1. Introduction
Plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) is an eco-friendly electrochemical surface treatment technique that produces highly stable oxide coatings on a variety of metals (Mg, Al, Ti, Ta, Nb, Zr) and their alloys with high crystallinity, substrate adhesion, and physical, chemical, and thermal stability [
1,
2,
3,
4]. PEO necessitates high anodic voltage (several hundred volts) to promote the local dielectric breakdown of the growing oxide film, resulting in numerous short-lived micro-discharges generated continuously over the metal electrode surface [
5]. The breakdown process entails intricate electrochemical, thermal, and plasma processes that incorporate both metal and electrolyte components into coatings.
Magnesium and magnesium alloys are desirable materials for practical applications due to their low density, high strength-to-weight ratio, excellent dimensional stability, biodegradability and biocompatibility, large hydrogen storage capacity, high specific capacity for batteries, good electromagnetic shielding, high machinability, and so on [
6,
7]. The main drawback of magnesium-based materials is their poor resistance to corrosion which limits their application [
8]. Surface modification of magnesium and its alloys is commonly used to improve their anti-corrosion properties and create functional coatings for a variety of applications [
9].
In recent years, PEO has become a popular method for improving the surface properties of magnesium and its alloys and forming multifunctional coatings [
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18]. Some studies have shown that oxide coatings formed on magnesium alloys can be used in photocatalytic applications [
19,
20,
21,
22,
23]. The present study focuses on the investigation of photoluminescent (PL) and photocatalytic properties of coatings formed by PEO of AZ31 magnesium alloy in aluminate electrolyte with the addition of CeO
2 particles in different concentrations. PEO coatings formed on AZ31 magnesium alloy in aluminate electrolytes containing MgO and MgAl
2O
4 phases [
22]. Both of these phases have found application in photocatalysis [
24,
25] and as hosts for photoluminescence materials [
26,
27] due to the presence of various kinds of oxygen vacancies and other defects.
Adding CeO
2 particles to the electrolyte causes their incorporation into the coatings during PEO on magnesium alloys, which improves their corrosive properties [
28,
29]. The main idea behind this work was to create MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings in order to improve the photocatalytic and PL properties of a single MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating and optimize the amount of CeO
2 particles in the electrolyte. The properties of CeO
2 such as its low toxicity, strong oxygen storage capacity, high chemical stability, and ability to display dual oxidation states of cerium, Ce
3+/Ce
4+, have drawn a lot of attention in the field of photocatalysis due to the formation of abundant oxygen vacancies in CeO
2, which serve as active electron trap centres, inhibiting recombination of photo-generated electron/hole pairs [
30,
31,
32,
33,
34].
The photocatalytic and PL properties of the MgO/CeO
2 and MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 systems have received little attention in the literature [
35,
36,
37], with no data available for the MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 system. Consequently, in this study, the MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings formed by PEO were characterized using SEM/EDS, XRD, Raman spectroscopy, and DRS to investigate the effect of CeO
2 on the morphology, chemical composition, crystal structure, and absorption properties of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2. The PL of the MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings was thoroughly investigated, as the incorporation of CeO
2 into MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coatings increases the PL intensity by more than an order of magnitude. Methyl orange (MO) dye was used to test the photocatalytic properties of the formed coatings. MO is an example of a typical azo-anionic dye, which is hard to degrade, hazardous to the environment, and potentially dangerous to human health if it finds its way into the soil and water resources.
2. Materials and Methods
The starting material for the of preparation PEO coatings was a rectangular sample of AZ31 magnesium alloy (96% Mg, 3% Al, 1% Zn, Alfa Aesar) with dimensions of 25 mm × 10 mm × 0.81 mm. Samples preparation for PEO includes their ultrasonic cleaning with acetone and dried in a warm air stream. Subsequently, insulating resin was applied to the samples, exposing only the 15 mm × 10 mm active surface to the electrolyte.
The electrolytic cell was made of double-walled glass and cooled with water (refer to Figure 10 in Ref. [
22]). To ensure that particles were distributed evenly in the electrolytic cell, the electrolyte was stirred with a magnetic stirrer. The tubular stainless-steel cathode was positioned around the anode samples of AZ31 magnesium alloy, which were used, and positioned in the centre of the electrolytic cell. The electrolytic solution was prepared using 5 g/L NaAlO
2 in distilled water with the addition of CeO
2 particles in concentrations ranging from 1 g/L to 8 g/L. The PEO processes were performed using a DC power source (Consort EV261) at a constant current density of 150 mA/cm
2 and treated for 10 min. The electrolyte was kept at a temperature of (20 ± 1)
oC. Samples were rinsed in distilled water after the PEO to inhibit additional electrolyte component deposition during drying.
The morphology, thickness, elemental and phase analysis of the PEO coatings were performed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM, JEOL 840A, Tokyo, Japan) with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS, Oxford INCA, Abingdon, UK), X-ray diffraction (XRD, Rigaku Ultima IV, Tokyo, Japan), and Raman spectroscopy (TriVista 557 Raman system, S&I GmbH, Germany). The optical properties of the PEO coatings were examined by UV-Vis diffuse reflectance spectra (DRS, Shimadzu UV-3600, Tokyo, Japan). Room temperature PL excitation and emission spectra were acquired by spectrofluorometer (Horiba Jobin Yvon, Fluorolog FL3-22, Edison, NJ, USA) with a 450 W xenon lamp as the excitation source.
The photodegradation of MO, the model compound for organic pollution, was investigated at 20
oC under artificial solar radiation in order to assess the photocatalytic activity (PA) of the coatings that were formed. The photocatalytic reactor was a double-walled glass with water cooling (refer to Figure 1 in Ref. [
38]). The samples were positioned on the stainless steel holder 5 mm above the bottom of the photocatalytic reactor. A magnetic stirrer that was positioned underneath the holder was used to mix the 10 cm
3 solution of MO. The MO concentration was 8 mg/L at first. A 300 W lamp (OSRAM ULTRA-VITALUX UV-A, Germany) placed 25 cm above the solution's upper surface was used to illuminate the samples. To reach adsorption-desorption equilibrium, the initial MO solution and samples were left in the dark for an hour prior to illumination. By measuring the MO decomposition after a suitable time of light exposure, PA was ascertained. A UV-Vis spectrometer (Thermo Electron Nicolet, Evolution 500, UK) was used to measure the maximum MO absorption peak at 464 nm. Using a standard curve that demonstrated a linear relationship between concentration and absorbance at this wavelength, the absorbance was converted to MO concentration.
3. Results and Discussion
Figure 1 displays the top view and cross-section SEM micrographs of the coating created in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with the addition of CeO
2 particles at different concentrations. Changing the concentration of CeO
2 particles has no discernible effect on the surface morphology or coating thickness. All coatings share a common morphology defined by the presence of molten regions dispersed throughout the surface created when the molten oxide heats up, melts, and then cools down in contact with the surrounding electrolyte and pores formed as a result of gas bubbles released during the PEO [
39]. The coatings formed after 10 minutes of PEO are about (22 ± 1) μm thick.
Integrated EDS analysis of coatings is given in
Table 1 (the relative errors are less than 5%). The coatings' chemical constituents are Mg, Al, O, and Ce. Electrolyte is the main source of Al. Small amounts of Ce are present in coatings, which increase with the concentration of CeO
2 particles in the electrolyte.
The XRD patterns of PEO coatings formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with different concentrations of CeO
2 particles added, along with the XRD pattern of pure CeO
2 particles and AZ31 magnesium alloy substrate, are displayed in
Figure 2a. The peaks observed in XRD patterns of CeO
2 particles at 2θ values of 28.7, 33.2, 47.6, 56,4, 59.2, 69.5, 76.8 and 79.2 degrees, correspond to the (111), (200), (220), (311), (222), (400), (331), and (420) crystalline planes of cubic fluorite structure of CeO
2 (JCPDS Card No. 75-0162). The formation of MgO (JCPDS card No. 79-0612) and MgAl
2O
4 (JCPDS card No. 77-0435) phases, as a result of an interaction between the AZ31 substrate and the electrolyte components, are indicated by the XRD pattern of PEO coating formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 [
22]. The X-ray penetration through the porous oxide layer and reflection of the substrate makes diffraction peaks from the substrate significant. The diffraction peaks of CeO
2 can be clearly seen together, with the diffraction peaks arising from MgO and MgAl
2O
4 in the XRD patterns of the PEO coatings formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with the addition of a high concentration of CeO
2 particles (4 g/L and 8 g/L). This is primarily due to the low concentration of evenly distributed CeO
2 particles throughout the surface coatings.
To verify that CeO
2 particles are also present in PEO coatings formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with the addition of lower concentrations of CeO
2 particles (1 g/L and 2 g/L), we conducted Raman measurements (
Figure 2b). The Raman spectrum of CeO
2 particles exhibits a prominent band located approximately at 465 cm
−1, identified as the F
2g mode of the cubic fluorite structure of CeO
2 attributed to the symmetrical vibration of oxygen atoms surrounding the Ce
4+ [
40]. This mode can be found on the Raman spectra of all coatings formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with the addition of CeO
2 particles, indicating that CeO
2 particles were incorporated into the coatings.
During PEO, particles from the electrolyte can be incorporated into the coatings in three ways: reactive, partly reactive, and inert [
41]. The melting point and particle size are the two most important factors in determining the incorporation mode. Particles with a high melting point, such as CeO
2 (around 2400
oC), are distinguished by an inert mode of incorporation [
42], which also applies to our case.
PL excitation and emission spectra of MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating are shown in
Figure 3. The PL emission spectrum excited at 265 nm (
Figure 3a) is characterized by a strong emission band in a red region with a maximum at about 720 nm which is associated with F
+ centres in MgAl
2O
4 [
43] and a broad band in the range from 350 nm to 600 nm which is associated with oxygen vacancies (e.g. F, F
+, F
2, and F
22+ centres), mostly in MgO [
44,
45]. Upon excitation with 340 nm (
Figure 3b), two PL bands with peak positions at about 410 nm and 660 nm can be observed in the PL emission spectrum, which is related to oxygen vacancies in MgO [
46].
Under 265 nm excitation PL intensity of the band with a maximum at about 720 nm is not significantly affected by the incorporation of CeO
2 particles to the MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coatings, but the PL intensity of the broad band with a maximum at about 410 nm is significantly increased (
Figure 4a). PL emission spectra excited at 340 nm also show that the PL intensity of the band with a maximum of about 410 nm increases with the increase in the concentration of CeO
2 particles incorporated in the MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coatings (
Figure 4b). The ratio of the PL intensity of the coatings formed in 5 g/L NaAlO
2 with the addition of 8 g/L CeO
2 particles and without is about 20. In addition to this PL band, a PL band with a maximum at around 520 nm as well as PL bands in the red region of weak PL intensity can be observed in the PL emission spectra (
Figure 4a,b).
PL excitation spectra monitored at 720 nm of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings consist of one intense band with a maximum of about 265 nm (
Figure 4c). The content of CeO
2 in the MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings does not affect the PL intensity of this band, which is in agreement with the corresponding PL emission spectra in
Figure 3a. PL excitation spectra monitored at 410 nm and 520 nm of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings consist of at least three bands at about 265 nm, 315 nm, and 340 nm. The transition at 340 nm is the most intense of these excitation transitions.
The increase in the PL intensity of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings compared to pure MgO/MgAl
2O
4 is due to the creation of oxygen vacancies as a result of the incorporation of CeO
2 because PL originating from CeO
2 particles is negligible. Bands with maxima at around 410 nm and 520 nm are attributed to F
+ and F centres, respectively [
47,
48,
49].
Figure 5a illustrates how the concentration of CeO
2 particles in the electrolyte affects the MO photodegradation efficiency using the formed coatings.
C0 is the initial concentration of MO, and its concentration at time
t is C. For every CeO
2 concentration, three samples were examined and the mean values are displayed in
Figure 5a. Samples collected under identical conditions have very high reproducibility (within 3%) for the PA. The concentration of CeO
2 particles added to the electrolyte affects the PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings, which is significantly higher than that of MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating. The highest PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings was achieved with the addition of 2 g/L of CeO
2 particles.
The first-order kinetic Langmuir Hinshelwood model (
Figure 5b) provides a good description of the photocatalytic degradation of MO:
The first-order kinetic constant
kapp, determined by non-linear least squares fitting over the whole experimental time range [
50], is provided in Table insert in
Figure 6b, along with the corresponding standard squared deviation (σ) and linear correlation coefficient (R
2). As the concentration of CeO
2 particles in the aluminate electrolyte increased up to 2 g/L, the degradation rate constant
kapp increased from 0.0809 h
−1 to 0.1273 h
−1. The sensitivity of MO degradation on the content of CeO
2 in MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings was confirmed by a decrease in the degradation rate constant observed when the concentration of CeO
2 in aluminate electrolyte increased up to 8 g/L.
CeO
2 particles have a very low PA in organic dye degradation due to the rapid recombination of photo-generated electron-hole pairs [
51]. Because the concentration of CeO
2 particles in the formed MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings is so low, the contribution of CeO
2 particles to the total PA of these coatings is negligible. Since the morphology, thickness, and phase structure of all formed coatings are essentially the same (
Figure 1 and
Figure 2), CeO
2 particles can contribute to increase the PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating primarily by broadening the optical absorption range of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings or by slowing down the fast recombination of photo-generated electron/hole pairs.
UV–Vis DRS spectra of CeO
2 particles and formed coatings are shown in
Figure 6. A broad absorption band in the mid-UV region is typical for MgO/MgAl
2O
4 formed in aluminate electrolyte [
22]. The used CeO
2 particles have an absorption band-edge at about 440 nm. Due to the low concentration of CeO
2 in the formed coatings, the shift of the absorption curves towards the visible region is insignificant, especially for low concentrations of CeO
2 particles in the electrolyte (1, 2, and 4 g/L). This indicates that the increased PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings compared to MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating is due to a decrease in photo-generated electron/hole recombination rate as a result of MgO/MgAl
2O
4 and CeO
2 coupling.
PL and PA measurements indicate that the high concentration of various types of oxygen vacancies and other defects in the formed coatings are related to the significant PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings. The formation of oxygen vacancies during PEO introduces the defect states within the material's bandgap facilitating photo-generated charge carrier separation which leads to an increase in PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings formed in aluminate electrolyte with the addition of CeO
2 particles in relation to MgO/MgAl
2O
4 coating formed in pure aluminate electrolyte. The PA of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings is influenced by the concentration of CeO
2 particles added to the aluminate electrolyte. The MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coating, which was formed in the aluminate electrolyte with the addition of 2 g/L CeO
2 particles, had the highest PA. As the concentration of CeO
2 particles in the aluminate electrolyte increases, the PA decreases because CeO
2 particles serve as photo-induced electron capture centers [
52].
Ten consecutive photocatalytic tests were conducted on the most active photocatalyst in order to investigate the potential application of MgO/MgAl
2O
4/CeO
2 coatings in photocatalysis.
Figure 7 shows the recycling test of MO photo-degradation as well as morphology and compositions before and after 10 runs. The morphology, composition and PA did not change, suggesting that the produced photocatalyst had a high degree of chemical and physical stability.