1. Introduction
Wound management poses a considerable challenge for patients and contributes significantly to healthcare costs [
1,
2]. Ischemia, often associated with conditions like diabetes mellitus, hampers the natural process of wound healing. While various treatments exist, none have demonstrated convincing clinical efficacy under ischemic conditions [
3].
Peptide growth factors play a crucial role in wound healing [
4], and the significance of neuropeptides in this context has only recently been acknowledged [
5]. Neuropeptide Y (NPY), a 36-amino acid peptide, is the most abundant neuropeptide in the brain, participating in both central and peripheral nervous processes. Centrally, NPY regulates appetite, feeding, stress response, anxiety, circadian rhythms, and blood [
6]. It is associated with the adrenergic mediators along the terminal ends of sympathetic nerve fibers. NPY stimulates endothelial cell proliferation and migration, and angiogenesis [
7,
8,
9,
10], which is particularly relevant for ischemic wound healing.
Humans have four 4 different G-protein coupling functional NPY receptor subtypes (Y1R, Y2R, Y4R and Y5R) [
11]. Y4R is predominantly expressed in the colon, small intestine, and prostate, preferentially activated by pancreatic polypeptide (PP). Conversely, Y1R, Y2R and Y5R exhibit high affinity for NPY [
12]. Y1R is highly expressed in smooth muscle cells and mediates vasoconstriction, including in the skin [
13,
14]. The presence and function of Y2R and Y5R in the skin are not well understood [
15]. In the cornea of mice, the expression of Y1R, Y2R, and Y5R was differentially studied in induced angiogenesis through immunohistochemistry [
8]. Y2R, but not Y1R or Y5R, was detected on the formed blood capillaries [
8]. In full-thickness skin wounds made on the back of Y2R-deficient mice, topical NPY neither stimulated angiogenesis nor restored delayed wound healing, unlike in wild-type mice [
8]. These results underscore the importance of Y2R in mediating the beneficial effects of NPY on angiogenesis and wound healing in normoxia.
The situation appears different under ischemic conditions, where Y2R protein levels were increased in ischemic compared to nonischemic full-thickness skin wounds in rabbits [
16]. In rats,
Y2R mRNA was absent in nonischemic muscle but induced in ischemic skeletal muscle, and exogenous NPY promoted angiogenesis specifically in ischemic skeletal muscle [
17,
18]. Notably, there are no studies investigating the effect of NPY on cutaneous wound healing under ischemic conditions in rats or other animal species, and the expression of NPY receptors in skin and skin wounds remains unknown [
8].
The delivery system for growth factors is crucial [
19,
20,
21]. Hydrogels, composed of three-dimensional polymeric materials, swell upon contact with water, and their mechanical properties determine the release profile of pharmaceutical agents [
22]. Unfortunately, there is no standardized laboratory test to evaluate the impact of hydrogels on the release of bioactive molecules [
23,
24].
In this study, we explored the release of NPY in an amorphous hydrogel in vitro using a Franz diffusion cell [
24]. Furthermore, we investigated the effects of NPY in vivo on ischemic wound healing in a validated preclinical model [
20,
25]. Insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I), known to promote wound healing in this model, was used as a positive control [
20]. Wound areas were measured until termination postoperative day 14, when biopsies were taken for
in situ hybridization analysis of
Y2R mRNA using the RNAscope
® technology and for histological examination.
3. Discussion
This study aimed to investigate the impact of repeated topical application of the neuropeptide Y (NPY) on ischemic full-thickness skin wounds in a standardized animal model. Despite NPY treatment showing an increase in new blood vessel formation, analogous to the observed stimulatory effects on cultured endothelial cells [
9], this heightened angiogenesis did not correlate with accelerated wound closure rates.
NPY activates cells through four main functional receptors. We opted to examine the presence of Y2R because findings from multiple studies have suggested that Y2R plays a crucial role in mediating NPY-induced angiogenesis and is up-regulated under ischemic conditions [
8,
10,
28]. Unexpectedly, using the RNAscope
® technique,
Y2R mRNA could not be detected in the wounds, but it was detected in neurons as expected [
29]. While Pradhan et al. [
16] detected
Y2R mRNA in rabbit full-thickness skin wounds using qRT-PCR, the mRNA levels in the ischemic wounds were not increased compared to those in normal skin. It is possible that our assay was less sensitive than theirs. Silva et al. [
30] ] treated endothelial cells (HUVEC) with proinflammatory cytokines and observed a significant downregulation of
Y2R mRNA, while
Y1R mRNA remained unchanged. This observation is relevant, considering that proinflammatory cytokine levels are elevated in ischemic wounds [
31]. The absence of
Y2R expression may also be attributed to the gradual vascularization of the skin flap from underneath, transitioning it from ischemic to nonischemic tissue. Notably, intracutaneous pO
2 levels did not differ between the skin flap and adjacent normal skin on postoperative day 14 in the animal model employed in this study [
20].
In contrast to NPY, topical application of IGF-I stimulated the closure of the ischemic wounds over 14 days, consistent with previous results in this animal model [
19]. Beckert et al. [
20] conducted a study applying IGF-I daily using two different carriers and found that IGF-I in a PVA film was more effective than IGF-I delivered in a methylcellulose gel, supporting the notion that the mode of peptide delivery is crucial for their stimulatory effect. Our goal was to achieve sustained delivery of peptides, assuming that this would prolong their bioactivities in the wounds. The selected hydrogel has been used alone or as a carrier for bioactive compounds in rodent wound healing studies [
32,
33,
34,
35,
36,
37] and met our objective by delaying the release of the NPY depot, at least in the in vitro Franz Cell setup. The mechanisms contributing to sustained release are likely multiple, such as electrostatic interaction between the basic NPY with positive net charge at pH less than 7.0 [
38] and the polyanionic polymer carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) of the hydrogel, along with diffusion resistance.
Given the exploratory nature of this study, a relatively high dosage of NPY was chosen. Ekstrand et al. [
8] delivered 1.5 µg NPY to 6-mm biopsy wounds using pellets made of sucralfate and poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate). Sucralfate inhibits pepsin activity [
39], potentially increasing the half-life of NPY in wounds. Their dosage should be compared with ours, which involved delivering 50 µg NPY to 8-mm wounds. The in vitro release experiment indicated a delivery rate of 0.4-0.5 µg NPY per hour. Additionally, the molecular forms that the delivered full-length NPY
1-36 adopts in the proteolytic microenvironment of the wounds remain unknown. In human serum (25-50 ng NPY/ml), proteinases generate NPY species with different receptor affinities [
40]. The dominant species NPY
3-36 is generated by dipeptidyl peptidase IV (DPPIV), implicated in angiogenic processes during wound healing [
41]. In summary, there is a need for optimization of topical NPY administration to wounds.
One drawback observed was the unfavorable tissue reactions to the hydrogel, evident by the presence of foreign bodies and multinucleated giant cells in the granulation tissue. CMC is a common constituent in hydrogel, film, and fiber wound dressings [
42]. For instance, the growth factor rhPDGF-BB is formulated in aqueous sodium CMC as Regranex
® 0.01% gel, and no foreign bodies were observed in rat wounds treated with
nonmodified sodium CMC [
43]. In contrast, wound treatment with another brand of amorphous hydrogel composed of
modified (crosslinked) CMC resulted in foreign bodies with associated multinucleated giant cells [
44], highlighting the impact of chemical modification on the biocompatibility and biodegradability of CMC. We do not have information on the structure of the CMC in the hydrogel used here. It is recognized that the viscosity of hydrogels increases with the degree of crosslinking. The viscosity of the hydrogel matches that of a crosslinked CMC [
45,
46]. This brand is approved by FDA for the use in tissue expansion [
45]. Although the hydrogel was slightly diluted (5%) and acidified, this modification is unlikely to have caused the adverse tissue reactions, as Pilakasiri et al. [
47] reported similar tissue reactions to the hydrogel in full-thickness excisions in normoxic skin. They observed adverse consequences of the hydrogel residues, particularly on epithelialization during the later stages of wound healing, as foreign bodies in the granulation tissue may impair keratinocyte migration [
48]. This may explain our findings of no effect of the hydrogel on early wound healing up to postoperative day 6, i.e., wound contraction, but less epithelialization than expected based on previous observations in the same animal model [
25]. Taken together, hydrogel residues may have impeded epithelialization and potentially masked beneficial effects on epithelialization during the later stage of wound healing.
NPY treatment led to an increase in the number of immune cells in the wounds. We speculate that the heightened infiltration of inflammatory cells is not the consequence of increased deposition of foreign bodies. The immunomodulatory effects of NPY are complex, and both anti-inflammatory and pro-inflammatory properties have been attributed to NPY [
11,
49].
A notable discovery was the presence of melanophages in the wounds. The literature provides inconsistent information on whether melanin is present in the skin of albino rats [
50,
51,
52]. Our histology results indicate that wounds of albino rats do contain melanin, although the sources of melanin are currently unknown. One possibility is that microorganisms colonizing the wounds may have the capacity to produce melanins [
53].
Collectively, our findings imply that NPY has the potential to improve wound healing, but further work is required to optimize the dosing regimen.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, M.S.Å., L.A., A.-M.H. and L.N.J.; methodology, M.S.Å, M.B., L.M.R.G. and A.-M.H.; validation, M.S.Å., L.A. and A.-M.H.; formal analysis, M.S.Å., A.-M.H. and L.N.J.; investigation, M.S.Å. and L.A.; resources, M.S.Å. and A.-M.H.; writing—original draft preparation, T.S.; writing—review and editing, M.S.Å.; visualization, L.A.; supervision, M.S.Å. and A.-M.H.; project administration, M.S.Å., A.-M.H. and L.N.J.; funding acquisition, M.S.Å. and L.N.J. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.