3.2.1. Full replacement of Glucose with Another Osmotic Agent
Development of effective and safe osmotic agents for PD has greatly been hampered by the risk of hyperosmolar syndrome due to the high solute concentration needed to obtain efficacious peritoneal UF [
55].
A possible new substitute for glucose as an osmotic agent in PD solution is
Hyperbranched Polyglycerol (HPG), a biocompatible polymer with a 50-60% dendrimeric structure containing hydroxyl end groups that is hydrophilic, water-soluble, and chemically stable in aqueous solution [
56]. Small HPG polymers (0.5-3 kDa) have been investigated in experimental models as a glucose-sparing strategy for PD treatment.
In a chronic rat model of PD, the effects over a 3-month period of a glucose-free HPG-based solution were compared to those of glucose-based PDS [
57]. While waste removal was similar, the HPG-based solution preserved peritoneal UF significantly better than did glucose-based solution. The experimental solution also induced smaller changes in the structure (thickening of the submesothelial compact zone) and angiogenesis of PM, as well as a lower number of cells expressing VEGF, alpha-SMA, and the macrophage marker MAC387. Transcriptome-based pathway analysis identified the activation of more inflammatory signaling pathways in the PM of rats receiving glucose-based PDS than in the HPG group, including signaling for cytokine production in T cells and macrophages [
57]. In a rat model of metabolic syndrome (obese type 2 diabetic ZSF1 rats), La Han et al. [
58] reported that after 3 months of daily intraperitoneal injection use, HPG-containing solution (glucose free) offered better protection of the PM function (peritoneal UF) and structure (thickness, cellular infiltrate) as compared to icodextrin solution and low-GDP solution. Moreover, HPG-based PD solution had less systemic adverse effects on the metabolism, serum antioxidant capacity, and immune response [
58].
HPG appears a promising biocompatible osmotic agent in the development of a glucose-sparing PD solution. However, recent data on the pharmacokinetics of osmotic HPG (1 and 3 kDa) may raise some safety concerns [
59]. Rats received intraperitoneally or intravenously a single dose of 3H-labelled HPG-containing solutions. Results show that systemic elimination of the HPG polymers investigated mainly depends on kidney function, implying the risk of HPG accumulation in patients on chronic dialysis [
59]. Thus, metabolism of HPG and the potential hazards in terms of tissue disposition and plasma accumulation with long-term use require further studies.
Another osmotic agent under recent development is
Steviol Glycosides (SG), active compounds contained in the leaves of the sweetener plant stevia rebaudiana which have shown therapeutic effects in several pathologic states [
60,
61].
Kopytina et al. [
62] examined the biocompatibility of SG-containing fluids (which are glucose free) as compared to glucose-based fluids. Dialysis membrane experiments showed that SG has an osmotic capacity similar to glucose.
In vitro, high glucose-based PDS induced in human omental peritoneal MCs a MMT process with up-regulation of mesenchymal markers (fibronectin, VEGF, Snail 1) and down-regulation of E-Cadherin, an epithelial marker. These markers were not significantly affected when cells were exposed to the SG-containing fluid. Concentration of angiogenic factors VEGF-A and fibroblast growth factor 2 was also up-regulated in supernatants by glucose but not by SG treatment. Moreover, in a mouse model of PDS exposure for 40 days, treatment with glucose-based PDS induced thickness of PM, increase of blood vessels, high recruitment of leukocytes, and release of inflammatory cytokines. In mice exposed to SG-based fluid all these alterations were markedly reduced, preserving the MC monolayer. Transport capacity of the experimental solution in terms of urea extracted from the blood proved similar to that of glucose solution.
These results indicate that SG may be used as an osmotic agent for PDS to replace glucose, with a better biocompatibility profile than glucose both in vitro and
in vivo. These results, however, are preliminary: safety and clinical efficacy of SG require further investigation [
62], particularly in consideration of the very high daily SG exposures required to achieve an adequate osmotic action for fluid removal and depuration.
3.2.2. Addition of Membrane-Protective Compounds to Glucose-Based PD Solution
One further strategy to improve biocompatibility in PD is the addition of protective compounds in the dialysate containing standard glucose concentration, so as to counteract peritoneal fluid toxicity.
The most extensively studied cytoprotective agent is the glutamine-releasing dipeptide
, Alanyl-Glutamine (Ala-Gln). PD fluids cause cellular stress and suppress the stress response mechanisms exerted by heat shock proteins [
63], resulting in increased vulnerability of MCs and altered function of immunocompetent cells. Supplementation of PD solution with Ala-Gln improved MC stress response and survival in vitro and ex vivo [
64], reduced peritoneal thickness and angiogenesis and the peritoneal expression of IL-17, alpha-SMA and TGF-beta [
65]. Likewise, addition of Ala-Gln (8 mM) to PD fluid was able to reduce vasculopathy induced by glucose-based dialysate in human umbilical vein endothelial cells [
66]. By restoring perturbed cytoprotective responses, Ala-Gln reduced endothelial cell damage and improved the cells’ survival [
66].
In the first clinical study, a randomized cross-over phase I/II study, PD effluent samples were collected from 20 PD patients, undergoing a peritoneal equilibration test using a standard glucose-based solution with or without Ala-Gln 8 mM 4 weeks apart in a randomized order [
67]. Ala-Gln-supplemented PD solution restored the cellular stress response with a 1.51-fold increase in heat-shock protein expression, and peritoneal glutamine levels. Ala-Gln addition was likewise associated with improved cellular immune competence. No change was observed in peritoneal UF or small PD solute transport [
67].
Samples of PD effluent obtained during that study [
67] were then analyzed by metabolomic and proteomic analyses. Targeted metabolomic profiling detected and quantified a higher number of metabolites (198 small molecules) than in previous studies and indicated an anti-oxidative effect by Ala-Gln supplementation [
68]. Upregulation of the antioxidant protein thioredoxin reductase-1 might explain the cytoprotective effects of Ala-Gln additive [
69]. A novel proteomic workflow resulted in 2506 unique proteins being identified in PD effluent proteome [
70]. Compared to plasma, proteins linked to membrane remodeling and fibrosis were found to be overrepresented in PD effluent, whereas proteins involved in response to stress, host defense, and oxidative stress were underrepresented. After treatment with Ala-Gln-supplemented dialysate PD effluent proteomes showed restoration of biological processes involved in stress response and immune defense, as well as enrichment of cellular processes linked to fibrosis. Improvement of cellular stress response by Ala-Gln addition might occur through modulation of Akt-dependent pathways [
70]. This study confirms the potential of PD effluent proteome in providing a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved in ongoing peritoneal pathological processes [
71].
More recently, in a randomized crossover study, 50 stable PD patients were treated for 8 weeks with Ala-Gln (8 mM) or placebo added to a neutral-pH low-GDP solution [
72]. Ala-Gln supplementation significantly increased the appearance rate of dialysate CA-125 (reflecting improved MC status), and the
ex vivo-stimulated release of IL-6, which reflects improved peritoneal immune competence, in PD effluent samples. Ala-Gln-enriched PD fluid was also associated with reduction of protein loss, and lower levels of biomarkers of systemic inflammation. No significant differences were found between the two dialysates (supplemented or not with Ala-Gln) with respect to peritoneal UF and transport of some small solutes [
72].
A sufficiently powered phase III trial is now required to assess the impact of Ala-Gln added to PD fluid on hard clinical endpoints [
73].
Another potential additive to PDS is
Sulodexide, a heparinoid formulation comprised of 80% heparin and 20% dermatan sulphate. Supplementation of the overnight glucose-based PD bag with sulodexide (50 mg) for 30 days to 16 CAPD patients improved peritoneal function, as shown by increased urea and creatinine transport and reduced protein loss [
74]. These favorable results in peritoneal function were also observed in six CAPD patients who assumed sulodexide orally at monthly increasing dosages for 5 months [
75]. No significant change was found in peritoneal UF or peritoneal glucose absorption. Use of sulodexide was associated with a statistically significant and dose-dependent reduction in inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6, IL-8, and IL-1b in the dialysis fluid [
75].
More recently, PD effluents collected from 7 CAPD patients after an overnight exchange with 1.5% dextrose had sulodexide 0.5 LRU/ml added or not, and the effects on gene expression, secretory activity, and protein synthesis in MCs were examined [
76]. Unsupplemented effluent dialysate induced an increased gene expression and secretion of several molecules including IL-6, TGF-beta, monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), VEGF, and vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 (VCAM-1). Use of sulodexide significantly reduced such proinflammatory, proangiogenic, and profibrotic phenotypes and the intracellular generation of free radicals. Moreover, supplementation of the PD effluent with sulodexide was associated with a weaker (-21%) stimulation of collagen synthesis [
76].
The efficiency of sulodexide in the long-term outcome of PD remains to be established.
A novel strategy to protect peritoneal tissue during PD treatment is that of M
olecular Hydrogen dissolved into PD fluid. The therapeutic application of molecular hydrogen has received increasing attention over the last years [
77], including treatment of various kidney diseases [
78]. Molecular hydrogen is an antioxidant with high biosafety and demonstrated anti-inflammatory and cell lethality-regulating effects [
79,
80].
In a pilot study, Terawaki et al. [
81] examined the effects on peritoneal and systemic oxidative stress of a single administration of a dialysate enriched with molecular hydrogen through immersion of the PD bag in H2-rich electrolyzed water for 2 hours. Blood and PD effluent samples were obtained from six CAPD patients during a peritoneal equilibration test using standard dialysate or, two weeks later, hydrogen-enriched dialysate. Use of the latter was associated with a reduction in both peritoneal and systemic oxidative stress as measured by the redox state of albumin, without any detrimental effects [
81]. In a subsequent clinical trial, six prevalent PD patients were treated for 2 weeks with a molecular hydrogen-dissolved PD fluid [
82]. Treatment was well tolerated, with a trend in some patients toward an increase of CA125 and mesothelin in the PD effluent samples, suggesting enhanced regeneration of MCs.
In the experimental setting, Nakayama et al. [
83] examined the effects of molecular hydrogen-containing dialysate on the PM of experimental PD rats. PD rats treated for 10 days with intraperitoneal injection of hydrogen-rich dialysate as compared to rats treated with a commercially available low GDP neutral pH PD solution, were able to preserve MCs and the PM with fewer cells in the peritoneal surface tissue testing positive for proliferation, apoptosis and vimentin, together with a dominant presence in the peritoneum of M2 macrophages, which have remodeling/healing actions in damaged tissues [
84]. The cytoprotective effect of molecular hydrogen might be exerted through regulation of phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) activity on anti-fibrotic molecules [
85]. After the induction in a mouse model of PF by a high-glucose solution, treatment for 4 weeks with a molecular hydrogen-rich solution succeeded in alleviating PF as compared to a high-glucose dialysate [
86]. This was evidenced by: hematoxylin-eosin staining, Masson trichrome staining, and immunohistochemistry staining for fibronectin, alpha-SMA, and MMP-1 of mouse peritoneum; expression of mesothelial-mesenchymal markers E-cadherin and vimentin; and peritoneal function evaluated by the absorption rate of saline [
86]. These results were associated with upregulation of PTEN expression inhibiting the activation of P13K/AKT/mTOR pathways in peritoneal MCs induced by ROS, a key step in PF [
87]. Interestingly, the expression of PTEN was found to be lower in the peritoneum of PD patients with UF requiring catheter removal than in patients without PD at the time of catheter placement [
86].
Development of molecular hydrogen-enriched peritoneal dialysate is a promising approach to attenuating PF, but the specific action mechanisms in cells and the metabolic process of molecular hydrogen in the human body need further investigation.
A recent experimental study investigated the activity of
peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARgamma) in modulating the development of PD-induced PF [
88]. PPARgamma protein has pleiotropic biological functions; activation of it with specific agents may inhibit fibrosis development in several human tissues [
89]. The modulation of renal tubulointerstitial fibrosis by PPARgamma could occur through regulating the expression of glucose transporter type 1 (GLUT1) [
90]. Aberrant expressional and functional changes of GLUT1 proved to be implicated in the development of various human fibrotic disorders including PF [
91,
92]. Notably, high glucose levels may significantly alter the expression of GLUT1 in peritoneal MCs [
93].
In rat and cellular PF models, Feng et al. [
88] demonstrated the fibrosis-regulating role of PPARgamma. In a rat PF model, intraperitoneal injection of PPARgamma agonists (rosiglitazone, 15d-PGJ2) elevated the down-regulated expression of PPARgamma and GLUT1 mRNA levels in the PM, decreased blood levels of glucose, creatinine and urea nitrogen, and alleviated PF by reducing the thickness of the submesothelial layer and the collagen fiber content. GLUT1 protein expression proved to be positively regulated by PPARgamma during its modulation of PF progression. The PPARgamma antagonist GW9662 had opposite effects aggravating PF progression. In a cellular PF model, the elevated expression of TGF-beta and alpha-SMA was inhibited by PPARgamma agonists and promoted by GW9662. Moreover, PPARgamma silencing in rat peritoneal MCs markedly decreased the expression of PPARgamma and GLUT1, increased gene expression of TGF-beta and alpha-SMA, and promoted cell proliferation. All these alterations were changed the opposite way by overexpression of PPARgamma [
88].
This work discloses new molecular mechanisms underlying functional alterations of peritoneal MCs associated with PF pathogenesis, and new potential targets (PPARgamma expression) for treating PF patients on PD, which deserves further exploration. However, a PPARgamma agonist, rosiglitazone, has been restricted or even withdrawn from the market in most countries owing to concerns about its cardiovascular safety [
94].
Another potential PD solution additive is M
elatonin. Melatonin is a neuroendocrine hormone, secreted by the pineal gland, that upregulates the expression of antioxidant enzymes acting via its receptor [
95]. Melatonin can also inhibit cell apoptosis through the PI3K/Akt/mT0R pathways [
96].
In different MC types, including peritoneal cells from PD patients after overnight dwelling, melatonin reduced pyroptosis and the downstream triggered proinflammatory responses and neoangiogenesis induced by high glucose [
97]. The protective effect of melatonin was confirmed in vivo in mice treated for 6 weeks with a high glucose dialysate, with or without melatonin injected intraperitoneally. Use of melatonin prevented the increased thickness of PM, maintained peritoneal UF, and reduced glucose absorption. Molecular mechanisms involved in the action of melatonin against MC pyroptosis induced by high glucose include maintenance of mitochondrial integrity, quenching of ROS, and activation of PI3K/Akt/mT0R survival signaling mediated by the melatonin receptor MT1R [
97].
Melatonin treatment holds promise in preserving peritoneum integrity in PD, but it requires further exploration.
3.2.3. Addition of Osmo-Metabolic Agents to PD Solution with Low Glucose Content
The osmo-metabolic approach in formulating new PD solutions is based on the replacement of most glucose in the PD dialysate with other osmolytes [
11]. Osmo-metabolites can be defined as those substances possessing both osmotically and metabolically favorable properties. The osmo-metabolic approach might ensure a sort of bioactive glucose sparing, by reducing the intraperitoneal glucose load without compromising UF, and mitigating the underlying systemic unfavorable metabolic effects induced by the high glucose load [
11].
L-carnitine and xylitol are two representative examples of osmo-metabolic agents, suitable for use in PD fluid, being chemically stable in aqueous solutions, highly water soluble, and osmotically active. L-carnitine (molecular weight 161.2 Da) is a compound essential for fatty acid metabolism, that modulates the levels in the mitochondria of acetyl-CoA, a metabolic intermediate that can affect liver glucose production and muscle glucose disposal [
98]. Experimental studies on L-carnitine-containing PD solution has shown good biocompatibility in several in vitro and in vivo models, while clinical studies in CAPD patients have demonstrated effectiveness for removing fluid from the peritoneal cavity, as well as better preservation of urine volume and significant improvement in insulin sensitivity as compared to glucose-based solutions [
99].
In its turn, xylitol (molecular weight 151.2 Da) is a five-carbon sugar alcohol, metabolized within the nonoxidative branch of the pentose monophosphate shunt giving rise to glycolytic intermediates [
100]. Xylitol-containing PD solution proved more biocompatible than glucose-containing solution in several studies in MCs (Arduini A, Patent PCT/EP2006/060162). In a clinical trial conducted by Bazzato et al. [
101], six insulin-dependent diabetic patients on CAPD were treated for a minimum of five months with D-xylitol fully replacing glucose as the osmotic agent in the PD solution. Results showed maintenance of peritoneal UF and fluid balance, significant improvement of the glycemic control (lowering of glycated hemoglobin, 50% reduction of exogenous insulin dosage) and of the lipid profile [
101].
Note that in all these clinical studies addition to the PD solution of either L-carnitine or xylitol was safe and well tolerated by patients.
More recently, we developed a new PD solution containing both L-carnitine and xylitol, to achieve a favorable synergetic action of the two osmo-metabolic compounds. Low-dose glucose was maintained in the experimental solution to take advantage of its UF ability, at a concentration (27.7 mmol/L) that did not seem to have the deleterious effects the higher concentration did [
102]. The biocompatibility of the new PD solution formulation was compared to many commercial PD solutions in an experimental model of MCs exposed to the PD fluid only on the apical side, mimicking the condition of a PD exchange [
103]. Compelling evidence showed that the experimental PD solution was associated with higher cell viability and better preservation of the integrity of the mesothelial layer (no disruption of tight junctions triggering EMT and no drop in transepithelial electric resistance). In addition, the L-carnitine+xylitol solutions showed limited capacity to cause activation of the inflammasome in MCs, allowing proper cellular homeostasis to be maintained. Analysis of the secretion by MCs of 27 proinflammatory cytokines, growth factors and chemokines, showed a reduced release of TNF-alpha, fibroblast growth factor and VEGF compared to conventional PD solutions [
103]. Further in vitro data obtained in human mesothelial and endothelial cells support the good biocompatibility of the L-carnitine+xylitol formulation [
104]. As compared to a neutral-pH low-GDP solution, the experimental solution was better able to preserve cell viability and membrane integrity, without changes in transepithelial resistance or albumin permeability of MCs, and did not increase the gene expression of TGF-beta or its dependent transcription factor SNAIL. Activation of mesothelial- and endothelial- mesenchymal transition, as shown by upregulation of alpha-SMA and vimentin and down-regulation of E-cadherin both at gene and at protein levels, was not found in cells exposed to the L-carnitine+xylitol formulation, which also induced a quite mild inflammatory and angiogenic response [
104].
Altogether, the available evidence indicates that a PD solution containing L-carnitine and xylitol does not exert pro- fibrotic, -inflammatory, or -angiogenic effects unlike available PD fluids, preserving in the meantime viability and integrity of mesothelial and endothelial cells. These favorable actions might not be simply attributed to the low glucose content of the innovative PD solution. Metabolic alterations represent an increasingly recognized pathogenic factor that underlies fibrosis in many organs [
105]. Exposure to glucose-based PD fluid leads in mouse peritoneum to hyperglycolysis, a metabolic alteration accompanied by dynamic mitochondrial changes that is stimulated by TGF-beta and is correlated with the development of MMT [
106]. Blocking hyperglycolysis by using 2-deoxyglucose, which modulates glycolysis by inhibiting hexokinase 2, inhibited TGF-beta1-induced profibrotic cellular phenotype and peritoneal fibrosis in a mouse model [
106].
Targeting molecular alterations in MCs such as metabolic reprogramming (hyperglycolysis) might represent a more appropriate tool to control PD-related PF than targeting fibroblast activation [
106]. Supplementation of PD fluids with 2-deoxyglucose demonstrated antifibrotic effects and could improve the functional permeability of mesothelial and endothelial cells of the PM [
107]. However, the safety of this approach must be proved
in vivo. An alternative strategy is coupling glycolysis with the Krebs cycle by increasing the mitochondrial activity of pyruvate dehydrogenase complex through reduction of the intramitochondrial acetyl-CoA pool using L-carnitine [
14]. As a matter of fact, we recently showed in a mouse model of PF that daily intraperitoneal infusion of L-carnitine, xylitol and low glucose dialysate for 15 days, compared to a low-GDP solution, prevented the development of fibrosis and did not affect peritoneal angiogenesis [Trepiccione F., oral communication, ERA Congress, Milan, 2023].
A phase II, prospective, multicenter study to investigate the tolerability and the efficacy of osmo-metabolic agent-based PD solutions in CAPD patients (NCT04001036) was recently concluded [
108]. The novel solutions proved well tolerated, and no adverse safety signals were observed. The results of the trial indicate the noninferiority of the osmo-metabolic agent-based PD solutions compared to standard solutions in terms of peritoneal transport and adequacy as targets [
108].
For the future of PD, it is of utmost importance to find new osmotic agents targeting its effect on biocompatibility and fluid balance but also, and no less important, on the metabolism of the patient. The osmo-metabolic approach makes it possible to reduce the amount of glucose in the PD fluid, and to take advantage of the pharmaco-metabolic properties of the osmolytes to correct potential metabolic abnormalities or deficiencies. The ongoing ELIXIR trial (NCT03994471), a six-month international multicenter randomized study whose primary objective is the noninferiority of the experimental solution based on L-carnitine, xylitol, and low glucose as compared to a glucose-based PD regarding efficacy and safety, will help to define the role of the novel solution in daily PD clinical practice.