3.1. Trials for Powder Manufacture
In order to manufacture composite Al-Ag powders, several modifications of the ball milling technique were tested. The images of the original aluminum scrap and resulting materials are shown in
Figure 2. In a previous study [
104], composite powders were successfully produced of D16 alloy (duralumin, similar to the AA2024 grade) and copper powder under the same milling parameters (125 mL milling pot, argon atmosphere, 580 rpm.) with lighter 15 mm balls of stainless steel (balls to powder mass ratio 24:1) after as long as 1 h. In the present study, however, the pioneer sample obtained after 1 h of Al milling together with 10 wt.% Ag under Ar with a set of 15 mm tungsten carbide balls (almost twice as heavy as those of steel) represented huge chips cold welded to each other and covered with black powder. Apparently, despite intense purging with argon, the amount of residual air in the milling pot appeared to be sufficient to oxidize silver at an elevated temperature caused by the heat release from the high-speed collisions between heavy balls. Taking that into account, the next sample was prepared via longer (2 h) milling with the addition of 1.25 mL of toluene as a process control agent to prevent both cold welding of aluminum pieces and oxidation of silver particles. Although no visual evidence of silver oxidation and cold welding was observed, the swarf particles were flattened but still too large in size, and silver particles did not look attached to them. Heavier balls were expected to accelerate the structural evolution of aluminum particles: flattening, accumulation of microstrains and embrittlement, and further progress of two competing processes of fracturing in the hardened regions and agglomeration of the resulting smaller pieces caused by cold welding (first, into flattened lamellar structures, and finally, into compacted equiaxed solid shapes) [
61,
105,
106,
107]. However, in the present study, the base material was represented by quite large pieces, several mm in size. Furthermore, even when strain hardened, highly refined aluminum was characterized with extremely high ductility and formability along with low strength, in contrast with the Al-Zn and Al-Cu series of alloys, e.g., ‘AA 7075’ and ‘AA 2024’ grades, characterized with high hardness (due to precipitation hardening) and significant size reduction during ball milling [
108,
109,
110,
111].
For the mentioned reasons, the next step towards powder elaboration was testing additives that could promote particle size reduction. For that purpose, two alternatives were tried. A first step was the addition of 20 wt.% anhydrous LiCl to aluminum powder to promote ‘cutting’ of its ductile particles with hard, brittle salt pieces. That salt was selected because it was anhydrous and therefore was not expected to provide aluminum oxidation with bonded water during ball milling. Also, it was insoluble in toluene but soluble in ethanol and acetonitrile (with the potential to be removed by dissolution in those liquids without aluminum oxidation). Another alternative was the addition of 1 wt.% Ga to provide aluminum embrittlement — manifestation of the Rehbinder effect caused by the impact of mechanical stress and adsorption-active liquid metal. The anticipated result was enhanced aluminum fragmentation during ball milling, avoiding the potential formation of Ag
2Ga at elevated temperatures [
112]. Trials of either of those additives included their milling with Al scrap for 1 h under Ar atmosphere using a set of ‘big’ (15 mm) or ‘small’ (10 mm) tungsten carbide balls under the same ball-to-powder mass ratio of 47:1. In the case of LiCl, disperse materials were obtained; however, the ‘big’ balls provided worse particle size reduction as a lot of large flattened flakes were not grinded into powder. The addition of Ga resulted in the formation of equiaxed solid objects with almost spherical shapes (again, larger for ‘big’ balls) that could be attributed to a drastic acceleration of ‘particle structural evolution’ during ball milling from the combination of intense fracturing and cold welding processes.
Summarizing the abovementioned results, the powders for the experiments were prepared by adding 1.25 mL of toluene, sealing the milling pot under Ar, and 2 h of ball milling with ‘small’ (10 mm) tungsten carbide balls. For the experiments, the following powder compositions were prepared: Al–20 wt.% LiCl, Al–20 wt.% LiCl–10 wt.% Ag, Al–1 wt.% Ga, and Al–1 wt.% Ga–10 wt.% Ag (units in wt.% are fractions of Al mass in the samples). In the respective images, only samples with Ag were depicted (samples without Ag had a similar look). Eventually, rather fine powers were obtained.
3.3. Microstructure, Specific Surface Area, and Elemental Composition
The microstructures of the original aluminum swarf and composite powders are illustrated in
Figure 4. The depicted piece of aluminum swarf had traces of machining (grooves, rough edges, bends, and cuts). The powders containing LiCl had notably finer particles than those with Ga. So, under the tested milling conditions, better refinement was achieved by intensive mechanical grinding with 20 wt.% of the salt rather than via fracturing induced by the Rehbinder effect in the presence of 1 wt.% Ga. The particles mostly represented agglomerates of smaller pieces that formed from the combination of the abovementioned processes of fracturing (in the case of Ga) or disintegration by cutting (for LiCl) with cold welding under high-energy collisions between the milling balls.
The specific surface area was measured for the Al–LiCl–Ag and Al–Ga–Ag samples by the low-temperature nitrogen sorption method. According to the results, for the first powder, it achieved 2.105 m2/g, which was considerably higher than 0.146 m2/g for the second one. That data was generally in agreement with the results of the powders’ inspection via SEM: smaller particles containing LiCl provided a more extended surface.
The base material of the particles was depicted in gray shades (from dark to light ones), while the inclusions of heavy metals (Ag, W) were depicted in whitish and white colors. The tiny white spots with sharp edgy contours more likely corresponded to WC chipped-off from the milling balls in the form of small particles, which, due to their hardness, were ‘incrusted’ into the ductile metal without significant deformations of their shape. The larger whitish areas with blurry outlines represented the sites enriched with Ag that, due to its high ductility, could be ‘merged’ with aluminum.
The output from the EDX analysis is illustrated by
Figure A1 (see
Appendix A) and summarized in
Table 1, wherein the elemental compositions for the selected scanned points are listed. For the aluminum swarf, no elements other than aluminum and a minor (up to 0.8 wt.%) amount of oxygen were detected. Thus, no significant oxidation of the starting material took place, and the original aluminum was almost ‘oxygen-free’. The powder samples obtained by milling with LiCl demonstrated the presence of Cl. Most of the currently used EDX setups were not intended for the detection of Li: its low X-ray signal and high probability of absorption by the detector window resulted in a small emitted intensity [
113]. In the present study, Li fell beyond the detection limits as well. In contrast to the XRD analysis results, the EDX data proved the presence of Ga in the respective samples. For the powder samples, their enrichment with Ag and contamination with WC were demonstrated. Also, the EDX analysis output confirmed that the powder samples contained relatively high contents of oxygen, which was in agreement with the XRD analysis results. Obviously, during high-energy ball milling with heavy tungsten carbide balls, the conditions favoring Al oxidation with residual air were established, and the ‘grinding’ effects of Li and Ga increased the intensity of that process. However, oxygen quantification by the EDX method is not reliable since it has low-energy X-ray emission that can be absorbed by the specimen or the detector window [
114]. Moreover, the implementation of carbon surface coatings makes quantification of carbon infeasible [
115], while the XRD analysis results proved its presence in the samples. For those reasons, no precise data on the light element content in the samples was obtained from the EDX investigation.
The XPS survey scanning of the surfaces of the Al–LiCl–Ag (sample 1) and Al–Ga–Ag (sample 2) composites revealed the characteristic peaks of Al, O, C, Ag, and faint lines of F (see
Figure 5). For the first sample, considerable amounts of Li and Cl were detected as well, while for the second one, faint lines of Ga were observed. Binding energy calibration was carried out by fixing the adventitious C1s peak (285.0 eV, maximum for C–C/C–H bonds) as an energy reference; that peak corresponded to carbon contamination adsorbed on the samples’ surface. The resulting high-resolution spectra peaks (represented in
Figure 5b–g) were deconvoluted into a number of patterns corresponding to different atomic states of the identified elements. The XPS spectrum for Al2p revealed the predominance of the oxidized state (Al
3+) over the metallic aluminum (Al
0). In the Ag3d spectrum of the Al–LiCl–Ag sample, for the Ag3d
5/2 component, two states with binding energies of 366.8 and 367.8 eV were identified, which was less than the binding energy of that line in pure metallic silver (368.2 eV [
116]). The observed binding energies were recognized as those for the Ag
3+ and Ag
+ states, respectively [
117], and those detected for the Li and Cl lines were typical for the respective ions presenting in different salts [
118]. The spectra of the O lines (especially for the Al–Ga–Ag sample) were wide, which could be attributed to the presence of various states of oxygen at the surface. Those states probably resulted from the formation of oxides, hydroxides, and carbonates onto the aluminum surface, as well as carbon-containing contaminants.
The tables with the concentrations of the elements detected on the samples’ surfaces, inserted in the XPS survey scan, are shown in
Figure 5a. The XPS analysis results proved the presence of the light elements (C, O, and Li), which were not detected by EDX analysis. The numerical data proved the high contents of oxygen on the samples’ surfaces. Its content was higher in the sample with LiCl than in that with Ga. Some carbon contamination was observable as well.
3.4. Reaction Kinetics
The experimental results on the hydrogen evolution kinetics for the composite powder samples are depicted in
Figure 6. As it can be seen from the plot for AlCl
3 aqueous solution (only the first 20 min. of the experiments lasting for 1 h are depicted), all kinetic curves had a short acceleration section at the beginning followed by a steep uprise that was gradually changed for a deceleration portion, and a plateau. The highest hydrogen evolution rate of 792 mL/g/s corresponded to the Al–Ga–Ag sample, while the second- and third-fastest reactions were observed for Al–LiCl–Ag and Al–Ga samples (586 and 588 mL/g/s, respectively), and the slowest process (183 mL/g/s) took place in the case of the Al–LiCl composite. It was revealed that the samples modified with Ag demonstrated considerably higher reaction rates as compared to the samples with the same ‘grinding agent’ (LiCl or Ga), as expected. Another notable observation was that the samples with LiCl achieved a higher degree of aluminum ‘conversion into hydrogen’ as compared to those milled with Ga. The final hydrogen yields after 1 h of experiment achieved (80.2±0.5), (76.7±0.7), (84.6±0.2), and (86.8±1.4)% for Al–Ga–Ag, Al–Ga, Al–LiCl–Ag, and Al–LiCl samples, respectively. The obtained results could be explained based on the samples’ analyses results.
Presumably, for the powders with Ga, more severe oxidation of aluminum took place during ball milling, leading to its lower content in the samples, while in the case of LiCl, aluminum particles could, in contrast, after some time get partially protected with the salt particles attached to their surfaces. Such an assumption was supported by the results of XRD analysis (slightly larger Al2O3 peak areas for the samples containing Ga as compared to those with LiCl pointed to higher aluminum oxide contents) and XPS data (considerable amounts of Li and Cl on the surface of the salt-containing sample). It should be noted that the above assumption was derived from the contribution of all oxidized aluminum (not only oxidized surface layers). Also, it was notable that, for the aluminum samples with the same ‘milling agent’, their ‘preoxidation degrees’ were not significantly and similarly differed from each other by the presence or absence of Ag. Therefore, the ‘preoxidation’ was seemingly caused by the impact of the ‘milling agents’, while Al coupling with Ag barely boosted that process. The contamination of the samples with WC from the milling balls also reduced their ‘consumable’ aluminum contents since weighing the samples prior to experiments was carried out without taking that factor into account.
The version explaining the deviations in the reaction rates could be the following. Although the powders with LiCl obviously had significantly finer particles (that was proved by both the specific surface measurements and microphotographs) and, therefore, were anticipated to have a larger specific surface area, the presence of the said incrusted salt particles could potentially hinder aluminum oxidation at the beginning as their dissolution might take some time. Such an idea was in agreement with the XPS data, which demonstrated considerable amouns of Li and Cl on the surface of the Al-LiCl-Ag sample. Also, that analysis revealed that the Al-LiCl-Ag sample also had a higher O content on its surface, which could delay to reaction beginning as well. And the positive impact of Ag on the reaction rates of the corresponding samples lies in the fact that the mechanical coupling of Al with the nobler silver resulted in the formation of ‘microgalvanic cells’ that enhanced galvanic corrosion of the less noble aluminum in conductive media (salt aqueous media) that was accompanied by vigorous hydrogen evolution.
Another set of experiments was carried out with the most ‘promising’ samples, modified with Ag, which were tested at 60 °C in 2 M NaCl and CaCl
2 solutions. The respective results fell far beyond expectations since no observable reaction progress was detected under those conditions. Raising the temperature up to 80 °C made a difference; however, for NaCl solution, the kinetics was still quite unimpressive (nearly 11% hydrogen was released in 4 h). Considerably better results were obtained for the CaCl
2 media (see
Table 3). The reaction started immediately, in contrast with the case of AlCl
3, and no acceleration sections were recognized at the beginning (however, that probably could result from the peculiarities of the measurement system that needed to reach a slight overpressure to start ejecting water or to restart that operation after a pause). The maximum hydrogen release rates were generally comparable (that was confirmed with the overlapping error bars of the respective kinetic curves), 72 and 89 mL/g/s for the powders with Ga and LiCl, respectively. However, before achieving high outputs, the trends turned towards deceleration. Three hours of experiments yielded as much as (46.7±2.1) and (31.8±1.9)% hydrogen for the Ag-modified samples with LiCl and Ga, respectively. The reaction actually continued its progress at the moment of the experiment termination, albeit it progressed very slowly. Along their deceleration portions, the kinetic curves had distinguishable stairstep shapes. In studies [
34,
35,
36] the process of Al oxidation in Ca(OH)
2 solutions was reported to start with rapid consumption of OH
− ions with vigorous hydrogen release, then pause due to passivation, and then, after a while, restart due to reactivation. In the present study, such a peculiarity could arise from the consideration that CaCl
2 solution did not support continuous formation of soluble Al-based compounds, and the formation of a dense reaction product layer onto the particles’ surfaces took place. After that, it took some time for the ‘encapsulated’ aluminum to be reached by liquid media via its diffusion through the poorly permeable reaction product layer and, probably, small pitting corrosion sites, and for the emerging hydrogen bubbles to gain pressure to break through the shells. In more detail, the difference between the effects of the tested solutions is discussed below.
The pH values of the 2 M AlCl
3 , CaCl
2, and NaCl solutions measured at 25 °C with a Multiparameter Transmitter M300 (JSC ‘Mettler Toledo’, Greifensee, Switzerland) were 1.25±0.03, 6.21±0.03, and 6.87±0.03. The beneficial effect of AlCl
3 is constituted in its hydrolysis into highly soluble complexes: Al(H
2O)
63+ (pH < 3.6), [Al(OH)(H
2O)
4]
2+ and [Al(OH)
2(H2O)
2]
+ (pH ~ 4), [Al(OH)(H
2O)
4]
2+ and [Al(OH)
4]
− (5.2 < pH < 6.7), and [Al(OH)
4]
− (pH > 7.0) [
119,
120]. According to that data, the measured pH corresponded to the Al(H
2O)
63+ soluble compound, i.e., the hydrolysis of the AlCl
3 salt delivered rather a large amount of chlorine ions, which are known to promote aluminum corrosion [
121,
122]. In studies [
123,
124], CaCl
2 was reported to be hydrolyzed with the formation of [CaOH]
+; the fraction of the ‘released’ chlorine ions, however, was far less than that for AlCl
3. And the NaCl solution was subjected to negligible hydrolysis at most. As it was discussed in a previous study [
104], the reaction between aluminum samples and aluminum chloride solution with hydrogen evolution resulted in the formation of the hydroxychloride compound Al
m(OH)
nCl
3m−n (m ≥ 1; 0 < n ≤ 3m). As compared to the typical reaction products, AlOOH and Al(OH)
3, such complex compounds are characterized by a much higher solubility in water. The replacement of a dense, poorly permeable layer of the reaction product depositions isolating the particle surfaces from aqueous media with the reaction product resulted in its continuous removal by dissolving in the solution itself. And that was a crucial factor that ensured continuous aluminum oxidation with hydrogen generation. The impact of the other tested solutions, CaCl
2 and NaCl, presumably constituted in the clustering of the less numerous chloride ions near the structural imperfections in the Al crystal lattice (e.g., vacancies, voids, dislocations, grain boundaries, inclusions, and second-phase particles [
125]) that caused localized destruction of the poorly soluble passivation layer of the conventional reaction products via pitting corrosion mechanisms.
The inspection of the long-term stability of the samples provides valuable information about their exploitation properties. Continuous exposition to air and even storage in argon or nitrogen environments were reported to result in the degradation of their hydrogen generation properties (aging) due to the formation of aluminum oxide over the surfaces exposed to the air environment and a decrease in the microstructure imperfections due to recovery, recrystallization, or grain growth processes [
126,
127,
128]. In the present study, however, despite extensive purging with argon and the implementation of toluene, the ‘fresh’ samples already contained an observable amount of oxygen (that was proved by X-ray diffraction analysis, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy). Such an issue was not unique: in a number of preceding studies, high-energy ball milling was reported to cause partial oxidation of the hydroreactive material (magnesium or aluminum) with residual or leaking air or with residual oxides present at the surface of the milling tools [
129,
130,
131]. Preventing aluminum from oxidation during milling should be ensured. To eliminate that ‘preoxidation effect’, additional efforts on the milling equipment and process optimization should be applied. For instance, a lid with nozzles could be manufactured for the milling pot to ensure its better purging with argon. Probably, a larger amount of toluene might be helpful. Lower rotational speed in combination with longer ball milling could be tested as well in order to reduce energy release per impact while ensuring appropriate particle size reduction. Upon ensuring ‘oxygen-free’ ball milling mode (or one close to that), the samples should be tested for long-term stability under air and argon atmospheres.
From the summarization of the key ideas stated above, the following major conclusions can be drawn. All samples (with Ag and without it) lacked roughly 10–20% of the expected hydrogen yield. Since the high-energy ball milling was performed using a set of heavy tungsten carbide balls, the collisions between them were quite powerful and resulted in a large heat release per impact. That, together with the ‘size-reducing effects’ (i.e., exposing extra aluminum surface) of lithium chloride or gallium, led to an observable oxidation of the original aluminum during milling. The powders modified with Ag demonstrated high hydrogen evolution rates. The achieved hydrogen yields were lower than they were expected due to the abovementioned oxidation effect and, to a minor extent, due to the contamination with tungsten carbide pieces, since a smaller fraction of unoxidized aluminum, capable of reacting with hydrogen generation, remained in the samples. In the experiments with the AlCl3 solution, fast reaction progress was attributed to its almost complete hydrolysis, which delivered a lot of chloride ions. The chloride ions provided the formation of complex compounds with high solubility in the solution, which ensured their continuous removal from the samples’ surfaces. In the case of the CaCl2 ‘brine’, an incomparably smaller amount of chlorine ions was formed from its hydrolysis, and their potential impact constituted in clustering in the vicinity of the aluminum crystal lattice imperfections and local destruction of the passivation layer by the pitting corrosion mechanism.
Although the hydrogen production performance of the tested composite materials turned out to fall beyond initial expectations, they seemed to have potential for improvement. It should be noted that the corrosion resistance of 1xxx aluminum alloy grades is so strong that those materials can be applied in direct contact with seawater and antiskid salts [
111]. Therefore, some other scrap of aluminum could be more vulnerable to oxidation with the same saline solutions with hydrogen evolution and have lower ductility, beneficial for particle size reduction during milling. The procedure for the ball milling of aluminum with Ga and Ag or LiCl and Ag definitely should be upgraded so as to avoid aluminum oxidation. For the powder particles, additional investigation of their cross-sections by SEM-EDX techniques could be recommended to establish their internal structure and elemental distribution, as it was performed in studies [
55,
61,
126]. To recover the precious metal (silver) from the reaction product/solid residuals, density separation techniques with heavy liquids could be tested [
132].