3.3. Raman spectroscopy
Employing a statistical approach to data collection,
Figure 2 summarizes the three most representative Raman spectra in the 100 - 1600 cm⁻¹ region obtained from distinct areas of siderite decomposition products for samples Sd1 and Sd4. All collected Raman spectra exhibited a prominent arrangement of hematite (α-Fe₂O₃) bands in the 200 - 700 cm⁻¹ region, featuring
A1g and
Eg modes (
Figure 2) correlated with symmetric stretching and bending Fe-O vibrations [
30,
31]. Around 1320 cm⁻¹ observed a strong band attributed to two-magnon scattering arising from the interaction of two magnons created on antiparallel closed spins [
32]. Notably, the positions of the hematite bands varied slightly based on the collection site. Some areas indicated a crystalline bulk phase (α-Fe₂O₃
b) [
30,
31], while others suggested a Ti or Al-doped or more nanocrystalline form of hematite (α-Fe₂O₃
n) [
33]. Interpretative challenges in Raman spectra of investigated samples arose concerning an additional band observed in the 650 - 670 cm⁻¹ range. Multiple hypotheses exist for the origin of this band, including surface resonance of incomplete symmetry of hematite, stress-induced defects, the first overtone of the two-magnon scattering band [
34], and contaminant or impurities [
35,
36]. Some papers reported that this band is also related to the
A1g mode in orthorhombic magnetite structure [
37,
38,
39,
40]. Some instances suggested surface resonance or stress-induced defects in hematite, while in others, their nature was related to the coexistence of hematite with magnetite (grey-colored band in
Figure 2). The latter hypothesis suggests that the
A1g-magnetite band position around 663 or 664 cm
-1 is related to a less defective phase, while its shift toward lower frequencies points to a more defective spinel structure. These findings underscore the complex interplay of factors influencing Raman spectra and microscopic phase heterogeneity with different degrees of structure order depending on the locations.
3.4. Magnetic measurements
The temperature-dependent magnetization curves (
M-T) of all the investigated siderites were measured during heating and cooling in an external magnetic field of 1.2 T, as shown in
Figure 3. Above temperature about 360
oC for all samples one can observe a small decrease in magnetization, which indicates the initial decomposition temperature of the studied siderites. This temperature is very close to that (350 ◦C) observed for pure siderite [
41]. Note that thermal stability of siderite can be affected by partial substitution of Fe
2+ in the cationic sublattice. A rapid increase in magnetization is observed at above 400
oC for samples Sd4 and Sd5, above 440
oC for Sd1 and Sd2, with broad and even double maximum in temperature range from ~470
oC to ~530
oC, which indicative of some new magnetic phases generation. We assume that up to this temperature range and under vacuum pressure siderite transformation into magnetite according to equation [
42]:
The above reaction also allows for the formation of hematite, but two paths are possible, illustrated by the equations below [
42,
43]:
Based on equations (2) and (3), we can conclude that hematite is formed only when siderite is present in the sample. Here equation (3) requires a brief comment. At higher temperatures, oxidizing magnetite leads to hematite but magnetite and hematite have different crystal symmetries, from this reason hematite domains must nucleate before they can grow [
43,
44]. As was shown [
43], the high-temperature oxidation grows magnetite at the surface and hematite in the interior. It means that different reactions occur in the interior (where hematite forms) and at the surface (where new magnetite forms) [
43]. As shown in equation (3), for every 12 formula units of Fe
2O
3 created, one unit of Fe
3O
4 is added to the surface. The hematite and magnetite thus formed will have different degrees of crystallization.
Above ~530
oC, with the temperature increasing, a decrease in magnetization is visible (
Figure 3), which suggests some magnetic transition. The Curie temperatures were calculated based on these slopes and marked on the plots. These temperatures are slightly lower than those for bulk magnetite (583
oC) [
45]. This may be because the Curie temperature decreases with decreasing particle size [
46] and the substitution of Fe ions by magnesium [
47]. After that, the magnetization slowly decreases with the increase in temperature, and the minimum is close to 800
oC (
Figure 3). The magnetic transition temperatures were also calculated based on these slopes (
Figure 3). Such high temperatures can indicate the magnetic transition of hematite (680
oC) [
48], but these values are a bit too high on this iron oxide. This effect can be explained based on the Dzialoshinskii theory [
49], which assumes that the temperature at which the basal plane anisotropy passes zero is shifted with the substitutions, and the transition at ~680
oC can be shifted considerably by partially substituting Cr, Al, Ga, or Mn for the iron in α-Fe
2O
3. Additionally, for the siderite samples, Sd2 at temperature ~715
oC and Sd4 at ~730
oC are visible some maxima on magnetization curves. This effect can be related to the decomposition of dolomite [
50], which is in higher amounts of these samples. However, such a maximum was not observed for sample Sd5, where the concentration of dolomite is higher than in sample Sd2. For this reason, we can assume that this peak is likely Hopkinson-peak effects and was observed for hematite-containing samples [
51,
52]. Hopkinson peak is usually associated with the unblocking of single-domain grains, making them superparamagnetic or increased domain wall motion in larger multi-domain grains due to enhanced thermal energy; both mechanisms cause an increase in magnetization, though this is particularly enhanced in fine single-domain grains [
52].
During cooling back to room temperature (RT), the plots show that the magnetization values were not reversible with temperature. The calculated Neel temperature for hematite present in all samples are marked on the plots (
Figure 3). Further, a sharp decrease in magnetization curves in the temperature range from ~300
oC to ~400
oC is observed which indicates some magnetic transition in these samples. This transition is likely related to the magnetic transition in magnetite, where Mg replaces some of the Fe ions. In such a case, we can talk about Mg-rich magnetite, the so-called magnesio-magnetite, where magnetic transitions were observed in this temperature range for such type of compounds [
47,
53].
3.5. Mössbauer Spectroscopy
The
in-situ Mössbauer spectra of investigated siderites were obtained during heating up to temperature 750
oC and then cooling to room temperature.
Figure 4 shows selected
in-situ spectra obtained during heating the sample Sd1, and
Figure 5 presents spectra obtained during cooling this sample up to room temperature. For other samples, these spectra are collected in
Figures S1–S3 (Supplementary Materials). The hyperfine parameters of the Mössbauer components for all samples and temperatures are listed in
Table S1 (Supplementary Materials).
Up to temperature 300
oC, all spectra were fitted with a single doublet associated with Fe
2+ ions in siderite. Obtained isomer shift (IS
Sd) and quadrupole splitting (QS
Sd) for initial samples of siderite are in very good agreement with literature data [
54,
55,
56]. In the temperature range of 300
oC - 500
oC, the concentration of this component decreases to zero (
Figure 6a). In this temperature range, siderite decomposition takes place. Changing hyperfine parameters (IS
Sd(T) and QS
Sd(T)) characterizing this doublet versus temperature (T) are illustrated in
Figure 6a. Based on these relationships, the temperature dependence of the isomer shift and quadrupole splitting for siderite was determined, as presented in the equations below:
Based on equations (4) and (5), it is easy to determine the ISSd and QSSd values for siderite in a wide temperature range, in particular at 0 oC, they will be respectively 1.237 mm s-1 and 1.822 mm s-1.
Between temperatures 300
oC and 600
oC, the most significant changes are observed in the Mössbauer spectra. The results of magnetic measurements also indicate this (
Figure 3). At a temperature of 350
oC, a sextet with a hyperfine magnetic field of approximately 38 T also begins to be visible. Temperature 400
oC is the temperature at which magnetic components dominate the spectra. Marked sextets are associated with hematite (
Figure 4). Obviously, the room temperature Mössbauer spectrum of this iron oxide is represented by one sextet associated with only crystalline lattice site for Fe
3+ in hexagonal α-Fe
2O
3. However, these sextets will be related to the formation process of this iron oxide, i.e., hematite is "produced" in portions from magnetite and siderite decomposition. Therefore, these sextets represent different degrees of crystallinity of this iron oxide. The possibility of substituting Fe ions by, among others, Al, Ti, Mn or Mg should also be allowed at high temperatures. These substitutions will cause a decrease in the hyperfine field in hematite [
57,
58]. Both, the size of the crystallites and the impurities in the hematite will cause the magnetic transition to occur in a broader range of temperatures, and in the Mössbauer spectra, we observe this as the appearance of components with smaller fields.
Figure 6b shows the change of average isomer shift IS
Hem and hyperfine magnetic field B
Hem versus the temperature of all magnetic components representing hematite during the heating and cooling of all siderite samples. The average value means a weighted average for all components representing Fe
2O
3. Based on changes in the value of the isomer shift of hematite with temperature, the dependence of this parameter on temperature was determined, as shown in equation (6):
The isomer shift value determined from equation (6) at room temperature (RT) is 0.370 mm s
-1. This is a typical value for this iron oxide at RT [
57,
58,
59,
60], thus confirming the correctness of the interpretation and way of fitting of the Mössbauer spectra. Similarly to the values of the hyperfine magnetic field (B
Hem) in RT, which are slightly above 51 T, the dependence of the B
Hem on temperature is consistent with the literature [
57,
58,
59,
60,
61]. Additionally, for the B
Hem(T) relationship for hematite, it can be seen that the values are almost identical for all samples during cooling. Slightly lower B
Hem values were obtained during heating, probably due to the different degrees of crystallization of this oxide with increasing temperature and substitution Fe
3+ by other ions [
49,
58].
Apart from the sextets associated with hematite, its remaining magnetic part is visible in the spectra but has no clear absorption maxima. X-ray diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, and magnetic measurements indicate that this part of the spectrum is related to magnetite. These measurements also show that it is low-crystallinity magnetite. It is worth noticing that such magnetite is formed in all heated siderite samples. According to equation (1), this magnetite is formed due to siderite decomposition but is simultaneously transformed into hematite (equation (2)), and a small part of this spinel is again created during hematite generation. It is impossible to fit this part of the spectrum with two sextets characterizing Fe ions in the tetrahedral and octahedral coordination in the structure of this spinel [
61]. This part of the spectra was fitted with a magnetic field distribution. The obtained value of the isomer shift of this distribution (
Figure 6c) will be the average value characterizing two positions (tetrahedral and octahedral) of Fe ions, similar to the value of the hyperfine field (
Figure 6c). For samples Sd2 and Sd5, the values of isomer shift are smaller in comparison to the two other samples. Such lower values of this parameter can result from the substitution of iron for magnesium in octahedral sites [
62]. During the cooling process, the concentration of this distribution in the spectra is almost constant up to a temperature of 400
oC, where a slight increase in the contribution of this component up to room temperature was visible. At the same time, the hyperfine field decreases slightly in this temperature range. This effect can be explained by considering the doublet observed in the Mössbauer spectra of cooled samples (
Figure 5 and
Figures S1–S3). The concentration of this doublet (
Table S1) remains constant, but starting from a temperature of about 400
oC, it begins to decrease with temperature decreasing (
Figure 6d). Below 200
oC, its content is close to zero. This doublet is probably associated with magnesio-magnetite. High Mg content in the magnetite structure significantly reduces the magnetic transition temperature [
53], as indicated by the results of magnetic measurements. It is also worth noting that even when the samples are cooled to room temperature, the spectra have no clear lines related to balk magnetite. This fact would indicate a high degree of disorder in this phase as well as small sizes of crystal grains.
The ferric doublet visible in the Mössbauer spectra during heating and cooling siderite samples (
Figure 4,
Figure 5,
Figures S1–S3, Table S1) is multi-faceted but generally represents non-magnetic and superparamagnetic iron oxides particles and is therefore described as NPS. Changing of isomer shift IS
NPS versus temperature for this component (
Figure 6d) while heating and cooling are linear and fitted, as shown in equation (7):
As shown above, in the cooling process, from a temperature of about 600
oC, this ferric doublet represents the paramagnetic form of Mg-rich magnetite. At high temperatures (above 600
oC), it constitutes deposits of the paramagnetic phase of both magnetite and hematite. Below a temperature of 600
oC, the nature of this doublet appears to be different in the cooling and heating processes, as indicated by the quadrupole splitting QS
NPS dependence on the temperature of this component (
Figure 6d). The values of this parameter obtained during the heating of the samples are much higher than those calculated during the cooling process. Higher quadruple splitting values are characteristic of hematite nanoparticles [
63,
64].