2.2. Oligo DNA Adsorption, Detection and Extraction Using NC/NH2-PEG-rGO Hybrid Membranes in Complex Media
The efficiency of NC and NC/NH2-PEG-rGO hybrid membranes in detecting and extracting ssDNA was assessed by measuring fluorescence intensity after a 60-minute incubation of the membranes in various ionic complex solutions containing MnCl
2, MgCl
2, or MnCl
2/MgCl
2. The resulting data is presented in
Figure 4. Based on the results, the fluorescence intensity of the NC membrane in all ionic complex solutions does not exhibit any significant difference in immobilizing ssDNA, with the highest fluorescence recorded at approximately 250 r.f.u. for MgCl
2 ionic solution.
In the context of the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membrane, the measurements indicate a significantly greater affinity for immobilizing ssDNA in the complex solution containing MgCl
2, resulting in a fluorescence intensity of approximately 525 r.f.u. In contrast, the complex solution containing the MnCl
2 concentration demonstrates lower affinity, yielding a fluorescence intensity of around 330 r.f.u. While this affinity is lower than that observed with MgCl
2, it still demonstrates the higher membrane capacity to interact with ssDNA in different conditions when compared with the NC membrane. The divalent cations Mn
2+ and Mg
2+ from the complex solution enhance the interactions between ssDNA and the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO membrane. This can occur because divalent cations can promote the condensation of ssDNA, reducing its exposure to the surrounding solvent and promoting interactions with hydrophobic surfaces [
52,
53]. The positively charged cations can interact with the negatively charged phosphate groups in the ssDNA backbone, neutralizing the negative charges and reducing electrostatic repulsion between ssDNA and the membrane surface, thereby facilitating its immobilization [
54,
55].
Furthermore, MnCl
2 and MgCl
2 can create specific binding sites on the membrane surface through their coordination chemistry. These binding sites act as anchor points for ssDNA, enhancing its immobilization in a site-specific manner. MnCl
2 and MgCl
2 interact with the DNA molecule, stabilizing its secondary and tertiary structures. This stabilization makes the ssDNA more rigid and structured, increasing its affinity for binding to the membrane. Additionally, divalent cations enhance ssDNA stability by strengthening hydrogen bonding, while hybrid membrane amino groups engage in specific hydrogen bonding interactions with ssDNA nitrogenous bases, thereby enhancing overall adsorption onto the membrane [
56,
57,
58].
The divalent ions (Mg
2+ and Mn
2+) in the complex solutions demonstrates a higher affinity for immobilized ssDNA compared to the previous study, where the Na+ ions did not exceed values higher than 300 r.f.u. [
13]. According to the Manning-Oosawa theory, approximately 88% of the DNA surface charge is neutralized by divalent counterions (Mg
2+, Mn
2+), while in the case of monovalent ions (Na
+), this value is reduced to 76%, resulting in a lower charge density [
59]. The lower charge density of monovalent ions means that they may not neutralize DNA’s negative charges as effectively as Mg
2+ ions. The higher charge density of Mg
2+ ions allow for more effective charge neutralization of DNA, reducing electrostatic repulsion and facilitating DNA-protein binding [
59,
60].
Various components, including serum proteins found within αMEM, particularly BSA and SDS, play a crucial role in reducing the non-specific binding of oligo ssDNA to diverse surfaces in the medium while simultaneously promoting its adherence to the membrane. BSA acts as a protective barrier, protecting the negatively charged oligo ssDNA molecules against repulsive electrostatic interactions with NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO, while SDS deactivates nucleases and regulates non-specific adsorption on the surface of the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membrane [
61,
62,
63,
64,
65]. Moreover, αMEM incorporates glucose and other carbohydrates, leading to an increase in the solution’s osmotic pressure. This heightened osmotic pressure has the potential to induce a flow of water from the surrounding medium into the membrane, thereby enhancing the adsorption of oligo ssDNA onto the membrane’s surface [
66,
67].
The role of pH in modulating the interaction between ssDNA and the membrane is also important for understanding the binding dynamics. At Tris-HCl pH 8, the environment is slightly alkaline, resulting in partial deprotonation of both ssDNA and the amino groups (-NH
2) on the membrane’s surface. This exposes negatively charged phosphate groups on the ssDNA backbone and positively charged amino groups on the membrane, promoting attractive electrostatic interactions between ssDNA and the membrane, facilitating ssDNA adsorption. On the other hand, at Tris-HCl pH 7 the environment is slightly acidic. This pH level can influence the charge state of both ssDNA and the membrane. The phosphate groups on the ssDNA backbone and the amino groups (-NH
2) on the membrane surface are both partially protonated, resulting in a reduced net charge on both molecules. This reduction in charge weakens the electrostatic interactions between ssDNA and the membrane, making it easier for ssDNA to detach or desorb from the membrane [
68,
69,
70,
71].
However, considering the aforementioned phenomena, the immobilization of ssDNA to the surface of the modified membrane seems to be controlled by a series of factors which need to be specifically modulated: components in the ionic solution, ionic valence and pH.
Table 1 illustrates the mass (pg) of ssDNA desorbed from NC and NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membrane after 60 minutes of incubation in the three complex media containing MnCl
2, MnCl
2/MgCl
2, and MgCl
2. In the case of the NC membrane, the results indicate that the desorbed mass does not significantly differ among the ionic complex used, ranging from 285 pg for MnCl
2 to 300 pg for MgCl
2. Conversely, for NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membranes, the highest mass detachment was observed in the case of MgCl
2, approximately 610 pg, while the lowest was noted in the case of MnCl
2, with approximately 390 pg. These findings suggest that, on average, a greater quantity of ssDNA is desorbed from NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membranes compared to the NC membrane.
The difference in the amount of ssDNA desorbed from the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO hybrid membranes in all the media used can be attributed to the fact that Mg
2+ ions are smaller than Mn
2+ ions, enabling them to neutralize the negative charges more effectively on the ssDNA molecule. Moreover, the smaller size of Mg
2+ allows them to access and interact with binding sites on the membrane more effectively. Thus, smaller ions can fit into tighter spaces and reach sites that might be less accessible to larger ions, enhancing their binding efficiency [
72,
73].
Furthermore, both Mg
2+ and Mn
2+ ions are divalent cations, but Mg
2+ ions have a higher charge density compared to Mn
2+ ions. This higher charge density results in stronger electrostatic interactions with negatively charged functional groups on the membrane’s surface, such as oxygen atoms or other electronegative elements. This enhanced electrostatic attraction makes Mg
2+ ions more likely to bind to the membrane. In addition to the charge density, Mg
2+ ions are known to form stable coordination complexes with phosphate groups, which are abundant in ssDNA and RNA molecules. These complexes can enhance the binding of DNA to surfaces. While Mn
2+ ions are capable of forming similar complexes, they may be less effective in binding ssDNA to the membrane due to their lower charge density [
74,
75,
76].
Compared to our previous study where the NC-GO hybrid membrane emerged to extract approximately 335 pg of ssDNA with NaCl, in this case, the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO membrane implies a much higher extraction yield, with over 600 pg of ssDNA in the case of MgCl
2 [
13]. This effect can be attributed to the presence of amino (NH
2) and polyethylene glycol (PEG) functional groups on the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO membrane that can enhance its ability to interact with and immobilized ssDNA molecules. These functional groups can provide additional binding sites and alter the surface charge of the membrane, potentially making it more favorable for ssDNA adsorption while leaving the graphene surface available for π-π interactions with ssDNA. The specific chemical composition and functional groups on the NC/NH
2-PEG-rGO membrane may also favor interactions with Mg
2+ ions compared to the interactions that occur between the NC-GO membrane and Na
+ ions.
Although the NC/NH2-PEG-rGO membrane effectively extracts a higher quantity of ssDNA from these complex media containing various ionic particles, we recognize the necessity for further refinement. Undertaking additional research endeavors will facilitate the enhancement of both the efficiency and dependability of our technique, thereby expanding its versatility in the extraction of diverse biomolecule types from various sample sources. This advancement holds promise for the enrichment of molecular biology applications and other fields that depend on precise biomolecule extraction methods.