2. Carbon-11 Production
Carbon-11 may be produced for PET by many different cyclotron-promoted nuclear reactions [
4,
5]. Early methods used irradiations of solid targets, such as the
10B(d,n)
11C,
11B(d,2n)
11C, and
11B(p,n)
11C reactions on boron trioxide [
6]. Nowadays, however, carbon-11 is produced almost exclusively by the much higher yielding [
7,
8] and more easily manageable
14N(p,α)
11C nuclear reaction on high pressure nitrogen gas [
9]. Typically, the nitrogen has an initial pressure of about 225 psi and irradiations are performed with moderate to high beam currents (typically 40–150 μA) of moderate energy protons (~16.5 MeV). Many compact biomedical cyclotrons are commercially available for this purpose [
10,
11]. For example, in our laboratory, over 3 Curies of carbon-11 can be produced from a 40-minute irradiation of a nitrogen-oxygen mixture with a 45 μA beam of 16.5 MeV protons from a PETtrace cyclotron. By contrast with this scale of carbon-11 production, only 10 to 20 mCi of a tracer is typically required to be administered to a human subject for a PET experiment.
The chemical form of the retrieved carbon-11 depends on both cyclotron target gas composition and irradiation dose (
Scheme 2) [
9,
12]. Initially, for proton irradiation of nitrogen, [
11C]cyano radicals and [
11C]carbon monoxide are formed by recoil reactions of nucleogenic
11C atoms with nitrogen and traces of oxygen, respectively. Even at low radiation dose (10
-3 eV molecule
-1s
-1), a trace of oxygen (1–10 ppm) radiolytically oxidizes the [
11C]cyano radical to [
11C]carbon dioxide. At high irradiation doses, [
11C]carbon monoxide also oxidizes radiolytically to [
11C]carbon dioxide, leaving only a trace of [
11C]carbon monoxide. Thus, relatively intense proton irradiation of high purity nitrogen that contains trace oxygen is an effective means for producing [
11C]carbon dioxide in high radiochemical purity and high activity (
Scheme 2A). The product is free of chemical impurities, provided that only a low concentration of oxygen (1–10 ppm) is present. Normally, however, the cyclotron target body is made of aluminum which may consume traces of oxygen and lead to diminishing radioactivity recovery over many successive irradiations. Therefore, oxygen (0.1–0.5% v/v) is normally added to the nitrogen target gas to ensure reliable and consistently high recovery of carbon-11 radioactivity. Higher concentrations of oxygen however generate potentially troublesome nitrogen oxides by radiolysis. These can be removed by on-line passage of the recovered irradiated gas into a trap filled with a mixture of chromium trioxide, copper sulfate, and 2 M sulfuric acid that has been dried onto a silica gel support [
13]. Alternatively, the recovered [
11C]carbon dioxide can be concentrated in a trap composed of a small coil of stainless steel tube immersed in a cryogen, either liquid nitrogen or liquid argon. Liquid argon is preferred because its higher temperature (–185 °C) avoids co-trapping of nitrogen (b.pt. –196 °C) and oxygen (b.pt. –183 °C). Nitrogen trapped by liquid nitrogen cooling may cause a rapid and poorly controllable gas expansion upon the release of the [
11C]carbon dioxide at room temperature into a flowing inert gas stream. Alternatively, [
11C]carbon dioxide can be trapped without any of the added oxygen on molecular sieves (3, 4, or 5 Å) at room temperature and then released in concentrated form by a flush with an inert gas at higher temperature [
14]. This method is overall efficient and reliable, and therefore widely used.
If hydrogen (~5% v/v) is present in the irradiated nitrogen target gas, nucleogenic carbon-11 atoms either react with nitrogen to generate [
11C]cyano radicals, which then react with hydrogen to form [
11C]hydrogen cyanide, or they sequentially abstract hydrogen to produce [
11C]methane (
Scheme 2B). At low dose rate (10
-4 eV molecule
-1 s
-1), a significant proportion of the radioactivity is recovered as [
11C]hydrogen cyanide. However, at high dose rate (>0.1 eV molecule
-1 s
-1), radiolytic reduction of [
11C]hydrogen cyanide becomes very significant and nearly all the carbon-11 (>95%) is retrieved as [
11C]methane. Thus, high activities of [
11C]methane can be produced. [
11C]Methane is readily recovered and concentrated from irradiated target gas by passage into a Porapak N trap at room temperature or a Porapak Q trap at –186 °C [
15]. The [
11C]methane can then be released at a higher temperature.
The experience of many laboratories is that recovered activities of [
11C]methane are substantially lower than recovered yields of [
11C]carbon dioxide for the same energy and beam current in high-intensity production irradiations. For example, Buckley et al. [
16]. reported that the recovery of [
11C]methane was only 65% of that for [
11C]carbon dioxide from the same irradiation conditions on the same target chamber. Some laboratories however report appreciably higher molar activity for [
11C]methane than [
11C]carbon dioxide [
15,
17].
The potential to produce predominantly [
11C]hydrogen cyanide by the proton irradiation of nitrogen-hydrogen gas mixtures has been well explored but has not delivered a really practical method for high level production. For example, a yield of 0.67 Ci of [
11C]hydrogen cyanide has been produced from an irradiation of a flowing nitrogen-(1%) hydrogen mixture (60 psi) in a heated (200 °C) quartz lined target with 30 μA of 15 MeV protons for 30 to 45 minutes [
18,
19]. This yield however represents only about 20% of that expected for carbon-11 from such an irradiation.
In PET imaging experiments on animals and human subjects, the mass of administered tracer must be limited to avoid possible toxicity and to comply with the tracer principle, which is to avoid perturbation of the biochemical system being studied. In this regard, an extremely important consideration in the production of carbon-11 is the molar activity (
Am) of the chemical species that is produced. The molar activity is defined as the ratio of radioactivity (e.g., in Ci or GBq) to the total mass of all isotopologues (e.g., in μmol) of the chemical species in question at a specific time, such as the end of the radionuclide production (ERP).
Am values decrease with the decay of the radionuclide. For a
11C-labeled product, the isotopologues to be considered are the corresponding natural abundance
12C and
13C isotopologues. As mentioned above, a cyclotron irradiation may produce a few Curies of carbon-11. One Curie of carbon-11 corresponds to about 0.1 nmol, an extremely small amount of substance with a theoretical molar activity of 9,200 Ci/μmol. However, cyclotron irradiations typically produce carbon-11 with much lower molar activities of 20 to 100 Ci/μmol. This is because sources of trace non-radioactive isotopologues, known as carrier, may enter the cyclotron target or the radioactive product recovery system. For example, during [
11C]carbon dioxide production, carbon dioxide may be produced from organic materials during irradiation or a trace of atmospheric carbon dioxide may contaminate the target or product recovery apparatus. Therefore, scrupulous measures are required to minimize ingress or production of trace carrier [
20,
21]. This includes, for example, using ultra-pure nitrogen, as free as possible of any hydrocarbons and carbon dioxide, as the target gas. Application of careful measures to eliminate potential sources of carrier in post-irradiation chemical processing can lead to good conservation of molar activity [
22,
23]. Labeled products are described as no-carrier-added (NCA) where such measures are reasonably taken. If carrier is deliberately added, they are described as carrier-added (CA). In the remainder of this review, the discussed products are NCA, unless mentioned as being CA. Herein, cited
Am values are for the end of radiosynthesis (EOS) and radiochemical yields are decay-corrected, unless otherwise stated.
An ability to produce tracers for PET imaging depends on being able to convert a primary cyclotron-produced product, either [11C]carbon dioxide or [11C]methane, into the tracer by rapid and high-yielding post-irradiation chemical means. In practice only 2 or 3 physical half-lives can be allowed for a full tracer production, including the separation and formulation of tracer for intravenous administration. Because of its reactivity, [11C]carbon dioxide has some direct but limited utility (e.g., for 11C-carboxylation reactions). However, [11C]methane must be transformed into some other labeling agent to be useful. Likewise chemical transformations of [11C]carbon dioxide can produce more useful labeling agents.
Whereas the preponderance of carbon-11 chemistry is done in solution, methods for performing 11C-chemistry in the gas phase are highly attractive. They can often be performed on-line and very rapidly in a flow of suitably inert carrier gas (e.g., nitrogen or helium) and they allow easy product isolation, often in a solvent of choice. Catalysts and reactants can often be used repeatedly, and the apparatus can be readily automated for protection of personnel from radioactivity. We now discuss known and important post-irradiation gas phase transformation methods in carbon-11 chemistry, indicating how they have been successful. Opportunities for improvement and expansion will also become apparent.
Scheme 1.
Decay of carbon-11 (
A) and principle of PET (
B). Reprinted and modified from Li and Conti, 2010 [
3] with permission from Elsevier.
Scheme 1.
Decay of carbon-11 (
A) and principle of PET (
B). Reprinted and modified from Li and Conti, 2010 [
3] with permission from Elsevier.
Scheme 2.
Processes leading to [11C]carbon dioxide and [11C]methane by proton irradiation of nitrogen gas with low level oxygen (A) or ~ 5% hydrogen (B), respectively.
Scheme 2.
Processes leading to [11C]carbon dioxide and [11C]methane by proton irradiation of nitrogen gas with low level oxygen (A) or ~ 5% hydrogen (B), respectively.
Scheme 3.
Conversions of [11C]carbon dioxide into other 11C-labeling agents: (A) [11C]methane; (B) [11C]carbon monoxide; (C) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (D) [11C]carbon disulfide.
Scheme 3.
Conversions of [11C]carbon dioxide into other 11C-labeling agents: (A) [11C]methane; (B) [11C]carbon monoxide; (C) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (D) [11C]carbon disulfide.
Scheme 4.
Conversion of [11C]methane into: (A) [11C]carbon dioxide; (B) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (C) [11C]acetylene.
Scheme 4.
Conversion of [11C]methane into: (A) [11C]carbon dioxide; (B) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (C) [11C]acetylene.
Scheme 5.
Halogenations of [11C]methane to produce useful labeling synthons: (A) fluorination; (B) chlorination; (C) bromination; (D) iodination.
Scheme 5.
Halogenations of [11C]methane to produce useful labeling synthons: (A) fluorination; (B) chlorination; (C) bromination; (D) iodination.
Scheme 6.
Conversions of [11C]carbon monoxide into other labeling synthons and intermediates: (A) [11C]phosgene; (B) [11C]carbonyl difluoride; C) Proposed for [11C]methanol.
Scheme 6.
Conversions of [11C]carbon monoxide into other labeling synthons and intermediates: (A) [11C]phosgene; (B) [11C]carbonyl difluoride; C) Proposed for [11C]methanol.
Scheme 7.
Conversions of [11C]methanol into (A) [11C]formaldehyde; (B) [11C]iodomethane.
Scheme 7.
Conversions of [11C]methanol into (A) [11C]formaldehyde; (B) [11C]iodomethane.
Scheme 8.
Conversion of [1-11C]ethanol into [1-11C]ethylene.
Scheme 8.
Conversion of [1-11C]ethanol into [1-11C]ethylene.
Scheme 9.
Conversions of [11C]carbon tetrachloride into [11C]phosgene.
Scheme 9.
Conversions of [11C]carbon tetrachloride into [11C]phosgene.
Scheme 10.
Metathetical conversions of [11C]haloalkanes into useful labeling synthons by passage over heated silver(I) or sodium salts into: (A) and (B) [11C]methyl triflate; (C) [11C]nitroalkanes; (D) [11C]methanethiol; (E) [11C]mesyl chloride; (F) [methyl-11C]methyl isocyanate.
Scheme 10.
Metathetical conversions of [11C]haloalkanes into useful labeling synthons by passage over heated silver(I) or sodium salts into: (A) and (B) [11C]methyl triflate; (C) [11C]nitroalkanes; (D) [11C]methanethiol; (E) [11C]mesyl chloride; (F) [methyl-11C]methyl isocyanate.
Scheme 11.
Conversions of [11C]iodomethane into: (A) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (B) [11C]carbon disulfide.
Scheme 11.
Conversions of [11C]iodomethane into: (A) [11C]hydrogen cyanide; (B) [11C]carbon disulfide.
Scheme 12.
Conversion of [11C]hydrogen cyanide into [11C]cyanogen bromide.
Scheme 12.
Conversion of [11C]hydrogen cyanide into [11C]cyanogen bromide.
Scheme 13.
Conversion of [1-11C]butyric acid into [1-11C]propylketene.
Scheme 13.
Conversion of [1-11C]butyric acid into [1-11C]propylketene.