1. Introduction
The opening decades of this century witnessed an upsurge of interest in synthetic nucleic acids: single or double stranded DNA and RNA, and their chemically-modified analogues, which have firmly established their kind as promising therapeutics to engage various target genes and their products at the pre- or post-transcriptional level [
1,
2]. In comparison to small molecule drugs, oligonucleotides are capable of recognizing and directly binding the target, which is most often a biologically important RNA molecule, through Watson-Crick complementary interactions, which ensures high specificity of their action. The attention to oligonucleotide therapy sparkled in the late 1970s with the advent of antisense technology [
3], subsequent discovery of RNA interference (RNAi) in the late 1990s adding another dimension to it [
4]. To-date, many oligonucleotide analogues with chemical modifications in the various parts of the molecule: nucleobases, sugar or phosphate backbone have been developed. The first generation of antisense agents were the derivatives with modification in the phosphate group to ensure enzymatic resistance in the body, such as phosphorothioates [
5], methyl phosphonates [
6], and many others [
7,
8,
9,
10] up to the most recent mesyl phosphoramidates [
11,
12,
13] and phosphoryl guanidines [
14,
15,
16]. Next wave involved the compounds with modifications in the ribose ring, such as 2'-
O-methyl [
17,
18] or 2'-
O-methoxyethyl (MOE) RNAs [
19,
20], 2’-α- or β-fluoro-DNAs [
21,
22], bridged/locked nucleic acids (B/LNAs) [
23,
24,
25,
26], and tricyclo-DNAs [
27]. A merger of the above two types are the gapmers with 2’-modified 3’ and 5’-terminal “wings”, and 6-10 nt DNA stretch in between, usually all-phosphate-modified [
19,
20]. A separate group encompasses DNA mimics in which the sugar and phosphate backbone is replaced by a unnatural substitute; examples are peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) [
28] and phosphordiamidate morpholino oligomers (PMOs) [
29,
30]. Up until now, FDA has approved more than a dozen of nucleic acid-based drugs: notably, nusinersen (Spinraza) [
31], eteplirsen (Exondys 51) [
32] and its morpholino kin [
33,
34], all of them acting through the antisense mechanism on rare genetic disease targets; and the RNAi mediators small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) starting with patisiran (Onpattro) [
35] that was quickly followed by others [
36,
37,
38,
39]. Furthermore, well over a hundred oligonucleotide drug candidates are currently going through various phases of clinical trials [
40].
Thus, there is little doubt that oligonucleotides and their analogues have huge therapeutic potential, which is confirmed every year by FDA approval of yet another nucleic acid drug [
41]. However, due to their intrinsically low cellular uptake and tissue distribution, and, in many cases, unfavorable pharmacokinetics and rapid clearance from the body, nucleic acid drugs did not yet unfold their full therapeutic potential [
42,
43]. Moreover, the inability more often than not to effectively overcome additional barriers inside the cell on the way to their biological target, such as endosomal entrapment and nuclear translocation [
44,
45,
46,
47], poses further obstacles on the path of oligonucleotides to the clinic.
To improve therapeutic activity of oligonucleotides, various delivery agents were proposed, such as lipids [
48,
49,
50], polymers [
51], in particular, polyethyleneimine (PEI) [
52], dendrimers [
53], inorganic nanoparticles [
54], cell-penetrating peptides [
55], and oligonucleotide conjugates with different transport molecules [
56]. However, despite huge advances recently made in this field [
57], there is still no generally applicable and, even more so, inexpensive, way for boosting
in vivo efficacy of oligonucleotide therapeutics through the improved delivery. A potential step forward to the solution of this problem could be the reducing the total negative charge of the phosphate backbone, e.g. by introduction of cationic moieties, which has been previously shown to improve their intracellular penetration [
58,
59]. In particular, the attachment of multiple copies of spermine to neutralize a significant proportion of the net negative charge of the oligonucleotide has been shown to promote cellular uptake in the absence of transfection agents [
60] as well as increase the affinity to the nucleic acid target through electrostatic interaction [
61,
62]. However, the attachment of spermine according to the above method required an expensive and bulky phosphoramidite synthon [
63], which coupling efficacy, in particular, upon multiple incorporations, may be compromised by a generally lower stability of the primary alcohol-derived phosphoramidites compared to, e.g., nucleoside phosphoramidites (especially, after some storage in a freezer even at –20
oC). Herein, a post-synthetic conjugation, e.g.
via the amide bond formation between a carboxylic acid and a (poly)amine may offer a useful alternative.
We [
64] and others [
65] have described phosphoramidite synthons for modification of synthetic oligonucleotides with a carboxyl group, either in the form of a protected carboxylic ester, which can be cleaved selectively, or as the free carboxyl, which is then activated by a suitable peptide coupling agent either on solid phase [
64] or post-synthetically in solution [
66] to couple to a range of primary amines including polyamines, and short peptides. An alternative approach involved a phosphoramidite incorporating a pre-activated carboxyl group in the form of
N-succinimidyl ester that can be converted to a range of amides upon amine treatment on solid phase [
65]. However, this synthon (5'-Carboxy-Modifier C10) as well as the other commercially available reagent (5'-Carboxy-Modifier C5) can only work for the 5’-terminal conjugation, whereas the spermine phosphoramidite offers more flexibility as it can be incorporated on the 5’ or 3’-end, or on both ends at the same time [
63]. Some extra flexibility can be achieved by switching to solid-phase conjugation at the 2’-position
via 2’-
O-(carboxymethyl)-uridine synthon but this approach is sequence-dependent [
67]. In order to find a conjugation method that may be applicable to any position within oligonucleotide chain, we decided to focus on phosphate modification.
The Staudinger reaction has been explored as a way of converting the internucleotidic phosphate to the phosphoramidate moiety as early as in 1970s [
68]. In particular, an early paper by Letsinger and Schott described a conjugation of Ethidium Bromide dye to the internucleotidic position of an oligonucleotide
via Staudinger reaction [
69]. Later, Heindl
et al. introduced a convenient
N-(sulfonyl)-phosphoramidate chemistry [
70,
71], which we recently extended to a range of novel internucleotidic groups [
72,
73] including, most notably, the mesyl phosphoramidate group [
74] that proved to be useful as a backbone modification of antisense oligonucleotides [
11,
12,
13].
Recently, an approach to oligonucleotide functionalization by various reporter groups
via sulfonyl azides was published, which presented a further extension of the Staudinger chemistry at the internucleotidic position [
75]. Very recently, it was successfully applied to siRNA to peptide conjugation [
76]. In this Communication, we describe an orthogonal approach to oligonucleotide modification and conjugation at the internucleotidic position
via sulfonyl azide-mediated Staudinger reaction in tandem with amide bond formation between a side-chain carboxyl group and a range of amines including di- and polyamines.
2. Results and Discussion
We have previously shown that the Staudinger reaction between an organic azide and the support-bound internucleotidic β-cyanoethyl phosphite triester (
1,
Figure 1) formed upon phosphoramidite coupling during solid-phase DNA synthesis, can serve as a versatile and convenient method for the chemical modification of oligonucleotides at the phosphate position [
77]. In this work, we used commercially available 4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl azide
A or its readily prepared activated esters (
B-
D) to modify one or more internucleotidic phosphate groups of an oligonucleotide at the ends or inside the sequence
via Staudinger reaction (
2a-
d,
Figure 1). Thus, a carboxylic acid function, either free or in its pre-activated form, can be introduced into various positions of an oligonucleotide chain at the phosphate position, and subsequently employed to react with a suitable primary amine (see
Table 1) with the formation of a stable amide bond. The Staudinger reaction with azides
A-
D can be performed manually after the synthesis of the corresponding oligonucleotide at the last phosphate position adjacent the 5’-end, skipping usual iodine oxidation. More conveniently, it can be done automatically by substituting azide solution for standard oxidizer in the synthesizer bottle during solid-phase phosphoramidite DNA synthesis (see
Section 4).
Initially, we employed the commercially available 4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl azide
A to introduce a free carboxy group at the internucleotidic phosphate position next to the 5’-end. A 0.25 M solution of
A in acetonitrile was used that contained 5% pyridine to buffer the acidity of the carboxylic acid function to avoid any danger of the premature cleavage of the acid-labile 5’-DMTr group and the acid-mediated scission of the phosphite triester. After the Staudinger reaction, an activation of the carboxyl group was carried out on solid phase using a well-known peptide coupling agent HBTU in the presence of HOBt [
78,
79,
80] similarly to previously published methods [
64,
67], which was followed by a treatment with a solution of a primary amine (
Table 1) in acetonitrile at 25
oC for 1 h. At the end of the reaction, cleavage from support and deprotection of the oligonucleotides under mild conditions was ensured by addition of conc. aq. ammonia solution and standby at 25
◦C for 18 h. Following usual work-up, a series of novel oligonucleotide derivatives containing
N-(4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate (ξ) group with different amide-attached side-chains were obtained (
Table 1). The crude oligonucleotides modified at the 5’-terminal internucleotidic position were usually cleaved retaining the 5’-DMTr group, which can be removed by acidic treatment (80% aq. acetic acid, 30 min) on or after the purification step. The structures of modified oligonucleotide and conjugates were confirmed by MALDI-TOF MS (Supplementary Material,
Table S1), and the HPLC conversions were good to acceptable (
Figure 2A, S1, S2). Thereby, after usual post-synthetic processing we obtained a number of amide-linked oligonucleotide conjugates with amines, including, in particular, polycyclic aromatic or polyamine residues, or zwitter-ionic groups in good yields (
Table 1).
Reaction mixtures of oligonucleotide or conjugate syntheses were analyzed by reverse-phased (RP) HPLC. In some profiles such as for a diamine (
5) or a polyamine (
6) (
Table 1), by-products associated with acrylonitrile addition to the free primary or secondary amino groups were obtained (Supplementary Material,
Figure S2). To avoid this side-reaction, it was found to be advantageous to pre-treat the support-bound oligonucleotide with 50% triethylamine in acetonitrile for 30 min to remove the β-cyanoethyl groups from the internucleotidic phosphates and convert the carboxyl group to its triethylammonium salt to promote the subsequent activation with HBTU/HOBt.
Next, we set out to ascertain if the unprotected carboxyl group can stay unchanged during solid-phase DNA synthesis by the phosphoramidite chemistry to be introduced into the next to the 3’-end or internal position within oligonucleotide chain. Therefore, the activation and amine treatment steps were skipped and, after the mild aq. ammonia treatment at 25
oC to avoid potential amide formation, the oligonucleotides were isolated as carboxylic acids (
Table 1,
A1-
A5). Thus, we demonstrated that the carboxyl group does not need a special protection during DNA synthesis, and can be introduced into any internucleotidic position within oligonucleotide chain including 3’-terminal or internal position. This may open up further possibilities for conjugation at a modified phosphate group through amide formation upon activation in aqueous or aqueous – organic solution by, e.g. a water-soluble carbodiimide, as described previously [
66]. It was possible to clearly distinguish the oligonucleotide with a free carboxyl group (
A3) from the one with amide group (
D2) by co-injection on RP-HPLC (
Figure 3A). The paired peaks of the corresponding P-derived diastereomeric oligonucleotides were present.
To find out if one can skip the
in situ activation of a free carboxyl group by a coupling agent on solid phase, which may potentially lead to unwanted side-reactions such as base modification [
81], we synthesized the activated pentafluorophenyl ester of (4-azidosulfonyl)-benzoic acid
B by a DCC-mediated reaction of
A with pentafluorophenol as a stable crystalline solid (see
Section 4 for details). It was successfully used to obtain amide-linked oligonucleotide conjugates at the next to 5’-end internucleotidic position (
Table 1, the B series). However, the introduction the
B modification at any internal position within oligonucleotide chain resulted in a multiple product formation indicating that the pentafluorophenyl ester is too reactive to withstand the conditions of solid-phase DNA synthesis (data not shown). Furthermore, the after-synthesis treatment with 50% triethylamine in acetonitrile to remove the β-cyanoethyl group from the phosphates to avoid potential acrylonitrile addition to the amino groups side-reaction in the case of B5 or B6 was found to be detrimental to the integrity of the active ester. Therefore, a less activated 4-nitrophenyl (4-azidosulfonyl)-benzoate
C was obtained to see if the 4-nitrophenyl group can survive the conditions of DNA synthesis unchanged. However, neither the internally-linked conjugates nor multiple conjugates were available with 4-nitrophenyl ester
C likewise, and the yields were lower than with
B. Further attempts to lower the reactivity of aryl ester by making 4-chlorophenyl 4-(azidosulfonyl)-benzoate were likewise unsuccessful to obtain either 3’-terminal or internal modification in acceptable yields (data not shown). Thus, we tried a still less activated pentafluorobenzyl ester of 4-(azidosulfonyl)-benzoic acid
D to introduce a more stable yet sufficiently reactive ester groups into oligonucleotides
via Staudinger reaction. Contrary to both aryl esters
B and
C, a relatively weakly activated pentafluorobenzyl ester
D proved to be stable under the conditions of solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis. The application of the ester
D for modification of internucleotidic phosphate groups allowed us to obtain amide-linked conjugates without pre-activation by post-synthetic treatment with conc. aq. ammonia (
1) or 1,1-dimethylethylenediamine (
7) (
Table 1,
Figure 5) including those with next to the 3’-terminal or internal modification such as
D1,
D3,
D5/
D7, or more than one conjugated position, e.g.
D4, up to the exhaustive replacement of all the internucleotidic phosphates with modified groups, e.g.
D6/
D8 (
Table 1).
Typical elution profiles of the amide-linked oligonucleotide conjugates obtained are presented in
Figure 2,
Figure 3,
Figure 4 and
Figure 5 (see also
Figures S1-S7, Supplementary Material). As expected, the replacement of one phosphate group with
N-(4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate (ξ) in the model 6-mer hexathymidylate
A1 led to a slight increase in the retention time compared to the unmodified one (
Figure 2B). In the conjugate with benzylamine
A9, the presence of a hydrophobic benzyl group, as expected, resulted in a significant increase in retention time compared to
A1 (
Figure 2B). A new chiral centre at the phosphorus atom to which the sulfonamide group is attached led to the separation of two diastereomers in both cases, more prominent in the case of the less polar benzylamide
A9. For most 15- and 17-mer 5’-unprotected oligonucleotides with one modification in different positions of the chain, a single peak corresponding to the main product was observed in the profiles with no detectable separation of diastereomers (
Figure 2A, S1-S4, S5A, S6, and S7A). Yet, for some of the longer sequences, two peaks of stereoisomers were clearly distinguishable (
Figures 3B, S4B, S6B).
Longer 17-mer oligonucleotide conjugates
A7,
A8,
A14,
A15 obtained with azide
A with HBTU/HOBt activation (
Figure S3), and the same sequences
B1,
B2,
B3,
B4 derived from pentafluorophenyl ester
B, respectively (
Figure 3B) all show gradual increase in the retention time that correlates with the increase in hydrophobicity of the amines from
1 to
4. According to elution profiles, the conjugation reaction with aqueous ammonia,
n-propylamine, benzylamine and 1-pyrenemethylamine proceeded with high yields in both series
A and series
B, the latter resulting in cleaner products and slightly higher yields. In the case of the azide
C, only two derivatives were synthesized: amide
C1 and benzylamide
C2. As evident from their HPLC profiles (
Figure S5), these two conjugates contained higher amounts of impurities than in the case of
A and
B. This prompts us to conclude that 4-nitrophenyl 4-(azidosulfonyl)-benzoate
C may also be used for oligonucleotide modification and conjugation but with somewhat lesser efficiency.
The corresponding 15-mer oligonucleotide conjugates
D1-
D4 obtained from pentafluorobenzyl ester
D and having one or two
N-(4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate (ξ) groups were prepared in high yield (
Figure S6), and used later to study the thermal stability of complementary duplexes with DNA and RNA (see below). The fully modified oligonucleotide conjugate
D6 with 1,1-dimethylethylenediamine residue at each internucleotidic position demonstrated a significant increase in retention time compared to the singly modified conjugate
D5 (
Figure 4A). In turn, the singly modified conjugate
D5 showed a small decrease in the retention time compared to the unmodified control presumably due to the presence of a polar zwitter-ionic group [
82], but this effect was not observed for the 5'-dimethoxytritylated
D7 (
Figure 4B). The separation of the main peak into the peaks of diastereomers was detected only for the fully modified
D6 and
D7, which are the mixtures of 32 stereoisomers due to the presence of a chiral centre at each of the five internucleotidic positions.
Additional characteristics of the modified oligonucleotides and conjugates were studied by 20% denaturing PAGE. Firstly, we compared the mobility of 15-mer oligodeoxyribonucleotides containing amide and benzylamide residues in different position of oligonucleotide backbone. The mobility of oligonucleotides
A3,
A4, and
A5 containing amide residue (
Figure S11, lanes 2, 4, and 7) was close to the unmodified control oligonucleotide (
Figure S11, lane 1), and, at the same time, is higher than the mobility of the conjugates
A11,
A12, and
A13 containing hydrophobic benzyl groups (
Figure S11, lanes 3, 5, and 8). This data is in accord with previous observation that the amide-linked
N-(4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate group (ξ) in oligonucleotides likewise other sulfonyl phosphoramidate groups is negatively charged under physiological pH similarly to the natural phosphodiester group [
70,
72].
Next, we studied the difference in electrophoretic mobility between the oligonucleotide
D5 with one zwitter-ionic group, and a fully modified sequence
D6, as well as their 5’-DMTr versions
D7 and
D8. Presence of one zwitter-ionic group led to the decrease in the total negative charge of the oligonucleotide by one unit, which, in turn, resulted in a significant decrease in mobility (
Figure 5, lanes 3 and 4) compared to the unmodified controls (
Figure 5, lanes 1 and 2). Exhaustive substitution of all the phosphate groups with zwitter-ionic groups dramatically reduced the mobility (
Figure 5, lanes 7 and 8), but nevertheless did not result in complete disappearance of the net negative charge of the oligonucleotide under the experimental conditions (pH 7.5). Interestingly, for the 5’-DMTr analogue of the fully modified oligonucleotide, we practically did not see any staining by the Stains-All dye (
Figure 5B, lane 6), which may be explained by the screening of the remaining negative charge by the bulky DMTr group (compare
Figure 5A and 5B). Other dyes need to be explored to ensure efficient visualization of extensively modified oligonucleotide sequences on PAGE such as described previously [
83].
Figure 5.
Electrophoretic comparison of the mobility of oligonucleotide conjugates with zwitterionic group: lanes: (1) – unmodified 5’-d(TTTTTT), (2) – unmodified 5’-DMTr-d(TTTTTT), (3) – sample D5, (4) – sample D7, (5) – sample D6 and (6) – sample D8.
Figure 5.
Electrophoretic comparison of the mobility of oligonucleotide conjugates with zwitterionic group: lanes: (1) – unmodified 5’-d(TTTTTT), (2) – unmodified 5’-DMTr-d(TTTTTT), (3) – sample D5, (4) – sample D7, (5) – sample D6 and (6) – sample D8.
To ascertain the impact of the amide-linked
N-(4-carboxybenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate (ξ) group on thermal stability of complementary duplexes with DNA and RNA, we prepared four 15-mer oligodeoxynucleotides
D1,
D2,
D3 and
D4 containing a primary carboxamide modification (
Figure 1,
3, R’ = H), which had either one group at the 3’ or 5’-end, or in the middle of the sequence, or two groups at both ends (
Table 2). All the oligonucleotides were analyzed by HPLC and purified by PAGE. UV melting studies revealed that one group at either end, or two of the modifications at both ends did not have a significant adverse effect on the thermal stability of the duplexes of modified oligonucleotides with either DNA or RNA in comparison with those of the unmodified control. The most destabilizing effect had the modification in the middle of the sequence
D3, which exceeded that of the doubly modified oligonucleotide
D4 (
Table 2). Thus, one may conclude that the
N-(4-carboxamidobenzenesulfonyl)-phosphoramidate (ξ) group may be well suited for a single modification at any position of an oligonucleotide chain, or for multiple modifications at the ends of the sequence.