2.1. Structural processes in HMTA aqueous solutions
The HMTA molecule acts as an amine base, and thus it may undergo protonation reactions with solvent molecules. The proton-transfer mechanism can be described as:
The possible proton transfer reactions that may occur in HMTA aqueous solutions are shown in
Figure 1. Each reaction corresponds to a subsequent protonation step.
The molecular structure of HMTA permits, not only a molecular hetero-aggregation, but also a self-aggregation reaction. In addition, other processes such as a proton-transfer reaction of HMTA with the solvent (water) may also occur. Processes related with conformational changes are unlikely due to the rigid molecular structure of HMTA.
The hetero-aggregation reaction of HMTA with water is likely to occur at low concentrations of amine, where the solute–solvent interactions are expected to be stronger, and can be described as through the following scheme:
The (H
2O)
m and HMTA ∙ mH
2O complexes denote the corresponding water clathrate and the mixed aggregate between water and HMTA molecules, respectively and both are constituted through hydrogen bonds [
15,
16,
17,
18]. Parameter m is the number of water molecules that are associated in the formation of the water clathrate and mixed aggregate. The possible hetero-aggregation reactions that may occur in HMTA aqueous solutions are presented schematically in
Figure 2. Each reaction corresponds to a subsequent aggregation step.
At intermediate concentrations of HMTA aqueous solutions, a self-aggregation reaction of HMTA may occur that can be described as:
with n designating the aggregation number and (HMTA)
n the HMTA aggregate. The self-aggregation mechanism is usually a stepwise reaction [
19]. Nevertheless, for low values of the aggregation number, this reaction can be approximated as a mean mechanism that is described by equation (3). The possible self-aggregation reactions that may occur in HMTA aqueous solutions are illustrated in
Figure 3.
In an effort to verify which mechanism occurs upon dilution of HMTA in water, we recorded the Raman spectra of solutions in the dense concentration region at 20 °C. The polarized (VV) spectra in the 0.00018 to 0.083 mole fraction region are presented in
Figure 4. The depolarized (VH) spectrum is shown only for the solution with the 0.083 mole fraction of HMTA. No significant spectral changes are observed with varying the HMTA mole fraction in solutions. At mole fractions below 0.0018, the spectra are dominated by the presence of the solvent bands, especially in the frequency range above 3000 cm
−1. The bands observed in the fingerprint region, that is below 1500 cm
−1, are due to CNC deformation and stretching, CN stretching and CH2 deformation, twisting and wagging vibrations [
20,
21]. In the 2800–3000 cm
−1 region, the high-intensity bands are assigned to the symmetric and asymmetric C-H stretching modes, while above 3000 cm
−1 the spectrum is dominated by the presence of broad and strongly overlapping bands that are attributed to the O-H stretching modes of the hydroxyl functional groups that belong to water molecules. It is also detected a relatively sharp band near ~3636 cm
−1, which is assigned to the O-H stretching modes of the hydroxyl of water molecules that are hydrogen bonded with HMTA molecule. As solutions become more concentrated in the amine, the intensity of the ~3636 cm
−1 peak reduces, nevertheless it continues to exist. This means that even in the concentrated amine solutions, HMTA complexation with water takes place. From the depolarized spectrum, it seems that the 785 cm
−1 band, assigned to the stretching mode of the CNC with A
1 symmetry, is strongly polarized. The rest of the bands are only partially polarized. The experimental and theoretically estimated Raman frequencies of HMTA in solution and in vacuum, respectively, as well as a tentative assignment are presented in
Table 1.
In
Figure 5, the calculated spectra of HMTA protonated species with one, two, three and four protons are illustrated. The experimental polarized (VV) Raman spectrum of the HMTA solution corresponding to 0.051 mole fraction is also presented for direct comparison. The results indicate that we can rule out the protonation of HMTA due to the large differences between the experimental and the theoretically calculated spectra of the protonated molecules of HTMA. The spectra of the protonated molecules of HMTA yield way more peaks compared to the experimental spectrum, especially in the fingerprint region.
In
Figure 6, we present the calculated spectra of HMTA aggregated species with one, two, three and four water molecules. The experimental polarized (VV) Raman spectrum of an HMTA solution corresponding to 0.051 mole fraction is again shown for comparison reasons. Almost all bands coincide in frequency, while they slightly differ only in their relative intensities in the low-frequency region. The results reveal that the theoretical findings are in close agreement with the experimental Raman spectrum corresponding to 0.051 mole fraction even though the calculation is carried out in the vapor state. In addition to the very good identification of the experimental spectrum with the theoretically calculated ones in the range from 250–1500 cm
−1, we also have an identification of the peak at ~3636 cm
−1 of the experimental spectrum, which is attributed to the O-H stretching mode of the water molecule that is hydrogen bonded to the HMTA amine molecule. The reason why this peak appears at higher wavenumbers in the theoretical compared to the experimental spectrum is because all the theoretical spectra were calculated in the gas phase. This is also the reason why the C-H vibrations are also shifted to higher wavenumbers in the theoretical spectra. The CH
2 groups are in the outer space of the molecule, and as such, are the most strongly affected by the presence of other neighboring molecules. The peak observed slightly above 3500 cm
−1 in the theoretical spectra is attributed to the N-H stretching vibration of the hydrogen bond with water. In the experimental spectra, this peak is not detected probably because it is overwhelmed by the spectrum of water in that frequency region.
In
Figure 7, the calculated spectrum of the HMTA· 20H
2O aggregate species with twenty water molecules is presented. This aggregate was chosen to be studied theoretically because it closely mimics the experimental solution with 0.051 mole fraction (molality equal 3), in which the HMTA:H
2O molar ratio is 1:18.5. The experimental polarized Raman spectra of three HMTA solutions corresponding to 0.051, 0.067 and 0.083 mole fractions are also presented for comparison.
Also in this case, a very good resemblance is observed between the experimental and theoretical spectrum in the fingerprint region. Furthermore, the intense peak observed in the highest frequency of the HMTA· 20H2O aggregate’s theoretical spectrum is attributed to the O-H stretching mode of the water molecule that is hydrogen bonded to the HMTA amine molecule and is related with the peak located at ~3636 cm−1 in the experimental spectrum. This peak appears at higher wavenumbers because the calculation was performed in the gas phase without considering any intermolecular interactions. The same also holds for the theoretically predicted frequencies of the C-H vibrations that are also calculated at higher wavenumbers relative to the experimental frequencies. Based on this more complex theoretical calculation, we can safely attribute this peak to the hydroxyl groups of the water molecules that are in the outer part of the aggregate. One hydrogen atom of these water molecules is bound to another water molecule of the aggregate, while the second hydrogen atom is free and not bounded to other water molecules of the aggregate.
Let us now examine if a self-aggregation of HMTA is likely to occur at higher mole fractions. We present in
Figure 8, the calculated spectrum of HMTA self-aggregated species with aggregation number n equal to one, two, three and four. The experimental polarized (VV) Raman spectra of two HMTA solutions with 0.00018 and 0.083 mole fractions corresponding to two limiting concentrations are also presented for comparison. We observe an adequate matching between the experimental spectrum of the concentrated amine solution with the theoretically calculated spectra for the self-aggregation reaction between HMTA molecules (see
Table 1). These results indicate that a self-aggregation mechanism may occur upon dilution of HMTA in aqueous environment.
From the above discussion, we can conclude that in the dilute solutions the dominating mechanism is the hetero-aggregation reaction of HMTA with water, while at higher mole fractions a self-aggregation mechanism occurs. Experimental evidence for protonation of HMTA was not found.
2.2. Sensing of the aggregation processes via ultrasonic absorption measurements
The sound absorption coefficient
a for a non-electrolytic system is given by [
22,
23]:
The first term of the sum is related to the relaxing part that is frequency dependent and is associated with the relaxation processes that may be present in the system studied. The second term is related with the non-relaxing or classical part, which is frequency independent at least in the frequency range where the measurements are performed. The so-called non-relaxing term is also labelled with B and includes contributions from several co-existing effects such as, the vibrational relaxation, the viscous absorption, the thermal absorption and the radiation, as:
Usually, the contribution of the latter is ignored because it is insignificant relative to the rest three contributions. The sound absorption coefficient due to vibrational relaxation is a linear function of temperature and appears constant when the system is at a given temperature under thermodynamic equilibrium. Viscous contribution to the sound absorption or Stokes term is given by:
with η
V and η
S denoting the shear and volume viscosity, respectively. Other symbols have their usual meanings, that is density
ρ and sound velocity
u. The third contribution is the thermal sound absorption or Kirchhoff term and is a function of several thermodynamic parameters including thermal conductivity
Q of the solution and the specific heats under constant pressure
Cp and volume
Cp/Cv, respectively. The equation for the estimation of the thermal losses is:
where
γ is the ratio
Cp/Cv. For most systems, thermal losses may be considered as negligible relative to the viscous losses and in general
B is frequency independent [
22,
23].
For simple liquids, the sound absorption coefficient can be fitted in the frequency-domain by a single Debye-type equation through the equation [
22,
23,
24,
25]:
with
fr denoting the characteristic relaxation frequency of the process. The corresponding relaxation time of the process is given by:
In the a/f2 vs f semi-log plot, the classical absorption B is observed as a straight line, while the relaxation process appears as an excess sigmoidal form over this straight line. The single Debye-type process appears as a simple exponential relaxation in the time-domain.
The absorption spectra in the frequency reduced form (
a/f2) as a function of frequency for all concentrations of HMTA aqueous solutions at 20 °C are shown in
Figure 9. Symbols represent experimental points, while the solid sigmoidal lines denote the single Debye-type relaxation profiles for each concentration. The solvent ultrasound absorption coefficient was found constant in the MHz frequency range studied in this study and equal to ~20×10
−17 s
2/cm. The results reveal that the relaxation amplitude increases in the mole fraction range 0.035–0.083 and decreases in the range 1.8×10
−7–1.8×10
−2. The trend of the relaxation amplitude is shown by arrows in the graph. The fitting using Debye-type profiles was adequate to fit all the experimental spectra as indicated by the goodness of fit observed in
Figure 9. The single relaxation mechanism observed in the acoustic spectra of the HMTA aqueous solutions is attributed to the aggregation reaction, which is clearly a structural process. These processes are related to shear (structural) viscosity and dominate in strongly associated solutions and neat liquids consisting of polar molecules, such as alcohols, amines, water, etc. that are bonded with hydrogen bonds.
The characteristic relaxation frequency
fr, the amplitude of the relaxation
A and the classical ultrasound absorption
B were the only free fitting parameters in the non-linear least-mean square fitting procedure and their values as a function of HMTA mole fraction are presented in
Figure 10 (a) and (b), respectively.
As already discussed, the association mechanism is two-fold. Amine molecules form structures with several water molecules in the region of low concentrations and amine molecules form structures of different sizes ranging from monomers to clusters of monomers in the range of intermediate concentrations. As is evident from the experimental acoustic spectra, all steps of the association reaction are detected as one “mean” Debye-type relaxation. It is interesting to note that the relaxation frequency experiences a drastic change below and above 0.018 mole fraction of HMTA. Initially, the characteristic frequency slightly increases, while above this mole fraction suddenly decreases. Analogous behavior is demonstrated by the relaxation amplitude in the same mole fraction. The only difference between the two acoustic parameters is that they exhibit exactly the opposite trend. Furthermore, for each acoustic parameter the rate below and above the 0.018 mole fraction is quite different.
The crossover 0.018 mole fraction signifies two separate regions with distinct structural characteristics. The relaxation observed in dilute solutions is attributed to hetero-association of HMTA with water molecules, while at higher concentrations the observed relaxation is assigned to the self-association reaction of HMTA molecules. The behavior demonstrated in
Figure 10 is assigned as a “spectral signature” of the system’s structural transition from hetero- to self-aggregation of HMTA. Indeed, the amplitude of the relaxation initially decreases with concentration and then suddenly increases implying the enhancement of the self-aggregation of HMTA at the expense of the hetero-aggregation mechanism of HMTA with water molecules which is stronger in the low-concentration limit. The classical contribution
B to ultrasound absorption coefficient per squared frequency
a/f2 appears almost constant for all solutions as expected.
The structural model proposed for the HMTA aqueous solutions considering intermolecular interactions is expected to be reflected in several physicochemical properties of the system. In
Figure 11 (a) to (d), we present the concentration dependence of the kinematic viscosity, the mass density, the sound speed, and the adiabatic compressibility of all HMTA aqueous solutions studied. All measurements were performed at 20 °C. Interestingly, all four properties exhibit the same behavior with relaxation frequency and amplitude illustrated in
Figure 10 revealing two separate regions with distinct characteristics attributed to the structural variation taking place. These physicochemical properties were not chosen accidentally. The viscosity of a fluid is a measure of its resistance to deformation at a given rate and thus, it is a physicochemical parameter that is very sensitive to intermolecular relaxation due to molecular association in these solutions through hydrogen-bonding interactions. Sound velocity is an important thermo-physical property mirroring the dynamic response of the condensed phase. The velocity of sound in a liquid is sensitive to molecules’ changes and is dependent on the degree of order of the molecules. On the contrary, the sound absorption coefficient is sensitive to changes in particle size and molecular interactions. Mass density is very important in the investigation of concentration-induced structural changes in the liquid state. The transition from a loose to a more rigid structure, and vice versa is related to changes in the coordination and the cross-linking of interstitial spaces in the overall structure, which is reflected in the concentration dependency of the mass density. Finally, the adiabatic compressibility provides important information concerning specific interactions between like and unlike molecules in the binary liquid mixtures. The expression for the adiabatic compressibility is:
and it is a measure of the instantaneous relative volume change of the fluid as a response to a pressure change. The results presented in
Figure 11 reveal a transition from a more loose-packed structure to a more rigid one in agreement with the proposed structural model proposed based on the vibrational and acoustic spectroscopic data. The mass density and especially the kinematic viscosity data of the HMTA aqueous solutions reveal that amine molecules would exert an influence on the water structural organization.
Our results are in line with the reported X-ray data that have revealed a novel type of clathrate structure, where each amine molecule is found to occupy cavities within water clathrates constituted by hydrogen-bonded water molecules [
26]. Furthermore, HMTA aqueous solutions exhibited a strong deviation from the ideal behavior suggesting the dominant role of the solute-solvent interactions [
27].