3.1. Characterization of electrode modification materials
The structures of ZIF-67 and MWCNTs were analyzed by XRD, and the physical and chemical properties of the materials were determined. The XRD pattern of ZIF-67 (
Figure 1a) shows that the diffraction peak is basically consistent with that of simulated ZIF-67, which proves that ZIF-67 has been successfully synthesized [
25]. The diffraction peaks of the acidified MWCNTs (
Figure 1b) at 26.35
◦ and 44.12
◦ corresponded to the characteristic peaks of graphic-carbon standard card PDF#75-1612, indicating that the skeleton was intact and intact after acid treatment [
26].
FTIR plays an important role in identifying functional groups.
Figure 1c is the FTIR spectrum of MWCNTs before and after acidification treatment. The absorption peak caused by the C=O stretching vibration in -COOH appeared at 1624 cm
-1 [
27], and the stretching vibration peak of -OH caused by intramolecular association appeared at 3435 cm
-1 [
28,
29]. This result shows that there are a certain amount of -OH and -COOH functional groups in the MWCNTs. The absorption peak of acid-treated MWCNTs was sharper at 1624 cm
-1, indicating that the mixed acid introduced more C=O to the MWCNTs. At the same time, C=O was further oxidized into -COOH, which increased the carboxyl functional groups. The absorption peak at 3435 cm
-1 widened, indicating that acidification introduced more -OH into the surface. In conclusion, acid treatment increases the amount of carboxyl and hydroxyl groups on the surface of MWCNTs, which greatly improves the dispersity of MWCNTs.
Specific surface area and pore size distribution are important parameters affecting the performance of electrode materials. Thus, the N
2 adsorption-desorption isotherms and pore size distributions of ZIF-67 and ZIF-67/MWCNTs were investigated. As shown in
Figure 1d, both ZIF-67 and ZIF- 67/MWCNTs exhibited type I isotherms. The average pore size was 4.8478 nm, which was in the range of 2-50 nm, indicating that the pores were mainly composed of mesopores.The BET specific surface area (SBET) of the ZIF-67 and ZIF-67/MWCNTs nanocomposites were 1324.1918 m
2/g and 1237.6814 m
2/g, respectively.The prepared ZIF-67/MWCNTs had relatively low specific surface area, which may be due to the fact that MWCNTs occupy a part of the pore volume of ZIF-67 in their attachment to ZIF-67. Overall, the ZIF-67/MWCNTs exhibited a large specific surface area, which is expected to play a positive role for the adsorption and conductivity properties of Cu
2+.
The element types and chemical states in the sample ZIF-67 were analyzed by XPS.
Figure 1e is the full XPS spectrum of ZIF-67, which confirms that C, O, N and Co coexist in ZIF-67. Peaks of C1s, O1s, N1s and Co 2p are clear without obvious impurity peaks. The results are in good agreement with the XRD and SEM test results, which proves that the material has been successfully synthesized. The C1s spectrum of ZIF-67 (
Figure 1f) show that there are mainly three different types of C in C1s, which are C-C (284.7 eV), C-O (286.4 eV) and C=O (288.8 eV). Meanwhile, the O1s spectrum (
Figure 1g) corresponds to the Co-O bond and C-O bond at 532.1 eV and 533.7 eV, respectively. The N1s XPS spectrum shows that the peaks at 398.6 eV and 400.2 eV, respectively, correspond to two states of nitrogen existence in the material: pyridine-N and pyrrorole-N [
30,
31,
32] (
Figure 1h). According to the XPS spectrum of Co 2p, the peaks at 796.7 eV and 781.2 eV are characteristic peaks of Co 2p
1/2 and Co 2p
3/2, respectively [
33,
34] (
Figure 1i). In addition, there are two satellite peaks, 802.1 eV and 786.2 eV, which confirm the presence of Co
2+ in ZIF-67 [
35,
36]. This indicates that cobalt in ZIF-67 exists in the form of divalent ions.
The morphology of the electrode modification solution after sonication was characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). As shown in
Figure 2a,b, the skeleton structure of ZIF-67 is intact, uniform in shape and clearly visible in outline. It has a typical and regular rhomboidal dodecahedron structure, part of which is broken into fine particles under the action of ultrasound. As shown in
Figure 2c,d, the acidified MWCNTs showed a tubular structure, uniform diameter, smooth surface, and well-ordered dispersion. From the TEM results (
Figure 2g,h), it was further demonstrated that the MWCNTs after acidification were in a hollow tubular structure, which provided conditions for Cu
2+ transport. The modification liquid after ultrasonic mixing of ZIF-67 and MWCNTs in a certain proportion is shown in
Figure 2e,f. ZIF-67 was completely broken into nanoparticles and wrapped together with tubular MWCNTs.
3.2. Electrochemical characterization of electrodes
The electrochemical properties of the GCE, ZIF-67/GCE, MWCNTs/GCE and ZIF-67/MWCNTs/GCE were tested by CV and EIS in a 5 mM K
3[Fe(CN)
6] solution containing 1 M KCl.
Figure 3a shows the CV curves of different modified materials with a scanning range of -0.2V to 0.8 V and a scanning rate of 20 mV/s. After comparison of the four electrodes, it was found that MWCNTs/GCE showed the highest peak current and the lowest peak potential difference (the difference between the oxidation peak and the reduction peak, 57 mV), which can be attributed to the peak potential difference being inversely proportional to the electron transfer rate constant [
37]. MWCNTs have the highest electron transfer rate constant among the four, indicating the good electrical conductivity of MWCNTs. Compared with ZIF-67/GCE, the oxidation peak current of ZIF-67/MWCNTs/GCE increased by approximately 37%, while the peak potential difference decreased from 110 mV to 90 mV, indicating that the addition of MWCNTs improved the conductivity of ZIF-67. In order to investigate the charge transfer resistance between the electrode modification material and the electrolyte interface, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) test method was used. The solution resistance (Rs) denotes the intersection of the semicircle in the high frequency region with the x-axis. The charge transfer resistance (Rct) indicates the charge transfer rate, and the size is the diameter of the semicircle [
38]. The smaller the diameter of the semicircular arc, the smaller the resistance to electron transfer, the faster the rate of electron movement, and the better the conductivity of the material modified on the electrode surface. From the Nyquist plot in
Figure 3b, it can be seen that the diameter of the semicircular arc of MWCNTs/GCE is the smallest, indicating that MWCNTs have the best electrical conductivity. Compared with ZIF-67/GCE, ZIF-67/MWCNTs/GCE showed a smaller semicircle diameter and a correspondingly smaller electron transport resistance, indicating that MWCNTs improved the conductivity of ZIF-67, which was consistent with the CV results.
3.4. Detection of Cu2+ by SWSV
The electrodes of different modified materials were analyzed by SWSV in HAc-NaAc solution containing 0.2 μM Cu
2+. As shown in the SWSV curve shown in
Figure 5a, the stripping peak appearing at approximately -0.1 V is the stripping peak potential of Cu
2+. The peak current response of ZIF-67/GCE was three times higher than that of the bare GCE, which was attributed to the good adsorption performance and catalytic activity of ZIF-67. The MWCNTs/GCE showed a higher electrochemical signal but a weaker dissolution peak for Cu
2+, reflecting the indispensability of ZIF-67. When the electrode was modified by ZIF-67 and MWCNTs, the response of Cu
2+ significantly increased, which was attributed to the increase in the number of active site of MWCNTs and the superior conducting ability. When Nafion is added, the sensor performance of the electrode is further improved, which is due to the ability of Nafion to enhance the adsorption capacity of heavy metal ions through electrostatic attraction. Meanwhile, the modification of Nafion can improve the stability of the electrode and effectively prevent the accessories on the electrode surface from falling off. Therefore, ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion was selected as the electrode modification material.
The sensitivity of the sensor was tested by using ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE as the working electrode under optimized experimental conditions. In the illustration of
Figure 5b, it can be found that the peak current increases with increasing Cu
2+ concentration in the range of 0.2~0.8 μM. Correspondingly, in the calibration curve in
Figure 4, the Cu
2+ concentration is positively correlated with the stripping peak of Cu
2+. The linear equation is y=57.5x+2.3152 (R
2=0.9904). The sensitivity of the sensor constructed by ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion to detect Cu
2+ is 57.5 μA/μM. According to the 3σ/S criterion (where σ is the standard deviation and S is the slope of the calibration graph) [
39], the limit of detection (LOD) was calculated to be 15.0 nM. This shows that the electrochemical sensor constructed by ZIF-67, MWCNTs and Nafion has a synergistic effect on the detection of Cu
2+, and Cu
2+ can be effectively reduced and stripped to realize the trace detection of Cu
2+.
3.5. Effect of scan rate
To determine the mechanism of electrochemical oxidation of Cu
2+ by ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE. The effect of scan rate was investigated using CV.
Figure 5c shows the cyclic voltammograms obtained for 0.2 μM Cu
2+ at different scan rates (0.04-0.2 V/s). From
Figure 5d, it can be seen that the oxidation peak current (Ipa) of Cu
2+ gradually increases with the increase of the scan rate. the I
pa of Cu
2+ is linearly correlated with the scan rate, and the linear equation is: I
pa(μA) =582.54 ν+33.44(V/s) (R
2=0.969). From the equation, it can be seen that the current is linearly related to the scan rate. Therefore, the redox behavior of Cu
2+ on ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE is a typical adsorption-controlled process [
40]. In addition, it can be seen from
Figure 5e that the oxidation peak potential (E
pa) tends to be positively shifted with the increase of scanning rate, and its linear equation is E
Pa = 0.0244 lnν + 0.4103 (R
2=0.977). These results indicate that the electrochemical oxidation process of Cu
2+ on ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE is irreversible. The electron transfer number (n) can be obtained according to the Laviron equation [
41].
where α, n, k
θ, and T are the electron transfer coefficient, electron transfer number, electron transfer rate constant, and absolute temperature, respectively. Based on this equation, the value of αn was calculated to be 1.053. Using the recognized value of α of 0.5 for irreversible reactions, the number of electrons involved in the electrochemical oxidation of Cu
2+ was calculated to be 2.12. This indicates that the electrochemical oxidation of Cu
2+ on the surface of the sensor based on ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE is the behavior of the two protons and two electrons involved.
3.6. Effect of Co2+ on the detection of Cu2+
A constant deposition potential of -0.4 V was applied to the working electrode. Electrons are transferred from the working electrode to the ZIF-67/MWCNTs /Nafion/GCE interface, where Cu
2+ obtains electrons and is reduced to Cu. When the forward scanning voltage is applied and the Cu
2+ stripping peak potential (-0.1V) is reached, the Cu deposited on the electrode is oxidized into Cu
2+ and returned to the solution. At the same time, electrons return to the surface of the electrode, and the stripping current signal of Cu
2+ is detected. In this process, ZIF-67 has a good adsorption and catalytic capacity for Cu
2+. The addition of MWCNTs and Nafion significantly improves the enrichment degree of Cu
2+ and the stability of the electrode. For the catalytic ability of ZIF-67, different amounts of Co
2+ were added to the HAc-NaAc solution to verify the effect on the adsorption of heavy metals. As shown in
Figure 5f, the stripping peak of Cu
2+ is significantly higher than that without the addition of Co
2+ after the addition of excess Co
2+ in the HAc-NaAc solution. It can be concluded that Co
2+ in ZIF-67 plays a catalytic role in the detection of heavy metals [
42].
3.7. Research on the repeatability, reproducibility, stability and anti-interference ability of the sensor
In addition to the sensitivity and LOD of the sensor, the repeatability, reproducibility, stability and anti-interference ability of the sensor are also important indicators to detect the performance of the sensor. SWSV tests were performed on ZIF-67/MWCNTs/Nafion/GCE seven consecutive times to verify the repeatability of the electrodes. As shown in
Figure 6a, the peak stripping potential of Cu
2+ was almost consistent in seven tests, and the relative standard deviation (RSD) was 0.49%, which further demonstrated that the electrode had good repeatability. Seven electrodes were used under the same conditions to test the reproducibility of the electrodes. As shown in
Figure 6b, the peak stripping potential of the seven electrodes did not deviate significantly, and the RSD was 2.21%, less than 5%, which proved that the sensor had good reproducibility. To test the anti-interference ability of the electrode, 4 μM interfering metal ions such as Zn
2+, Co
2+, Ba
2+, Mn
2+, K
+, Fe
2+, Na
+ , Mg
2+, Cr
6+, Fe
2+, Hg
2+, Cd
2+ and Pb
2+ were added to the solution containing 0.2 μM Cu
2+. It can be clearly observed from
Figure 6c that after the addition of a high concentration of interfering ions, the detection of Cu
2+ (within 8%) was not affected. This indicates that the sensor has high selectivity. Finally, stability tests were conducted on the original electrode, and the electrode was placed seven days later. As shown in
Figure 6d, the peak current seven days later was 95% of the original, indicating that the sensor had good stability.