was recovered for comparison of UV spectra and high-resolution MS spectra. High-resolution MS 198.0036 [M-H]−, calc’d for C7H4O6N1, [M-H]−, 198.1044.
4.4. Experiment mimicking the production of RFC in salmon fillets
Solutions containing: 1) 0.2 mM L-DOPA and 20 mg salmon fillet homogenate, 2) 0.2 mM L-DOPA alone, or 3) 20 mg salmon fillet homogenate alone in 1 mL 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.4, were oxidized by mushroom tyrosinase (50 U) at 37°C. After vigorous mixing for 4 h, aliquots of each oxidation mixture were analyzed for melanin markers. Aliquots of 200 µL were mixed with 800 µL Soluene-350 and were then analyzed for A500 and A650 [
37]. Aliquots of 100 µL were subjected to AHPO to analyze PDCA and PTCA, to HI hydrolysis to measure 4-AHP, 3-AHP, and HI-DOPA [
35], and to HClO
4 precipitation followed by HCl hydrolysis to measure PB-5SCD [
39,
40]. Melanin marker values were normalized per mg salmon protein.
Figure 1.
The typical position of (A) red spots (red focal change (RFC)) and (B) black spots (melanized focal change (MFC)) on Atlantic salmon fillets.
Figure 1.
The typical position of (A) red spots (red focal change (RFC)) and (B) black spots (melanized focal change (MFC)) on Atlantic salmon fillets.
Figure 2.
Summary of chemical degradation by AHPO and HI hydrolysis of EM and PM. EM consists of DHI and DHICA (with a carboxyl group) units. For details, see the Introduction.
Figure 2.
Summary of chemical degradation by AHPO and HI hydrolysis of EM and PM. EM consists of DHI and DHICA (with a carboxyl group) units. For details, see the Introduction.
Figure 3.
Macroscopic grading of focal black spots (BS) (a-c) and red spots (RS) (d-f) of the cranioventral section of Atlantic salmon fillets (Material #1). The spots were classified into three categories based on their size (diameter) and pigmentation: small/weak stained spots (<3 cm), medium-sized spots (3 cm) with clear discolouration, and large spots (3-6 cm) with distinct discolouration.
Figure 3.
Macroscopic grading of focal black spots (BS) (a-c) and red spots (RS) (d-f) of the cranioventral section of Atlantic salmon fillets (Material #1). The spots were classified into three categories based on their size (diameter) and pigmentation: small/weak stained spots (<3 cm), medium-sized spots (3 cm) with clear discolouration, and large spots (3-6 cm) with distinct discolouration.
Figure 4.
HPLC chromatograms of AHPO (a, b) and HI hydrolysis (c, d) of BS-large (a, c) and RS-large (b, d), respectively.
Figure 4.
HPLC chromatograms of AHPO (a, b) and HI hydrolysis (c, d) of BS-large (a, c) and RS-large (b, d), respectively.
Figure 5.
(a) UV-VIS absorption spectra of MFC and RFC solution in Soluene-350. (b) Difference spectra of MFC and RFC solution that are subtracted from the control spectrum, respectively.
Figure 5.
(a) UV-VIS absorption spectra of MFC and RFC solution in Soluene-350. (b) Difference spectra of MFC and RFC solution that are subtracted from the control spectrum, respectively.
Figure 6.
Summary of spectrophotometric and chemical degradation analyses of control, MFC (BS-small, BS-medium, BS-large) and RFC (RS-small, RS-medium, RS-large) in Materials #1. The number of samples in each group = 3. Since A500, A650/A500 ratios, PDCA and 4-AHP were small values, these values were multiplied by 1000, 100, 2, and 10, respectively. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.
Figure 6.
Summary of spectrophotometric and chemical degradation analyses of control, MFC (BS-small, BS-medium, BS-large) and RFC (RS-small, RS-medium, RS-large) in Materials #1. The number of samples in each group = 3. Since A500, A650/A500 ratios, PDCA and 4-AHP were small values, these values were multiplied by 1000, 100, 2, and 10, respectively. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.
Figure 7.
Summary of spectrophotometric and chemical degradation analyses of control (n = 2), MFC (BS-small, n = 3; BS-medium, n = 17; BS-large, n = 7) and RFC (1 RS-small, 2 RS-medium, n = 3) in Materials #2. As A500, A650/A500 ratios, PDCA and 4-AHP showed small values, these values were multiplied by 1000, 100, 2, and 10, respectively. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.
Figure 7.
Summary of spectrophotometric and chemical degradation analyses of control (n = 2), MFC (BS-small, n = 3; BS-medium, n = 17; BS-large, n = 7) and RFC (1 RS-small, 2 RS-medium, n = 3) in Materials #2. As A500, A650/A500 ratios, PDCA and 4-AHP showed small values, these values were multiplied by 1000, 100, 2, and 10, respectively. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.
Figure 8.
Our current hypothesis of the biosynthetic pathway of the melanogenic components of MFC and RFC. The oxidation of DHI and DHICA via DOPAchrome gives MFC (EM). On the other hand, the protein-bound DOPAquinone and DOPAchrome formed by the reaction of DOPAquinone and DOPAchrome with salmon proteins produce protein-bound DOPA and protein-bound DHI included in RFC.
Figure 8.
Our current hypothesis of the biosynthetic pathway of the melanogenic components of MFC and RFC. The oxidation of DHI and DHICA via DOPAchrome gives MFC (EM). On the other hand, the protein-bound DOPAquinone and DOPAchrome formed by the reaction of DOPAquinone and DOPAchrome with salmon proteins produce protein-bound DOPA and protein-bound DHI included in RFC.
Figure 9.
Summary of the mimicking experiment. Mushroom tyrosinase was added to mixtures of salmon fillet homogenate (20 mg/mL) + DOPA (1 mM), DOPA (1 mM) alone, and salmon fillet (20 mg/mL) alone followed by measuring the melanin markers. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.
Figure 9.
Summary of the mimicking experiment. Mushroom tyrosinase was added to mixtures of salmon fillet homogenate (20 mg/mL) + DOPA (1 mM), DOPA (1 mM) alone, and salmon fillet (20 mg/mL) alone followed by measuring the melanin markers. Error bars represent one standard error from the mean.